You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jonathan Benteke
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jonathan Benteke


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Zedman Flag Hemel Hempstead 11 Sep 16 9.45pm

Yesterday's result was both pleasing and a relief. Benteke scoring his first goal for the club is an enormous boost. I am fully behind Alan Pardew and Steve Parish because I think we have had an excellent transfer window. Benteke, Townsend, Mandanda are proving their worth already and I am sure Tompkins will do well. For me the signing of Flamini was the icing on the cake. We were all looking for an experienced and classy midfielder and in the Frenchman I think we have the perfect answer. However I am dismayed at the treatment of our Academy players. I was hoping to see our three most promising youngsters get a chance to show their worth this season. Instead Jake Gray goes to Luton on a free and Kaikai and Jerome Boateng are sent to the lower leagues for another season. Out of nowhere Jonathan Benteke appears and comes on against Middlesbrough. How exactly can that happen? We have already named our 25 man squad and as a 21 year old he can't be regarded as an under age player. Or am I missing something? Both Sullay and Jerome must be looking on with a jaundiced eye at this happening. That aside I think we now have a very strong squad and I am looking forward to the visit of Stoke next Sunday. A perfect chance for us to showcase our club on live TV. But then again, this is Palace.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 11 Sep 16 9.49pm

You seem convinced of Boateng's quality yet don't even know his first name

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 11 Sep 16 9.55pm

Originally posted by Zedman

Yesterday's result was both pleasing and a relief. Benteke scoring his first goal for the club is an enormous boost. I am fully behind Alan Pardew and Steve Parish because I think we have had an excellent transfer window. Benteke, Townsend, Mandanda are proving their worth already and I am sure Tompkins will do well. For me the signing of Flamini was the icing on the cake. We were all looking for an experienced and classy midfielder and in the Frenchman I think we have the perfect answer. However I am dismayed at the treatment of our Academy players. I was hoping to see our three most promising youngsters get a chance to show their worth this season. Instead Jake Gray goes to Luton on a free and Kaikai and Jerome Boateng are sent to the lower leagues for another season. Out of nowhere Jonathan Benteke appears and comes on against Middlesbrough. How exactly can that happen? We have already named our 25 man squad and as a 21 year old he can't be regarded as an under age player. Or am I missing something? Both Sullay and Jerome must be looking on with a jaundiced eye at this happening. That aside I think we now have a very strong squad and I am looking forward to the visit of Stoke next Sunday. A perfect chance for us to showcase our club on live TV. But then again, this is Palace.

U21 don't count towards 25 man squad

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 11 Sep 16 9.55pm

Benteke JR was signed for the development squad on a 1 year deal presumably to asses whether he has the necessary skill set to progress be a premier league player like his brother. The guys have gone out on loan to progress their careers as staying with the squad would mean bit part action, if any, with the first team. This all happened before the transfer window closed when we had Remy, Benteke Snr, Wickham all vying for the front man of our squad with Appiah and Campbell on the way back. Since then Remy has gone back to Chelsea and Wickham got a knock keeping him out. That left us with no cover at all for Benteke as Appiah and Campbell are both not fit yet.

I don't see Benteke Jnr. being used often but it was a needs must tbh and I think the other lads are far better off getting a full season of competitive football behind them than the odd minute here and there. I doubt they are bothered as they are focusing on getting into the starting 11 of their current teams to show they have what it takes to get into ours and if they aren't, they should be.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Sep 16 9.58pm

Originally posted by Zedman

Yesterday's result was both pleasing and a relief. Benteke scoring his first goal for the club is an enormous boost. I am fully behind Alan Pardew and Steve Parish because I think we have had an excellent transfer window. Benteke, Townsend, Mandanda are proving their worth already and I am sure Tompkins will do well. For me the signing of Flamini was the icing on the cake. We were all looking for an experienced and classy midfielder and in the Frenchman I think we have the perfect answer. However I am dismayed at the treatment of our Academy players. I was hoping to see our three most promising youngsters get a chance to show their worth this season. Instead Jake Gray goes to Luton on a free and Kaikai and Jerome Boateng are sent to the lower leagues for another season. Out of nowhere Jonathan Benteke appears and comes on against Middlesbrough. How exactly can that happen? We have already named our 25 man squad and as a 21 year old he can't be regarded as an under age player. Or am I missing something? Both Sullay and Jerome must be looking on with a jaundiced eye at this happening. That aside I think we now have a very strong squad and I am looking forward to the visit of Stoke next Sunday. A perfect chance for us to showcase our club on live TV. But then again, this is Palace.

You are missing something.

J Benteke is classed as under age
He played because of injuries
Boateng is considered not good enough and will be sold unless he improves dramatically
KaiKai is likely to continue to improve if he gets game time. Something he wouldn't have got here
This is Jonny's make or break season, in my opinion he is going to go next year. I would love him to prove me wrong.


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (11 Sep 2016 10.14pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 11 Sep 16 10.04pm

It's a joke ....players graft for years to try and make their first team debuts...this guy justs rolls up and plays, and is now a premiership player ( he couldn't get in to a Belgium second division team). ... Smacks of nepotism ! Also, these actions can cause unrest in the camp...tread carefully AP

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 11 Sep 16 10.12pm

Originally posted by Hutchyeagle

It's a joke ....players graft for years to try and make their first team debuts...this guy justs rolls up and plays, and is now a premiership player ( he couldn't get in to a Belgium second division team). ... Smacks of nepotism ! Also, these actions can cause unrest in the camp...tread carefully AP

You appear to have ignored the circumstances behind Benteke Jnr's selection.

 

glaziermart Flag 11 Sep 16 10.14pm

I made a point of criticising Pardew in another thread regarding his press conference where he said 'young strikers like him are hard to come by' I got slammed by some on here, probably fairly, but i honestly was not saying he was not going to be good one day, it was just that Pards comments i think were disrespectful to both Keshi Anderson and Freddie Ladapo. Why is Christian's brother seen to be ahead of them?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Sep 16 10.16pm

Originally posted by Hutchyeagle

It's a joke ....players graft for years to try and make their first team debuts...this guy justs rolls up and plays, and is now a premiership player ( he couldn't get in to a Belgium second division team). ... Smacks of nepotism ! Also, these actions can cause unrest in the camp...tread carefully AP

Did you read any of the other posts?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

chris123 Flag hove actually 11 Sep 16 10.27pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

I made a point of criticising Pardew in another thread regarding his press conference where he said 'young strikers like him are hard to come by' I got slammed by some on here, probably fairly, but i honestly was not saying he was not going to be good one day, it was just that Pards comments i think were disrespectful to both Keshi Anderson and Freddie Ladapo. Why is Christian's brother seen to be ahead of them?

JB has joined our development squad. Anderson and Ladapo have gone out to get some 1st team football. So not sure what you are objecting to.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 11 Sep 16 10.27pm

Originally posted by chris123

You appear to have ignored the circumstances behind Benteke Jnr's selection.

..you're wasting your time, they cannot think.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Sep 16 10.39pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Benteke JR was signed for the development squad on a 1 year deal presumably to asses whether he has the necessary skill set to progress be a premier league player like his brother. The guys have gone out on loan to progress their careers as staying with the squad would mean bit part action, if any, with the first team. This all happened before the transfer window closed when we had Remy, Benteke Snr, Wickham all vying for the front man of our squad with Appiah and Campbell on the way back. Since then Remy has gone back to Chelsea and Wickham got a knock keeping him out. That left us with no cover at all for Benteke as Appiah and Campbell are both not fit yet.

I don't see Benteke Jnr. being used often but it was a needs must tbh and I think the other lads are far better off getting a full season of competitive football behind them than the odd minute here and there. I doubt they are bothered as they are focusing on getting into the starting 11 of their current teams to show they have what it takes to get into ours and if they aren't, they should be.

What a very good post, agree entirely!

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Sep 16 10.57pm

One of the negative side effects of establishing ourselves in the Premier League is that it is now significantly harder for academy players to break into the first team.

How many academy players have we brought through in the last 20 years that would get into our current strongest 11? Zaha, Clyne and possibly Moses?

Not a lot over such an extended period of time. I think the unfortunate reality is that we, as a club, have essentially outgrown the level of our academy which served us so well in the Championship.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

chris123 Flag hove actually 11 Sep 16 11.21pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

One of the negative side effects of establishing ourselves in the Premier League is that it is now significantly harder for academy players to break into the first team.

How many academy players have we brought through in the last 20 years that would get into our current strongest 11? Zaha, Clyne and possibly Moses?

Not a lot over such an extended period of time. I think the unfortunate reality is that we, as a club, have essentially outgrown the level of our academy which served us so well in the Championship.

Playing for the 1st team is not the only metric though surely? The academy provides a much wider sporting service to the community.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 11 Sep 16 11.22pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

One of the negative side effects of establishing ourselves in the Premier League is that it is now significantly harder for academy players to break into the first team.

How many academy players have we brought through in the last 20 years that would get into our current strongest 11? Zaha, Clyne and possibly Moses?

Not a lot over such an extended period of time. I think the unfortunate reality is that we, as a club, have essentially outgrown the level of our academy which served us so well in the Championship.

It's not just us, the academy system throughout the Premier League has been pretty poor the last 5 years. It doesn't produce players ready for high end football, and the vast majority learn far more from going out on loan/playing for lower league clubs.

How many players have gone from an academy to a Premier League regular without doing a tour of the football league?

All I can think of is Sterling and Rashford. Compare that to Stones, Lallana, Clyne, Kane, Rose, Bertrand, Smalling, Alli and so on who all played at another level first.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Sep 16 11.37pm

Originally posted by chris123

Playing for the 1st team is not the only metric though surely? The academy provides a much wider sporting service to the community.


Not the only metric perhaps but certainly the primary metric, especially in the context of a thread where the OP is moaning about the lack of chances given to academy players in the 1st team.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Sep 16 11.53pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

It's not just us, the academy system throughout the Premier League has been pretty poor the last 5 years. It doesn't produce players ready for high end football, and the vast majority learn far more from going out on loan/playing for lower league clubs.

How many players have gone from an academy to a Premier League regular without doing a tour of the football league?

All I can think of is Sterling and Rashford. Compare that to Stones, Lallana, Clyne, Kane, Rose, Bertrand, Smalling, Alli and so on who all played at another level first.


Absolutely agree. It's a league wide issue and that's exactly why I don't think it's fair to criticise the treatment of our academy players when every other club in the league is doing the same thing.

The brutal nature of this league and the amount at stake means that we cannot afford to be romantic and play unproven prospects unless they are as good as £10m+ alternatives which we now have the money to buy.

It's sad and one of the many things I miss about being in The Championship but is a price we have to pay in order to see a Palace team containing English, French and Belgian internationals.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 12 Sep 16 2.47am

Let's be honest about this. Junior was only brought in because Senior may have insisted in it.
Junior did not provide anything of significance and will quickly be reduced to the ranks of 'also rans'.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 12 Sep 16 3.54am

Sorry but I just do not understand fans who constantly want this or that young player given first team action.

We have a Premier League management structure all of whom look at and comment on young players outside of the first team squad. They decide that this or that player is better off leaving (example Jake Gray) or going on loan to gain first team experience.

It is wonderful for our own young players to come through the ranks and make the grade. Surely though the football experts in our club know a damn site more about an individuals talent to make the call than someone who simply supports the club. Most of the time those supporters have never even seen the youngster they are carrying a torch for play.

The likes of Williams, KaiKai and Boateng are now in the last chance saloon. Next season they will all have to be good enough to be named in our twenty-five man squad due to their age - a position Williams has already reached.

Edited by james03 (12 Sep 2016 3.55am)

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 12 Sep 16 6.27am

Originally posted by james03

Sorry but I just do not understand fans who constantly want this or that young player given first team action.

We have a Premier League management structure all of whom look at and comment on young players outside of the first team squad. They decide that this or that player is better off leaving (example Jake Gray) or going on loan to gain first team experience.

It is wonderful for our own young players to come through the ranks and make the grade. Surely though the football experts in our club know a damn site more about an individuals talent to make the call than someone who simply supports the club. Most of the time those supporters have never even seen the youngster they are carrying a torch for play.

The likes of Williams, KaiKai and Boateng are now in the last chance saloon. Next season they will all have to be good enough to be named in our twenty-five man squad due to their age - a position Williams has already reached.

Edited by james03 (12 Sep 2016 3.55am)


You are trying to take away people's human right to spout s*** about football? That's at least half the fun.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jonathan Benteke