You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew's Best and Worst Buys in transfer market
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew's Best and Worst Buys in transfer market


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Dan89 Flag Se25 15 Sep 16 4.58pm

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

est1905 Flag 15 Sep 16 5.02pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

While not the worst by any means I think I should put it out there that Mutch is very very average

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 Sep 16 5.12pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

Ameobi was a short term deal, Sanogo & Bamford were loanees, McCarthy just got an England call up.

 

pssguy Flag 15 Sep 16 5.15pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Ameobi was a short term deal, Sanogo & Bamford were loanees, McCarthy just got an England call up.

Still behind Hart though

 

pssguy Flag 15 Sep 16 5.16pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

Let's hope so. But Sako looked pretty good after a couple of games

 

est1905 Flag 15 Sep 16 5.17pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Ameobi was a short term deal, Sanogo & Bamford were loanees, McCarthy just got an England call up.

Macarthy got an England call because there was NOONE else available that has top flight experience. He was never going to play.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 Sep 16 5.18pm

Originally posted by est1905

Macarthy got an England call because there was NOONE else available that has top flight experience. He was never going to play.

Bet you he wouldn't have got a call up if he was still with us.

 

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 15 Sep 16 5.51pm

Originally posted by est1905

Macarthy got an England call because there was NOONE else available that has top flight experience. He was never going to play.

and NOONE is welsh, a winger and once played for unmentionable team on the south coast, so does not qualify

Edited by tshepp897 (15 Sep 2016 5.52pm)

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 15 Sep 16 6.07pm

Sako is poor.

Wasn't at first. But he is slow, boring, unimaginative and gives the ball away nearly as much as Punch.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 15 Sep 16 6.18pm

Interesting, that all the bad ones didn't cost much.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 15 Sep 16 6.19pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Ameobi was a short term deal, Sanogo & Bamford were loanees, McCarthy just got an England call up.

They were still signings made by AP

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Sep 16 6.26pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

Has made 1 appearance for Burnley this season where he is on 'Loan'. Came off the bench in the 80th minute last week at home to Hull replacing Andre Gray.

 

teedee Flag Croydon 15 Sep 16 7.06pm

Worst

Sonogo and Bamford


 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 15 Sep 16 7.26pm

Personally, I don't think the money A.P spent on his dancing lessons produced what any of us might have hoped for.

 

est1905 Flag 15 Sep 16 7.59pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Bet you he wouldn't have got a call up if he was still with us.

You may be right there

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 15 Sep 16 8.06pm

Originally posted by teedee

Worst

Sonogo and Bamford


This thread is about 'buys'.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 15 Sep 16 8.09pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

Sako is poor.

Wasn't at first. But he is slow, boring, unimaginative and gives the ball away nearly as much as Punch.

When did you last see him play to come up with those gems.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 15 Sep 16 8.43pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Interesting, that all the bad ones didn't cost much.

Agreed - all of the 'bad' signings were low-risk and low-cost - which is the sign of a club/manager who know what they're doing. Not that anyone will admit it.

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 15 Sep 16 8.47pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

We've made some notable transfer blunders in the past but, despite the suggestion in this thread, none imo under AP. Under time pressure he's made some really good ones. And under time pressure he's made some low risk speculative freebie signings. Adebayour is for me the standout low achiever amongst these. But not a blunder.
Wilf was the standout loan back and later re-signing. How much has our club benefitted from this? Arguably this deal and the sale of Bolasie has set us up financially. Great, great business.
On the other hand are these AP's signings or SP's? A joint effort I think.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 15 Sep 16 8.58pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We have done some great business in the last window but I was thinking, pardew has had some blunders in the windows,he been at the club. Such as ameboi, sangogo, Bamford and mcarthy just to name a few. In your opinion who's been the best signing made by pardew and the worst.

Best: Benteke or Mandanda

Worst: Alex mccarthy or Bamford

Over to you?

Whilst Benteke looks a great player, to me when you spend over 30 million its not really a great buy.

Mark Bright cost us 75k, Ian Wright cost us a bag of chips, AJ was actually a makeweight in a deal involving Morrison so actually cost us nothing. These to me constitute great buys.

But then again i'm a tight f@cker so what do I know!

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew's Best and Worst Buys in transfer market