You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Where's our leader
November 16 2026 11.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Where's our leader


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Nov 16 10.07am

One of our biggest problems at the moment is we have no leader on the pitch. Someone who can organise the defense at corners, who can scream at players not to push forward when it leaves us vulnerable at the back, who can grab a game by the scruff of the neck. Why the hell is it up to AP to try and get a message on the pitch to put a man on the post for a corner. As much as I love dann why wasn't he doing that? We look completely lost at times.....and please don't turn this into a Jedinak thread.

Edited by spartakev2 (20 Nov 2016 10.08am)

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 20 Nov 16 10.26am

Just have to remind you then, Jedinak was a leader.He was always batteling and an example to everyone.
H3re you go,,, could turn Jedinak this one.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Nov 16 10.38am

Leave Jedi out of the post. We all know he's one of the greatest leaders this club has ever had, but he wasn't going to be playing, so he wouldn't of been the answer even if he'd stayed. Although conversion to centre half could of been an option? s*** I'm turning it into a Jedi thread.
In answer to your question, we appear to have none. I really think everyone was expecting a ball to the edge of the area. Still can't believe the man on the corner of the 6 yard box was not positioned as they still have some height in there. Totally suckered punched, but we are mentally weak back there right now and we constantly #findawaytolose

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Mad4palace Flag 20 Nov 16 11.17am

It's impossible not to bring Jedinak into this conversation. But I also think Delaney is a better captain than Dann, Dann was ok yesterday in pushing the defence out etc but he doesn't command players into position or rally the troops like either Jedi or Delaney did. Also I think the leadership from the GK position is a problem, shouldn't Hennessey have told someone to stand where De Bruyne passed for the 2nd goal? Especially after we'd nearly conceded from the same routine corner. This also applies to Mandanda who's had a few similar instances.

Puncheon is actually one of the better leaders in the team but more leaders need to come from the back 4 and goalkeeper.

 

Hoof Hearted 20 Nov 16 11.22am

Jedinak = Class

 

The Dolphin Flag 20 Nov 16 11.44am

Jedi lover here - but he has gone.
He has not been replaced and we do not seem to have a leader or organiser on the field.
I was unable to attend yesterday but I have seen the goals ad infinitum and they are scary defensively.
AP says he doesn't care about clean sheets - he should do - a lack of them will get him the sack very shortly!
Dann obviously does not lead otherwise the second goal yesterday would never have happened.
Hennessey - and I do not blame him by the way - was yelling (obviously not loudly enough) to get the near post covered and no one listened.
Under a dynamic Captain that would not have happened!

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 20 Nov 16 11.48am

Well you would have thought Cabaye as Pardew said once he is the man that let's him know what is going on out there.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 20 Nov 16 11.52am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Jedinak = Class

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

Whatever class he had, had gone.

As for leadership, clearly it's not as important as people make out. If it was, results with him in the side over the entirety of the last two seasons would have been better.

Edited by NickinOX (20 Nov 2016 12.07pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 20 Nov 16 12.05pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Jedi lover here - but he has gone.
He has not been replaced and we do not seem to have a leader or organiser on the field.
I was unable to attend yesterday but I have seen the goals ad infinitum and they are scary defensively.
AP says he doesn't care about clean sheets - he should do - a lack of them will get him the sack very shortly!
Dann obviously does not lead otherwise the second goal yesterday would never have happened.
Hennessey - and I do not blame him by the way - was yelling (obviously not loudly enough) to get the near post covered and no one listened.
Under a dynamic Captain that would not have happened!

Spot on. Dann is the captain and is right in the thick of the action at the back. No excuses not stamping his authority back there. Relying on messages from the bench isn't practical under match conditions. Total amateur hour back there. If he's not willing/unable to fill this role then change him. Judging by the second goal I'd put Hennessy as captain, at least he seemed to understand the danger.

Edited by Booted Eagle (20 Nov 2016 12.07pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Nov 16 2.02pm

I really, really,really hate saying this, BUT, if his contract is paid up and he's available instantly I'd take Barton in a heartbeat. Yes I know he's a knob. Am I going crazy?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 20 Nov 16 2.09pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

Whatever class he had, had gone.

As for leadership, clearly it's not as important as people make out. If it was, results with him in the side over the entirety of the last two seasons would have been better.

Edited by NickinOX (20 Nov 2016 12.07pm)

I'm glad that these stats are out there.

The game next week is absolutely huge. We need to pick up three points and given our display against City, which was great going forward, I think we will. Genuinely.

I have a degree of faith in this team. Losing Souare was a massive blow to us. We should have had back up in that position because Kelly as we know is simply not a left back. That is poor on Pardew and I think the board's account not to have real backup there.
But players like Dann, Wilf, McArthur, Cabaye and Benteke are Premier League players without a doubt. We didn't get a hammering from either Liverpool or City and that speaks volumes. However, defensively we've been woeful and we just need to pick that up. Otherwise we really are going down.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Nov 16 2.34pm

Villa's gain has been our loss.

Jedi, denied brighton victory this weekend. hats off to the bearded one.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

curlyeagle Flag crowborough 20 Nov 16 4.13pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I really, really,really hate saying this, BUT, if his contract is paid up and he's available instantly I'd take Barton in a heartbeat. Yes I know he's a knob. Am I going crazy?

I was tempted to post this suggestion myself! Just the kind of player in my humble opinion that we are missing. We have absolutely no leaders on the field at all.

Yesterday again players arguing with each other all over the field. None of them seem to want to take responsibility, constantly pointing the finger at each other.

I can see worrying times ahead if the team is not quickly galvanised and sadly I don't see Pardew being the man to do this.

 


Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days

palace-metros Flag Redhill 20 Nov 16 5.44pm

This is indeed a major issue. The second goal was nothing short of embarrassing and is down to lack of leadership on the pitch. It's not the first time is it?
I think SD is a great player for us but it is becoming increasingly evident that he is not a leader and captain. Delaney possibly the nearest we have to anyone who can do that job although I fear his performances may be affected if he cannot concentrate solely on his own game. Clearly the goalkeeper should dictate if posts are covered even at the expense of the manager's preferences, so I would question what Hennessey's role in all this is.

Wish there was an easy answer but for the time being if Dann retains the Captaincy, he needs a proper kick up the a*se as do his players. As for the Barton suggestion, do we really need to go for someone like that?

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

Username Flag Horsham 20 Nov 16 10.04pm

Originally posted by curlyeagle

I was tempted to post this suggestion myself! Just the kind of player in my humble opinion that we are missing. We have absolutely no leaders on the field at all.

Yesterday again players arguing with each other all over the field. None of them seem to want to take responsibility, constantly pointing the finger at each other.

I can see worrying times ahead if the team is not quickly galvanised and sadly I don't see Pardew being the man to do this.


Christ, you think Barton is a leader? The man falls out with every dressing room he's ever played in?

Think a big part of the issue is lack of consistency in the team.

We play the same players, but we've been forced to make so many minor changes each week we're just not settled, and that's what causes people to miss marking, not drop in while the other goes forward etc.

Look at the back five. We've had both Mandanda and Hennessey now. At centre half we've varying partnerships of Delaney, Dann and Tomkins. Ward and Kelly have both played left and right back and we've also had Souare of course.

In front, we've had Cabaye, McArthur and Puncheon all available but we've been struggling to get the system right. Puncheon is influential but always stuggles as a number 10 and doesn't get close enough to Benteke. So against Liverpool we play him deeper which is where we get more from him and push McArthur forward. Problem is then McArthur's partnership with Cabaye is broken and we don't look anywhere near as solid. So yesterday we start with McArthur and Cabaye together, are more solid, but Punch can't get on the ball enough.

Point is, we've had so many slight variations on system, personnel etc this season. I think yesterday ended positively in that we might have solved that midfield issue by dropping Townsend, moving Punch to the left and having Wickham off Benteke. That keeps the McAbaye partnership and we looked cohesive going forward.

If we can keep Hennessey/Dann/Tomkins (or Mandanda if that's what Pards wants) together for four/five games I think we'll look a lot more solid. If the answer is plugging someone else in at left back as well, then I do think this mistakes will disappear.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

pssguy Flag 20 Nov 16 10.53pm

John Terry - January transfer window

Not likely to get a look in at Chelsea. Just make sure he has enough appearances to get a title winners medal (with them not us)

Heard lots of his pay is based on appearances so may be finding things a bit tough

 

pssguy Flag 20 Nov 16 10.55pm

Originally posted by pssguy

John Terry - January transfer window

Not likely to get a look in at Chelsea. Just make sure he has enough appearances to get a title winners medal (with them not us)

Heard lots of his pay is based on appearances so may be finding things a bit tough

in fact, whilst I'm at it make him player-manager. No need for pardew and if he does a good job will be shoo-in for Chelsea job when Conte self-combusts

 

palace-metros Flag Redhill 20 Nov 16 11.08pm

I wonder if Pardew fears a player with leadership qualities on the pitch might be a rival to him. I think that might be an exaggeration but Jedi has gone and Delaney might be sidelined by Tompkins. Dann doesn't seem to be one I'm afraid.

This is such an important role. Look at Swansea without Ashley Williams. (Not sure if we ever stood a chance of getting him but I know we were linked in rumours at one stage - shame we missed out)

Address this and we can fly again.

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

james03 Flag Bangkok 21 Nov 16 3.49am

Cabaye is the choice for me.

Dann is not vocal enough and it was, IMO, his fault we lost to Burnley. He is the man of the pitch who should have been telling the players to hang back and settle for a point. Instead he leads the charge up the pitch and our lack of decent cover leaves us exposed for them to get the winner.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Ay Nik Eagle Flag Oroklini, Cyprus 21 Nov 16 6.29am

For me our leader is sat on the Bench and not being utilised by Pardew. Step forward Mathieu Flamini.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Where's our leader