You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > [SPOILERS] Star Wars VII
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

[SPOILERS] Star Wars VII


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
coulsdoneagle Flag London 18 Dec 15 8.57am

[Major Spoilers]

What do we think? As a Star Wars nut I was quite happy with it, it was basically a remake of episode 4 but it was good.

Thought John Boyega was excellent, and was a funny Han type to have the mantel passed to! As for his charecter it's a bit strange, all the promotion for the film show him with saber and suggest he is a Jedi trainee but it seems like he isn't even majorly force sensitive, the only suggestion was when Kylo Renn looked at him after the slaughter and said there was an awakening later. Maybe he will pick up the mantel in VIII.

Daisy was a cool charecter. She seemed clunky in her delivery and a bit awkward at first but picked up as the film wore on. Seemed like overnight she became a sick head Jedi and managed to smash a trained Dark Jedi. But promising for the series over all.

The oldies all did their bit and I'm glad it was very much a mantel passing film, Luke looked cool and it's sad to see Han go but we always knew it's what Harrison ford wanted. Thought they should have done something like given Finn his jacket or DL - 44 blaster and had a bit of continuity.

Thought BB-8 was really quite funny and the thumbs up scene with Finn was a good laugh. C3-PO was annoying as was the R2 plot device where he wakes up from sleeping with the plans to find Luke.

Kylo/Ben was a great baddie, although he went from Being hugely powerful to being schooled by Rey. It will be interesting to see what happens with him. Did Han turn on the saber to stop him from having to kill his dad or not?

Supreme leader Snooke looked crap. Cgi looked bad on that. Should have gone for makeup and prosthetics it's always better. He looked like a monster out of the hobbit.

Poe Dameron had the potential to be a far cooler charecter than he was. He started great with sharp lines and the chemistry between him and Finn was great as a pupil/teacher vibe. But then we had nothing from him until a very forgettable couple of Space fighting scenes. Including the last one which had nothing on any flying scenes from any movie 1-6.

The other villains were very forgettable and the only one who seemed interesting was the nameless one Finn fought with a saber, that should have been Phasma and given her outfit some actual use and made her like a new boba

Still bugged about the Finn force sensitive issue!


All in all pretty enjoyable. 8/10 I'm glad it's back.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (18 Dec 2015 9.02am)

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 18 Dec 15 1.15pm

Sorry, can't agree with that.

I thought the film was poor. For the money and effort put into it they come up with a plot line that is practically identical to Episode IV : A New Hope. And that is probably the biggest disappointment.

I thought John Boyega's acting was truly awful, and really hoped his character would be killed off at the end. Another Hayden Christensen in the making.
The lead stormtroopers character was abysmal, still if you hire Game of Thrones actors you deserve all you get.
God knows what has happened to Carrie Fisher, she doesn't sound anything like her previous voice and seems to be acting through gritted teeth.
Pity that Max Von Sydow character didn't last long, he could have been good for the film series.

Not all bad, though :-
The BB8 droid was a good character and Chewbacca was exceptional, thank god they didn't kill him as well.
Daisy Ridley's performance as Rey developed well through the film and by the end, you could see her as an established character.
Kylo Ren's character is good for the film though no idea what this Snoake character is supposed to have come from.
Good to see some returning characters, ie. Admiral Akbar and Nien Nunb but what has happened to Lando and Wedge ?

I read a review from the New York Times last night, and the critic had it spot on. Despite it's flaws (ie. Jar Jar Binks, Hayden Christensen etc), The Force Awkens makes you appreciate the prequels alot more.

The fact that it's Star Wars, the devoted fans will love it anyway.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Dec 15 1.40pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Dec 2015 1.15pm

Sorry, can't agree with that.

I thought the film was poor. For the money and effort put into it they come up with a plot line that is practically identical to Episode IV : A New Hope. And that is probably the biggest disappointment.

I thought John Boyega's acting was truly awful, and really hoped his character would be killed off at the end. Another Hayden Christensen in the making.
The lead stormtroopers character was abysmal, still if you hire Game of Thrones actors you deserve all you get.
God knows what has happened to Carrie Fisher, she doesn't sound anything like her previous voice and seems to be acting through gritted teeth.
Pity that Max Von Sydow character didn't last long, he could have been good for the film series.

Not all bad, though :-
The BB8 droid was a good character and Chewbacca was exceptional, thank god they didn't kill him as well.
Daisy Ridley's performance as Rey developed well through the film and by the end, you could see her as an established character.
Kylo Ren's character is good for the film though no idea what this Snoake character is supposed to have come from.
Good to see some returning characters, ie. Admiral Akbar and Nien Nunb but what has happened to Lando and Wedge ?

I read a review from the New York Times last night, and the critic had it spot on. Despite it's flaws (ie. Jar Jar Binks, Hayden Christensen etc), The Force Awkens makes you appreciate the prequels alot more.

The fact that it's Star Wars, the devoted fans will love it anyway.


He's about 104 years old. How many more films do you think are in him?

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 18 Dec 15 1.46pm

Christopher Lee would have been around 80 when he made his appearances in the prequels.

Obviously, it wouldn't have been major parts in the film series but little cameos. I suppose it all depends on the actors opinion, some love to appear in films later in life, whilst others retire from it completely.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 18 Dec 15 4.38pm

Disagree about John Boyega, thought he did very well and it was Daisy that looks like the weak link. Thought they didn't develop any of the characters enough. Yeah it was a re skin of episode 4 that I agree with but I think it's more like a franchise reboot than a sequel, hopefully will diverge far more with the next film. Main gripe is with the forgettable flying scenes and the sudden change of Rey from a scrap collector to a match for a trained force sensitive rogue Jedi.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 18 Dec 15 4.41pm

Also wedge the actor doesn't want much to do with Star Wars. Still thought they could have mentioned him. As for Lando perhaps episode 8? After all that's episode 5 that he was introduced in first time round

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 18 Dec 15 5.47pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Dec 2015 1.15pm

Sorry, can't agree with that.

I thought the film was poor. For the money and effort put into it they come up with a plot line that is practically identical to Episode IV : A New Hope. And that is probably the biggest disappointment.

I thought John Boyega's acting was truly awful, and really hoped his character would be killed off at the end. Another Hayden Christensen in the making.
The lead stormtroopers character was abysmal, still if you hire Game of Thrones actors you deserve all you get.
God knows what has happened to Carrie Fisher, she doesn't sound anything like her previous voice and seems to be acting through gritted teeth.
Pity that Max Von Sydow character didn't last long, he could have been good for the film series.

Not all bad, though :-
The BB8 droid was a good character and Chewbacca was exceptional, thank god they didn't kill him as well.
Daisy Ridley's performance as Rey developed well through the film and by the end, you could see her as an established character.
Kylo Ren's character is good for the film though no idea what this Snoake character is supposed to have come from.
Good to see some returning characters, ie. Admiral Akbar and Nien Nunb but what has happened to Lando and Wedge ?

I read a review from the New York Times last night, and the critic had it spot on. Despite it's flaws (ie. Jar Jar Binks, Hayden Christensen etc), The Force Awkens makes you appreciate the prequels alot more.

The fact that it's Star Wars, the devoted fans will love it anyway.


Although, I thought more of the film than you, I felt it took awhile to get going. I can agree with most of this especially the Daisy vs John's acting bit.

As my family left the cinema we all said when will the dark side learn not to build large spherical bases with super weapons and trenches.

As with the prequels the audience is probably meant to be a lot younger than me and so I leave you with my 7 year old thoughts, which was "I really liked that!"

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Bekken Flag 18 Dec 15 7.20pm


What's Star Wars? *yawn*

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 18 Dec 15 9.18pm

I thought it was really good actually.

Obviously the biggest flaw was the huge plot similarities with Episode IV. Don't think there's much potential for repeat in the following instalments now Han's dead and hopefully as a whole the trilogy will work really well.

I disagree with previous posters about John Boyega (Finn). I thought he acted really well. His fear at the start was convincing and part of the reasons why I thought the first third was the best written and directed part of the film. Daisy Ridley (Rey) was a touch unconvincing but really grew into the role.
I did think it was really bizarre that Finn was hyped up as being the Jedi and then Rey seemed to be the one with the force. Strange marketing. I'd quite like them both to end up as Jedi.

The old characters came in pretty well but some of the new ones were forgettable. The alien in the green island, Maz Kanata (had to look it up) didn't seem all that special to me so I hope she's ditched. Supreme Leader Snoke and the ginge General weren't at all threatening or convincing. Who is Snoke? He'll probably get given some backstory as being Palpatine's former lover or something to make his power seem credible.

Kylo Ren was interesting but some critics are bigging him up as being the best Star Wars villain ever which is nonsense. He was good. I liked the concept of him being a Vader fanboy, that's a clever idea actually.

But overall it was great, the actors played really well off each other, the nostalgia was nice and the action good.

I honestly don't like JJ Abrams much. His Star Trek films are frankly a bit average and I'm glad he's not directing the next one (for now!). He has set up the new mythology of this trilogy really well though and I'm looking forward to the new films!

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Hoof Hearted 19 Dec 15 12.13pm

Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) looked gorgeous in Star Wars VI

[Link]

Carrie Fisher was on Graham Norton's show last night....

[Link]

She's aged badly... bless her.

[Link]

The things they sell on eBay........ LOL

Edited by Hoof Hearted (21 Dec 2015 10.11am)

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 20 Dec 15 4.02pm

6.5 out of 10 for me...thats two disappointments in Spectre and now The Force Awakens...tried to fit in too much in too short a space...which left the plot feeling clunky and 'forced' (see what I did there). Finng grew on me by the end and BB8 was great...was there much point in having Lea and Luke in it?

The best thing was that it felt like Episode iV rather than being too CGI heavy and as such I hope they retain that balance for the next two.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 20 Dec 15 6.05pm

Just back from the Platinum cinema in Dubai, thought the film was excellent.....view it for what it is, a proper adventure and don't over analyse it...just enjoy!!

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 20 Dec 15 9.01pm

Quote the silurian at 20 Dec 2015 6.05pm

Just back from the Platinum cinema in Dubai, thought the film was excellent.....view it for what it is, a proper adventure and don't over analyse it...just enjoy!!


yeah the geeks will never be satisfied

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 21 Dec 15 7.56am

Quote the silurian at 20 Dec 2015 6.05pm

Just back from the Platinum cinema in Dubai, thought the film was excellent.....view it for what it is, a proper adventure and don't over analyse it...just enjoy!!


This...I watched it Zurich last night and loved it,followed by a Fondue and schnapps,I loved that too.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 21 Dec 15 10.54pm

Thought it was was enjoyable, well written and quite well acted until the last half an hour. I liked all the nods to days gone by (Finn in the Falcons turret, stormtrooper TK338 getting a name check, Han Solo admitting that there's always a way to blow the big uber base up etc).

However, the climax was uninspiring apart from the unexpected patricide by Kylo Ren (who needs to keep his mask on if he wants to look and sound badass).

7.5 / 10.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 22 Dec 15 12.52pm

It was decent, unfortunately I'll never know fully how much I could have enjoyed it as my b****** of a little brother took great pleasure in telling me the Han Solo twist the day before. I spent most of the film trying to work out whether I thought the girl was incredible or slightly above average. I'm still not sure.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 23 Dec 15 1.04am

When making VII, JJ was very unashamed in saying he wanted it to feel like A New Hope, as he wanted to recreate the experience he had watching that as a child for a new generation, whilst knowing that (most of) the original generation would hopefully appreciate it too.

Whether you think that is a good or bad thing is obviously subjective.

The other argument is that the basic framework of that narrative is a great story. A nobody plucked from obscurity to go on a quest with destiny, accompanied by a wise old sage to defeat evil. Lord Of The Rings, Harry Potter, King Arthur & countless others all use it... It wasn't a fresh idea when A New Hope used it.

As for Rey being revealed as the potential Jedi, and not Fin as per the marketing... That's called holding something back.
JJ is all about the mystery, misleading & the reveal. And there's TWO more parts to go.

Have to agree on Snoke though... That whole concept didn't work. In the script he was much more obscured/hooded/mysterious like the Emperor. Shame.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Blue'n'red Flag Field of Chels (Orpington) 23 Dec 15 2.13am

I got told about the Han Solo twist/death the night before too so was expecting that ... Still jumped when Han got light-sabred though!
It at times that I was watching a compression/mash up of the original trilogy (parts 4-6) ... Death Star/tunnel chase, father and son reveal ... The son losing a limb.
I have a hunch that Rey and Kylo Ren are siblings ... Why not play the separated at birth thing again ... Kylo also told Rey that Han was the father she never had, after Han's death ... Leia embraced Rey in a mother's hug.
However the flashbacks upon touching the light sabre could mean she's Luke's child?
Where were the republic? We saw the resistance.
Which planets were destroyed by the star killer?
Why did they park the falcon at the bottom of the steps? Unnecessary scenic footage?

LOVED the jokes from BB8, chewwie's conversation with the nurse and Kylo's reference to clones.
Storm troopers still cannot shoot straight!!!

Edited by Blue'n'red (23 Dec 2015 2.14am)

 


They say hard work never hurt anyone ... but why take a chance?

Jamesrichards8 Flag 23 Dec 15 2.59am

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Dec 2015 1.15pm

Sorry, can't agree with that.

I thought the film was poor. For the money and effort put into it they come up with a plot line that is practically identical to Episode IV : A New Hope. And that is probably the biggest disappointment.

I thought John Boyega's acting was truly awful, and really hoped his character would be killed off at the end. Another Hayden Christensen in the making.
The lead stormtroopers character was abysmal, still if you hire Game of Thrones actors you deserve all you get.
God knows what has happened to Carrie Fisher, she doesn't sound anything like her previous voice and seems to be acting through gritted teeth.
Pity that Max Von Sydow character didn't last long, he could have been good for the film series.

Not all bad, though :-
The BB8 droid was a good character and Chewbacca was exceptional, thank god they didn't kill him as well.
Daisy Ridley's performance as Rey developed well through the film and by the end, you could see her as an established character.
Kylo Ren's character is good for the film though no idea what this Snoake character is supposed to have come from.
Good to see some returning characters, ie. Admiral Akbar and Nien Nunb but what has happened to Lando and Wedge ?

I read a review from the New York Times last night, and the critic had it spot on. Despite it's flaws (ie. Jar Jar Binks, Hayden Christensen etc), The Force Awkens makes you appreciate the prequels alot more.

The fact that it's Star Wars, the devoted fans will love it anyway.


Agree with everything you've said. Snoake is straight out of the guardians of the galaxy. Not star wars esque at all. I thought the whole thing was pretty bland and disappointing. Say what you will about the prequels- they were cheesy awkward and at times embarrasing, but they never felt the need to completely alter the characters that we know and love. This new one had none of the stupidity of the prequel films but lacked fun and any of the trademark star wars archetypes.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 23 Dec 15 8.18am

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 23 Dec 2015 2.59am

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Dec 2015 1.15pm

Sorry, can't agree with that.

I thought the film was poor. For the money and effort put into it they come up with a plot line that is practically identical to Episode IV : A New Hope. And that is probably the biggest disappointment.

I thought John Boyega's acting was truly awful, and really hoped his character would be killed off at the end. Another Hayden Christensen in the making.
The lead stormtroopers character was abysmal, still if you hire Game of Thrones actors you deserve all you get.
God knows what has happened to Carrie Fisher, she doesn't sound anything like her previous voice and seems to be acting through gritted teeth.
Pity that Max Von Sydow character didn't last long, he could have been good for the film series.

Not all bad, though :-
The BB8 droid was a good character and Chewbacca was exceptional, thank god they didn't kill him as well.
Daisy Ridley's performance as Rey developed well through the film and by the end, you could see her as an established character.
Kylo Ren's character is good for the film though no idea what this Snoake character is supposed to have come from.
Good to see some returning characters, ie. Admiral Akbar and Nien Nunb but what has happened to Lando and Wedge ?

I read a review from the New York Times last night, and the critic had it spot on. Despite it's flaws (ie. Jar Jar Binks, Hayden Christensen etc), The Force Awkens makes you appreciate the prequels alot more.

The fact that it's Star Wars, the devoted fans will love it anyway.


Agree with everything you've said. Snoake is straight out of the guardians of the galaxy. Not star wars esque at all. I thought the whole thing was pretty bland and disappointing. Say what you will about the prequels- they were cheesy awkward and at times embarrasing, but they never felt the need to completely alter the characters that we know and love. This new one had none of the stupidity of the prequel films but lacked fun and any of the trademark star wars archetypes.

I'll see you and raise you this:

Finn - we can just "use the force!"
Han - no no thats not how it works!
Chewie - graaaag! (actually that's exactly how it works...)

Worked for me :-)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > [SPOILERS] Star Wars VII