You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pep Guardiola - overrated?
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pep Guardiola - overrated?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Pussay Patrol Flag 12 Dec 16 8.44am

At Barcelona he was boss during a golden era with Messi, Xavi, iniesta etc in their pomps. Even dowie would get success with that squad. At Bayern he inherited a squad already streets ahead of their domestic rivals and the previous boss won the treble

His first real challenge in English football and he's come up short

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

jimruss Flag Sidcup 12 Dec 16 9.05am

I'm not sure you can say he's come up short just yet, it's his first season in a new league.

I think it's certainly tougher than he was expecting it to be, I'd say next season will be when we can really judge if he has come up short. He could quite easily still win the league with Citeh this year although that looks increasingly unlikely.

Once he's had a full season and really put his stamp on the squad then we'll find out what he's made of

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 12 Dec 16 9.29am


don't know about over-rated, but certainly has an element of Unproven.

Where he was undoubtedly one of the best managers while at Barcelona, circumstances meant that he was able to reach that pinnacle.
He had Messi, Xavi, iniesta et al, plus He, himself was part of The Barcelona ethos and understood the players and the playing style better than anyone. They made the Perfect partnership. but there are not other clubs quite like Barcleona. and for this reason, you have to half-disgrard his accomplishments there.

For my money, His Stint at Bayern wasn't convincing. He took over a job where the club was already winning the league. His test was the Champions league, which he failed.

None of this means he is a bad Manager, and his time at barca has proven Than he can do it, given the right tools.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 12 Dec 16 12.22pm

I don't think anyone can suggest he was a bad manager or didn't do well with his available talent at Barcelona.

You only have to look at Martino, Vilanova, and to an extent Enrique to realise that he did very well. And Rijkaard arguably had a better team and he outperformed him.

But there is definitely an element that he was embedded in the system, the ethos, the history, the culture and so had an advantage.

I think the Premier League is much more competitive that the Bundesliga or La Liga. And Man City are not playing well.

He is also trying to impose the dreaded transition on a side. And it is difficult to do.

There are some glaring tactical errors - he allowed a relatively under-confident Leicester side a huge amount of space behind to attack which seems foolhardy, but he's a very good manager. And I suspect that will show out. And they are a long way from out of the title race despite some horror results recently.

Conte in some ways had a much easier job. They already had the personnel to be a counter-attacking defensive side. He just had to do some formation switches.

Citeh require more substantial changes to really play the way Guardiola wants.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 5.26pm

Would have him at SP in the blink of an eye. Perhaps he needs red and blue in his life (barca and bayern + palace)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 5.36pm

At least they can't sing Glad All Over. They'd be better off with Louise Redknapp dancing on strictly to GAO than Stones c0cking it up left right and centre as he tries to over complicate passing between their 1st/2nd line.

 


COYP

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 8.03pm

20 trophies as a manager. Average of nearly 95 points a season. Complete fraud.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 13 Dec 16 10.17am

Of course he is a good manager when his teams are full of top drawers. Let's see what he's made of in a much more competitive league. Wish he, Mourinho, Conte and Klopp had to work with the Stoke/WBA/Burnleys instead of squads full of international stars. Then we would discover their true "greatness".

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 13 Dec 16 1.54pm

I'm not saying he's a bad manager, of course not, his record speaks for itself but I like to measure managerial value by those who overachieve. That's why I rate Clough as the greatest British manager because he took an unfashionable club, from a lower division, right to the top. Then repeated the trick with Forest, won the Champions league and retained it.

That Barca team was probably the greatest set of players ever assembled - you could have a traffic cone as the coach and they'd still won everything !

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 13 Dec 16 2.00pm

Looks like he's trying to reinvent the wheel sometimes. Plus he has John Stones who's a cracking defender for the opposition. Bravo is terrible as well, weird signing.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 13 Dec 16 2.08pm

Guardiola - “I am not a coach for the tackles. I don’t train for tackles. What I want is to try to play well and score goals. What are tackles?"

He's just a rich man's Pardew

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

leejaneagles Flag 13 Dec 16 7.45pm

Give him next season and I think he'll prove himself.

He has a unique way of wanting to play and as someone else mentioned, he likes to reinvent the wheel.

I think he's found out he's stubborn this season, if he's a true great, he'll realise it's a personal weakness he has to work on.

Bravo is the key evidence for this. Joe Hart is a solid top keeper (not the best in the league but capable of being in a title winning side). He's adored by City which means a lot and knows the Premier League.

He threw all that away because Bravo can supposedly pass a ball under pressure. As it turns out, he can't, it just looked that way because Spanish teams wouldn't press Barcelona's back line.

It will be a mixture of buying the right players for his formation - he'll simply have to replace Clichy and Sagna as full-backs but also sticking to what he believes in - John Stones.

I really think with the right team around him Stones will flourish and play the football Guardiola wants.

If the first game of next season he has Joe Hart as No. 1, new blood at full-back and to everyone's shock John Stones at centerback he will look like a man who has learned from his mistakes but also stayed strong to his convictions.

If he insists on Bravo and then buys a Center-back the height of Mascherano though he's an arrogant fool.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 13 Dec 16 9.23pm

I reckon he's about the same level as Alan Pardew.

Going by the posts on here so far....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 14 Dec 16 2.03pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Give him next season and I think he'll prove himself.

He has a unique way of wanting to play and as someone else mentioned, he likes to reinvent the wheel.

I think he's found out he's stubborn this season, if he's a true great, he'll realise it's a personal weakness he has to work on.

Bravo is the key evidence for this. Joe Hart is a solid top keeper (not the best in the league but capable of being in a title winning side). He's adored by City which means a lot and knows the Premier League.

He threw all that away because Bravo can supposedly pass a ball under pressure. As it turns out, he can't, it just looked that way because Spanish teams wouldn't press Barcelona's back line.

It will be a mixture of buying the right players for his formation - he'll simply have to replace Clichy and Sagna as full-backs but also sticking to what he believes in - John Stones.

I really think with the right team around him Stones will flourish and play the football Guardiola wants.

If the first game of next season he has Joe Hart as No. 1, new blood at full-back and to everyone's shock John Stones at centerback he will look like a man who has learned from his mistakes but also stayed strong to his convictions.

If he insists on Bravo and then buys a Center-back the height of Mascherano though he's an arrogant fool.

Joe Hart is massively overrated and it was the right decision to move him on.

But Bravo hasn't proved to be the replacement they wanted (although still much better suited to the style of football they wanted to play). He's not an awful keeper just not good enough and his confidence on the ball is tested too much because Man City defenders aren't good enough.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Struzzo Flag Brentford 18 Dec 16 1.37am

Five years to work out the ins and outs of the league and he'll be prove he is "all that"- the complexity of the league is nothing like Germany or Spain, the football is different, the culture is different and the other teams are (generally) harder to beat. He's clearly a smart guy but he needs time to work out what works.

He won't be given that long though.

That said, I can't see any team being completely dominant (IE winning consistent league titles) any time soon, nor making any real noise in the Champions League. So it's hard to judge what is successful.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 18 Dec 16 11.31am

Originally posted by OknotOK

Joe Hart is massively overrated and it was the right decision to move him on.

But Bravo hasn't proved to be the replacement they wanted (although still much better suited to the style of football they wanted to play). He's not an awful keeper just not good enough and his confidence on the ball is tested too much because Man City defenders aren't good enough.

Lets sell them Mandanda for 30 mil. He wants to go and we make a fat profit

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 19 Dec 16 11.58am

Originally posted by sickboy

Lets sell them Mandanda for 30 mil. He wants to go and we make a fat profit

Mandanda is actually in line with the sort of keeper he wants. Very comfortable on the ball, wants to be able to pass out from the back.

If you look at the stats pre-injury we were one of the sides passing most out from the back in the league.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 19 Dec 16 2.14pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

Mandanda is actually in line with the sort of keeper he wants. Very comfortable on the ball, wants to be able to pass out from the back.

If you look at the stats pre-injury we were one of the sides passing most out from the back in the league.

Which, i think, put our defence under pressure too near our own goal.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Dec 16 7.57pm

Time and again we see a messianic figure, a blue eyed boy.....who did well elsewhere and is feted as the next big premier league manager................................followed by 'boom tish, another bum'' and consigned to the dustbin of history.

guardiola will be no different.

anyway, the most over-rated one-trick-pony is Arsene Wenger.....totally predictable and transparent. All the good managers have figured him out by now and he will never ever win the title again.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Dec 2016 8.00pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 21 Dec 16 12.48pm

judge him over 3 seasons and then make your mind up. He's certainly one of the best and we'll see whether he can impress his footballing philosophy on City and make it work in the Prem and with an English team in European comps by winning silverwear. That is the real measure of success and it's too early to call at this stage.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pep Guardiola - overrated?