You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Osborne & Google SHOCKER
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Osborne & Google SHOCKER


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Sportyteacher Flag London 11 Feb 16 6.53pm

Would Google's 3% tax bargain with HMRC amounting to £130m for last decade's worth of profits, lead to a potential conflict of personal/ professional interests with our Chancellor of The Exchequer? Why apparently YES:

[Link]

Oh, and the UK Boss of Google doesn't know what his salary is when quizzed today by Public Accounts Committee:

[Link]

Furthermore, check out the behaviour of his brother not that George may be fully aware of his behaviour:

[Link]

Finally, the next company on the name & shame for calculated tax avoidance is (drumroll) 'come on down, GAP':

[Link]

Nice to know that HMRC and Osborne are doing their very best to maintain essential revenue for our public services....

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Feb 16 7.21pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Nice to know that HMRC and Osborne are doing their very best to maintain essential revenue for our public services....

Remind us how much tax Google paid under the previous Labour administration?

 

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 11 Feb 16 7.26pm


I assume that they paid a legally correct amount under both administrations.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 Feb 16 7.26pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Remind us how much tax Google paid under the previous Labour administration?

That is a moot point. Yes perhaps they should have done more, but talking about what a previous labour government (who were just as neoliberal as any Tory Government)doesn't actually tackle the issue. it is up to George and co to sort it out..

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Feb 16 9.39pm

Originally posted by 20 Spaces Isnt Enoug


I assume that they paid a legally correct amount under both administrations.

Correct but the haters gonna hate.

The rules are the problem, not just in the UK but world wide. The tax laws just haven't kept up with the modern world.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Feb 16 2.14am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Remind us how much tax Google paid under the previous Labour administration?

Shock, horror. Previous Labour goverment, just as cr"p as the current government. What does that tell me? That they are all one and the same, that's all.

I'm tired of politicians using the previous administration as cover for them just doing more of the same with a couple of little tweeks here and there.

It's not about what went before, it's about what they are going to do now. Show us who you are NOW... Oh they have and it's the some ole thing. Self centred polititians in the pockets of big business.

SURPRISE !!!

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Feb 16 2.31am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Correct but the haters gonna hate.

The rules are the problem, not just in the UK but world wide. The tax laws just haven't kept up with the modern world.

^^ Is the right answer..

I have an idea about corporate/global tax.

If a private company trades in four countries or more then it should be considered "Global". Once a company is global, it should have to set a fix amount of income as tax, say 15% (could be a bit less, maybe more). Each country where the company trades gets an equal share of the tax pot. As the company trades in more and more countries, each country of trade still gets and equal share of that 15%.

The more countries a company trades in different countries, the bigger that 15% pot will be. Companies could plan a lot better, their tax costs would be simpler and it would encourage countries to attract investment to get a slice of their profits from the trade they do. It would also be a lot easier for those countries to get the tax they are entitled to as all you would have to do is look at the the overall profit a company is making to know exactly how much tax would be due.

Simple, open and transparent.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Feb 16 3.43am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Remind us how much tax Google paid under the previous Labour administration?

Probably none, but then New Labour might be the worst politic movement since the third reich. I prefer the tory's to blairs betrayal gang.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Only 10 a year!! Flag 12 Feb 16 8.57am

I think people need to see the bigger picture and look at how many people Google employ and how much tax is raised via PAYE/NI as well as them settling their Tax.
They are also a very good employer offering extremely good wages and conditions, their offices at Victoria are amazing.
But then again maybe we should just drive them away and let them set up somewhere else and employ people in another country.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 12 Feb 16 9.17am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

^^ Is the right answer..

I have an idea about corporate/global tax.

If a private company trades in four countries or more then it should be considered "Global". Once a company is global, it should have to set a fix amount of income as tax, say 15% (could be a bit less, maybe more). Each country where the company trades gets an equal share of the tax pot. As the company trades in more and more countries, each country of trade still gets and equal share of that 15%.

The more countries a company trades in different countries, the bigger that 15% pot will be. Companies could plan a lot better, their tax costs would be simpler and it would encourage countries to attract investment to get a slice of their profits from the trade they do. It would also be a lot easier for those countries to get the tax they are entitled to as all you would have to do is look at the the overall profit a company is making to know exactly how much tax would be due.

Simple, open and transparent.

Ok, so how is

a. A country going to attract investment when being able to set your own tax rates is a major way of doing this?

b. A company does 50% of it's business in one country and 10% each in 5 others, but they all get the same share of the pot?

It might well lead to companies paying tax, but all you will do is replace corporate tax avoidance with a reverse Nation based tax non-avoidance - every nation wanting an equal piece of the pie even if their roles are not equal.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 12 Feb 16 10.14am

Originally posted by nickgusset

That is a moot point. Yes perhaps they should have done more, but talking about what a previous labour government (who were just as neoliberal as any Tory Government)doesn't actually tackle the issue. it is up to George and co to sort it out..

That should be the Conservatives motto...

"Making s*** happen....again!"

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 12 Feb 16 10.49am

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

I think people need to see the bigger picture and look at how many people Google employ and how much tax is raised via PAYE/NI as well as them settling their Tax.
They are also a very good employer offering extremely good wages and conditions, their offices at Victoria are amazing.
But then again maybe we should just drive them away and let them set up somewhere else and employ people in another country.

Good post and totally agree.

 

Hoof Hearted 12 Feb 16 10.55am

Originally posted by nickgusset

That is a moot point. Yes perhaps they should have done more, but talking about what a previous labour government (who were just as neoliberal as any Tory Government)doesn't actually tackle the issue. it is up to George and co to sort it out..

It always is when we attack Labour and you rabid left wingers about hypocrisy.

Mentioning Gordon Brown's gold sale gaffe is met with "not that old chestnut".

The simple fact is, tax rules are there to be exploited and everyone tries it on from the man in the street to the corporate giant.

HMRC and the government of the day are usually not as fly or well informed/advised by the likes of Google.

Ranting at Osborne, as if it's his fault big players have created mind boggling corporate structures to limit/avoid taxation is ridiculous.

As soon as a new tax directive is pursued by our government or anyone else, the corporate lawyers and accountants are all over it with loopholes to exploit.

 

DanH Flag SW2 12 Feb 16 10.57am

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

I think people need to see the bigger picture and look at how many people Google employ and how much tax is raised via PAYE/NI as well as them settling their Tax.
They are also a very good employer offering extremely good wages and conditions, their offices at Victoria are amazing.
But then again maybe we should just drive them away and let them set up somewhere else and employ people in another country.

Only employer's NIC is an actual cost on the company though, PAYE and employee's NIC is an income tax.

Employees don't have the same scope to creatively structure their affairs in order to reduce their liability. And the 3% reported is on their profits after they've taken a corporate tax deduction for all salary costs, not just on their revenue.

The public, quite rightly, just want it to be a level playing field. It's not the company's fault for using the laws to their advantage, it's the laws itself.

 

Hoof Hearted 12 Feb 16 11.15am

Originally posted by DanH

Only employer's NIC is an actual cost on the company though, PAYE and employee's NIC is an income tax.

Employees don't have the same scope to creatively structure their affairs in order to reduce their liability. And the 3% reported is on their profits after they've taken a corporate tax deduction for all salary costs, not just on their revenue.

The public, quite rightly, just want it to be a level playing field. It's not the company's fault for using the laws to their advantage, it's the laws itself.

Dan.... you fancy yourself (literally too LOL) as a bit of an accountant no?

Do you have any ideas for designing and creating new future proof tax laws to stop Google and others like them taking the p1ss?

It's all very well criticising the existing laws but many have tried to have wordings that they thought were watertight only to find accountancy firms like KPMG creating ways round them within days of their announcement.

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 12 Feb 16 12.20pm

Originally posted by DanH

Only employer's NIC is an actual cost on the company though, PAYE and employee's NIC is an income tax. But it is payable due to Google employing people on very good terms and conditions.

Employees don't have the same scope to creatively structure their affairs in order to reduce their liability. And the 3% reported is on their profits after they've taken a corporate tax deduction for all salary costs, not just on their revenue.

The public, quite rightly, just want it to be a level playing field. It's not the company's fault for using the laws to their advantage, it's the laws itself.

People need to see the benefits of Google employing people in this country as a whole rather on one particular point.
Incentives are given to all sorts of companies to invest and employ in this country and as long as the benefit outweighs the negatives then surely that is ok. It is only a few weeks ago that 'The Public' were demanding the Government bailed out the steel industry to save jobs.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Feb 16 12.24pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

I think people need to see the bigger picture and look at how many people Google employ and how much tax is raised via PAYE/NI as well as them settling their Tax.
They are also a very good employer offering extremely good wages and conditions, their offices at Victoria are amazing.
But then again maybe we should just drive them away and let them set up somewhere else and employ people in another country.

Lots of Global employers have major hubs in the UK - not only are they good employers, they provide that same PAYE / NI benefit into the coffers via their workforce - They also pay their requisite amount of tax.

If by asking them not to take the piss with their tax affairs people think they will walk away then think again - they wont do it in a million years.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Feb 16 12.34pm

A spokeswoman for Mr Osborne said he was travelling in a private capacity.

Great thread.

They need to find a way of taxing multinational companies on sales in the respective countries. And only allow the dodgy/clever accounting practices to take place in the one country where the HQ is based.

 


Optimistic as ever

Only 10 a year!! Flag 12 Feb 16 12.51pm

Originally posted by The Sash

Lots of Global employers have major hubs in the UK - not only are they good employers, they provide that same PAYE / NI benefit into the coffers via their workforce - They also pay their requisite amount of tax.

If by asking them not to take the piss with their tax affairs people think they will walk away then think again - they wont do it in a million years.


HSBC have moved a huge amount of their workforce to Hong Kong so I am not sure its right to be complacent.

I have worked for a few small to medium sized companies over the years and arranged 'deals' over VAT and Tax, whether this is correct or not those deals kept companies afloat and people in jobs and put money into the Government coffers that they might not have got if they had been hard nosed.

I am sure there were a lot of things taken into consideration including the historical nature of the debt, is it right? not strictly but anyone involved in business or finance knows sometimes you have to negotiate to get deals done and move on.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Feb 16 12.51pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

Ok, so how is

a. A country going to attract investment when being able to set your own tax rates is a major way of doing this?

b. A company does 50% of it's business in one country and 10% each in 5 others, but they all get the same share of the pot?

It might well lead to companies paying tax, but all you will do is replace corporate tax avoidance with a reverse Nation based tax non-avoidance - every nation wanting an equal piece of the pie even if their roles are not equal.

From the company's point of view, this would make it easier. They would know exactly what they have to pay in tax. In addition if a global company wanted to expand into a country, it could do that without increasing it's tax burden, making it attractive to expand and employ people globally.

It would incentivise nations to attract global companies so they could get a share of that global pot. Which in the case of some global companies is billions. Some countries have corporate tax rates so low that the only benefit they get is the handful of people they employ in that country. With my system a each nation would get some revenue from this world company as well as the employment.

National corporate tax rate setting has been a way of attracting companies but it doesn't work. You set a rate and then another country offers a lower rate which is what the problem is in the first place, some countries set a rate so low to get the employment and these companies end up hardly paying anything to anyone, because each nation is competing with is neighbour.

In regards the share of the pot for each country, the problem that is created by each country trying to work out how much tax to charge has lead to the the situation we face now, with companies able to move or hide revenue by claming that they don't do much business in the host country.

Say, as you point out a company does 50% in one country and 10% in the others, the country where the 50% is done will get other benefits, more business in the 50% country, will relate to more employment in that country, with the company not having to worry about how much tax it will pay in one country as opposed to another. This will save that company money as well as the country trying to collect tax.

The share of the pot element could maybe be tweeked in some way if it turms out truly unfair but my suggestion aims to simplify the system for both host nations and companies alike. Encourage expansion and growth by making it easier for companies to set up in many different countries and also it would focus countries wanting corporate investment to use other ways, such as infrastructure improvement, skilled work force, pay rates etc to attract investment.

I'm not a tax expert, this is just an idea. It may have some flaws, I don't know but I think the principle is a good one. We need to treat global companies as just that, global. Imagine you have 50 Corporates all doing business in a particular country. That would add up to some serious tax income for that country. Right now, no one really gets anything at all and we all lose out.

Forcing companpies to pay, 15% here and 2% there and so on ends up with no one getting anything. IT has taken 10 years for our government to get just 130 million out of Google and at what cost to HMRC. What a joke.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Osborne & Google SHOCKER