You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is this 1 on Pulis?
November 16 2026 1.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is this 1 on Pulis?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
burtmacp Flag 23 Feb 14 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 23 Feb 14 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

 


Most certainly not European.

james03 Flag Bangkok 23 Feb 14 8.45am

Timid? Not quite what I saw.

Despite all of the media frenzy Manchester United are reigning Champions, currently sixth in the league and in the last sixteen of the Champions League. They have purchased only two players this season and that cost them seventy million pounds! Rooney and the rest of the side were bouyed by his new contract thus commitment to the club. Added to all this that was the strongest United side, and the most experienced, Moyes has put on the pitch all season.

Had we gone all gung-ho they would have put at least five past us. For the entire first half they were limited to a few chances and we actually matched them. We also did not concede in the first ten minutes after the break.

We gave it our best shot and we lost - no big shock. There are other far more winnable games left this season and we were NEVER going to win every game betweeen now and the seasons end.

Jedinak will be plaing in the World Cup finals. How many of their players will be doing the same - eight, nine, ten perhaps?

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

palace chick Flag South Croydon 23 Feb 14 8.47am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

Agreed! Discipline is so important in these types of matches against the top sides. Jedi gave away a free kick just outside the box before the close of the first half. It was Rooney territory and then the Chamack challenge for the pen ruined the game plan. I'm sure Pulis won't be happy about both those instances?

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 23 Feb 14 8.56am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

That is true but I thought we lacked a little bit of adventure. I'm not suggesting gung-ho but I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble. If you take it we will lose to the top 6 teams then there is a case for being more adventurous? We could really do with the odd point again the top sides. To be honest I was a little disappointed yesterday, I thought we had a chance of getting a point.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Username Flag Horsham 23 Feb 14 9.14am

The opening ten minutes yesterday was the most aggressive and positive we have been this season.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 23 Feb 14 9.23am

Quote Andy_G at 23 Feb 2014 8.56am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

That is true but I thought we lacked a little bit of adventure. I'm not suggesting gung-ho but I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble. If you take it we will lose to the top 6 teams then there is a case for being more adventurous? We could really do with the odd point again the top sides. To be honest I was a little disappointed yesterday, I thought we had a chance of getting a point.

You make a reasonable point, but, we tried an adventurous approach at Anfield, and were 3 down before our second wind! There is a gulf in class, about 500 squillion pound or so of purchased class, so, we need a solid plan. It will work against most sides in this division.

 


Most certainly not European.

FinchleyEagle Flag 23 Feb 14 9.39am

We definitely employed the best tactics for the game but they just had too much. Their forward line is worth about £100m at todays prices.

Our entire squad is about a fifth of that !

We have Chelsea, Liverpool and Man City to come and these are games where again its likely we'll get nothing, however that setup is our best chance.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (23 Feb 2014 9.40am)

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 9.54am

The game plan was working but it was all ripped to pieces with the penalty.It changed the whole dynamic of the game and I felt that Man Utd would get another.

Some would say that Chamakh's foul was a "Forwards tackle" - It appeared he got caught on his heels when Evra ran past him and he tackled with the 'Wrong' leg.Rash challenge indeed.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 23 Feb 14 10.27am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)


I agree with the op to an extent...we're in danger of going into these games against the top 10 in very much the same way we did under freedman. Problem is we soak up pressure then concede late in the game not giving us time to get back into the game.

I say to Liverpool, chelski and Man city we go for it.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 23 Feb 14 10.32am

We were far more attacking than I expected us to be but they were better than us.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 14 11.00am

Quote topcat at 23 Feb 2014 10.32am

We were far more attacking than I expected us to be but they were better than us.

Absolutely true, and we were really good. Normally you'd expect the top teams of the league to walk games like this, but we've made them all work for it. But for the penalty, we might have been able to get a point.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 23 Feb 14 11.20am

Quote james03 at 23 Feb 2014 8.45am

Timid? Not quite what I saw.

Despite all of the media frenzy Manchester United are reigning Champions, currently sixth in the league and in the last sixteen of the Champions League. They have purchased only two players this season and that cost them seventy million pounds! Rooney and the rest of the side were bouyed by his new contract thus commitment to the club. Added to all this that was the strongest United side, and the most experienced, Moyes has put on the pitch all season.

Had we gone all gung-ho they would have put at least five past us. For the entire first half they were limited to a few chances and we actually matched them. We also did not concede in the first ten minutes after the break.

We gave it our best shot and we lost - no big shock. There are other far more winnable games left this season and we were NEVER going to win every game betweeen now and the seasons end.

Jedinak will be plaing in the World Cup finals. How many of their players will be doing the same - eight, nine, ten perhaps?


Sound analysis of the game and issues.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

nhp61 Flag Goring-By-Sea born, now in Brackne... 23 Feb 14 1.24pm

Quote james03 at 23 Feb 2014 8.45am

Timid? Not quite what I saw.

Despite all of the media frenzy Manchester United are reigning Champions, currently sixth in the league and in the last sixteen of the Champions League. They have purchased only two players this season and that cost them seventy million pounds! Rooney and the rest of the side were bouyed by his new contract thus commitment to the club. Added to all this that was the strongest United side, and the most experienced, Moyes has put on the pitch all season.

Had we gone all gung-ho they would have put at least five past us. For the entire first half they were limited to a few chances and we actually matched them. We also did not concede in the first ten minutes after the break.

We gave it our best shot and we lost - no big shock. There are other far more winnable games left this season and we were NEVER going to win every game betweeen now and the seasons end.

Jedinak will be plaing in the World Cup finals. How many of their players will be doing the same - eight, nine, ten perhaps?

Totally agree with Booted Eagle. This puts things in perspective.

I admit I was very worried we would concede during the first few minutes of the second half, as that has happened a lot of times this season.

Palace played well, held their own for a large portion of the game, had a couple of chances that, had one or two gone in, could have changed the final outcome. Man United had to work hard for their win.

The penalty was the game changer. I don't blame Chamakh for that, he was a forward at the back trying to help out the defence, and he was unlucky.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 1.28pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Feb 2014 1.24pm
and he was unlucky.

Why was Chamakh unlucky ?
It was a rash challenge with his "Wrong" foot and was a definite penalty.I am sure he regrets his actions like we all do from time to time and I should know !!!

In terms of myself, I recall the song "My Way" - "Regrets I've had a few" but in my case NOT "Too few to mention" !!!!


 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 23 Feb 14 1.39pm

I remember thinking after the Fulham game that we just didn't have any class in the side whereas yesterday we didn't have quite enough, a big leap forward in just a few months. I thought we were just behind in the first half but still had some decent chances and in the second (until the penalty) we were the better side.
Bit of a sickener yesterday but on reflection I think we have enough to stay up.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Petereagle Flag Brockley 23 Feb 14 2.02pm

Quote Andy_G at 23 Feb 2014 8.56am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

That is true but I thought we lacked a little bit of adventure. I'm not suggesting gung-ho but I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble. If you take it we will lose to the top 6 teams then there is a case for being more adventurous? We could really do with the odd point again the top sides. To be honest I was a little disappointed yesterday, I thought we had a chance of getting a point.

I think we gave it our best shot, with a realistic gameplan. Man U really do have a galaxy of talent, and this was one of their best performances all season.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 23 Feb 14 2.25pm

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 9.23am

Quote Andy_G at 23 Feb 2014 8.56am

Quote moylerg at 23 Feb 2014 8.34am

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!

Nope. The gameplan was sound. Soak pressure, organised defence, hit them on the break, with the likelihood of us doing so increasing the longer the game was scoreless, as they would have chased for a winner more. If not for a rash challenge, it may have worked. So, no blame on Pulis, this is how we setup against top sides.

Edited by moylerg (23 Feb 2014 8.34am)

That is true but I thought we lacked a little bit of adventure. I'm not suggesting gung-ho but I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble. If you take it we will lose to the top 6 teams then there is a case for being more adventurous? We could really do with the odd point again the top sides. To be honest I was a little disappointed yesterday, I thought we had a chance of getting a point.

You make a reasonable point, but, we tried an adventurous approach at Anfield, and were 3 down before our second wind! There is a gulf in class, about 500 squillion pound or so of purchased class, so, we need a solid plan. It will work against most sides in this division.

The Liverpool game was under IH so that doesn't count as he was inept. True the money difference is massive and they had 3 top quality players in attack but I till think we could have gave them a it more to deal with. A point or two of the top sides means we can lose a game against the bottom teams and it not be a big loss.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 2.37pm

Quote Andy_G at 23 Feb 2014 2.25pm

I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble.

In fact we had more corners and shots on goal than they had !


 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 23 Feb 14 3.07pm

Quote Willo at 23 Feb 2014 2.37pm

Quote Andy_G at 23 Feb 2014 2.25pm

I think we could have threatened them more, gave them something to think about. It was a little bit to easy for them, they never really looked in trouble.

In fact we had more corners and shots on goal than they had !



Frankly I was disappointed in Manchester yesterday. Apart from Rooney I did not see anybody really special. Van Persie seemed off colour and Mata lost his way eventually. I thought Rooney was their only ace in the hole and he did have a good game. I would have liked us to have tested their defense because I'm not sure how solid they really are.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is this 1 on Pulis?