You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > MNF analysis of us from the corner
November 16 2026 11.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

MNF analysis of us from the corner


Mad4palace Flag 21 Nov 16 11.01pm

Jamie Carragher analyzing the 2nd Toure goal:

- Benteke was marking Toure on the previous set pieces
- McArthur occupies the space near the 6 yard box
- Lee comes on, tells Wickham to pick up Toure (Benteke now off)
- Wickham and Hennessey tell Lee to sit where McArthur was before, McArthur now occupying Silva
- Lee doesn't go, looks over to the bench
- Wickham asking the dugout for instructions while letting Toure get the wrong side of him
- Corner comes in, no man on front post, Wickham flat footed against an unmarked Toure... Goal.


I think Wickham should take the biggest criticism from this, he didn't do his job first and let Toure go. I think the keeper has also got to be stronger in ordering players where he wants them. Lee ended up in two minds. McArthurs choice to pick up Silva messed things up too, maybe he should have told Lee to pick up Silva.

Pardew is probably not exempt from criticism either here, he switched peoples roles around with the substitution of Benteke which ended up confusing everyone.

Also, I don't really understand Puncheon's or Cabaye's role from the corner, they're not marking anyone, nor did they block the lines in which De Bruyne could pass into.

 

McCorry Flag Bromley 21 Nov 16 11.43pm

Game long gone now, Swansea next hopefully they've woken up by then.

 

chateauferret Flag 22 Nov 16 4.35pm

Still wondering WTF Einstein thought he was doing with that substitution. Confused us, put us back on the back foot and removed our goal threat all in the one dunt. Not making sure the players knew what they were supposed to be doing was just an additional turd on top.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Mad4palace Flag 22 Nov 16 4.43pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Still wondering WTF Einstein thought he was doing with that substitution. Confused us, put us back on the back foot and removed our goal threat all in the one dunt. Not making sure the players knew what they were supposed to be doing was just an additional turd on top.

I would have taken Wickham off, I know there's some unwritten rule about not substituting a sub but Benteke knows his role on corners and Wickham's one of the worst players on our team in terms of managing the game.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 22 Nov 16 4.45pm

I blame it on Toure's agent for not slagging Man City off enough so that his player got off the bench.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Nov 16 4.47pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Still wondering WTF Einstein thought he was doing with that substitution. Confused us, put us back on the back foot and removed our goal threat all in the one dunt. Not making sure the players knew what they were supposed to be doing was just an additional turd on top.

Switching to a 4-5-1 to see out the game I guess. Benetke was knackered, and with Wickham we had an outlet. I guess Lee was considered a fresh 'imputus' to revitalise midfield and shut down City in the middle of the pitch.

I suspect he wanted to ensure Beneteke didn't push himself to hard and get an injury, what with the Swansea, Southampton and Hull games coming up.

Definitely makes sense to me. I think the players definitely get the blame for both goals. Changes in a team are pretty common, and they should know what to do.

And that definitely includes covering the low ball into the box from a corner. We didn't defend like that when we were 10.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Nov 16 5.51pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Still wondering WTF Einstein thought he was doing with that substitution. Confused us, put us back on the back foot and removed our goal threat all in the one dunt. Not making sure the players knew what they were supposed to be doing was just an additional turd on top.

Really? You don't think one of our highly paid players shouldn't have thought, hm the last 2 corners they've played low across our 6 yard box, maybe rather than just standing on the edge of the penalty box I should go on the post, or the edge of the 6 yard box, just I'm case those nasty mancs try it again.
Honestly if the whole team gets confused when you take a forward off and put a midfielder on, we have serious issues.

 

Mad4palace Flag 22 Nov 16 6.22pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Really? You don't think one of our highly paid players shouldn't have thought, hm the last 2 corners they've played low across our 6 yard box, maybe rather than just standing on the edge of the penalty box I should go on the post, or the edge of the 6 yard box, just I'm case those nasty mancs try it again.
Honestly if the whole team gets confused when you take a forward off and put a midfielder on, we have serious issues.

Watch the analysis from MNF; McArthur is supposed to be in that space where the drilled in ball goes but from the first corner gets dragged by a run from Silva, on the second one McArthur marks Silva; leaving the space free.

Someone should be on the edge of the 6 yard area, Hennessey and Wickham tell Lee to go there but supposedly that's not Lee's job according to Carragher and Puncheon is telling Lee to mark someone else.

All very confusing, I think Wickham and McArthur are at fault as well as Lee for being indecisive but Pardew is the one making the changes and confusing everyone to start with.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Nov 16 7.43pm

that goal has left me the most annoyed/frustrated and dumbfounded for many a year and coming in the week when our average wage is announced at £37k a week just defies logic.

Who is at fault - answer everyone from manager down.

Even at park Sunday level the teams i played in always knew that you would pick up the near post at EVERY defended corner.

Why was a man not on the post - Cayebe often does this? What are Millen and Pardew doing on the training ground.

Then 10 minutes earlier an almost identical routine should have led to a goal.

Therefore the next corner you make sure you don't make the same mistake.

Tomkins and Danns should have got that defence organised - instructions from the bench are irrelevant and unnecessary.

Highly paid international stodd there and did nothing. Cabeye was in the wrong position, Wayne just fell over (i think he is the least to blame) and Wickham was wrong side of his man.

BUT of course that ball should never have been allowed to travel that far and how Pardew can make some excuse about instructions from the bench is beyond me. And why players are waiting for instructions is also even worse.

It was a complete joke of a goal.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Nov 16 10.15pm

Originally posted by palace99

that goal has left me the most annoyed/frustrated and dumbfounded for many a year and coming in the week when our average wage is announced at £37k a week just defies logic.

Who is at fault - answer everyone from manager down.

Even at park Sunday level the teams i played in always knew that you would pick up the near post at EVERY defended corner.

Why was a man not on the post - Cayebe often does this? What are Millen and Pardew doing on the training ground.

Then 10 minutes earlier an almost identical routine should have led to a goal.

Therefore the next corner you make sure you don't make the same mistake.

Tomkins and Danns should have got that defence organised - instructions from the bench are irrelevant and unnecessary.

Highly paid international stodd there and did nothing. Cabeye was in the wrong position, Wayne just fell over (i think he is the least to blame) and Wickham was wrong side of his man.

BUT of course that ball should never have been allowed to travel that far and how Pardew can make some excuse about instructions from the bench is beyond me. And why players are waiting for instructions is also even worse.

It was a complete joke of a goal.

Absolutely, and all this Crap of the players being confused by the substitution. .. worse than Sunday league.

 

chateauferret Flag 22 Nov 16 11.13pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Absolutely, and all this Crap of the players being confused by the substitution. .. worse than Sunday league.

When I said the subsitution confused the players I meant in a general sense, not specifically referring to this particular shambles. Of course a bonkers substitution causes confusion. You change the system to one that the team isn't expecting and isn't prepared for, and moreover to one which fixes something that ain't broke. Asking for trouble. Why do you think there is constant advice about avoiding substitutions when defending a corner? Change has to be managed, not just imposed.

Wickham is not a defender and it's reasonable for those with expertise in organising defences to be sorting him out instead of leaving him to his own devices or having him try to send smoke signals to the bench asking for advice. If players in his position are appealing to the bench to know where to stand it's because the team as a whole is not properly drilled but moreover because there is no clearly understood chain of command.

Cf. "I leave it to the team to decide who is to take the penalty", being the excuse for Cabaye taking the ball away from Benteke and then bottling the f***ing thing.

It's all down to a lack of organisation and that comes from Pardew.


Edited by chateauferret (22 Nov 2016 11.28pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

palace-metros Flag Redhill 22 Nov 16 11.40pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Really? You don't think one of our highly paid players shouldn't have thought, hm the last 2 corners they've played low across our 6 yard box, maybe rather than just standing on the edge of the penalty box I should go on the post, or the edge of the 6 yard box, just I'm case those nasty mancs try it again.
Honestly if the whole team gets confused when you take a forward off and put a midfielder on, we have serious issues.

Good post. Really not sure how anyone can argue with this.

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

Mad4palace Flag 22 Nov 16 11.57pm

Originally posted by palace-metros

Good post. Really not sure how anyone can argue with this.

No one is arguing with it, just there were a lot of other factors that went wrong, including the fact that players were presumably instructed to stand where they did. If we're honest, the goal doesn't go in if Wickham stays on Toure.

The players are to blame, namely; Hennessey, Wickham, Cabaye, McArthur and Lee but it undoubtedly stems from the management and training.

But I still can't for the life of me understand why both Cabaye and Puncheon are standing in the same passing line. Anyone understand their job there?

skysports-palace-toure-benteke_3837343.jpg Attachment: skysports-palace-toure-benteke_3837343.jpg (62.63Kb)

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 23 Nov 16 10.07am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

No one is arguing with it, just there were a lot of other factors that went wrong, including the fact that players were presumably instructed to stand where they did. If we're honest, the goal doesn't go in if Wickham stays on Toure.

The players are to blame, namely; Hennessey, Wickham, Cabaye, McArthur and Lee but it undoubtedly stems from the management and training.

But I still can't for the life of me understand why both Cabaye and Puncheon are standing in the same passing line. Anyone understand their job there?

No, I don't understand their job at all, and there is absolutely no way that is where Pardew has told them to stand. If they can't figure out, oh maybe one of us should guard the near post, then I give up hope.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Mad4palace Flag 23 Nov 16 10.11am

My take on what should have happened:

Edited by Mad4palace (23 Nov 2016 10.12am)

skysports-palace-toure-goal conceded corner.jpg Attachment: skysports-palace-toure-goal conceded corner.jpg (70.94Kb)

 

mab66 Flag Cobham 23 Nov 16 12.27pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

My take on what should have happened:

Edited by Mad4palace (23 Nov 2016 10.12am)


Can you add another speech bubble reminding Wickham that whilst he's been gawking vacantly at Pardew the corner has already been taken!

 

eternallymissed Flag Haywards Heath 23 Nov 16 2.13pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

My take on what should have happened:

Edited by Mad4palace (23 Nov 2016 10.12am)


I've not seen anything on the goal since the game and my view on the Holmesdale didn't make it clear who was where.

Looking at this, the players take the blame but for me it has to be Hennesey, as a goalkeeper myself the first thing you do when you concede the corner is get everyone in place. If subs have happened and there is confusion you take charge and tell players where to be.

If I had a player on the penalty spot all alone and no obvious blocking lines for a pass i'd be screaming at someone to get onto him.

You can say all you want about Pardew and his ability or lack thereof with tactics, you cannot do anything about these crap mistakes that we keep making


Edited by eternallymissed (23 Nov 2016 2.14pm)

 


Forget Saw, forget Nemesis Inferno, forget Oblivion. No rollercoaster in the UK is as scary as the one Crystal Palace fans get to ride

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 23 Nov 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

I would have taken Wickham off, I know there's some unwritten rule about not substituting a sub but Benteke knows his role on corners and Wickham's one of the worst players on our team in terms of managing the game.

He could have just put Wickham wide left (a roll he's played many times before in his career), and kept Benteke on... It was a f***ing stupid substitution and completely disrupted the rhythm of the side, and ultimately led to the goal...

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Mad4palace Flag 23 Nov 16 4.16pm

What did happen:

Toure goal.jpg Attachment: Toure goal.jpg (286.12Kb)

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > MNF analysis of us from the corner