You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 03 Dec 16 5.40pm

So much better and effective when Cabaye doesn't play. Thought he was outstanding today.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Dec 16 5.46pm

As was Zaha. Never seen him work so hard.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 03 Dec 16 5.59pm

Originally posted by Jules111

So much better and effective when Cabaye doesn't play. Thought he was outstanding today.

Disagree. I thought he was a weak link in the first half, but he turned it on in the second half and showed great vision for our 3rd goal.

He did put in his fair share of chasing down when he was the furthest forward midfield player too.....OK, so he did play well overall :-)

Macca was everywhere though and I thought he was our midfield boss today.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 03 Dec 16 6.01pm

Cabaye is the problem. Mr P made a big mistake when he turned up and told everyone that if they wanted the same £80K a week as Cabaye they would have to do as well as him. I would imagine that the person who cuts the oranges at half time considered asking for £80k a week based his performances for Palace so far.
This is the same as in any workplace if the Boss introduces a favourite over everyone else and they turn out to be an average Joe.
I think the team spirit is better when Cabaye does not play as the other team players do not feel that they have to defer to him and try and play through him and watch him generally try to run things and usually fail miserably.

It will be great for Palace if his performances ever reach the level of his wages and hype.

 

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 03 Dec 16 6.16pm

Ledley's the man to calm things down - hope he can hang onto his place in the team.

 

Jaha Flag 03 Dec 16 6.40pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Cabaye is the problem. Mr P made a big mistake when he turned up and told everyone that if they wanted the same £80K a week as Cabaye they would have to do as well as him. I would imagine that the person who cuts the oranges at half time considered asking for £80k a week based his performances for Palace so far.
This is the same as in any workplace if the Boss introduces a favourite over everyone else and they turn out to be an average Joe.
I think the team spirit is better when Cabaye does not play as the other team players do not feel that they have to defer to him and try and play through him and watch him generally try to run things and usually fail miserably.

It will be great for Palace if his performances ever reach the level of his wages and hype.

Cabaye is horribly overrated and overpaid. He breaks up play fairly well from time to time but isn't the creative player he often gets credit for and i don't think, obviously, that we missed him that much today. He often just f***s up set pieces and gets in everyones way as you've said

 

Jaha Flag 03 Dec 16 6.41pm

punch i thought was class today, helping out defensively and putting pressure on everyone. Managed to keep the ball in some tough spots where i was certain he was going to loose it. Got to love him

 

Pierre Flag Purley 05 Dec 16 10.13am

Yes you have to say the Puncheon played well and Ledley just got on with it without causing any dramas. Didn't miss Cabaye at all.

 

7Oaks Eagle Flag Sevenoaks 05 Dec 16 4.28pm

Agree Puncheon and Ledley were both superb - Hopefully they will be picked to start against Hull leaving Cabaye on the bench.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 05 Dec 16 6.10pm

Just one thing missing from Punch's game. Goals, for a number 10 he has an abysmal strike rate. We have a top class goalscorer now but he needs to knock in 7 or 8 per season to back him up.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon