You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pundits - Best and Worst - Then and Now
November 22 2026 8.27pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pundits - Best and Worst - Then and Now


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
OldFella Flag London 06 Aug 16 10.44am

Prompted to write this thread by Steve (Schteve) McClaren on TV yesterday evening - must have really wound the Newcastle fans up to hear him pontificating on where they were going wrong!

My current favorites - Gary Neville (come back soon), Jamie Carragher

Worst, i.m.o. - McClaren, Andy Townsend, Trevor Francis

From the old days?

Best - Big Mal, Brian Clough

Worst - Alan Mullery!

How about yours?

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 06 Aug 16 1.39pm

Ian Holloway asked him why Newcastle got relegated and Schteeeve replied "You had better ask Rafa that!". Best; Jonathan Pierce. Worst;Robbie Savage. Ollie's Dad,Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Aug 16 2.09pm

Worst after Claridge are the two Alan's - Shearer and Hansen.
Souness and Gray pretty dire too.
Maybe Neville and Carragher best Duo as they have as they seem to have turned their club differences into differences of opinion and some decent banter.

All of the Presenters are probably worse than the pundits. Lineker is the only one I know the name of as the others are so rubbish I don't want to know their names.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 08 Aug 16 3.59pm

Best - Paul Merson and Gary neville, also Danny Murphy

Worst - Gary Birtles and Peter Beagrie, unbelievably biased.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 08 Aug 16 5.28pm

Can't believe that either someone would choose Merson as the best or Souness as the worst.

Personal opinions obviously, but Hansen went on far too long and Lawrenson is now the worst out there. Deliberately cynical thinking it makes him sound cool.

For the best I think it is between Souness and Neville, although I think that Shearer has improved markedly over the last 12 months (he just needs to improve his delivery) and that Murphy is progressing as well.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

palace64 Flag bromley 08 Aug 16 5.35pm

the only ones i watch are the soccer sat boys but i read the bird from count down is on fridays now its bad enough playing on a friday now the armchair fan has to put up with that

 

Ulysses 08 Aug 16 8.47pm

I remember when ITV had the rights to the Premier League and Andy Townsend had a segment called the Tactics Truck. It was quite possibly the most horrific football-based analysis I've ever seen.

Not a pundit, but I find Clive Tyldesley nauseating. He probably still w***s furiously to the final 2 minutes of the Manchester United 1999 Champions League final - would always find a way to mention it, regardless of the match he was commentating on.

Since he became a regular, Souness has been consistently excellent: articulate, insightful and avoids resorting to cliché.

 

johnno42000 Flag 09 Aug 16 6.42pm

Not very keen on any of the present day 'experts'.

I did used to like Brian Moore.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

corkery Flag Cork City 12 Aug 16 5.02pm

Ramon Dunphy, 'Ronaldo is only a cod.'. 'Never mind him, he left his wife for a young one.'
[Link]

 


We'll never die

Baldfella Flag Wigan 12 Aug 16 5.06pm

Current favourites Merson, Carragher, Neville and Jeff Stelling

Current worse anyone on BT Sport! They'll never beat Soccer Saturday

Always used to like watching Rodney Marsh just to see him wind people up

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Aug 16 5.08pm

Originally posted by corkery

Ramon Dunphy, 'Ronaldo is only a cod.'. 'Never mind him, he left his wife for a young one.'
[Link]

All of the RTE ones are comedy gold. TV3 terrible. Hamman drunk and dishevelled springs to mind.

Anybody in England should really watch the RTE panel - anyone who hasn't seen it would probably be left in awe.

 


Red and Blue Army!

benay Flag Bromley 12 Aug 16 5.14pm

Ron Atkinson surely???

 


I'm a Pepper your a Pepper He's a Pepper She's a Pepper wouldn't you like to be a Pepper!

matthau Flag South Croydon 12 Aug 16 5.15pm

can't beat ol Brian moore

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Aug 16 5.22pm

Crerand, McNab, Dougan and Allison - 1970 World Cup - great fun.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Aug 16 6.25pm

Originally posted by Baldfella

Current favourites Merson, Carragher, Neville and Jeff Stelling

I second this but would add Graeme Souness, Danny Murphy, Alan Smith and Danny Higginbotham.Ian Holloway doesn't do a bad job either !

 

bertshead Flag Castlederg 12 Aug 16 6.29pm

Originally posted by chris123

Crerand, McNab, Dougan and Allison - 1970 World Cup - great fun.

These lot were a brilliant watch and all ITV commentators were pretty good for me, Brian Moore,Gerald Sinstadt and Hugh Johns back in the day.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Aug 16 6.30pm

Originally posted by bertshead

These lot were a brilliant watch and all ITV commentators were pretty good for me, Brian Moore,Gerald Sinstadt and Hugh Johns back in the day.

Absolutely.Pleasant memories.

Another from bygone days 'Des Lynam' who doesn't live far from me.


Edited by Willo (12 Aug 2016 6.38pm)

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 12 Aug 16 6.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

Absolutely.Pleasant memories.

Another from bygone days 'Des Lynam' who doesn't live far from me.


Edited by Willo (12 Aug 2016 6.38pm)

who done the infamous' and now the cock sucker'gaff.?
meant to say cup soccer bt spooner'd it.
7o's presenter. tash.about same time as brian moore.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 12 Aug 16 7.58pm

dickie davis.
just rem !

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

chateauferret Flag 12 Aug 16 10.05pm

Originally posted by Ulysses

I remember when ITV had the rights to the Premier League and Andy Townsend had a segment called the Tactics Truck. It was quite possibly the most horrific football-based analysis I've ever seen.

Not a pundit, but I find Clive Tyldesley nauseating. He probably still w***s furiously to the final 2 minutes of the Manchester United 1999 Champions League final - would always find a way to mention it, regardless of the match he was commentating on.

Since he became a regular, Souness has been consistently excellent: articulate, insightful and avoids resorting to cliché.

There's really nothing more annoying than a commentator who goes out of his way to mention a particular historical occasion donkey's years ago whenever he happens to have access to a microphone. It's only recently when watching England that commentators have stopped banging on about the 1966 World Cup, and that only happened because England have been so sh"te in major competitions. And so instead they're now constantly singing the praises of the 1996 Euros squad, as if they'd actually won something. (They might have done two years later if David Beckham had refrained from kicking Simeone, but this is England, remember - always one button-press away from self-destruct).

It's not as if we talk about the 1990 FA Cup every time AP appears on the screen, is it?

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pundits - Best and Worst - Then and Now