You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worth a try?
November 16 2026 11.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Worth a try?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 31 Oct 16 11.17am

Chelsea let in goals en masse before they changed to 3 at the back with a 5 man midfield. Can the same work for Palace? Tomkins/Dann/Delaney at the back, a midfield of Ward, Cabaye, MacArthur, Chungy/Ledley, Puncheon with trio of Zaha/Benteke/Townsend on top. Think it could work out fine if the players know their jobs and start working as a unit. Anyone agree?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 31 Oct 16 11.25am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Chelsea let in goals en masse before they changed to 3 at the back with a 5 man midfield. Can the same work for Palace? Tomkins/Dann/Delaney at the back, a midfield of Ward, Cabaye, MacArthur, Chungy/Ledley, Puncheon with trio of Zaha/Benteke/Townsend on top. Think it could work out fine if the players know their jobs and start working as a unit. Anyone agree?

A 3-5-3? Could be tricky if the referee can count.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 31 Oct 16 11.31am

You are absolutely right - meant Zaha/Benteke top and Townsend at the moment a benchwarmer. Guess even Andre Mariner is able to count to 11.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 31 Oct 16 12.07pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

You are absolutely right - meant Zaha/Benteke top and Townsend at the moment a benchwarmer. Guess even Andre Mariner is able to count to 11.

Don't be too sure

3-5-2 is one of the least popular systems with good reason; it's very difficult to perfect and I don't think we have the personnel to do it. Let's face it, our lot are now struggling with 4-2-3-1, which we've been playing for ages. I don't think we've two players who could be effective wing-backs and I've seen the argument, when this has been discussed previously, that we could instead have a midfield player who drops into a back four when we're defending. I can't see that working either as we're confused enough now when defending, without any more complications. My suggestion would be to stop playing Kelly out of position and use Fryers instead and make our mind up if it's going to be Dann/Tomkins or Dann/Delaney.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

palace99 Flag New Mills 31 Oct 16 12.12pm

3-4-3 has worked well for Chelsea and Moses has been a revelation at right wing back.

We could do the same with maybe Zaha as right wing back and have a fluid 3 upfront with 2 playing off Benteke e.g. Punch and Townsend and maybe Remy when/if fit.

3 centre backs could be Damo on left Dann in middle and Tomkins or Wardy right side (Tomkins plays right back too so would be at home).

Not sure who could play left wing back - maybe Fyers, but other than that I do think we have the personnel to make this work.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 31 Oct 16 12.58pm

I'd drop Ledley for a forward and play 4-4-2 but we don't have another forward to compliment Benteke till Remy is fit.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 31 Oct 16 1.09pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I'd drop Ledley for a forward and play 4-4-2 but we don't have another forward to compliment Benteke till Remy is fit.

I think that would work a lot better for us, although it would probably need to be a 4-4-1-1 so we're not overrun in midfield. I suppose McArthur could fill in as a no.10 pending the availability of Remy?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 16 1.23pm

With a fit Papa maybe, but I can't really see Lee, Townsend or Zaha really having the defensive chops to make it work.

With Ward and Papa as wingbacks, it could work, as I think both link up well with Townsend and Zaha. With Ledley, Puncheon and McArthur across the centre (and likely Remi and Benetke upfront).

Kelly, Dann and Tompkins in a back three - Maybe not enough pace.

Our problems, this season, unlike the last three seasons, are defensive. I think we're getting forward well, and generally ok in front of goal, but we're too sloppy at the back.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mad4palace Flag 31 Oct 16 1.28pm

Conte understands that system and I'm sure he would have been coaching that system with the players probably from when he started there so well before they actually started playing it; what 3/4 weeks ago.

I understand we played it once or twice on the pre-season tour but I can't see any indication that is the system that Pardew has put much thought into playing. You can't just suddenly start playing an entirely different system and I don't think we have the right players to play it anyway, especially with Souare out; being the only real candidate for the LWB position.

 

Nest Flag 31 Oct 16 2.12pm

3 at the back means having three defenders who are capable on the ball and are positionally excellent, this is the most important part of this tactic. We most likely would get beat by very high scores

 

Reknaw Flag 31 Oct 16 9.50pm

If we're going to play a 3-5-2 then it would have to be Wilf and Townsend as the full backs. Cabaye McArthur Puncheon middle. Who up top with Benteke exactly? Gayle? Oh wait.

Don't think it would work.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 31 Oct 16 11.52pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

With a fit Papa maybe, but I can't really see Lee, Townsend or Zaha really having the defensive chops to make it work.

With Ward and Papa as wingbacks, it could work, as I think both link up well with Townsend and Zaha. With Ledley, Puncheon and McArthur across the centre (and likely Remi and Benetke upfront).

Kelly, Dann and Tompkins in a back three - Maybe not enough pace.

Our problems, this season, unlike the last three seasons, are defensive. I think we're getting forward well, and generally ok in front of goal, but we're too sloppy at the back.

..+ our forward players need to get involved in defending better, way too lackadaisical.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Nov 16 9.25am

If you're playing 3 at the back, one of them has to have a bit of pace.

 

Simbo2703 Flag Sayers common 01 Nov 16 9.28pm

I already posted self same idea, is Mr Pardew reading or is his head still stuck up his arse

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Nov 16 9.55pm

Wilf? Defend? I wish he would!

I tell you, I am seriously worried on that score.

It's a modern game and I think he needs to realise that he cannot afford to switch off defensively the way he has been doing.

He ball-watched and lost his attacker for the first goal on Saturday and I even saw him half turn his back on the shot for Leicester's third strike.

I remember Gabbidon turning his back on a shot - it is never good.

Lackadaisical is indeed the word.

I want to see Zaha acting in a far more mature and professional way.

Stop whinging, look sharp on and off the ball and be a man.

You're not a starlet anymore.

(dons helmet).

 

Carrick Flag In the Premierleague 01 Nov 16 10.02pm

We simply haven't got the personnel.

Wing backs need to be superfit and quick.
Rarely a standard right/left back/midfielder can adapt as a wing back.

The right and left centre backs need pace to widen and cover the wing backs when pushing forward. Ours have no pace whatsoever.
Chelsea have Dave and Cahill, with Luis sweeping.
All have pace!

 


Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Nov 16 1.30pm

Originally posted by Carrick

We simply haven't got the personnel.

Wing backs need to be superfit and quick.
Rarely a standard right/left back/midfielder can adapt as a wing back.

The right and left centre backs need pace to widen and cover the wing backs when pushing forward. Ours have no pace whatsoever.
Chelsea have Dave and Cahill, with Luis sweeping.
All have pace!

I disagree. I do think we COULD have the personnel.
If we played 2 of Dann/Tomk and DD and used say a faster Ward as the 3rd defender that could work.

Similarly, many rave about Zaha's improved defensive work so I do think he could fill the wing back role given time (he's a better natural fit than Moses).

So it's really on the left side that is a question mark. Chelsea play essentially a left back in that role so we could do similar.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 3.59pm

It would be a complete change of style, at the moment our biggest threat is on the wings, little comes through the middle. Take that threat away and we have nothing.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 4.00pm

Originally posted by Simbo2703

I already posted self same idea, is Mr Pardew reading or is his head still stuck up his arse

I'm sure he reads these boards avidly, and at this moment is probably p*****g himself laughing.

 

Carrick Flag In the Premierleague 03 Nov 16 4.52pm

Originally posted by palace99

I disagree. I do think we COULD have the personnel.
If we played 2 of Dann/Tomk and DD and used say a faster Ward as the 3rd defender that could work.

Similarly, many rave about Zaha's improved defensive work so I do think he could fill the wing back role given time (he's a better natural fit than Moses).

So it's really on the left side that is a question mark. Chelsea play essentially a left back in that role so we could do similar.

Unfortunately we need both the right and left centre back to be quick, so yes Wardy fits this mould but neither Dann, DD or Tomkins do.

Souare would make a seriously good wing back, but Wilf or Andros would not.

 


Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worth a try?