You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Switzerland to give citizens £1700 a month
November 22 2026 1.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Switzerland to give citizens £1700 a month


sitdownstandup Flag 31 Jan 16 7.50pm

well they're going to vote on it anyway...

[Link]

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 31 Jan 16 8.13pm

Believe this payment intended to replace all other state benefits. In which case my initial thought was that only anyone without having either rent/mortgage to pay could live on £1700 per month - unless they also worked or had other income -private pension - or similar. Biggest plus would be saving of millions in cost of administration over present benefit system being a universal set payment to all. Can't see it ever happening - certainly not in UK.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 31 Jan 16 10.05pm

I consider myself hard working and reasonable, in regards to views on life, people etc

Sure, it would the nation happier - you would hope stress would decrease, crime too. But, it may change attitudes over time, for the worse.

Why bother working, education etc will be some peoples views.

For me, i would probably, in all honesty do a lot more charity work, volunteer and work part time in a sociable, fun environment.

Do not under estimate boredom, people will get bored with no job. Health may change, people become lazy, it's dangerous territory.

I would rather they invested that money in housing benefits so that everyone has the chance to live in a respectable dwelling.

 


This was once a quality forum....

johnfirewall Flag 31 Jan 16 10.32pm

Would this not be discriminatory if it only applied to residents, the same grounds which prevented us from restricting benefits to EU migrants? Might be a bit suspicious if I suddenly turn up with a Swiss passport...

Edited by johnfirewall (31 Jan 2016 10.36pm)

 

lankygit Flag Lincoln 01 Feb 16 8.40am

Originally posted by johnfirewall

Would this not be discriminatory if it only applied to residents, the same grounds which prevented us from restricting benefits to EU migrants? Might be a bit suspicious if I suddenly turn up with a Swiss passport...

Edited by johnfirewall (31 Jan 2016 10.36pm)

It probably would if Switzerland was an EU member state, but it isn`t.

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Feb 16 9.51am

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

well they're going to vote on it anyway...

[Link]

I kind of like this idea, where in rather than having a complex system of benefits and claims, which the state may or may not make easy or difficult to claim and employing an entire government department to calculate, adjudicate, enforce etc the state makes a simple payment to all citizens based on a realistic standard of living, agreed by all - Tax Free.

Would it make people lazier or less likely to work - I doubt it, in the long run. Most people have ambition enough to seek work and income in excess of 'basic living costs' etc.

Of course there is the question of how many government jobs this would eliminate (but at least they'd know what their entitled to and could avoid the nightmare slog that is trying to get benefits paid, on time). The red tape and beauracracy around benefit claims is pretty poor, and borders on being Kafkaesque at times.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnfirewall Flag 01 Feb 16 3.32pm

Originally posted by lankygit

It probably would if Switzerland was an EU member state, but it isn`t.

That's a problem.

Are they accepting many refugees?

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 01 Feb 16 6.40pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I kind of like this idea, where in rather than having a complex system of benefits and claims, which the state may or may not make easy or difficult to claim and employing an entire government department to calculate, adjudicate, enforce etc the state makes a simple payment to all citizens based on a realistic standard of living, agreed by all - Tax Free.

Would it make people lazier or less likely to work - I doubt it, in the long run. Most people have ambition enough to seek work and income in excess of 'basic living costs' etc.

Of course there is the question of how many government jobs this would eliminate (but at least they'd know what their entitled to and could avoid the nightmare slog that is trying to get benefits paid, on time). The red tape and beauracracy around benefit claims is pretty poor, and borders on being Kafkaesque at times.

I was thinking the same, indeed a flat rate would encourage larger families etc. to work as they would get less benefits per head, or less housing if over 18.

Just the figures on the shrinkage in the Civil Service would be interesting. It would make Hoofy happy because there would be less gold plate pensions accruing.

The moral quandary would do you keep some sort of safety net at all?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

johnfirewall Flag 01 Feb 16 7.00pm

Originally posted by pefwin


The moral quandary would do you keep some sort of safety net at all?

For cases where you had say 15 kids and didn't work?

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 01 Feb 16 7.05pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

For cases where you had say 15 kids and didn't work?


that's what I am asking.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Feb 16 9.58am

Originally posted by johnfirewall

For cases where you had say 15 kids and didn't work?

Interesting question, I'd like to see such a system progress from 'dealing with those exceptions' that predate the shift to the 'mandatory payment' but excluding new additions. At some point people have to become responsible for controlling their own reproduction and that has to be incentivised. Mandatory adoption of children and mandatory sterilisation of men and women who break the rule seems the best solution to me.

But then I'd also be up for randomly sterilisation of 85% of the worlds population as well - In order to bring the 'virus with shoes' that is humanity under control with the minimal amount of cruelty.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Feb 16 10.04am

Originally posted by pefwin

I was thinking the same, indeed a flat rate would encourage larger families etc. to work as they would get less benefits per head, or less housing if over 18.

Just the figures on the shrinkage in the Civil Service would be interesting. It would make Hoofy happy because there would be less gold plate pensions accruing.

The moral quandary would do you keep some sort of safety net at all?

I think if you make exceptions for existing cases going into such a scheme (i.e. families already of an excessive size) and tie the scheme directly to realistic cost of living, it should cover most things.

Also in terms of encouraging people to work, there aren't the barriers that exist with the current system which actually decentivises people getting full time work and is fairly labyrinthine to navigate (you can earn so much, or work so many hours etc).

With a flat rate paid to everyone, income is income (after taxation) no need to worry about whether it will affect your base income. Why wouldn't you work on top of it, there is no incentive not to.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

mr. apollo Flag Somewhere in Switzerland 02 Feb 16 11.07am

2500chf goes nowhere here, don't judge it by UK standards. If you are unemployed you get 80% of your last working wage for 400 working days if you are married, up to a limit of 10,000chf / month. (6500£)

Also you get training to get back into the workplace (for foreigners tends to be German or French).

Interesting idea though, bet it never happens.


Edited by mr. apollo (02 Feb 2016 11.07am)

 



Glad

All

Over


You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Switzerland to give citizens £1700 a month