You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thoughts on yesterday
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thoughts on yesterday


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
SamCPFC17 Flag Croydon 11 Dec 16 12.08pm

Went up to Hull yesterday, and few things kept on coming up in conversation on the way back -
1. Plainly and simply, with Wilf in the form he is in we need to get him as involved in our attacking play as possible. Playing alongside Benteke through the middle as he did in the second half yesterday might well be a good idea in the long run.
2. Leading on from that, though I'm becoming increasingly frustrated with Andros' efforts, this could give him a chance to play out on the right as he is apparently so desperate to do.
3. Scott Dann could do with being relieved of the captaincy. He seems to have gone well off the boil since he has taken on the additional duty - honestly, I'm just not sure he can simultaneously be our best defender and our captain. The Scott Dann we all know would not have been so easily shrugged off by Diomande as he was for Hull's second.
4. Jesus Christ, if we're going to play 3-5-2/5-3-2, Pards needs to tell Ward & Fryers whether they're meant to be predominantly defenders or midfielders. Neither of them had a clue how much to push forward or hang back in the second half yesterday - the problem being that when they pushed forward, we left ourselves painfully exposed at the back (see Hull's 3rd), and when they sank back, we couldn't keep the damn ball. I really don't think playing 3/5 at the back is the answer.

Overall, I honestly think that we should try something like this for United on Wednesday -

GK: Wayne
CB: Dann
CB: Delaney (Captain)
RB: Ward
LB: Fryers
(if Tomkins is fit, play him at RB and Ward at LB)
CM: Ledley
CM: McArthur
RM: Townsend
LM: Punch
(more sided midfielders than wingers)
ST: Wilf
ST: Benteke

Any thoughts?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 11 Dec 16 12.46pm

Zaha is, and always has been, most effective on the right. I do not consider moving him to accommodate Townsend a good idea. What we really need to do is put him on a long and expensive contract before he sods off to Spurs or the like. If we need an AM/no. 10, which we probably do, or a striker, which we definitely do, then we must go out and buy them not play our best out of position. Townsend needs to get his thumb out of his arse, do as he's told and stop behaving like a sulky 13 year old who's been asked to tidy his bedroom.

It's difficult to say whether Dann's loss of form is due to the captaincy or not as the whole defence seem to have gone to pieces. It would be very difficult, from a morale point of view, to reallocate it mid-season.

The reason the full backs/wing backs or whatever they were, struggled is because we changed to a formation that we clearly haven't been working on in training. The centre backs were equally as confused; well more confused than normal I mean. I agree that 3-5-2 is not for us until we've at least remastered 4-2-3-1 and 4-4-2.

Edited by bexleydave (11 Dec 2016 12.58pm)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Mad4palace Flag 11 Dec 16 12.56pm

Finding it hard to disagree with most of what the OP said. Making Dann captain was another case of Pardew painting himself into a corner, he can't go back on that decision now.

Townsend is utterly infuriating, I wouldn't try to move Wilf to accommodate Townsend playing on the right though. I'd rather try Townsend in the hole and Punch on the left.

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 11 Dec 16 1.02pm

Originally posted by SamCPFC17

Went up to Hull yesterday, and few things kept on coming up in conversation on the way back -
1. Plainly and simply, with Wilf in the form he is in we need to get him as involved in our attacking play as possible. Playing alongside Benteke through the middle as he did in the second half yesterday might well be a good idea in the long run.
2. Leading on from that, though I'm becoming increasingly frustrated with Andros' efforts, this could give him a chance to play out on the right as he is apparently so desperate to do.
3. Scott Dann could do with being relieved of the captaincy. He seems to have gone well off the boil since he has taken on the additional duty - honestly, I'm just not sure he can simultaneously be our best defender and our captain. The Scott Dann we all know would not have been so easily shrugged off by Diomande as he was for Hull's second.
4. Jesus Christ, if we're going to play 3-5-2/5-3-2, Pards needs to tell Ward & Fryers whether they're meant to be predominantly defenders or midfielders. Neither of them had a clue how much to push forward or hang back in the second half yesterday - the problem being that when they pushed forward, we left ourselves painfully exposed at the back (see Hull's 3rd), and when they sank back, we couldn't keep the damn ball. I really don't think playing 3/5 at the back is the answer.

Overall, I honestly think that we should try something like this for United on Wednesday -

GK: Wayne
CB: Dann
CB: Delaney (Captain)
RB: Ward
LB: Fryers
(if Tomkins is fit, play him at RB and Ward at LB)
CM: Ledley
CM: McArthur
RM: Townsend
LM: Punch
(more sided midfielders than wingers)
ST: Wilf
ST: Benteke

Any thoughts?

Fully agree, but the arrogant man who runs the team will no doubt contrive to screw it up.

Edited by fed up eagle (11 Dec 2016 1.06pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 11 Dec 16 1.09pm

Puncheon is suspended isn't he?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 11 Dec 16 1.12pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Puncheon is suspended isn't he?

He is indeed.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

curlyeagle Flag crowborough 11 Dec 16 2.17pm

Sadly yet again we looked poorly prepared, unfit and at times totally disorganised!

Until Pardew gets to grips with this squad and installs some defensive dicipline we are going to continue to ship in goals week on week.

The work rate and desire of this squad is getting worse week on week. Yes we got a raw deal with a howler of a decision from the referee but the second and third goals from Hull were shocking defensively.

I don't like to see managers come and go but I have major doubts regarding Pardews ability to see us out of this mess we currently find ourselves in.

 


Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Dec 16 2.25pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Finding it hard to disagree with most of what the OP said. Making Dann captain was another case of Pardew painting himself into a corner, he can't go back on that decision now.

Townsend is utterly infuriating, I wouldn't try to move Wilf to accommodate Townsend playing on the right though. I'd rather try Townsend in the hole and Punch on the left.

Making Dann captain has been a mistake but I don't know what you mean by backed himself into a corner. We needed a player who was going to be pretty much first name on the team sheet. Dann seemed like a pretty logical choice at the time.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 11 Dec 16 2.50pm

Our workrate, desire and heart are the things that aren't in doubt IMO. We keep coming back from adversity. OK we then tend to throw it away, but we do keep coming back for more. For a team so low on confidence to come back after "that" decision shows immense character.
Obviously that will get harder to do with every poor result, so it's now that AP has to finally tweak his philosophy. Thing is, nothing wrong with being stubborn about how you want to play, but you have to have some flexibility in your approach and AP doesn't it seems. He's very like Pulis in that respect, neither one will ever change their philosophy, but in TP's case that mindset grinds out points, with AP's attacking one it throws them away.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 11 Dec 16 2.56pm

Whether Dann is captain or not will make little difference to the team performance or Dann's performance.Once the whistle blows it is the manager's job to dictate onfield tactics and player positioning. Prior to the introduction of the technical area,the manager was restricted to the bench area,but now he can be pitchside to issue orders.

What we are missing is a player who shouts, cajoles, remonstrates with their teammates,questions bad or misplaced passes,in short someone who gets angry when thing go wrong.We have already got 25,000 of this type at any home match,sadly none on the field.

What we need is someone with PASSION,and that is not currently Scott Dann.

 

Mad4palace Flag 11 Dec 16 2.57pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Making Dann captain has been a mistake but I don't know what you mean by backed himself into a corner. We needed a player who was going to be pretty much first name on the team sheet. Dann seemed like a pretty logical choice at the time.

I had always maintained the belief that changing the captain was a stupid decision, especially given that Jedinak and Delaney were still at the club when he changed it. After Jedinak was sold, Delaney should have just stayed the Captain, we've seen a fair few centre-backs brought in because Delaney is supposedly a "limited player" or it's said to be "probably his last year", yet none have managed to actually oust him from the team for very long. If it transpired this season that Tomkins kept Delaney out of the team then there is justification for changing it.

I just saw the decision as unnecessary from the beginning; Terry is still Chelsea captain, Rooney is still Manchester United's, Kompany is still Manchester City's. Why the unnecessary upheaval when Delaney played 31 games last season?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 3.13pm

My thought on yesterday is that Campbell has prevented much venting of spleens and red-hot bile directed at Pardew on HOL.One can only imagine the vitriol here if we had been defeated by Hull.

Edited by Willo (11 Dec 2016 3.13pm)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 11 Dec 16 3.21pm

I thought the third goal was horrendous. We let an average player like Livermore dance through our defence like Lionel Messi. In January i would replace all of our defenders because they are pants

 

Shortbutts Flag Birmingham 11 Dec 16 3.38pm


It wasn't the formation of the team that were at fault for Hull's second and third goals - just some really poor defending - Hull strolled through.

The players need to take responsibility. Shouting instructions
from the technical area will not stop them making such basic errors. I think Dann as captain needs to stand up and take control during the game - he's not been the same since coming back from his injury layoff. Otherwise let McArthur try a stint as captain. We also need more quality in January to at least put pressure on for a starting place.

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 11 Dec 16 3.42pm

Jimmy mac coming off seemed to change the whole dynamic of our team yesterday. Cabaye is a different style of player, Hulls second goal wouldn't have happened if jimmy mac had been on, he'd have been there. We will have to see what happens Wednesday. Watching united this afternoon we could be in for a long night!

 

travz Flag 11 Dec 16 3.59pm

It's no surprise that their 2 goals were down our left. A lef back is needed asap

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Dec 16 6.38pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I thought the third goal was horrendous. We let an average player like Livermore dance through our defence like Lionel Messi. In January i would replace all of our defenders because they are pants

Well said that man!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 6.46pm

I believe the fact remains that if we keep shipping goals as we have been doing until the end of the season we will find ourselves in the Championship.
Get back to basics I say !

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 11 Dec 16 6.51pm

Originally posted by travz

It's no surprise that their 2 goals were down our left. A lef back is needed asap


This with bells on .

Opponents have sussed that we are venerable ,crap and all round useless down our left. Anything coming down that side sees our defence pulled out of shape as we try to compensate . The Livermore goal yesterday was a prime example as Hull overloaded on that side, Dann was pulled to the left leaving a big hole that nobody filled ...

I will be a lot happier when we get a decent lb in January which we surely must

 

merganser Flag 11 Dec 16 7.57pm

The value of players such as Jedinak and Derry is that, though not gifted players themselves, they brought out 110 per cent in teammates . This more than compensated for their own deficiencies.

One particular concern is that Kelly seems to have zero appetite for the fray. He doesn't seem to enjoy the challenge of pitting his skills against some of the best forwards in football. He's fairly quick and heads the ball well. He is also a reasonable crosser of the ball. But some of his tackling, especially sideways, is as thin a tissue paper and he can't short-pass his way way out of tight situations. If he could a bit more zeal and enthusiasm into his game, he might improve. A bit of work on his psyche is required.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thoughts on yesterday