This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Howard Webb vs Palace
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Jonny_Johnson Tel Aviv 28 Apr 14 1.10am |
|
|
How sad it was to go into a match knowing that we would be playing against twelve..
Howard Webb is without failure the most duplicitous and unscrupulous referee in this country. He consistently favours the 'big' clubs (of which we will never be) and has no qualms about it whatsoever. The entire stadium were in unanimity at one point.
Judging by his performances vs Southampton and Villa it was clear that it would be an uphill struggle. That is not to say that Man City were not worthy winners; they were clearly a cut above us. But, we do not have to duly lose a match to have been swindled by a referees' performance.
Having said that, there is absolutely no recourse on the matter; we will continue to get him next season and suffer the consequences.
[Link]
|
Username Horsham 28 Apr 14 7.46am |
|
|
I thought he had a good game yesterday, despite the protestations of one particular person in the Holmesdale Upper.
Not sure what he did wrong?
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.
|
We are goin up! Coulsdon 28 Apr 14 8.15am |
|
|
His previous performances were shocking but I thought he did OK yesterday, not that he had many decisions to make.
The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.
|
indianapalace85 Bromley 28 Apr 14 8.19am |
|
Quote We are goin up! at 28 Apr 2014 8.15am
His previous performances were shocking but I thought he did OK yesterday, not that he had many decisions to make.
And the ones he did make were all wrong. One of them was a clear throw-in to us as it came off the Chelsea player's shoulder and he gave them the throw instead.
As per usual, Webb and the linesman just look at each other like gormless idiots and then just decide they'll give it to the big club.
Knowing our luck, we'll have him for Liverpool too, in which case we may as well hand them the 3 points now.
Edited by indianapalace85 (28 Apr 2014 8.20am)
Edited by indianapalace85 (28 Apr 2014 8.21am)
|
Bitter Harpenden 28 Apr 14 8.22am |
|
Quote indianapalace85 at 28 Apr 2014 8.19am
Quote We are goin up! at 28 Apr 2014 8.15am
His previous performances were shocking but I thought he did OK yesterday, not that he had many decisions to make.
And the ones he did make were all wrong. One of them was a clear throw-in to us as it came off the Chelsea players shoulder and he gave them a throw.
As per usual, Webb and the linesman just look at each other like gormlous idiots and then just decide they'll give it to the big club. If it came off a Chelsea player's shoulder, who should he have given it to, Palace or Man City?!
|
merganser 28 Apr 14 12.40pm |
|
|
IMO he had a good match - kept the game flowing.
Disagree that he is biased towards top clubs
|
hibbystu tadworth 28 Apr 14 12.45pm |
|
|
The obvious time wasting by s***ty when subbing went unchallenged and only 3 mins where added for 6 substitutions
I support Scotland, Hibs and the Palace, no glory hunters here!!!!!!
PLEASE SIR, CAN I HAVE A PIE!!
|
blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 28 Apr 14 12.47pm |
|
|
If Webb is supposed to be one of Britain's best then God help us. He is totally inconsistent and for some reason that I cannot explain he is right on top of situations and then makes the wrong decision. While he might have been less incompetent yesterday I think his track record this season stinks.
|
Westina 28 Apr 14 12.54pm |
|
|
The idiot in holmesdale upper tier is in our row.he always abuses the ref whoever it is and uses foul and abusive language. don't get me wrong we all have a moan at the ref but this bloke is beyond belief and nearly got a thump yesterday. He was also moaning about the lack of home support yesterday. The bloke is a real nuisance and needs banning...
|
passifid Brighton 28 Apr 14 12.57pm |
|
|
from what i saw he was mostly good yesterday, and more importantly i believe he enjoyed himself(several smiles at players)which is why i think it was kept so fair
there WERE times i thought that should be a foul etc, but then i remembered that he didn't give ne for a similar incident for us too so it was overall ok
|
Coach 3 Sandown Isle of Wight 28 Apr 14 1.28pm |
|
|
Couldn't get to the game yesterday due to illness so watched it on TV and had the benefit of replays not available in the stadium. I'd say on the day Webb got all the decisions basically right, unlike the Southampton game.
However, having said that one thing did come across, He was very quick to book Palace players but very slow to do the same to City players. Deliberate hanball, free kick rightly given but no card shown, tackle from behind (Milner on Ward) no card shown but when Ward did the same card out no problem. Mr Webb is very friendly with players from the "bigger" clubs and various England internationals, came out at half time laughing and joking with some of the City team but is stand offish with our players.
He does not overtly favour big teams, but clearly certain players get a good deal more from him than others. Bolasie would have to almost hit over the head with a brick to get much from him while Southamptons Llanana only has to give him a sideways look to get a free kick.
With luck he will cock up a major game in the world cup and be found out.
|
Eagles83 London 28 Apr 14 1.30pm |
|
|
I disagree with this - I actually think he got most of the obvious decisions right vs Aston Villa and yesterday vs Man City. I am clearly a Palace fan, but to get the Bolasie and handball decisions SPOT on as he did in the Villa game when the home crowd is on his back justifies his position as the leading referee in the EPL. Watching the game yesterday admittedly there was the odd decision which did not go our way. I think across the 2 games I have no reason to think that we are playing against 12 men at all.
|
trapperjohn Horsham 28 Apr 14 1.45pm |
|
Quote Coach 3 at 28 Apr 2014 1.28pm
Couldn't get to the game yesterday due to illness so watched it on TV and had the benefit of replays not available in the stadium. I'd say on the day Webb got all the decisions basically right, unlike the Southampton game.
However, having said that one thing did come across, He was very quick to book Palace players but very slow to do the same to City players. Deliberate hanball, free kick rightly given but no card shown, tackle from behind (Milner on Ward) no card shown but when Ward did the same card out no problem. Mr Webb is very friendly with players from the "bigger" clubs and various England internationals, came out at half time laughing and joking with some of the City team but is stand offish with our players.
He does not overtly favour big teams, but clearly certain players get a good deal more from him than others. Bolasie would have to almost hit over the head with a brick to get much from him while Southamptons Llanana only has to give him a sideways look to get a free kick.
With luck he will cock up a major game in the world cup and be found out.
I don't disagree with any of this, but I think that is part of playing to the referee, which you have to do in any sport. It is probably more true in the PL where there is a smaller pool of refs, so you do get the same one more frequently. Llanana was most certainly in his ear - hopefully our players will learn to do the same and have a chat and a joke with him as well. Perhaps that is already happening as I thought that he was much better v Villa than v Southampton; and prob better again yesterday. Whether that is right, is debatable, but if that is the way it is - then you need to adapt and try to use it to your advantage.
We now have another season to do this and for him to get to know OUR players as well. Will we start getting the same favours as the big 6 ? - probably not; but we may against other mid table and lower teams.
I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.
|
Ashford Eagle Folkestone, Kent 28 Apr 14 1.52pm |
|
Quote Coach 3 at 28 Apr 2014 1.28pm
Couldn't get to the game yesterday due to illness so watched it on TV and had the benefit of replays not available in the stadium. I'd say on the day Webb got all the decisions basically right, unlike the Southampton game.
However, having said that one thing did come across, He was very quick to book Palace players but very slow to do the same to City players. Deliberate hanball, free kick rightly given but no card shown, tackle from behind (Milner on Ward) no card shown but when Ward did the same card out no problem. Mr Webb is very friendly with players from the "bigger" clubs and various England internationals, came out at half time laughing and joking with some of the City team but is stand offish with our players.
He does not overtly favour big teams, but clearly certain players get a good deal more from him than others. Bolasie would have to almost hit over the head with a brick to get much from him while Southamptons Llanana only has to give him a sideways look to get a free kick.
With luck he will cock up a major game in the world cup and be found out.
Pretty much spot on with that assessment. Very quick to book our players and not so quick with the opposition. He didn't have a great deal to do other than that but I do wonder why he kept pointing at his watch for the substitutions and then added the standard 3. It's about time players were cautioned for taking so long to depart and if they have already been booked - tough! Give them a red and abort the change! As a minimum at least add time on!
|
jcreedy 28 Apr 14 1.58pm |
|
|
Whenever I watch him referee, it always seems to be about him, when it should just be about the football.
It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.
- John Bostock (Nov 2007)
|
joe_cpfc Basingstoke 28 Apr 14 2.08pm |
|
|
Can't stand the bloke and the way his tongue is so far up the famous players arses oh and that he's a terrible ref but I must say I thought he had a half decent game yesterday for once.
|
paperhat croydon 28 Apr 14 3.06pm |
|
Quote Westina at 28 Apr 2014 12.54pm
The idiot in holmesdale upper tier is in our row.he always abuses the ref whoever it is and uses foul and abusive language. don't get me wrong we all have a moan at the ref but this bloke is beyond belief and nearly got a thump yesterday. He was also moaning about the lack of home support yesterday. The bloke is a real nuisance and needs banning...
And when you complained about him the stewards said what?
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
Username Horsham 28 Apr 14 3.32pm |
|
Quote Westina at 28 Apr 2014 12.54pm
The idiot in holmesdale upper tier is in our row.he always abuses the ref whoever it is and uses foul and abusive language. don't get me wrong we all have a moan at the ref but this bloke is beyond belief and nearly got a thump yesterday. He was also moaning about the lack of home support yesterday. The bloke is a real nuisance and needs banning...
He's been sat near me for a few years now. Sometimes he can be (accidentally) funny. The problem is that he just hates Webb and is convinced there is an FA conspiracy against us. Even when he gave us a decision you got 'I'm surprised you saw that you tosser' or something. Yesterday was by far the worse it's been.
Doesn't bother me too much but I can see a few people around him getting agitated.
Still think Webb had a decent game, got the big decisions right and there were couple of bits of good refereeing such as coming back and booking players after letting the advantage go on for a minute or so.
Southampton was shocking and now the bloke can't win. People complained yesterday when he played advantage and Puncheon found Jerome 20 yards out in a position where a better first touch would have had him in on goal. They wanted the free kick. In the second half he pulled play back when we had possession and the same people complained again!
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.
|
bubble wrap Carparks in South East London 28 Apr 14 3.36pm |
|
|
Webb clearly shows a bias towards the bigger clubs, They heap huge pressure on Refs who know that mistakes against top sides are put under the microscope but quickly forgotten against the lesser sides. Fergie, Wenger, Mourinho are masters at manipulating refs.
|
Part Time James 28 Apr 14 3.41pm |
|
|
Watched the first half on TV. Shame on me for turning it off but we're safe and didn't really play football worth watching in the first half.
From my point of view on the sofa, Webb made a few decisions in the game that looked wrong and without the benefit of a TV replay, I can see why the fans were Tweeting about what a 'mare he was having. But I hate to say it(as I think it was Coach 3 said) with the benefit of TV replays I didn't see him get anything significantly wrong in the first half. In fact I struggle to name anything he got wrong. I thought he'd made some mistakes against Villa (namely in his giving of advantages, NOT in the lack of penalties we all wanted and thought we'd been given) but in the first 45 minutes of the Man City game I don't have any complaints.
In fact, if he was able to get these decisions right without the TV replays that I was privy to at home, he did a pretty damn good job.
I'd love to slate the guy, I'm not a fan of him at all, but I couldn't criticise him for the things everyone else was shouting about.
|