You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fielding an untainted side
November 16 2026 10.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fielding an untainted side


Mad4palace Flag 05 Feb 17 12.16am

With the rot fully settled into the old players, many of them being present in the team for the last 13 months of awful form, it must be time for quite a few of them to spend some time away from the first XI. With new signings relatively untainted by the sides low confidence, should we be trying to field a team a bit more like this?

Mandanda
Ward - Dann - Sakho - Van Aanholt
Zaha - McArthur - Milivojevic - Schlupp
Benteke - Remy

With the new signings, plus Remy you have 5 out of your 11 players that have not played through the awful last year.

Mandanda, when he returns should be relatively unscathed compared to Hennessey. McArthur and Zaha are the only players that have been in form for the past year, so they keep their place. Benteke can still notch a goal up front. Ward and Dann keep their place only by virtue of there being no one else to come in in their positions.

Flamini and Campbell are probably more unscathed by the awful form too, so might be worth giving them more time.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 05 Feb 17 12.20am

Worth a try. But the Gods that are Hennessy, Puncheon and Cabaye are surely immovable?

 


Spirit of 1974

FairweatherEagle Flag London 05 Feb 17 12.26am

Not a bad idea, would need a run of games to gain familiarity though. Also Townsend's been pretty decent lately so I'd be tempted to rotate with Schlupp and Zaha. We do need fresh (and competent) legs in midfield though, and I would bed in Milivojevic asap, we need him desperately IMO. Especially after today.

 

Mad4palace Flag 05 Feb 17 12.44am

Originally posted by FairweatherEagle

Not a bad idea, would need a run of games to gain familiarity though. Also Townsend's been pretty decent lately so I'd be tempted to rotate with Schlupp and Zaha. We do need fresh (and competent) legs in midfield though, and I would bed in Milivojevic asap, we need him desperately IMO. Especially after today.


Midfield is the heart of our problems. I'm astonished that Ledley is still being fielded at all, he shouldn't even be on the bench. Milivojevic HAS to work, otherwise I can't see any other outcome other than relegation. A 4-4-2 with 2 solid defensive midfielders and 2 up front would make us a much more stable outfit IMO. I rate Flamini based off what i've seen so I don't know why he and Milivojevic couldn't work in midfield if we had pace out wide and 2 up front.

I want 3 at the back to be an option but I have my doubts about Tomkins and Ward on that right side. Tomkins has been a serious disappointment this season and was at fault for at least 2 of their goals.

Certainly players like Hennessey, Ledley, Puncheon have to be taken out of the spotlight for a while.

 

EverOptimisticEagle Flag 05 Feb 17 7.00am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

With the rot fully settled into the old players, many of them being present in the team for the last 13 months of awful form, it must be time for quite a few of them to spend some time away from the first XI. With new signings relatively untainted by the sides low confidence, should we be trying to field a team a bit more like this?

Mandanda
Ward - Dann - Sakho - Van Aanholt
Zaha - McArthur - Milivojevic - Schlupp
Benteke - Remy

With the new signings, plus Remy you have 5 out of your 11 players that have not played through the awful last year.

Mandanda, when he returns should be relatively unscathed compared to Hennessey. McArthur and Zaha are the only players that have been in form for the past year, so they keep their place. Benteke can still notch a goal up front. Ward and Dann keep their place only by virtue of there being no one else to come in in their positions.

Flamini and Campbell are probably more unscathed by the awful form too, so might be worth giving them more time.


I have been thinking the same thing. Ringing wholesale changes could be the only option left. Couldn't do any worse.

 

meatpienz Flag brisbane 05 Feb 17 7.27am

Are Milivojevic and Schlupp available for Stoke?

 


Zaha has some green grass in front of him here. Finds Ambrose
not a bad effort ooooooooooh! what a goal by Darren Ambrose absolutely stunning strike!!! And, Crystal Palace lead @ Old Trafford.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 17 9.02am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

With the rot fully settled into the old players, many of them being present in the team for the last 13 months of awful form, it must be time for quite a few of them to spend some time away from the first XI. With new signings relatively untainted by the sides low confidence, should we be trying to field a team a bit more like this?

Mandanda
Ward - Dann - Sakho - Van Aanholt
Zaha - McArthur - Milivojevic - Schlupp
Benteke - Remy

With the new signings, plus Remy you have 5 out of your 11 players that have not played through the awful last year.

Mandanda, when he returns should be relatively unscathed compared to Hennessey. McArthur and Zaha are the only players that have been in form for the past year, so they keep their place. Benteke can still notch a goal up front. Ward and Dann keep their place only by virtue of there being no one else to come in in their positions.

Flamini and Campbell are probably more unscathed by the awful form too, so might be worth giving them more time.


Irrespective of the personnel available/picked, the one thing Allardyce definitely needs to take from your suggestion is to play 4-4-fcuking2 or 4-3-3 (or at worst 4-2-3-1), because playing three at the back isn't working and it was just a fluke that we got something at Bournemouth (or we just took them by surprise). I don't give a flying fcuk that it works for Chelsea, we aren't them by a long stretch.

We have had two very good spells in the PL, Pulis' half season and Pardew's two half season's in 2015, then it all went wrong, even though we basically have the same, or considerably better personnel. Apparently we employ experts in analysis and tactics and they need to examine those good spells, figure out what we were doing right, and get back to doing it again. We have to balance solid defending with actually scoring goals; when we can do that, we'll start winning games.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 05 Feb 17 9.06am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

With the rot fully settled into the old players, many of them being present in the team for the last 13 months of awful form, it must be time for quite a few of them to spend some time away from the first XI. With new signings relatively untainted by the sides low confidence, should we be trying to field a team a bit more like this?

Mandanda
Ward - Dann - Sakho - Van Aanholt
Zaha - McArthur - Milivojevic - Schlupp
Benteke - Remy

With the new signings, plus Remy you have 5 out of your 11 players that have not played through the awful last year.

Mandanda, when he returns should be relatively unscathed compared to Hennessey. McArthur and Zaha are the only players that have been in form for the past year, so they keep their place. Benteke can still notch a goal up front. Ward and Dann keep their place only by virtue of there being no one else to come in in their positions.

Flamini and Campbell are probably more unscathed by the awful form too, so might be worth giving them more time.

Yes agree totallly with this approach and the team you suggest.
The midfield, except McArthur, have added no pace, no creativity and no defensive support and give away possession.
Subs: Townsend, Cabaye, Flamini, Lee, Speroni, Kelley, Sako

Not selected: Puncheon, Ledley, Hennessy, Delaney

 

Rabbit-Tooth Flag London 05 Feb 17 9.08am

No Ward please. We've no one else but I'd rather have a youth team player.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 05 Feb 17 9.14am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

With the rot fully settled into the old players, many of them being present in the team for the last 13 months of awful form, it must be time for quite a few of them to spend some time away from the first XI. With new signings relatively untainted by the sides low confidence, should we be trying to field a team a bit more like this?

Mandanda
Ward - Dann - Sakho - Van Aanholt
Zaha - McArthur - Milivojevic - Schlupp
Benteke - Remy

With the new signings, plus Remy you have 5 out of your 11 players that have not played through the awful last year.

Mandanda, when he returns should be relatively unscathed compared to Hennessey. McArthur and Zaha are the only players that have been in form for the past year, so they keep their place. Benteke can still notch a goal up front. Ward and Dann keep their place only by virtue of there being no one else to come in in their positions.

Flamini and Campbell are probably more unscathed by the awful form too, so might be worth giving them more time.


Exactly how I feel.
All this seasons signings have to somehow make a team, if available.
Speroni
PVA
Sakho
Tomkins
Schlupp
Macca
Flamini
Luka
Zaha
Townsend
Benteke
With Remy, Kaikai, these to me should be the least tainted mentally of the lot.

Edited by Dangermouse (05 Feb 2017 9.19am)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

FairweatherEagle Flag London 05 Feb 17 5.36pm

Agree about a midfield of Flam/Mili. The others, all the old boys you've mentioned I reckon need a chance to get fit to SA levels and prove themselves once again, but could definitely do with missing a few matches.

 

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 05 Feb 17 7.27pm

This I think is the plan . That's why they bought them. I would rather see some youngsters come up as well.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fielding an untainted side