You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What are the odds?......
November 16 2026 11.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What are the odds?......


Glazier#1 Flag 16 Nov 16 1.13pm

.....that Gareth Southgate will manage Palace one day?

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 16 Nov 16 1.19pm

What are the odds of a truly successful club ever being so fixated on having former players in charge? Where has this happened with any great success? yet there's time after time clubs pander to this notion and appoint former players, with poor to awful results.

It's a small time attitude and is the opposite of appointing on merit. We need to move away from it ASAP frankly.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 16 Nov 16 1.32pm

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

What are the odds of a truly successful club ever being so fixated on having former players in charge? Where has this happened with any great success? yet there's time after time clubs pander to this notion and appoint former players, with poor to awful results.

It's a small time attitude and is the opposite of appointing on merit. We need to move away from it ASAP frankly.

Just a few off the top of my head.

Pep Guardiola - Barcelona
Diego Simeone - Atletico Madrid
Kenny Dalgish - Liverpool
Graeme Souness - Rangers
To a lesser extent Beckenbauer and Bayern Munich


Edited by tshepp897 (16 Nov 2016 1.34pm)

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

Part Time James Flag 16 Nov 16 1.38pm

Iain Dowie

 




Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 16 Nov 16 1.40pm

Originally posted by tshepp897

Just a few off the top of my head.

Pep Guardiola - Barcelona
Diego Simeone - Atletico Madrid
Kenny Dalgish - Liverpool
Graeme Souness - Rangers
To a lesser extent Beckenbauer and Bayern Munich


Edited by tshepp897 (16 Nov 2016 1.34pm)


These teams are all European giants, Palace are I'm afraid not.

 


Pro USA & Israel

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 16 Nov 16 1.40pm

Originally posted by Jimenez


These teams are all European giants, Palace are I'm afraid not.

Eddie Howe

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

bicycle repair man 16 Nov 16 2.14pm

Dougie Freedman

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 16 Nov 16 2.35pm

There is no club that has appointed a succession of former players with any success (in fact I'm not sure there's ever been another club that's so obsessed with appointing ex-players to posts within the organisation). Managerial appointments (all appointments) should be made on the basis of the best applicant for the job, irrespective of their playing history.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 16 Nov 16 2.47pm

Mowbray and Southate for Boro
Souness and Evans at Liverpool
Vialli, Gullit, and Hoddle at Chelsea
Hoddle at Spurs

the list goes on and on of ex-players who have been failures as managers at their clubs.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 16 Nov 16 3.14pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

Mowbray and Southate for Boro
Souness and Evans at Liverpool
Vialli, Gullit, and Hoddle at Chelsea
Hoddle at Spurs

the list goes on and on of ex-players who have been failures as managers at their clubs.

Do cups not count as success then? without checking i'm pretty certain souness and evans both won cups at Liverpool and maybe Gullit and Vialli at Chelsea.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 16 Nov 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Do cups not count as success then? without checking i'm pretty certain souness and evans both won cups at Liverpool and maybe Gullit and Vialli at Chelsea.

I don't know any Liverpool fans that think Souness or Evans were successes. Vialli and Gullit had appalling records as Chelsea managers given the money they were spending.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

victor43 Flag St. Albans 16 Nov 16 4.24pm

You're going to get examples of successful and unsuccessful managers who were ex players, but I agree that a playing career (whether at Palace or not) should have no bearing on whether someone gets the job or not.

If they're a good coach/ manager then I don't care about their playing history.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Nov 16 4.34pm

Originally posted by Jimenez


These teams are all European giants, Palace are I'm afraid not.

He asked for examples of truly successful clubs.

Barcelona and Ajax have done it many times, with success.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Nov 16 4.47pm

Originally posted by victor43

You're going to get examples of successful and unsuccessful managers who were ex players, but I agree that a playing career (whether at Palace or not) should have no bearing on whether someone gets the job or not.

If they're a good coach/ manager then I don't care about their playing history.

My view entirely.

Maybe 'Boards' think that a popular ex-player will be given greater slack by supporters and that these supporters will be more tolerant if things are not going so well.Perhaps this is one consideration and might tip the balance if it is a close call between candidates on a shortlist.

Edited by Willo (16 Nov 2016 4.48pm)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 16 Nov 16 6.21pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

I don't know any Liverpool fans that think Souness or Evans were successes. Vialli and Gullit had appalling records as Chelsea managers given the money they were spending.

They all won cups tho didnt they. You show me a Palace fan who wouldnt be happy with that. Also Vialli and Gullit were pre Abramovich and therefore before the stupid money and the first success they had for years. As for the scousers their views were skewed by years of success winning titles and european competition.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Nov 16 6.31pm

Originally posted by sickboy

They all won cups tho didnt they. You show me a Palace fan who wouldnt be happy with that. Also Vialli and Gullit were pre Abramovich and therefore before the stupid money and the first success they had for years. As for the scousers their views were skewed by years of success winning titles and european competition.

Liverpool won the FA Cup under Souness and the League Cup under Evans.
In actual fact Evans had over a 50% win-ratio at Liverpool.

Chelsea won the FA Cup with Gullit in charge and the FA Cup, League Cup, Cup Winners Cup amongst others when Vialli was manager.

Edited by Willo (16 Nov 2016 6.35pm)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 16 Nov 16 6.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

Liverpool won the FA Cup under Souness and the League Cup under Evans.
In actual fact Evans had over a 50% win-ratio at Liverpool.

I'd settle for that.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 16 Nov 16 11.23pm

I agree a lot of it is nostalgia and sentimentality.
The best players often don't make the best managers and ex palace players certainly don't have a great record.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Nov 16 3.25am

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

What are the odds of a truly successful club ever being so fixated on having former players in charge? Where has this happened with any great success? yet there's time after time clubs pander to this notion and appoint former players, with poor to awful results.

It's a small time attitude and is the opposite of appointing on merit. We need to move away from it ASAP frankly.

The club's DNA for a long time has been about producing local talent, finding a bargain and looking after one of your own.

It's romantic to think an ex player can come in and take us forward.

No shame in that and until we are at a place where ex players that are now managers are currently not good enough, then why not?

If we had say Mancini and broke into top 6 and forged us into a european force, then ofcourse wanting Freedman as boss would look odd, but if Freedman took say Celtic to new european heights and won plaudits, then why not. It's all relative and you have to remember a lot of old boys came back to help us out when we were in admin at various times.

 


This was once a quality forum....


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What are the odds?......