You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > china
November 16 2026 10.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

china


dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Dec 16 8.35am

Football has become money driven. The majority of premier league players are foreigners. Of the rest, a large proportion are first generation immigrants who have no loyalty to this place and I don't blame them. The issue of Zaha and Ivory Coast is a classic example.
The vast majority of the professional sportsmen follow the money. That's why there are currently so many here.
China are now offering the stars FIVE toTEN times what they get here, and England is one of the best payers thanks to Sky.
So Tevez. Is now almost the best paid footballer in the world at £350,000/ week. Renaldo has been offered £800,000/ week.
So what will Zaha do on £35K /week when they offer him £150K?
He has just shown he has no loyalty to England Whatsoever.
The premier is on the edge of big change. If we want to compete we will have to pay £500/ month Sky subscription and £ 300 per game to watch.
No, the future is China. They are well ahead of the game. They have just introduced video technology. Within 3 years most of the top players will be there. Look at the recent history of moneybal and you may understand this.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Dec 16 9.01am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

So what will Zaha do on £35K /week when they offer him £150K?
He has just shown he has no loyalty to England Whatsoever.

Zaha was homesick in Manchester so what would be like living in China and the comment about having no loyalty to England is rubbish as he waited long enough to be picked and wasn't. It's all well and good for the England managers telling him that he is in their thoughts but talk is cheap and the land of his birth showed him that if England didn't want him - they did

 

snytaxx Flag London 31 Dec 16 9.35am

I wouldn't worry too much about this if I were you.

While this country (China) definitely has huge footballing potential, it's domestic league is in no fit state to truly attract big football players in it's current format.

Go to any Chinese football match and you soon realise the whole thing is just for consumer entertainment, it has nothing to do with good old fashioned 'rule of law' football. We might complain about the ref at Palace but in China, it's an open secret that the ref is paid by the league to create 'entertaining matches'.

So yes, while a few footballers might well be tempted out here due to the wages, it will be a temporary fad and only just that. Just like how the American leagues are / were, you wait until you are old and not good enough to make the first team in your premier league outfit anymore, then you take a ten fold pay increase and move to China for a year, play some of the best / worst football of your career then take your money and retire. Good for them I say!

These concerns about how money affects the game have always existed (since the game took off commercially), the only thing that has changed are the players involved (the destination leagues). Once it was the USA, today it's China, tomorrow, who knows?

 

xomnea Flag 31 Dec 16 9.50am

[Link]

Sky to show Chinese Super League for the next three seasons.

 

chateauferret Flag 31 Dec 16 11.14am

Originally posted by snytaxx

I wouldn't worry too much about this if I were you.

While this country (China) definitely has huge footballing potential, it's domestic league is in no fit state to truly attract big football players in it's current format.

Go to any Chinese football match and you soon realise the whole thing is just for consumer entertainment, it has nothing to do with good old fashioned 'rule of law' football. We might complain about the ref at Palace but in China, it's an open secret that the ref is paid by the league to create 'entertaining matches'.

Which of course is why they want "Mark". Nothing to do with a track record in impartiality, fairness or judgement. Bent as a nine-bob bit and good at politics.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 31 Dec 16 5.16pm

Originally posted by snytaxx

I wouldn't worry too much about this if I were you.

While this country (China) definitely has huge footballing potential, it's domestic league is in no fit state to truly attract big football players in it's current format.

Go to any Chinese football match and you soon realise the whole thing is just for consumer entertainment, it has nothing to do with good old fashioned 'rule of law' football. We might complain about the ref at Palace but in China, it's an open secret that the ref is paid by the league to create 'entertaining matches'.

So yes, while a few footballers might well be tempted out here due to the wages, it will be a temporary fad and only just that. Just like how the American leagues are / were, you wait until you are old and not good enough to make the first team in your premier league outfit anymore, then you take a ten fold pay increase and move to China for a year, play some of the best / worst football of your career then take your money and retire. Good for them I say!

These concerns about how money affects the game have always existed (since the game took off commercially), the only thing that has changed are the players involved (the destination leagues). Once it was the USA, today it's China, tomorrow, who knows?

Great comments, sums it all up perfectly, particularly the failed attempt/s in US.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 Jan 17 2.14am

Football is too expensive for the working man in China. Last Palace match I watch in Hong Kong, China a G and T was seven quid.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

snytaxx Flag London 02 Jan 17 8.18am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Football is too expensive for the working man in China. Last Palace match I watch in Hong Kong, China a G and T was seven quid.

It's a 100 rmb (£12) for me to go and watch my local team (Beijing Guo An), I mean, it's alot cheaper than watching the Palace but then I guess it depends on what you mean by 'the working man'.

In the UK a working man could be a plumber earning over 40K a year, here it could be taxi driver earning barely earning 15K a year. It's just income really, nothing to do with the overall price of the ticket.

On a random cringe related tangent. The last time I went to a Chinese football match (Beijing Guo An vs Gui Zhou Ren He), the home fans were so disgusted that they were only winning 2-0 (60 minutes played),coupled with the likelihood some have probably watched way to many 'old firm' matches, they decided to start a 'riot'.

By 'riot' I mean it was a fat guy who got so angry when the away team were given a corner, he and his identical T-shirt wearing friends ran down to try and storm the pitch, only to be very easily repulsed by literally one guard. One of them then waddled back up the steps to where his popcorn and cinema sized bucket of cola was situated while the others recreated that fight scene from Team America (the one where both the puppets just kinda shuffle up again each other without really fighting). Freshly have returned to his seat, angry fat man then hurled all of his overpriced foot and drinks at the opposition player (lining up to take the corner). Sadly he missed and hit one of his own players warming up on the touchline who I might add, was not expecting a litre of coke to come flying out of the stands. Said fan then disappeared for 10 minutes back into the stadium concourse while he went and bought another bucket of coca cola and possibly a hot dog.

Oh China...

Edited by snytaxx (02 Jan 2017 8.19am)

 

chateauferret Flag 02 Jan 17 9.53am

Originally posted by snytaxx

On a random cringe related tangent. The last time I went to a Chinese football match (Beijing Guo An vs Gui Zhou Ren He), the home fans were so disgusted that they were only winning 2-0 (60 minutes played),coupled with the likelihood some have probably watched way to many 'old firm' matches, they decided to start a 'riot'.

By 'riot' I mean it was a fat guy who got so angry when the away team were given a corner, he and his identical T-shirt wearing friends ran down to try and storm the pitch, only to be very easily repulsed by literally one guard. One of them then waddled back up the steps to where his popcorn and cinema sized bucket of cola was situated while the others recreated that fight scene from Team America (the one where both the puppets just kinda shuffle up again each other without really fighting). Freshly have returned to his seat, angry fat man then hurled all of his overpriced foot and drinks at the opposition player (lining up to take the corner). Sadly he missed and hit one of his own players warming up on the touchline who I might add, was not expecting a litre of coke to come flying out of the stands. Said fan then disappeared for 10 minutes back into the stadium concourse while he went and bought another bucket of coca cola and possibly a hot dog.

You sure you weren't at The Valley watching Clowntown?

 


============
The Ferret
============

dreamwaverider Flag London 04 Jan 17 1.33am

After hearing about interst in Benteke made me realise just hoe pertinent China could be this year. I can see a lot of the Mercia Aru footballers jumping ship.
As foreigners here, who came purely for the money, who wouldn't go.?
Benteke Wil earn £ 10M virtually tax free over there.
Whatever you may think snytaxx I reckon hundreds of players will be on the move this year.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 04 Jan 17 1.37am

Mercia Aru = mercinary.
Could be a real cash cow for teams like us. Wouldn't be hard to raise £100M and then we really would have a fresh start.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 04 Jan 17 2.05am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Football has become money driven. The majority of premier league players are foreigners. Of the rest, a large proportion are first generation immigrants who have no loyalty to this place and I don't blame them. The issue of Zaha and Ivory Coast is a classic example.
The vast majority of the professional sportsmen follow the money. That's why there are currently so many here.
China are now offering the stars FIVE toTEN times what they get here, and England is one of the best payers thanks to Sky.
So Tevez. Is now almost the best paid footballer in the world at £350,000/ week. Renaldo has been offered £800,000/ week.
So what will Zaha do on £35K /week when they offer him £150K?
He has just shown he has no loyalty to England Whatsoever.
The premier is on the edge of big change. If we want to compete we will have to pay £500/ month Sky subscription and £ 300 per game to watch.
No, the future is China. They are well ahead of the game. They have just introduced video technology. Within 3 years most of the top players will be there. Look at the recent history of moneybal and you may understand this.

I wouldn't worry, not many footballers want to relocate to china for a couple of years

 


This was once a quality forum....

snytaxx Flag London 04 Jan 17 2.41am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

After hearing about interst in Benteke made me realise just hoe pertinent China could be this year. I can see a lot of the Mercia Aru footballers jumping ship.
As foreigners here, who came purely for the money, who wouldn't go.?
Benteke Wil earn £ 10M virtually tax free over there.
Whatever you may think snytaxx I reckon hundreds of players will be on the move this year.

From an English point of view, yes it would make sense to move here. However once you actually arrive, you (the footballer) would soon realise what a mistake you've made. Thats why you get players who move here for a season, take the pay check then leave again (i.e. Anelka).

I also think 'we' the fans often underestimate our players mindsets. Yes you can see lots of example of players 'jumping ship' because they get more money for essentially playing the same position e.g. Sterling moving from first team Liverpool to first team Man City. However while footballers are conscious about the money, after a while when they get so uber rich, money isn't as important as playing, because if you don't play, your value (and thus your wages) decreases e.g. Scott Sinclair.

This is why China will always be great for older players who know their days in their cushy top flight team are numbered. For other players who just follow the money, let me give you a cautionary tale of Demba Ba.

When he signed for Shanghai Shenhua, despite being injured, his team had promised it's fans he would play AND score on his debut. After sitting on the bench for 70 minutes and the team getting no where near the goal, the ref suddenly gave Shanghai a penalty, Ba was subbed on (limping) and was told to take the penalty. Only, he missed, and missed badly. However the ref decided that the defenders had encroached (even though none had) and demanded the penalty be retaken, which it was and Ba finally scored with the goal keeper essentially jumping out the way of the ball. Ba was then subbed off looking like an awkward teenager at a toddlers birthday party.

If Ba was just in it for a money, he made a terrible mistake, despite 'some' talent, the Chinese super league is basically made up of actors, sorry amateur footballers. While playing in a Shanghai derby match, an opposition player basically went all San Marino on him and broke his leg, he hasn't played since and may never again. Once his contract runs out, it looks like he will miss out on the rest of his career. Worth it? Probably not.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Jan 17 11.01pm

Now costa is tempted.
You only need a dozen or so big names to go and the floodgates will open.
I mean Costa £30M pa? Who would blame him to take if. that's £600K/ wk.
So how would Wilf react to £ 150/wk
Football and footballers.......money driven. China is gonna do some damage.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 14 Jan 17 12.08am

Just a fad. china is a cheap copier of talent. look at their purchases of antiques, quality consumer goods, foreign property, etc. They burn brightly and invest heavily for a short period of time before realizing that they are, in fact, still chinese and no amount of money or merchandise will change that. the term nouveau riche is an understatement. They are cheap, tasteless wannabes who rip off the poor in their own country and seek desperately to copy the culture of others. That'll never appeal to the global millions

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (14 Jan 2017 12.09am)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Hudsoneagle Flag 14 Jan 17 1.46am

The Chinese football leagues are not ready to truly take the game seriously so at this point high profile signings are just PR stunts for the top teams.

I read that if a team gets relegated then the fans just move on to the next team. They don't support their clubs the way the rest of the world support their clubs. Can you imagine being relegated from the Prem league and then having a 80% drop in season tickets sales? It would spell the end of any club, especially while paying one player a possible £350k a week!

While I don't mind seeing players nearing the end of their career going out there, it would be a concern if younger prospects started to go there. They say that simply training with world class players can bring your game along let alone what playing in the most competitive leagues can do to aid development...what would it do for a young prospect playing in China?

 

snytaxx Flag London 14 Jan 17 5.43am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Just a fad. china is a cheap copier of talent. look at their purchases of antiques, quality consumer goods, foreign property, etc. They burn brightly and invest heavily for a short period of time before realizing that they are, in fact, still chinese and no amount of money or merchandise will change that. the term nouveau riche is an understatement. They are cheap, tasteless wannabes who rip off the poor in their own country and seek desperately to copy the culture of others. That'll never appeal to the global millions

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (14 Jan 2017 12.09am)

It's definitely okay to have a certain amount of beef with China, however some of what you've written above is not only unjustified, it's damn right wrong.

Firstly China has plenty of talent, it just needs the right investment to bring it out. Dont believe me? Look at the Olympics, during the 1970s they won nothing, in the 1980's they started to invest and by the 1990's they started to break into the medal table. Now look at them! Give them a couple of decades and they will be at a world cup.

Moving on to their purchases of antiques. Again your right, the Chinese are buying a lot, however I might suggest you actually look at what kinds of antiques they are actually buying. I think you'd find alot of them are ancient Chinese artefacts which were illegally removed from China decades ago.

" They burn brightly and invest heavily for a short period of time before realizing that they are"

If you look at China's 5000 year history, you'd actually find they have been burning very brightly for longs periods of that, I mean they did invent gunpowder after all. Still don't let facts and history get in the way of a good rant.

"They are cheap, tasteless wannabes who rip off the poor in their own country and seek desperately to copy the culture of others

So they work hard and for not alot of money, not sure why this is suddenly a bad thing. They are all tasteless, despite having ancient culture, excellent culinary and interesting linguistics thats it - they are all totally tasteless because you said so. Whats next? Oh they 'rip off the poor in their country'. While any country with 1.3 billion people of course has issues, since 1980 they have managed to bring over 500 million people out of poverty, with another 200 million promised in the next 20 years. Still - not good enough for James Richards - f***ERS!

Whats the last 'argument'? - Oh they try and copy other peoples cultures? Absolutely - how DARE they come over to OUR country, invest £10,000's pounds of THEIR OWN MONEY in to OUR CULTURE to try and build bridges, and then, they have the cheek to want to enjoy the same things WE BRITISH want to enjoy. I mean, my god, why can't we have the kind of people who'd just insist we adopt their entire culture to suit them instead! HOW UTTERLY SELFISH!

...

Try again!
...

Edited by snytaxx (14 Jan 2017 5.53am)

 

snytaxx Flag London 14 Jan 17 5.50am

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

The Chinese football leagues are not ready to truly take the game seriously so at this point high profile signings are just PR stunts for the top teams.

I read that if a team gets relegated then the fans just move on to the next team. They don't support their clubs the way the rest of the world support their clubs. Can you imagine being relegated from the Prem league and then having a 80% drop in season tickets sales? It would spell the end of any club, especially while paying one player a possible £350k a week!

While I don't mind seeing players nearing the end of their career going out there, it would be a concern if younger prospects started to go there. They say that simply training with world class players can bring your game along let alone what playing in the most competitive leagues can do to aid development...what would it do for a young prospect playing in China?

As i've said before, it will be the older players coming out here.

Your also fairly well informed regarding fan loyalty. Sadly Chinese culture often rewards the strong, many fans don't really have the concept of football team loyalty, you just watch football to be entertained, why would you want to be associated with a team that loses alot? A questions many of us Palace fans have asked ourselves on occasion im sure.

As i've also said previous, players won't come here because the league isn't fair yet either. If you are a smaller side, it's almost impossible to beat a bigger team away from home because the referee's wont allow it. I went to a Beijing Guo An game once where the referee gave a penalty in he 91st minute against the away team (who where leading 0-1) because the goalkeeper committed handball. like... WTF? Plus don't forget the injury risk.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 14 Jan 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by snytaxx

As i've said before, it will be the older players coming out here.

Your also fairly well informed regarding fan loyalty. Sadly Chinese culture often rewards the strong, many fans don't really have the concept of football team loyalty, you just watch football to be entertained, why would you want to be associated with a team that loses alot? A questions many of us Palace fans have asked ourselves on occasion im sure.

As i've also said previous, players won't come here because the league isn't fair yet either. If you are a smaller side, it's almost impossible to beat a bigger team away from home because the referee's wont allow it. I went to a Beijing Guo An game once where the referee gave a penalty in he 91st minute against the away team (who where leading 0-1) because the goalkeeper committed handball. like... WTF? Plus don't forget the injury risk.

I have enjoyed reading your input about a league that I'm still only just learning about. I will tell you something, I like to bet on football and it strikes me now just how many games abroad might be fixed. It's a big concern ya know, because until now I would never have believed it.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > china