You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault
November 22 2026 1.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
johnfirewall Flag 05 Apr 16 10.05am

White boys from poor backgrounds have the lowest attainment levels at GCSE than any other social or ethnic group, according to a new report by the equalities watchdog

[Link]

Apparently because our dads don't all hang out with their union mates.

[Link]

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Apr 16 10.09am

Failure of society and a politicisation of education. Whilst Thatcher did introduce series changes to education that started the ball rolling (GCSEs etc) its basically the failure of the last five or six governments to actually address education as a function of developing children, rather than as a means of looking good for elections.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 05 Apr 16 12.10pm

The failure of successive governments to improve education standards is a national scandal. It is even more depressing when people use it as a political football.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 05 Apr 16 12.26pm

By all means lay the blame rightfully at mis-management, inequality and ongoing social ills but I can't stand all this ethnic lumping. It's just divisive. Either you come from a good family with positive role models or you don't.

Either you want to do well at school or for one reason or another you don't/aren't able to. Either your peers are a good influence or they are not and either you are unlucky enough to have been born poor and probably go to a crap school or you are not.

You can't just target whites when it is obvious the problems go beyond skin colour.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


johnfirewall Flag 05 Apr 16 12.31pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The failure of successive governments to improve education standards is a national scandal. It is even more depressing when people use it as a political football.

Surely there are 3 components here which affect the standard of education. Teachers, facilities/resources and the curriculum.

Some teachers aren't very bright themselves and it's claimed they have too much work from too large classes, but isn't what we teach and the way we do it a major factor? It's a big system to shake up.

 

johnfirewall Flag 05 Apr 16 12.33pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

By all means lay the blame rightfully at mis-management, inequality and ongoing social ills but I can't stand all this ethnic lumping. It's just divisive. Either you come from a good family with positive role models or you don't.

Either you want to do well at school or for one reason or another you don't/aren't able to. Either your peers are a good influence or they are not and either you are unlucky enough to have been born poor and probably go to a crap school or you are not.

You can't just target whites when it is obvious the problems go beyond skin colour.

It's an appaling article, (the Guardian one) not least in that suggests us white working class should just stick together. Clearly also resentment of the fact the posh old boys networks are still stronger than those historically maintained by union members.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 16 12.37pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

Surely there are 3 components here which affect the standard of education. Teachers, facilities/resources and the curriculum.

Some teachers aren't very bright themselves and it's claimed they have too much work from too large classes, but isn't what we teach and the way we do it a major factor? It's a big system to shake up.


Biggest problem imo is the test, test and test again regime. We are turning our kids into a great pub quiz team rather than ones that understand critical thinking.

 

johnfirewall Flag 05 Apr 16 12.42pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


Biggest problem imo is the test, test and test again regime. We are turning our kids into a great pub quiz team rather than ones that understand critical thinking.

On the other hand you can't just test them at 16 and realise their particular path of education wasn't working when it's too late.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Apr 16 12.43pm

It all went wrong with the three Rs

Talk about confusing

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Apr 16 3.56pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

White boys from poor backgrounds have the lowest attainment levels at GCSE than any other social or ethnic group, according to a new report by the equalities watchdog

[Link]

Apparently because our dads don't all hang out with their union mates.

[Link]

I think it curious that all failings of modern Britain are blamed on Maggie.

It makes you wonder why she was elected in 1979 - the country must have been a paradise in the seventies. Profitable manufacturing sector, efficient services, high level of home ownership, absolutely no kiddy fiddlers about and you could get a pint in a British pub at anytime of the day.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Apr 16 4.36pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

I think it curious that all failings of modern Britain are blamed on Maggie.

It makes you wonder why she was elected in 1979 - the country must have been a paradise in the seventies. Profitable manufacturing sector, efficient services, high level of home ownership, absolutely no kiddy fiddlers about and you could get a pint in a British pub at anytime of the day.

Maggie out! Personally, I think more damage was actually done under Major and Blair, than Thatcher.

Oddly, I think politicians like Thatcher are quite cohesive in that they bring factions of society closer together, admittedly in protest or admiration. The Miners strike, might well have economically sounded the death knell of mining and mining community, but it also rallied them togeather, along with other social movements.

In truth, I don't think its Thatcher's fault at all - I'd level the blame at the governments of the 90s and early 2000s. Thatcher brought many people together, as was witnessed with her death and passing.

Consumerism of the 90s finally destroyed the idea of youth culture and belonging to society and destroyed the notion of a working class through increasing impoverishment. Some of the issues may have started under Thatcher (housing boom and utility sell offs) but no the governments that followed took action to limit what were by their time obvious problems, in fact they fuelled them and fed on them.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Apr 16 4.47pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

By all means lay the blame rightfully at mis-management, inequality and ongoing social ills but I can't stand all this ethnic lumping. It's just divisive. Either you come from a good family with positive role models or you don't.

Either you want to do well at school or for one reason or another you don't/aren't able to. Either your peers are a good influence or they are not and either you are unlucky enough to have been born poor and probably go to a crap school or you are not.

You can't just target whites when it is obvious the problems go beyond skin colour.

I don't think it's skin colour Kerms, it's background and history. You will find teachers in tough areas confirming that the poor whites are generally doing less well and often more disruptive. We have discussed this at Mapletree Towers due to some direct knowledge of New Addington. I am guessing that the children and grandchildren of immigrants have role models that are highly motivated and competitive. They had the get up and go to emigrate. And most of us have some experience with 'tiger mothers'.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 05 Apr 16 5.34pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

By all means lay the blame rightfully at mis-management, inequality and ongoing social ills but I can't stand all this ethnic lumping. It's just divisive. Either you come from a good family with positive role models or you don't.

Either you want to do well at school or for one reason or another you don't/aren't able to. Either your peers are a good influence or they are not and either you are unlucky enough to have been born poor and probably go to a crap school or you are not.

You can't just target whites when it is obvious the problems go beyond skin colour.

Spot on

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Apr 16 5.54pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I don't think it's skin colour Kerms, it's background and history. You will find teachers in tough areas confirming that the poor whites are generally doing less well and often more disruptive. We have discussed this at Mapletree Towers due to some direct knowledge of New Addington. I am guessing that the children and grandchildren of immigrants have role models that are highly motivated and competitive. They had the get up and go to emigrate. And most of us have some experience with 'tiger mothers'.

White British families without many or any academic qualifications or ability will have by and large been okay after leaving school compared to ethnic minorities with few qualifications and/or limited English. For decades you could get a trade and apprenticeship or just by luck find yourself in a job that aftera few years pays the mortgage. For eample, the local garage might give you a chance or a family friend of a friend. Quite difficult for ethnic minorities to be hired by a local knuckle dragger.

Too many British people take services in this country for granted. Education, hospitals and healthcare, policing etc. Where there is little of these in home countries, they're probably more appreciated. Also if white British people have hardly or never paid tax they don't know the value of education. Or if the safety net is so safe that it has until now provided enough room/rooms, new mobiles and Sky telly, where's the incentive to raise your game?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Apr 16 6.02pm

What I want to know is when do teenagers stop talking like rappers in that manufactured Jafaican accent after they realise it limits their career prospects?

It isn't limited to any race, probably more which school or ability set or social group you're in at school. It's almost a novelty talking to a state school educated teenager who doesn't sound like Tinie Tempah.

There was a documentary on BBC2 on Sunday tracing a SE London family called the Nelsons over a century. The last generation black girl you'd think after hearing her speak in Jafaican and the little interest her unemployed from age 16 Mother showed she'd have no chance. It said at the end she'd passed her A Levels and was going to University.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (05 Apr 2016 6.04pm)

 


COYP

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 16 8.23pm

Poor folk don't do as well in school, jobs, housing and health as well-off folk and really well-off folk (all 68 of them) run everything and pretty much get what they want when they want.

And this is news?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Apr 16 8.25pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Poor folk don't do as well in school, jobs, housing and health as well-off folk and really well-off folk (all 68 of them) run everything and pretty much get what they want when they want.

And this is news?

In 2014 the University of Oxford admitted more girls called Eleanor than students who had received free school meals.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 05 Apr 16 9.09pm

I saw it with my own eyes 15 minutes ago. Black kids with pants around the seat of their pants, rapping, along with all the hand signals. Whilst the studious muslim kids seemed to have their heads buried in their text books getting a head start on their homework. I agree with Rudy most kids are so dumbed down that they all thing they are going to be playing in the NBA or are going to be Raps next big mogul....

 


Pro USA & Israel

Kingvagabond Flag London 06 Apr 16 1.59am

I'm not sure dumbed down is the right term but I would say that the media portrays an idea that if you're young and working class , to escape poverty you need to be a top sportsman (footballer or athlete as other sports are for the rich). Ironically, that's the opposite of the Tory (also dishonest) rhetoric of meritocracy.

What I would also say is that outside of my children with ASD, most disruptions in my classes are caused by white British boys who are pupil premium (what used to be called Free School Meals). Black and Asian children tend to very polite and (mostly) fairly studious. Coincidentally, all of my NQT (and ITT) training was on BME, Asian children, Eastern European children and SEN children. None of whom are struggling in my class. Go figure.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Big Guy Flag 06 Apr 16 7.29am

The reason poor white kids are not doing well in school is cultural not ethnic. The guardian article suggests out that the social cohesion of the poor white community was destroyed by thatcher in the 80s. There is an element of truth to this but only in so far as many poor white folk were unionised and were employed in the manufacturing industries. Many poor white folk were neither. The destruction of the poor white idyll of always being able to leave your door open or popping next door to borrow a cup of sugar had gone long before thatcher said there's no such thing as society, if it ever existed in the first place. No. What destroyed that culture was the success of other cultures more attractive to poor white kids. It could be argued that this started in the wake of the austerity following the Second World War, when music and literature encouraged a generation to rebel against the previous generation's failure to avoid killing each other. Rock n roll, beatniks, the stones, flower power, glam rock, punk rock, new wave, rap.......the list is endless. Nihilism became cool. You reap what you sow.

 


Time to go Alan

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault