You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time To Restrict Glenn Murray To Subs Bench
November 16 2026 1.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Time To Restrict Glenn Murray To Subs Bench


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
tonymikejoe Flag UK 23 Feb 14 11.08pm

I am not on here to slaughter last season's top scorer, in fact it is great to see him back, but I think we are a better team without him in the starting XI

We are on a tremendous run at the moment without Glenn Murray and I don't think a relegation scrap after such a long-term injury is the ideal situation for him.

His inclusion on Saturday meant Yannick Bolassie was stuck on the bench, which weakens the side, and I believe we are better with Chamakh up top with Ince behind.

Remember Murray wasn't exactly banging them in during last season's run-in and his one and only goal in his last dozen appearances was from the penalty spot.

He should be battling it out with the unfairly maligned Cameron Jerome as cover for Chamakh and we will see where he is at the start of next season.

This one is a write-off for him.

 

geezerspalace Flag Maidstone 23 Feb 14 11.22pm

Muzza was superb as was Chamakh...perhaps you should look more towards Ince looking for personal glory to get himself in the shop window...thanks to his wonderful dad, ahead of others. And Yannick was miles better than Ince. Stick with those fighting for the club and their team mates.

 


[Link] Lifelong Palace fan selling loads of Palace stuff I've collected over the years so please check out my Ebay store memorabilialane2011 Cheers, Ian

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 23 Feb 14 11.49pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 23 Feb 2014 11.08pm

I am not on here to slaughter last season's top scorer, in fact it is great to see him back, but I think we are a better team without him in the starting XI

We are on a tremendous run at the moment without Glenn Murray and I don't think a relegation scrap after such a long-term injury is the ideal situation for him.

His inclusion on Saturday meant Yannick Bolassie was stuck on the bench, which weakens the side, and I believe we are better with Chamakh up top with Ince behind.

Remember Murray wasn't exactly banging them in during last season's run-in and his one and only goal in his last dozen appearances was from the penalty spot.

He should be battling it out with the unfairly maligned Cameron Jerome as cover for Chamakh and we will see where he is at the start of next season.

This one is a write-off for him.

Incredible post. Murray would walk into every team in the Championship cos he's a natural goalscorer. You don't score 31 goals in a season without being a top, top striker. We need goals. He plays. He's just been out for 9 months and you expect him to start delivering already? He got another hour under his belt and had one of our shots on goal. His mere presence is enough to raise the mood in this instance. I guarantee he will score goals before the season is over! A fully-firing Murray will be in any starting eleven. He's a lethal finisher and the ONLY player we have with natural poacher's instinct. We need him now and hopefully by March he'll be fully match fit.


Edited by indianapalace85 (23 Feb 2014 11.51pm)

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 23 Feb 14 11.57pm

No. I don't expect him to be in top form after nearly a year out, didn't you read the post?

It's exactly because of this that I believe he should be on the bench, barring injury to Chamakh.


Quote indianapalace85 at 23 Feb 2014 11.49pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 23 Feb 2014 11.08pm

I am not on here to slaughter last season's top scorer, in fact it is great to see him back, but I think we are a better team without him in the starting XI

We are on a tremendous run at the moment without Glenn Murray and I don't think a relegation scrap after such a long-term injury is the ideal situation for him.

His inclusion on Saturday meant Yannick Bolassie was stuck on the bench, which weakens the side, and I believe we are better with Chamakh up top with Ince behind.

Remember Murray wasn't exactly banging them in during last season's run-in and his one and only goal in his last dozen appearances was from the penalty spot.

He should be battling it out with the unfairly maligned Cameron Jerome as cover for Chamakh and we will see where he is at the start of next season.

This one is a write-off for him.

Incredible post. Murray would walk into every team in the Championship cos he's a natural goalscorer. You don't score 31 goals in a season without being a top, top striker. We need goals. He plays. He's just been out for 9 months and you expect him to start delivering already? He got another hour under his belt and had one of our shots on goal. His mere presence is enough to raise the mood in this instance. I guarantee he will score goals before the season is over! A fully-firing Murray will be in any starting eleven. He's a lethal finisher and the ONLY player we have with natural poacher's instinct. We need him now and hopefully by March he'll be fully match fit.


Edited by indianapalace85 (23 Feb 2014 11.51pm)


 

Hambo Flag Crawley 24 Feb 14 12.27am

Chamakh is more effective behind another forward. Of the forwards available, Murray is the one that Pulis believes carries the biggest goal threat. He needs to integrate into a much changed team - and play games more than anything.

Losing at home to Man Utd does not automatically mean there are players to blame - be it Murray, Ince or whoever.

We did alright, they were better than us in the end.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

Farawayeagle Flag Sydney 24 Feb 14 1.00am

Strikers like Murray need to be playing as much and as often as possible. This is even more so in Murray's case after injury.
They are confidence players. To build that confidence you need to be on the field. He's an experienced player. He knows what you need in a relegation scrap.

I understand your thinking but I think it is flawed.

I think he will work well with Chamakh.

Yannick should be competing with Jerome and Puncheon for his place.

 


Founder Of The Crystal Palace Roller Coaster
Association

An Affiliate Of The Never A Dull Moment Club

R.I.P. DJ Hardline -- Gone Way Too Soon

GKAS Member 54

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 24 Feb 14 2.05am

F-ck me...... Now its pick on Murray time and he's only been back 5 minutes.
Some people on here are absolutely cretinous

Is there some way we could cypher out cretinous waffle bol-ox before it gets posted on the HOL.
Like a HOL youth side. To work up the social media boards to get to the 1st team....
"sorry mate you just aint cutting it here, going to have to let you go back to Brighton NSC"

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Feb 14 5.45am

Quote 7@burnley79 at 24 Feb 2014 2.05am

F-ck me...... Now its pick on Murray time and he's only been back 5 minutes.
Some people on here are absolutely cretinous

Is there some way we could cypher out cretinous waffle bol-ox before it gets posted on the HOL.
Like a HOL youth side. To work up the social media boards to get to the 1st team....
"sorry mate you just aint cutting it here, going to have to let you go back to Brighton NSC"

Of the seven posts on this thread yours is the only one not trying to discuss the point raised but preferring instead to insult the poster which to my way of thinking makes yours the cretinous waffle

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Feb 14 6.09am

Saturday was a sharpener for Glenn. I reckon TP played him not so much thinking of points against Man U but rather Sunderland, Cardiff and Villa, etc.

One step backwards in order to go two steps forward.

Burnley79 - the OP has raised a fair point to discuss. Daft if we can't have a civil debate about it without the histrionics. Join in.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 24 Feb 14 9.08am

Quote Hambo at 24 Feb 2014 12.27am

Chamakh is more effective behind another forward. Of the forwards available, Murray is the one that Pulis believes carries the biggest goal threat. He needs to integrate into a much changed team - and play games more than anything.

Losing at home to Man Utd does not automatically mean there are players to blame - be it Murray, Ince or whoever.

We did alright, they were better than us in the end.

Agree with all of the above. Chamakh is probably our most capable attacking player, the system should be made to suit him, Saturday's system certainly did that.

I think United's league position gave us too much belief that this was a 'winnable' tie. United were very impressive on Saturday, without ever really getting out of second gear. I thought the understanding between Murray and Chamakh was very encouraging on the whole. Likewise Jedinak and Ledley, we just ran into a good side.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 24 Feb 14 9.09am

Quote 7@burnley79 at 24 Feb 2014 2.05am

F-ck me...... Now its pick on Murray time and he's only been back 5 minutes.
Some people on here are absolutely cretinous

Is there some way we could cypher out cretinous waffle bol-ox before it gets posted on the HOL.
Like a HOL youth side. To work up the social media boards to get to the 1st team....
"sorry mate you just aint cutting it here, going to have to let you go back to Brighton NSC"


That would be handy..

 

Hoof Hearted 24 Feb 14 9.46am

I wondered why he changed the format to include Murray when we had played so well against WBA.

Bolasie carried more threat when he came on and although Murray did well, I sort of get what the OP is on about.

The real test of our format/lineups will be against the teams around us and I hope TP gets it right.

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Feb 14 9.59am

Regarding Ince in this game, I thought Man United just kept a close watch on him. If I was to pick either Ince or Bolasie going forward (sentiment aside) I'd pick Ince. What Bolasie seemed to bring to this game was the element of surprise. I could be totally wrong in this, but I thought MU looked like they didn't know enough about Bolasie (although, who does, he can be an unpredictable player). Bolasie played one of his better games and brought a lot to the pitch but for me (IMHO) he'd be kept on the bench in favour of Ince starting.

I realise this is a digression from the Murray discussion, but somebody did speak about Ince vs Bolasie in this thread.

Regarding Murray, Jerome came on and did well, but ultimately I don't think I could criticise the choice to start Murray.

 




cpj Flag Kent 24 Feb 14 10.10am

Quote tonymikejoe at 23 Feb 2014 11.08pm

I am not on here to slaughter last season's top scorer, in fact it is great to see him back, but I think we are a better team without him in the starting XI

We are on a tremendous run at the moment without Glenn Murray and I don't think a relegation scrap after such a long-term injury is the ideal situation for him.

His inclusion on Saturday meant Yannick Bolassie was stuck on the bench, which weakens the side, and I believe we are better with Chamakh up top with Ince behind.

Remember Murray wasn't exactly banging them in during last season's run-in and his one and only goal in his last dozen appearances was from the penalty spot.

He should be battling it out with the unfairly maligned Cameron Jerome as cover for Chamakh and we will see where he is at the start of next season.

This one is a write-off for him.


Sorry, but Jerome has 1 goal in 14 starts - if we go down it will be due to a lack of goals. We have to play Murray, even if he is a long way from being 100% fit, as he is our only chance of scoring some goals.

Anyway, if we are to go down, I'd prefer it if those who got us there at least had the chance to play in the Prem (that's why I was so annoyed that Garvan and Dobbie were written off so early on) and Murray certainly deserves that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 14 10.16am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 24 Feb 2014 9.46am

Bolasie carried more threat when he came on

Yes he did well, however he was introduced at 0-2 when the game was effectively won and Man Utd were content to see out the match.A different dynamic came into play.


 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 24 Feb 14 10.18am

Match time will bring match fitness.

I think it was a wise idea by Pulis to have Murray starting against a team who are more talented than to just cynically hack him down. 70 minutes at a very competitive level was exactly what Glenn needed.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 14 10.22am

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 24 Feb 2014 10.18am

Match time will bring match fitness.

I think it was a wise idea by Pulis to have Murray starting

I have NO problems at all with Pulis' decision to start Murray.At the end of the day Murray scored 30 goals for us last season (Albeit at a lower level) so he is a proven goalscorer. Jerome on the other hand struggles to score and has missed good chances so Murray deserved his chance.I can understand Pulis' thinking on this matter.


Edited by Willo (24 Feb 2014 10.22am)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Feb 14 10.27am

Quote Hambo at 24 Feb 2014 12.27am

Chamakh is more effective behind another forward. Of the forwards available, Murray is the one that Pulis believes carries the biggest goal threat. He needs to integrate into a much changed team - and play games more than anything.

Losing at home to Man Utd does not automatically mean there are players to blame - be it Murray, Ince or whoever.

We did alright, they were better than us in the end.


Is correct. Pulis decided not to loan him out for the rest of the season. Development games are not enough. Thus, having made the decision to put him in the squad, there is only one option: sacrifice a few games to get him fully match fit.

Even if it took a month from now to get him up to full Murray, on the 2 or 3 chances we will have in each of the final games, who would you rather have on the trigger: Murray, Gayle or Jerome?

 

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 24 Feb 14 10.58am

Quote Ian J at 24 Feb 2014 5.45am

Quote 7@burnley79 at 24 Feb 2014 2.05am

F-ck me...... Now its pick on Murray time and he's only been back 5 minutes.
Some people on here are absolutely cretinous

Is there some way we could cypher out cretinous waffle bol-ox before it gets posted on the HOL.
Like a HOL youth side. To work up the social media boards to get to the 1st team....
"sorry mate you just aint cutting it here, going to have to let you go back to Brighton NSC"

Of the seven posts on this thread yours is the only one not trying to discuss the point raised but preferring instead to insult the poster which to my way of thinking makes yours the cretinous waffle

ok just for you Ian I will share the obvious. Murray marshalls the front line better than both Jerome and of course Gayle who runs round like a headless chicken until he has the ball at his feet then he looks dangerous. Jerome holds the ball up the best out of the 3 but not by far from Murray as he equally does a superb job here IMO. Gayle when given the opportunity can score as we have already seen this season, Jerome cant. Murray on the other hand knows how to create space for himself in tight situations something gayle will learn over time, something we haven't got at present. Overall Murray is not only technically better than both Jerome and Gayle, but he also has their best qualities rolled into one. As for his dip in scoring goals last season, I was very pleased that he managed to score 31 goals in 3/4 of a season and that for me tell me how accomplished he is at scoring. Which again is something we need right now. We have tried the other format with both jerome and gayle and its not that effective in both cases. When Murray becomes sharper and Pulis knows this he will get that extra space all be it a few feet and start to score. I thought it was a master stroke playing Murray from the outset against Manure, because it would of been a coo if we got something from the game and also give Murray a good test against vidic as to what to expect from top premier league opposition in the weeks to come. Murray will score goals you can count on that in this division, I thought he marshalled the front line well in his first start for palace and to start to knock him before he gets started was way to harsh. Maybe in the OP's defence my he maybe a newish fan by his joining date and didn't get to see how affective Murray was last season.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Feb 14 11.14am

Nope, Murray was excellent on Saturday, and the ideal replacement for Jerome. Chamakah barring the penalty barely set a foot wrong. The starting squad from Saturday is the strongest team we have.

Chamakah and Murray also seemed to be working well togeather. Ok, we didn't score, but look who we were up against, and we still carved out chances (as many as they did).

The team that played Saturday, playing at the standard they achieved, would beat any of our relegation rivals.

Ince coming in off Murray and Chamakah will create a lot of opportunties.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time To Restrict Glenn Murray To Subs Bench