You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Video Analysis of Stoke Goal vs CPFC
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Video Analysis of Stoke Goal vs CPFC


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dmendenhall_9 Flag 20 Feb 17 4.57am

A short analysis video of the goal against vs Stoke City. While there were many errors that lead to the goal as I have watched it over and over again I can point to Puncheon and Hennessey as making the major mistakes that allow Stoke to go ahead. After watching it I think almost everyone will agree that there is NO WAY IN HELL that Hennessey or Puncheon should be starting next game.

Check it out and let me know what you think.

[Link]

Edited by dmendenhall_9 (20 Feb 2017 5.11am)

 

cardiff eagle Flag 20 Feb 17 6.39am

Was interesting. My points would be:

1. Zaha lost the ball, not puncheon. He could've played it off the man for throw in or slipped it inside for ward. However, so much happened since then that you can't blame the person who gave the ball away

2. When the ball was played forward for the goal I don't really blame puncheon too much or not anymore than Luca. Looking behind them there was a man to each stoke player and then Delaney was spare who could've picked up Allen.

3. Delaney runs too far back allowing Allen space to set himself and pick his angle.

4. Agree Hennessy was on back foot too much but think his general position was okish. Should've got their quicker perhaps but if he have stayed more to the right then Allen would've taken an earlier shot to the left instead.

Basically in general was a good goal and not much blame to be apportioned. Think Delaney for me is the one who stands out as he could see joe allens run from early, knew everyone else was being marked and should've gone to the ball rather than running away then going to the ball. Strikes me that he didn't have confidence in PVA to stop Ramadan turning and shooting so gambled that way rather than trusting the man marking.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 20 Feb 17 6.47am

Was too time consuming to look at it all on my phone. 5 minutes would be better and ideally you'd do it in a way that lends itself to silent viewing.

It looked like you nailed Punch right (from the bit I saw) but it would be insightful to know how he was instructed to play in that situation.

As for WH -- I couldn't be sure the point you were making. Then I got text message and couldn't be fagged to go back to it.

Bottom line: I liked what you did but try to make them shorter.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (20 Feb 2017 7.24am)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Feb 17 8.46am

Got caught 3 v 3 at the back. Three of our players were attracted to the ball and Sobhi leaving two of their players in acres of space one of which was Allen who scored.
We were cut through our midfield like a knife through butter yet again.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 20 Feb 17 9.42am

This goal is just another example of us being caught on the counter. This sort of goal has been conceded for a few seasons now especially in our home games with Defoe's 2 goals recently classic examples.

Our previous Premiership success came from being a counter attacking time with the pace of Zaha and Bolaise but this success was mainly in away games or against the top teams at home. When confronted by a 10 man defence at home we were always open to the break.
The main reason for these goals was and still is due to us losing the ball high up the pitch when we are attacking thus leaving us bare at the back. This is exactly what happened at Stoke.

To be fair to Pardew he tried to change our style so that we were not just counter attacking but the problem he had was just the same as before (and since ). That problem is we do not have a strong enough midfield. Too many times we give the ball away with the main culprits being Puncheon and Wilf. In this league you get punished for these mistakes.

I thought that Cabaye would be the answer to this problem but he has been a massive let down and no doubt he let Pardew down as well. Whether Luka will be the answer only time will tell but in the meantime Sam's only option is to pack the midfield and play more defensively. My main worry with this is that it requires a lone striker who works his socks off. Benteke doesn't do that , Remy might and Campbell will but he doesn't have the quality to score the goals we need. Benteke has the quality but Sam has got to get him out of first gear because Prem football now is all about being an 11 man game and it starts with the striker.
I'd like to see Luka and Cabaye playing in front of the defence to give the protection with McCarthur in front of them thus making us solid through the middle but it still needs a hard working striker.

A change of keeper is also well overdue. The amount of criticism towards Hennessey surely must have affected his confidence and that of the defenders in front of him ?

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 20 Feb 17 10.15am

Damo cocked up ,simple , he should have marked Allen but decided to help pva instead for some reason.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Feb 17 10.42am

Originally posted by Loz83

Damo cocked up ,simple , he should have marked Allen but decided to help pva instead for some reason.

Looking at it again, given the flight of the ball and the out-to-in run of Sobhi I can understand why Delaney got back into a more central position to try and nullify the attack. It appears that Tomkins is just looking at the ball, unaware of two Stoke players running free but he was badly exposed by our midfield not picking up Allen - who the hell was supposed to be tracking him ? This I feel was the major problem.It is not as if we were behind and chasing the game, it was 0-0 at the time at a tough place like Stoke. At the end of the day it is sinful that Allen got so much space.

Edited by Willo (20 Feb 2017 10.43am)

 

Mad4palace Flag 20 Feb 17 11.24am

Good analysis. The midfield was the most at fault here, Puncheon should have got back, he knows where Milivojevic is and that McArthur is way up field. That said, McArthur should be getting back quicker though and be there just to make the pass out to Ramadan a little harder to make, if Arnoutovic just has to think about it a little more then maybe he's tackled or overhits the pass. From the moment Wilf loses it McArthur doesn't do anything, he's looking back at a huge gap in the centre of midfield and he doesn't track back, he just needs to defend the space then either the initial pass might not be made or Allen won't have that space to run into. The defence is not really at fault here, only Delaney possibly should have not rushed back at full pelt like he did, he might have been better set/positioned to make the block on the shot a bit higher up.

Decent spot on Hennessey, although if he were to keep his original position then Allen would have just slipped it into the near post and if he comes too far to the left then he would have even more momentum taking him away from where Allen slots it in the end. His footwork was terrible though, nothing to spring from as dmendenhal points out and he gives up to much of the goal to aim at. The most apt description of Hennessey from your vid: "He literally just falls". The truth is Hennessey is a s*** athlete compared to practically all PL goalkeepers, especially compared to Speroni. But Hennessey doesn't make up for it with good positioning or footwork, that's arguably even worse. He only has decent kicking and that shouldn't be what a keeper is selected on.

Edited by Mad4palace (20 Feb 2017 12.53pm)

 

stevo Flag Reigate 20 Feb 17 12.42pm

Very insightful Devin, can you @ Punch & Hennesey to this please?

I know it's not twitter but damn that would be useful.....

 


Slowly slowly catchy monkey

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 20 Feb 17 2.10pm

Video too long and slow.

Could have been done in 2 mins maximum imo

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 20 Feb 17 4.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

Looking at it again, given the flight of the ball and the out-to-in run of Sobhi I can understand why Delaney got back into a more central position to try and nullify the attack. It appears that Tomkins is just looking at the ball, unaware of two Stoke players running free but he was badly exposed by our midfield not picking up Allen - who the hell was supposed to be tracking him ? This I feel was the major problem.It is not as if we were behind and chasing the game, it was 0-0 at the time at a tough place like Stoke. At the end of the day it is sinful that Allen got so much space.

Edited by Willo (20 Feb 2017 10.43am)

For once, I agree with Willo, the main problem with this goal was Punch and Luka both going to the ball, giving Allen a massive amount of space to run into. As for Damo, there isn't really much he could have done, Van Arnholt was getting beaten by Sobhi so he went to give him support and as Willo said, Sobhi's run and the flight of the ball meant that Damo didn't take up too bad a position in my opinion

Edited by Shifty97 (21 Feb 2017 7.37pm)

 

Mad4palace Flag 20 Feb 17 5.38pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

Video too long and slow.

Could have been done in 2 mins maximum imo

A little more editing down needed but I'm grateful that there is a fan putting in the time and effort to analyze our games and upload something. If the OP keeps doing these his videos will get better with practice. Most of us just watch the game once then a lot of the time spout crap about who was at fault for a goal (I include myself in this).

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 20 Feb 17 6.30pm

I agree that Zaha lost it I just think he needed more support from Puncheon but yeah it wasn't the greatest effort from Zaha.

I agree there was a man to man but that isn't enough to defend in the Premier League though we did get all crossed up in who was covering who (it was a nice run by Allen, wish Puncheon would make runs like that, ha).

Thanks for the comments.

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Was interesting. My points would be:

1. Zaha lost the ball, not puncheon. He could've played it off the man for throw in or slipped it inside for ward. However, so much happened since then that you can't blame the person who gave the ball away

2. When the ball was played forward for the goal I don't really blame puncheon too much or not anymore than Luca. Looking behind them there was a man to each stoke player and then Delaney was spare who could've picked up Allen.

3. Delaney runs too far back allowing Allen space to set himself and pick his angle.

4. Agree Hennessy was on back foot too much but think his general position was okish. Should've got their quicker perhaps but if he have stayed more to the right then Allen would've taken an earlier shot to the left instead.

Basically in general was a good goal and not much blame to be apportioned. Think Delaney for me is the one who stands out as he could see joe allens run from early, knew everyone else was being marked and should've gone to the ball rather than running away then going to the ball. Strikes me that he didn't have confidence in PVA to stop Ramadan turning and shooting so gambled that way rather than trusting the man marking.

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 20 Feb 17 6.34pm

Yes! Totally agree with what you are saying here. Puncheon losing the ball in bad positions is a normal thing now (I don't worry about Zaha as much because he usually only loses it in the final third and he has been one of our best players for 2 years now). I can't wait to see a midfield of McArthur, Luka, and Cabaye. I think we will see a lot more success in build up play, passing and ball retention. Crossing my fingers that 's our starting midfield next game. With those three I do see it difficult to pick out who are #10 will be and think we still need someone to fill that position (unless Cabaye changes his mind and wants to play there).

Originally posted by essetwentyone

This goal is just another example of us being caught on the counter. This sort of goal has been conceded for a few seasons now especially in our home games with Defoe's 2 goals recently classic examples.

Our previous Premiership success came from being a counter attacking time with the pace of Zaha and Bolaise but this success was mainly in away games or against the top teams at home. When confronted by a 10 man defence at home we were always open to the break.
The main reason for these goals was and still is due to us losing the ball high up the pitch when we are attacking thus leaving us bare at the back. This is exactly what happened at Stoke.

To be fair to Pardew he tried to change our style so that we were not just counter attacking but the problem he had was just the same as before (and since ). That problem is we do not have a strong enough midfield. Too many times we give the ball away with the main culprits being Puncheon and Wilf. In this league you get punished for these mistakes.

I thought that Cabaye would be the answer to this problem but he has been a massive let down and no doubt he let Pardew down as well. Whether Luka will be the answer only time will tell but in the meantime Sam's only option is to pack the midfield and play more defensively. My main worry with this is that it requires a lone striker who works his socks off. Benteke doesn't do that , Remy might and Campbell will but he doesn't have the quality to score the goals we need. Benteke has the quality but Sam has got to get him out of first gear because Prem football now is all about being an 11 man game and it starts with the striker.
I'd like to see Luka and Cabaye playing in front of the defence to give the protection with McCarthur in front of them thus making us solid through the middle but it still needs a hard working striker.

A change of keeper is also well overdue. The amount of criticism towards Hennessey surely must have affected his confidence and that of the defenders in front of him ?

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 20 Feb 17 6.38pm

Oh man, love what you said here. I totally agree that the defense is not to blame they are doing their best with overlapping runs, tracking back, etc. and it isn't an easy thing to do.

I agree with Hennessey I just think instead of backing up so hard he should be doing little side steps towards the ball staying in his arc. Again, it isn't a save I expect him to make but with better footwork and positioning it would at least give him a chance. Just pray that Speroni or Mandada start next game, two keepers who excel at footwork and positioning.

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Good analysis. The midfield was the most at fault here, Puncheon should have got back, he knows where Milivojevic is and that McArthur is way up field. That said, McArthur should be getting back quicker though and be there just to make the pass out to Ramadan a little harder to make, if Arnoutovic just has to think about it a little more then maybe he's tackled or overhits the pass. From the moment Wilf loses it McArthur doesn't do anything, he's looking back at a huge gap in the centre of midfield and he doesn't track back, he just needs to defend the space then either the initial pass might not be made or Allen won't have that space to run into. The defence is not really at fault here, only Delaney possibly should have not rushed back at full pelt like he did, he might have been better set/positioned to make the block on the shot a bit higher up.

Decent spot on Hennessey, although if he were to keep his original position then Allen would have just slipped it into the near post and if he comes too far to the left then he would have even more momentum taking him away from where Allen slots it in the end. His footwork was terrible though, nothing to spring from as dmendenhal points out and he gives up to much of the goal to aim at. The most apt description of Hennessey from your vid: "He literally just falls". The truth is Hennessey is a s*** athlete compared to practically all PL goalkeepers, especially compared to Speroni. But Hennessey doesn't make up for it with good positioning or footwork, that's arguably even worse. He only has decent kicking and that shouldn't be what a keeper is selected on.

Edited by Mad4palace (20 Feb 2017 12.53pm)

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 20 Feb 17 6.41pm

Thanks! I will try to make them shorter. The problem is I have to switch back and forth between two programs the whole time so that is where some of the delays are coming from (and I just talk slow I realized, ha).

That is why I recommend watching it in 1.5X or 2X speed on YouTube which you can access in the little settings wheel at the bottom right. I will try to speed it up myself next time but I didn't have the time this week.

Thanks for the feedback!

Originally posted by Mad4palace

A little more editing down needed but I'm grateful that there is a fan putting in the time and effort to analyze our games and upload something. If the OP keeps doing these his videos will get better with practice. Most of us just watch the game once then a lot of the time spout crap about who was at fault for a goal (I include myself in this).

 

mattteo Flag 22 Feb 17 10.46am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Was interesting. My points would be:

1. Zaha lost the ball, not puncheon. He could've played it off the man for throw in or slipped it inside for ward. However, so much happened since then that you can't blame the person who gave the ball away

2. When the ball was played forward for the goal I don't really blame puncheon too much or not anymore than Luca. Looking behind them there was a man to each stoke player and then Delaney was spare who could've picked up Allen.

3. Delaney runs too far back allowing Allen space to set himself and pick his angle.

4. Agree Hennessy was on back foot too much but think his general position was okish. Should've got their quicker perhaps but if he have stayed more to the right then Allen would've taken an earlier shot to the left instead.

Basically in general was a good goal and not much blame to be apportioned. Think Delaney for me is the one who stands out as he could see joe allens run from early, knew everyone else was being marked and should've gone to the ball rather than running away then going to the ball. Strikes me that he didn't have confidence in PVA to stop Ramadan turning and shooting so gambled that way rather than trusting the man marking.


Delaney needed to run back to be the back-up in case PVA lost the 1-on-1 duel. He couldn't have just let the guy with the ball to settle it with PVA and take on Joe Allen cause he was spare. Maybe in retrospective it sounds better, but it's a tough call. Puncheon is definitely at fault. But it's mostly cause Puncheon is not a box-to-box type of player that can go up and down the pitch that fast. If you play him in that advanced position as box-to-box or AM then you know it's gonna be trouble. He should just patrol in front of the defence like many other playmakers do in their old days, closing spaces and just "being there" preventing shots or players like Allen.
But in this case, it's unknown if that would have helped either. Neither he nor Milivojevic were EXTREMELY advanced and they could have, SHOULD HAVE, tracked down Allen.

I agree with the OP that it was Puncheon's mistake, but I don't agree that he should have moved higher up the pitch to help Zaha. In fact, he should have stayed deeper and secured that space in front of the defence, as it's obvious he can't just sprint back fast enough in situations like this (nor can McArthur or anyone if they stay too advanced)


Edited by mattteo (22 Feb 2017 12.54pm)

 

Holmesdale 1989 Flag 22 Feb 17 11.13am

Great video, great effort.

 

keynesr Flag Hampshire 22 Feb 17 11.25am

Absolutely fascinating, regardless of which player(s) may be to blame. Well done to the creator. Lets have more! Hopefully the Club can use this and similar videos when discussing etc with the players.

 

Mad4palace Flag 23 Feb 17 12.10am

I too have gone back and done my own in-depth analysis of Ledley and Tomkins vs Sunderland:

Attachment: Ledley and Tomkins vs Sunderland.mp4 (265.67Kb)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Video Analysis of Stoke Goal vs CPFC