You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Man U free kick
November 22 2026 8.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Man U free kick


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 23 Feb 16 1.26am

Anyone else can not believe that was not ruled out for offside? Fancy new idea a second wall behind the defending wall, but surely that interferes with play!!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Feb 16 2.32pm

A joke decision.

Someone better sort the refs out sharpish or these will become de rigueur every week.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 16 2.37pm

Originally posted by Stuk

A joke decision.

Someone better sort the refs out sharpish or these will become de rigueur every week.

FC Midtjylland have been using this and as far as I am aware haven't been penalised for it.

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 23 Feb 16 2.43pm

The famous words of Brian Clough come to mind, but these three were blatantly interfering with play and the referee is an idiot.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 16 2.59pm

Originally posted by twist

The famous words of Brian Clough come to mind, but these three were blatantly interfering with play and the referee is an idiot.

All to do with intrepretation regards "Interfering with play" but this is incident is certainly a talking point and I have found it fascinating.I'll will have a chat about this with a referee to see his take on it!!!!

Edited by Willo (23 Feb 2016 3.03pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Feb 16 3.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

FC Midtjylland have been using this and as far as I am aware haven't been penalised for it.

Yes, it's where they got the idea from but I don't really care about the Danish league.

They need to tell the refs here that it's not allowed. Block the view from an onside position, fair enough, but not that.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 16 3.32pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Yes, it's where they got the idea from but I don't really care about the Danish league.

They need to tell the refs here that it's not allowed. Block the view from an onside position, fair enough, but not that.

I did notice that when the ball was actually kicked, the Man Utd players were well outside the 6yd box. Furthermore they were running away from goal and away from where the ball was placed.Also the ball went in over the defensive wall and not over the Man Utd players who had been positioned behind the wall.
Interesting incident !

 

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Feb 16 3.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

I did notice that when the ball was actually kicked, the Man Utd players were well outside the 6yd box. Furthermore they were running away from goal and away from where the ball was placed.Also the ball went in over the defensive wall and not over the Man Utd players who had been positioned behind the wall.
Interesting incident !

Outside the 6 yard box or not, they were all offside and them running away was a further distraction than standing still would've been.

The ball went over the defensive wall but went in to the goal behind where the man u players had been.

Even Louis Van Moan couldn't believe they got away with it.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 16 3.46pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Outside the 6 yard box or not, they were all offside and them running away was a further distraction than standing still would've been.

The ball went over the defensive wall but went in to the goal behind where the man u players had been.

Even Louis Van Moan couldn't believe they got away with it.

They were obviously in an Offside position but it is all down to interpretation with regards to "Interfering with play".Factors to consider is the fact they were not standing still right in front of the keeper but running away from him and not playing the ball.As I say, interesting incident which has caused some debate !

Edited by Willo (23 Feb 2016 3.50pm)

 

essetwentyone Flag london 23 Feb 16 4.30pm

Van Moan said his players checked it out with the ref beforehand and he said it was ok. It was the same ref who gave the pen for Watford after Deaney had warned him what Jedinak was doing at corners. The moral of the story? - chat this ref up beforehand and listen carefully to what the other teams say to him !!

As for the free kick it's offside 100% - it doesn't matter which direction they were running in - they stood in front of the keeper intentionally to block his view.

If the refs do allow this tactic then maybe the defending team should just stand some men in front of this 2nd wall so that they can't run away from goal. There are probably loads of ways to defend this but they will all result in mayhem so the answer is for the refs to give offside every time and stop the tactic.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 16 5.03pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone


As for the free kick it's offside 100% - it doesn't matter which direction they were running in - they stood in front of the keeper intentionally to block his view.

Of course they were in an Offside position but just because one is in this position doesn't necessarily mean one is "Offside". All down to interpretation of "Interfering with play" and "Interfering with opponent"

The ball actually went over the defending wall and in.
If it had gone over the Man Utd players and in maybe the referee would have deemed it "Interfering with play"/ "Interfering with opponent". Just looking it at it from various angles.

Edited by Willo (23 Feb 2016 5.46pm)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 23 Feb 16 10.13pm

The mere fact that they are positioning themselves in that position certainly implies they are "interfering with play" as the only reason is to obstruct the keepers view.

Sometimes I can see talking points but this seems blatant. It's a new one for me, never seen it done before.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Feb 16 11.07pm

I've heard them talking about this on TalkSh1te this evening. Some idiot on there thought it was akin to a player going to the byline or taking a corner, crossing the ball back across the penalty area and then being deemed offside for being in front of the ball. Well, he can obviously only be offide if the ball is then played back towards him; in neither case is he blocking the view of the goalkeeper from incoming attack play. If I hadn't been driving I'd have phoned up and told him it was bollocks.

What disgusted me more about this was that Man U enquired quietly of the ref about whether it would be OK for them to shoot at goal with three men in an offside position interfering with the goalkeeper, but apparently nobody thought to advise the Shrewsbury defence that the laws of Association football were being suspended temporarily. So IMHO the goalkeeper and defenders were perfectly entitled to treat those players as if they were offside and expect a free kick if they interfered with play.

Surely if the ref is asked a question like that the only appropriate answer is to quote the offside law verbatim and then tell the captain that this law will, as usual, be applied.

 


============
The Ferret
============

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Feb 16 11.58am

Originally posted by Stuk

Yes, it's where they got the idea from but I don't really care about the Danish league.

They need to tell the refs here that it's not allowed. Block the view from an onside position, fair enough, but not that.

You can only be adjudged to be offside once the kick is taken. I think that's how it works, is that you block site for as long as possible and then move.

The best thing about the game was how much LVG was making of Man Utd beating Shrewsbury Town. How the mighty have fallen

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Feb 16 1.16pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

You can only be adjudged to be offside once the kick is taken. I think that's how it works, is that you block site for as long as possible and then move.

The best thing about the game was how much LVG was making of Man Utd beating Shrewsbury Town. How the mighty have fallen

That is blindingly obvious, what made you think anyone thought otherwise?

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Feb 16 1.18pm

Originally posted by Stuk

That is blindingly obvious, what made you think anyone thought otherwise?

No idea, I think I was half conscious when I wrote that nonsense. I love the fact that Man Utd have to stoop to such tactics to beat a team that is several leagues below them, struggling for a league win and scrapping to avoid relegation.

They seemed so proud of their win as well.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Feb 16 2.39pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

No idea, I think I was half conscious when I wrote that nonsense. I love the fact that Man Utd have to stoop to such tactics to beat a team that is several leagues below them, struggling for a league win and scrapping to avoid relegation.

They seemed so proud of their win as well.

Reminds me of when I played as a kid and was so proud of knowing the offside rule, that I'd tell the opposition "you're offside, you know?" Which the manager wasn't happy about.

Good point though that they basically have to cheat to beat a bottom half league 1 side.

 


Optimistic as ever

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 24 Feb 16 7.33pm

Well, for a start, they were all in an offside position when the ball was kicked and as for the interfering with play question, of course they were interfering with play – they made no attempt to win the ball, so what was point of them standing there otherwise? I’m no expert, but isn’t deliberately blocking the keeper’s line of sight considered interfering with play? This practice of the attacking side positioning players behind the defensive wall should be stamped out before everyone’s trying it on.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

essetwentyone Flag london 24 Feb 16 8.49pm

Originally posted by Willo

Of course they were in an Offside position but just because one is in this position doesn't necessarily mean one is "Offside". All down to interpretation of "Interfering with play" and "Interfering with opponent"

The ball actually went over the defending wall and in.
If it had gone over the Man Utd players and in maybe the referee would have deemed it "Interfering with play"/ "Interfering with opponent". Just looking it at it from various angles. unquote


Sorry I can't see any reason not to give it offside. Why were three of them standing there and then running - it was obviously intentional. As well as offside it could also be deemed ungentlemanly play !
Whatever - the goal should never have stood!


Edited by essetwentyone (24 Feb 2016 8.50pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 24 Feb 16 9.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

All to do with intrepretation regards "Interfering with play" but this is incident is certainly a talking point and I have found it fascinating.I'll will have a chat about this with a referee to see his take on it!!!!

Edited by Willo (23 Feb 2016 3.03pm)

What was Brian Clough's comment...." I pay players to interfere with playn and if they're not, I want to know why"

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Man U free kick