You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley or Chamakh in Starting Line up
November 16 2026 12.38pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ledley or Chamakh in Starting Line up


Kington Eagle Flag 08 Apr 14 1.02pm

During the time Chamakh was injured, Ledley played just behind Jerome and played the role very well. In my view Jerome plays a vital role in closing down, holding up play and generally keeping the opposition defense busy. So I would continue to play him even though he is not scoring. With Chamakh now back, I wonder if Pulis will pick him or keep him on bench or whether Ledley will play in another position. If so, who will he replace. Most logical option would be to stick to winning team and keep Chamakh on bench or would it be to rotate as we have mid week match coming against Everton ?

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 08 Apr 14 2.55pm

Keep the same team and get a win. If Fulham lose and other results go our way it really does not matter who we pick for the Everton game or any of the other remaining games this season.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

I'mPalace Till I Die Flag 08 Apr 14 2.59pm

Take KG out (I know he has had some good games recently) and put Ledley in his place. Then put Chamakh in just behind Jerome. That would be the best option. If we are trailing behing Ledley can be less defensive and attack a little more

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 08 Apr 14 3.11pm

Tony (Mr Pulis) will without a shadow of doubt continue with the same line up for Villa, if all players are fit and available.
Which will mean, the same starting line-up as the last 3 Matches.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 08 Apr 14 4.01pm


Haven't you heard, the £6.5million man who scored against Villa earlier this season has just scored 5 goals in the U21. His time has arrived

 

It's only a game Flag Praa Sands 08 Apr 14 4.13pm

Quote adrian b at 08 Apr 2014 4.01pm


Haven't you heard, the £6.5million man who scored against Villa earlier this season has just scored 5 goals in the U21. His time has arrived

That is good but TP will stick with a winning team who have done everything asked of them. Gayle will have to bide his time.

 


A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!


adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 08 Apr 14 4.41pm

Quote It's only a game at 08 Apr 2014 4.13pm

Quote adrian b at 08 Apr 2014 4.01pm


Haven't you heard, the £6.5million man who scored against Villa earlier this season has just scored 5 goals in the U21. His time has arrived

That is good but TP will stick with a winning team who have done everything asked of them. Gayle will have to bide his time.

The time has now been bided. Now's Gayles moment has arrived. Has scored in the U21, has scored against Villa already, is now fully fit, and......Vills are down and out. This is the time.

 

Master Coin Flag 08 Apr 14 4.51pm

Yes, we've had some great results in the last couple of games, however Chamakh's cameo on Saturday against Cardiff highlighted his obvious quality. He is a cut above most of the players in our squad and I'd be surprised if he was left out.

Sure, there is the old adage about not changing a winning team, however I think you can make exceptions when it massively improves the line-up. Not putting Chamakh straight back in for the Cardiff game made sense (not rushing him back and easing him in with a substitute appearance after an injury layoff) however no real excuse for leaving him out now.

 

Sparkie Flag Epping 08 Apr 14 4.58pm

As much as I want Cham in the side I say stick with the same team, would be harsh on anyone to be dropped right now.....at least we have Cham and Gayle to come on if and when needed.....Would be great to get a few results the next few games and then get the likes of Gayle some game time.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 08 Apr 14 5.02pm


Now's the time for Gayle. The team against Cardiff was to beat Cardiff. Now the team v Villa is to do just that. There's no Benteke so, with Agihoor misfiring, perhaps the time has come to chuck the kitchen sink at them.

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 14 5.41pm

Quote I'mPalace Till I Die at 08 Apr 2014 2.59pm

Take KG out (I know he has had some good games recently) and put Ledley in his place. Then put Chamakh in just behind Jerome. That would be the best option. If we are trailing behing Ledley can be less defensive and attack a little more

This
Ledley's best position is sitting in the centre alongside Jedi. Right now he is being a true pro and carrying out a job he is being asked to do. I would bet that once Pulis has a striker and supporting striker of his choice (ie someone that he signed for the position) Ledley will slot back in to where he belongs.


 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 08 Apr 14 6.22pm

Quote I'mPalace Till I Die at 08 Apr 2014 2.59pm

Take KG out (I know he has had some good games recently) and put Ledley in his place. Then put Chamakh in just behind Jerome. That would be the best option. If we are trailing behing Ledley can be less defensive and attack a little more

Sounds interesting to me and I would certainly give it a go!!!>

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 09 Apr 14 2.59am

It's nice to have so many options - competition for places a virtually fully fit squad. Villa are struggling to find 11 first team players.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 09 Apr 14 7.32am

I'd keep the team that was on the pitch as Chamakh came on for Bolasie, i.e. keep KG on and play Ledley on the left, with Bolasie held in reserve.

Never thought I'd be saying that about KG a couple of weeks ago.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 09 Apr 14 9.48am

On the Injuries list we are credited with having the following number of injured players: 0

Nevertheless, given he limped off only a few days ago, is Ledley fully fit?

 

Plane Flag Bromley 09 Apr 14 9.54am

Quote adrian b at 08 Apr 2014 4.01pm


Haven't you heard, the £6.5million man who scored against Villa earlier this season has just scored 5 goals in the U21. His time has arrived

Oh dear, got the price wrong Ade, pay more attention next time

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 09 Apr 14 2.25pm

Fcuk me Plane, he cost lots. That's enough said. And the name is AIDS, like the illness.

 

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 09 Apr 14 2.34pm

Stick with the same team until we are safe. Then we can try another and more adventerous approach. If we should change something from our last two fantastic games it should be to let Gayle get some gametime ahead of Murray.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley or Chamakh in Starting Line up