You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If Chamakh starts......
November 16 2026 12.38pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

If Chamakh starts......


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
rikz Flag Croydon 03 Apr 14 5.28pm

Who would you drop

Personally i think we need to start him, his by far our most technically gifted player so good in the number 10 position, good at holding the ball up, bringing others into play and helping hit on the counter.

Do we put him in for jerome i know he dont look like scoring but the constant work he puts in chasing defenders down and putting them under pressure is what we want away on sat. Straight swap for ledley or drop kg and put ledley deeper next to jedi, cant really see pulis dropping kg tho.

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 03 Apr 14 5.31pm

Good question. Nice position to be in I guess, a winning team with the prospect of our most talented player being added in.

Personally I would keep the same team, with him on the bench to possibly come on into the number 10 position if we are losing.

 

southport_eagle Flag Southport 03 Apr 14 5.37pm

I wouldn't drop Jerome after the shift he put in against Chelsea.

Chamakh is probably not match fit yet. I would put him on the bench. It would be handy to have Murray and Chamakh to come on if we are losing against Cardiff.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 03 Apr 14 5.48pm

Drop KG and play Ledley there then put Cham in his usual position.

 

Master Coin Flag 03 Apr 14 5.56pm

Would drop Jerome in a heartbeat. Frankly, the Chelsea game is one solid performance amongst a season of awful and this outlier shouldn't grant him a start in another pivotal game (unless we have no other option).

He cannot finish and is all huff and puff with no real end product.

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 03 Apr 14 5.59pm

Quote Master Coin at 03 Apr 2014 5.56pm

Would drop Jerome in a heartbeat. Frankly, the Chelsea game is one solid performance amongst a season of awful and this outlier shouldn't grant him a start in another pivotal game (unless we have no other option).

He cannot finish and is all huff and puff with no real end product.


This.

I admire his work rate, he was fantastic against Chelsea but Cardiff is a different game and we need to take our chances with better finishers.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 03 Apr 14 6.02pm

Quote joe_cpfc at 03 Apr 2014 5.48pm

Drop KG and play Ledley there then put Cham in his usual position.

Not wise to drop a player inform.

KG played really well against Chelsea.

 

bodge Flag 03 Apr 14 6.03pm

It would be harsh to change the team but for me it would be KG.

 

southport_eagle Flag Southport 03 Apr 14 6.03pm

I thought that KG was excellent last week. He won't be dropped.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 03 Apr 14 6.11pm

For me the obvious one to drop out is Bolasie, he offers nothing other than the fear factor of his speed, would be a good player to come on with 30 mins left.

 

deleted9 Flag 03 Apr 14 6.17pm

Pulis won't change the midfield. It's a midfield that has been working well together for a run of games now so to start mixing it up would be daft. He will only be making small like for like changes from now on I predict so the only player to lose their place will be Jerome.

I'd quite like to see them both start to be honest!

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 03 Apr 14 6.20pm

Would like to drop Puncheon, he's a lemon. Chamakh has to start if he's fit as he offers a real threat up front.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 03 Apr 14 6.40pm

obviously Pulis wont start him if he aint fit enough but if he is it could be a good thing for us having a pair of fresh legs on the pitch at this time of the season

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Apr 14 6.48pm

Quote Jordan555x at 03 Apr 2014 6.02pm

Quote joe_cpfc at 03 Apr 2014 5.48pm

Drop KG and play Ledley there then put Cham in his usual position.

Not wise to drop a player inform.

KG played really well against Chelsea.


Yes, have to agree there. I am one of many that are not always his greatest fans but I thought he was considerably better than usual against Chelsea. He certainly does have some very good days, just not enough for my liking.

 

gary3a Flag bromley 03 Apr 14 6.48pm

Quote Coach 3 at 03 Apr 2014 6.20pm

Would like to drop Puncheon, he's a lemon. Chamakh has to start if he's fit as he offers a real threat up front.


Yes he was crap on Saturday, getting behind the Chelsea defence
with ease, making their defenders look stupid playing little triangles with mariappa.....what a plum...

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Apr 14 6.48pm

Quote Coach 3 at 03 Apr 2014 6.20pm

Would like to drop Puncheon, he's a lemon. Chamakh has to start if he's fit as he offers a real threat up front.


Eh? Played well on Saturday.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Apr 14 6.49pm

Quote gary3a at 03 Apr 2014 6.48pm

Quote Coach 3 at 03 Apr 2014 6.20pm

Would like to drop Puncheon, he's a lemon. Chamakh has to start if he's fit as he offers a real threat up front.


Yes he was crap on Saturday, getting behind the Chelsea defence
with ease, making their defenders look stupid playing little triangles with mariappa.....what a plum...


Damn, you said it so much better

 

wainesworld Flag west wickham 03 Apr 14 6.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2014 6.48pm

Quote Jordan555x at 03 Apr 2014 6.02pm

Quote joe_cpfc at 03 Apr 2014 5.48pm

Drop KG and play Ledley there then put Cham in his usual position.

Not wise to drop a player inform.

KG played really well against Chelsea.


Yes, have to agree there. I am one of many that are not always his greatest fans but I thought he was considerably better than usual against Chelsea. He certainly does have some very good days, just not enough for my liking.

He has one good game, by his standards, and he's in form really !!!!

 

davenotamonkey Flag 03 Apr 14 7.22pm

Definitely drop Jerome. It's a statement of intent. With Jerome on the pitch as our striking option, we are settling for a draw.

Twitter seems to suggest Cham is 100% fit and ready to go. He needs to get on the pitch - then we take the game to Cardiff.

 

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 03 Apr 14 7.28pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 Apr 2014 6.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 03 Apr 2014 6.48pm

Quote Jordan555x at 03 Apr 2014 6.02pm

Quote joe_cpfc at 03 Apr 2014 5.48pm

Drop KG and play Ledley there then put Cham in his usual position.

Not wise to drop a player inform.

KG played really well against Chelsea.


Yes, have to agree there. I am one of many that are not always his greatest fans but I thought he was considerably better than usual against Chelsea. He certainly does have some very good days, just not enough for my liking.

He has one good game, by his standards, and he's in form really !!!!

Actually he played well against Newcastle as well. So he is in form! Believe me I have slated the hell out of this man, but credits due when credits due. If a player is playing well it is basic managerial knowledge to leave them in the side.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If Chamakh starts......