This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Benteke (we need more from him)
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Dan89 Se25 26 Feb 17 8.08am |
|
|
Despite him being top goal scorer. He brings little else to the team. His lazy, lack of movement and look uninterested and especially in the 1st half he had the service. If we manage to stay up and we're offered the 32m, we paid we should sell. If he doesn't score we may aswell play Campbell.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
bifffabazz Highworth, Wiltshire 26 Feb 17 8.13am |
|
|
I'd usually agree with you but thought he worked extremely hard in the first half, chasing everything down and pressuring a very nervy keeper. Not so sure about second half but as a team, we dropped off somewhat.
Spirit of 1974
|
Dan89 Se25 26 Feb 17 8.15am |
|
Originally posted by bifffabazz
I'd usually agree with you but thought he worked extremely hard in the first half, chasing everything down and pressuring a very nervy keeper. Not so sure about second half but as a team, we dropped off somewhat.
Maybe it's his fitness levels or that bad leg injury he suffered at Liverpool. I'd much rather wickham (when fit).
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
miss smith london 26 Feb 17 8.19am |
|
|
i do not think he is lazy he just looks slow and ponderous and his ball control is not that good neither,but he is still the best striker we have ,but a £30 mill player no way watched him play a few times last season for liverpool and every time i saw him i thought that he was very poor ,any how lets hope he improves in the remaining games,and it was a great win yesterday
|
Dan89 Se25 26 Feb 17 8.22am |
|
Originally posted by miss smith
i do not think he is lazy he just looks slow and ponderous and his ball control is not that good neither,but he is still the best striker we have ,but a £30 mill player no way watched him play a few times last season for liverpool and every time i saw him i thought that he was very poor ,any how lets hope he improves in the remaining games,and it was a great win yesterday
He could score, some important goals but what question is his link up play. Especially 2nd half was very poor imo.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
miss smith london 26 Feb 17 8.32am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
He could score, some important goals but what question is his link up play. Especially 2nd half was very poor imo. for long periods in the 2 nd half i was not sure if he was still on the pitch ,he also seems so hesitate in front of goal too, but his work rate like townsend has improved under sam
|
Username Horsham 26 Feb 17 9.03am |
|
|
Really don't understand this.
His work rate yesterday was good all game.
He was a threat every time the ball got near him. His link up play was pretty good. He hesitated once on his weaker foot, but that was a chance he created all by himself.
He can't be expected to chase every lost cause for 90 minutes, he needs more support. Yesterday when the midfield dropped deep he had to go back to picking and choosing when to chase. In the first half when he had Wilf, townsend, Cabaye and Punch supporting him, he was a le to really pressure their back three.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.
|
Pete53 Hassocks 26 Feb 17 9.28am |
|
|
He's okay but not he's £30 millions worth of okay. I couldn't help comparing Benteke with Lukaku when watching MotD last night.
Latish in the 2nd half of the Boro game Benteke received the ball in the opposition half with an opportunity to run at goal. However, with the ball at his feet, he looked indecisive - okay he held the ball but was a tad ponderous and in the end laid it off to Townsend who blasted over. Now watch Lukaku scoring the 2nd Everton goal. He powered forward with pace and confidence, knowing exactly what he was going to do, not looking to lay off, shrugged the defender away, and scored.
Benteke is big bloke and I was hoping that he would have more authority and strength on the ball and be harder to shake off in the way Lukaku is.
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 26 Feb 17 9.32am |
|
|
Doesn't work anywhere near hard enough. Needs to chase down and work their back line all game not just when he chooses to. If he can't start training earlier and finish later.
Bring back Brolin
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 26 Feb 17 9.35am |
|
|
By far our best striker, held the ball up well, linked up with overs well, had a few good chances. I was more disappointed with Townsend towards the end when Benteke played him in, instead of playing it to the back post where Benteke was reeling off, he blasted it from an angle he had 0% chance of scoring. It's those sort of choices that could cost us big, and we could of been punished due to his greed. Article in the mail suggesting benteke was furious with him after the game, and rigthtly so in my eyes.
|
Casual Orpington 26 Feb 17 9.38am |
|
Originally posted by Pete53
He's okay but not he's £30 millions worth of okay. I couldn't help comparing Benteke with Lukaku when watching MotD last night.
Latish in the 2nd half of the Boro game Benteke received the ball in the opposition half with an opportunity to run at goal. However, with the ball at his feet, he looked indecisive - okay he held the ball but was a tad ponderous and in the end laid it off to Townsend who blasted over. Now watch Lukaku scoring the 2nd Everton goal. He powered forward with pace and confidence, knowing exactly what he was going to do, not looking to lay off, shrugged the defender away, and scored.
Benteke is big bloke and I was hoping that he would have more authority and strength on the ball and be harder to shake off in the way Lukaku is.
Benteke is a tall bloke, but he's not a big bloke. He has virtually no shoulders , must have his shirts especially made. He is a threat though, but he had a free header early on that went straight at the keeper, 3 ft either side and it was a goal. I think he will go through his career scoring goals, but not being spectacular.
|
chateauferret 26 Feb 17 9.45am |
|
|
I thought he was better yesterday than he has been. Carried a threat but still needs more men around him. He's also contributing more at the back, compared with earlier when he was missing when needed to do what he's best at - winning headers.
Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 9.46am)
============ The Ferret ============
|
bodge 26 Feb 17 9.53am |
|
|
I hope we dont have to lose him to find out how good he is.
|
ParchmoreEagle Belair 26 Feb 17 9.53am |
|
Originally posted by Username
Really don't understand this.
His work rate yesterday was good all game.
He was a threat every time the ball got near him. His link up play was pretty good. He hesitated once on his weaker foot, but that was a chance he created all by himself.
He can't be expected to chase every lost cause for 90 minutes, he needs more support. Yesterday when the midfield dropped deep he had to go back to picking and choosing when to chase. In the first half when he had Wilf, townsend, Cabaye and Punch supporting him, he was a le to really pressure their back three.
^^^THIS^^^ and change the thread title to: Benteke (we need more TO him)
[Link]
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 26 Feb 17 10.19am |
|
Originally posted by Username
Really don't understand this.
His work rate yesterday was good all game.
He was a threat every time the ball got near him. His link up play was pretty good. He hesitated once on his weaker foot, but that was a chance he created all by himself.
He can't be expected to chase every lost cause for 90 minutes, he needs more support. Yesterday when the midfield dropped deep he had to go back to picking and choosing when to chase. In the first half when he had Wilf, townsend, Cabaye and Punch supporting him, he was a le to really pressure their back three.
This (again). Worked all game and was still working when he set up Townsend right at the end of the game.
|
Dangermouse Hastings 26 Feb 17 10.37am |
|
|
As I've said before we play a system that relies on a no.10 yet haven't had a proper one since Chamakh got injured. Benteke is on his own nearly all game and like it or not he's not a channel runner. We bought a target man centre forward, not an AJ type centre forward, so he cannot be criticised for not being AJ. Simple solution here is to play Campbell. He is the type to run down lost causes and work non stop. Given a good 12 game run in the team I'm sure he could score some goals too. Maybe we should start criticising Luka cos he doesn't go on mazy dribbles beating 4 players and pinging in 30 yarders, or Tompkins for not being John Terry. It's a tough job playing up top on your own, especially against a back three, but hey let's slate him anyway.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
MrCParrot Taunton 26 Feb 17 10.41am |
|
Originally posted by MKCPFC
This (again). Worked all game and was still working when he set up Townsend right at the end of the game.
Completely agree, let's support him not alienate.
He is class
Parrot
Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"
|
Dan1994 Wallington 26 Feb 17 11.07am |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
As I've said before we play a system that relies on a no.10 yet haven't had a proper one since Chamakh got injured. Benteke is on his own nearly all game and like it or not he's not a channel runner. We bought a target man centre forward, not an AJ type centre forward, so he cannot be criticised for not being AJ. Simple solution here is to play Campbell. He is the type to run down lost causes and work non stop. Given a good 12 game run in the team I'm sure he could score some goals too. Maybe we should start criticising Luka cos he doesn't go on mazy dribbles beating 4 players and pinging in 30 yarders, or Tompkins for not being John Terry. It's a tough job playing up top on your own, especially against a back three, but hey let's slate him anyway.
Exactly. We bought a target man who will hold up play and bring others in, which he does regularly when the service is there. A player who will also nod in goals from crosses, which he has done all season. Yesterday, he created chances for himself and was a threat - some could argue he should've had a goal.
People are saying playing Fraizier Campbell or Connor Wickham instead of Benteke... are you having a bubble? Wickham was notoriously crap for us last season to the point of people whinging about him every single game and his lack of aerial threat. I'm not gonna even bother with Fraizier Campbell, because he will be an okay striker for us next season if we get relegated.
[Link]
|
Dan89 Se25 26 Feb 17 11.41am |
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
Exactly. We bought a target man who will hold up play and bring others in, which he does regularly when the service is there. A player who will also nod in goals from crosses, which he has done all season. Yesterday, he created chances for himself and was a threat - some could argue he should've had a goal.
People are saying playing Fraizier Campbell or Connor Wickham instead of Benteke... are you having a bubble? Wickham was notoriously crap for us last season to the point of people whinging about him every single game and his lack of aerial threat. I'm not gonna even bother with Fraizier Campbell, because he will be an okay striker for us next season if we get relegated. At least wickham gives 100% in cpfc shirt. Benteke was terrible in the 2nd half. 1st half, he looked hungry, chased the gk down in the 2nd half, Didn't hold the ball up once and looked uninterested . You take away Benteke goals away, you have a nothing player.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|