You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > McCarthur
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

McCarthur


Rogers Don Flag Horsham 14 Jan 17 11.41pm

Why was he substituted again with the inevitable result? was he injured again? or was he knackered? Even a half fit McCarthur is better than Ledley and Cabaye.
Remy should have started instead. Schlupp should also have started at left back

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 14 Jan 17 11.48pm

jimmy mac is mustard, possibly our most influental player.

needs to be playing alongside cabaye, not instead of him.

dont know why he was subbed, hes so comfortable on the ball woth both feet its lovely to watch.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 14 Jan 17 11.49pm

His first game back after a lay off, hardly surprising if he was running out of steam.

 


Most certainly not European.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 15 Jan 17 12.51am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

jimmy mac is mustard, possibly our most influental player.

needs to be playing alongside cabaye, not instead of him.

dont know why he was subbed, hes so comfortable on the ball woth both feet its lovely to watch.

I know you hate Sam Allardyce, and did not want AP fired, but you are grossly stretching things if you think McCarhur was good for 90 minutes after being out injured.

I normally read your posts because you are generally reasonable, but your hatred for Sam seems to have clouded your judgement. It is almost as though you are looking for any excuse to criticize him.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 15 Jan 17 7.54am

Will get a nice bit of dough for him when we go down. Great little player.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Jacey Flag 15 Jan 17 9.13am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Will get a nice bit of dough for him when we go down. Great little player.

Sorry to disappoint,but we are not going down.
Sam, agreed needs time to settle in and see the big picture and with a few more signings before the window closes,he will keep us up,not like ' clueless',who would have taken us down.

 

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 15 Jan 17 9.24am

Originally posted by Rogers Don

Why was he substituted again with the inevitable result? was he injured again? or was he knackered? Even a half fit McCarthur is better than Ledley and Cabaye.
Remy should have started instead. Schlupp should also have started at left back

All easy to say at 11.41pm of course.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 15 Jan 17 10.18am

Originally posted by Rogers Don

Why was he substituted again with the inevitable result? was he injured again? or was he knackered? Even a half fit McCarthur is better than Ledley and Cabaye.
Remy should have started instead. Schlupp should also have started at left back

So you think we should have started a player who has been out all season and had basically no competitive minutes under his belt, start a player who has had less than 1 training session with the squad and play another who has just returned from injury for 90 minutes?

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 15 Jan 17 3.58pm

Could Schlupp have done any worse than Joel Ward playing out of position? The rest of the players looked as though they hadn't played together before.
As far as McArthur's concerned, would an extra 15 minutes have made any difference? He went off in the 79th minute and Carroll scored within 30 seconds. A great goal, but Ward didn't get tight enough to him.
Pardew also substituted McArthur's in two previous games and we lost both times.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 15 Jan 17 4.41pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Sorry to disappoint,but we are not going down.
Sam, agreed needs time to settle in and see the big picture and with a few more signings before the window closes,he will keep us up,not like ' clueless',who would have taken us down.

That's the spirit Jacey, Big Sam will turn it round. It was probably always going to get worse before it got better. He'll turn it around.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 15 Jan 17 4.48pm

Mcarthur is a good player, but one stat i saw last season that sticks with me is that he was the premier leagues most dribbled past player at one stage.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > McCarthur