You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Feb 17 1.15am

Please!

 


COYP

Hoof Hearted 27 Feb 17 10.24am

Nope.... not a Scooby Doo what you are on about Rudi?


bewildered of Bristol!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 10.28am

I think the Franchise was effectively killed with Gensys.

If the Sarah Conner Chronicles are cannon, then John Conner specifically sent Kyle Reese back in time, knowing he was his father. But then if the SCC are correct, Skynet has moved from fighting in the future, to fighting across time, and the whole thing is a high stake game of chess, and sacrifices.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 12.15pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think the Franchise was effectively killed with Gensys.

If the Sarah Conner Chronicles are cannon, then John Conner specifically sent Kyle Reese back in time, knowing he was his father. But then if the SCC are correct, Skynet has moved from fighting in the future, to fighting across time, and the whole thing is a high stake game of chess, and sacrifices.

You can't scrutinise a ridiculous time travel movie too closely. A paradox almost certainly can't happen in reality.
My theory is that a person traveling back in time to change the future could only change it by creating an alternate timeline that would leave their original one untouched. That is assuming that time travel is possible.
The Terminator franchise went down hill from no3 onward despite Claire Danes and 4 was totally misjudged. Genesys suffered from re casting key characters. You can't have anyone else playing Sarah Conner or Kyle Reese, it doesn't work and the plot had become hopelessly convoluted.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 12.34pm

Its a shame that most people missed the Sarah Conner Chronicles. The element of time travel becomes quite interesting and complex.

Those who travel to the past, and change it, create a new future, but themselves are consistent with the future they experienced. So when his older brother, Derek, who travels to the past in season 1, meets up with Jessie (his girlfriend in the future), who travels back later, his memory of the future is very different of events than hers.

Skynet and the Resistance, are conducting operations across time, more geared to influencing the war, rather than avoiding it (although John Conner in the now, won't realise that for some time). The resistance are setting up safe houses, and conducting operations often about denying assets to the machines, whilst Skynet is targeting people of key influence and influence the past (for example pushing new tech in AI to improve its chance of winning in the future) - as well as to ensure the future.

Or at least a future.

Also, Skynet and John Conner also exist (to some degree) in the past (so have knowledge to influence their own decisions in the future). Plus you get to see that the machines are 'somewhat more complex' than just operating systems.

Sadly it got canned rather than get a season 3, because we'd just been introduced to a second machine faction, who are operating in the past, to produce a different AI to Skynet. Who are on neither side, directly.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 12.48pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You can't scrutinise a ridiculous time travel movie too closely. A paradox almost certainly can't happen in reality.
My theory is that a person traveling back in time to change the future could only change it by creating an alternate timeline that would leave their original one untouched. That is assuming that time travel is possible.
The Terminator franchise went down hill from no3 onward despite Claire Danes and 4 was totally misjudged. Genesys suffered from re casting key characters. You can't have anyone else playing Sarah Conner or Kyle Reese, it doesn't work and the plot had become hopelessly convoluted.

From the first movie, the logical assumption, is that John Conner is aware that Reese is his father, as he gives him the photograph of Sarah. Its then logical that he sends him back knowing a) knowing that he will die b) that its already happened c) that not doing that will create 'an uncertain outcome'.

Remember that in T1, in the future, the humans have won. Skynets last gasp is to send a machine back. From Conner's perspective, this makes his actions inevitable, because not sending Reese back means he definitely won't exist, and the humans might not win. Of course the other possibility is that he is just fulfilling a deterministic agenda, and that Reese always travelled back to save Sarah and Father John.

So Conner really doesn't have a choice, whether he has free will or not, the only logical decision is to send someone back to protect his mother, and its always Reese (even if he didn't know, if he can send one person back, Reese is the ideal choice - even if Conner doesn't know Reese is his father, he's the only one likely to recognise her, because he carries that picture around).

Besides there aren't likely a lot of candidates to go on a suicide mission when the war has just been won, to save a woman, who they don't know and probably have no investment in.

So what actually occurs is the machine is creating a paradox, in which it may kill Sarah Conner and create a paradox, and JC is healing that paradox, by preventing it occurring, and in doing so, ensures his own existence in the process.

Remember that Reese might not have been JC original father. JC of the future might well have been older or younger, or black even - We just know he exists. The only paradox of Conner is changing who his father may be and when he is born. He was always going to be the saviour of the human race, provided he exists. All that changes is 'who John Conner is' which isn't a paradox of magnitude. Where as his non-existence would be.

There is a reason why the initials are J C, and the whole saviour / salvation thing is played up.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Pikester Flag Worthing 27 Feb 17 12.54pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

From the first movie, the logical assumption, is that John Conner is aware that Reese is his father, as he gives him the photograph of Sarah. Its then logical that he sends him back knowing a) knowing that he will die b) that its already happened c) that not doing that will create 'an uncertain outcome'.

Remember that in T1, in the future, the humans have won. Skynets last gasp is to send a machine back. From Conner's perspective, this makes his actions inevitable, because not sending Reese back means he definitely won't exist, and the humans might not win. Of course the other possibility is that he is just fulfilling a deterministic agenda, and that Reese always travelled back to save Sarah and Father John.

So Conner really doesn't have a choice, whether he has free will or not, the only logical decision is to send someone back to protect his mother, and its always Reese (even if he didn't know, if he can send one person back, Reese is the ideal choice - even if Conner doesn't know Reese is his father, he's the only one likely to recognise her, because he carries that picture around).

Besides there aren't likely a lot of candidates to go on a suicide mission when the war has just been won, to save a woman, who they don't know and probably have no investment in.

So what actually occurs is the machine is creating a paradox, in which it may kill Sarah Conner and create a paradox, and JC is healing that paradox, by preventing it occurring, and in doing so, ensures his own existence in the process.

Remember that Reese might not have been JC original father. JC of the future might well have been older or younger, or black even - We just know he exists. The only paradox of Conner is changing who his father may be and when he is born. He was always going to be the saviour of the human race, provided he exists. All that changes is 'who John Conner is' which isn't a paradox of magnitude. Where as his non-existence would be.

There is a reason why the initials are J C, and the whole saviour / salvation thing is played up.

Jamie,

Sometimes when you're standing in a pub, resplendent in your Husker Du T-shirt, explaining time travel to a new drinking buddy..... do you ever notice their eyes glaze over and they seem to be just nodding rather than really listening?

Just wondering like....

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Hoof Hearted 27 Feb 17 1.05pm

Originally posted by Pikester

Jamie,

Sometimes when you're standing in a pub, resplendent in your Husker Du T-shirt, explaining time travel to a new drinking buddy..... do you ever notice their eyes glaze over and they seem to be just nodding rather than really listening?

Just wondering like....

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 1.06pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

From the first movie, the logical assumption, is that John Conner is aware that Reese is his father, as he gives him the photograph of Sarah. Its then logical that he sends him back knowing a) knowing that he will die b) that its already happened c) that not doing that will create 'an uncertain outcome'.

Remember that in T1, in the future, the humans have won. Skynets last gasp is to send a machine back. From Conner's perspective, this makes his actions inevitable, because not sending Reese back means he definitely won't exist, and the humans might not win. Of course the other possibility is that he is just fulfilling a deterministic agenda, and that Reese always travelled back to save Sarah and Father John.

So Conner really doesn't have a choice, whether he has free will or not, the only logical decision is to send someone back to protect his mother, and its always Reese (even if he didn't know, if he can send one person back, Reese is the ideal choice - even if Conner doesn't know Reese is his father, he's the only one likely to recognise her, because he carries that picture around).

Besides there aren't likely a lot of candidates to go on a suicide mission when the war has just been won, to save a woman, who they don't know and probably have no investment in.

So what actually occurs is the machine is creating a paradox, in which it may kill Sarah Conner and create a paradox, and JC is healing that paradox, by preventing it occurring, and in doing so, ensures his own existence in the process.

Remember that Reese might not have been JC original father. JC of the future might well have been older or younger, or black even - We just know he exists. The only paradox of Conner is changing who his father may be and when he is born. He was always going to be the saviour of the human race, provided he exists. All that changes is 'who John Conner is' which isn't a paradox of magnitude. Where as his non-existence would be.

There is a reason why the initials are J C, and the whole saviour / salvation thing is played up.

Ha ha. Good one.

There is no doubt that the original movie is a wonderful piece of self contained science fiction but the wider issue of paradox does not stand up to scrutiny. If the machines could travel back in time they could have gone back and killed Sarah Conner's mother for example or the human race from day one. It is only conceivable that new parallel timelines can be created by changing past events or you could effectively kill your own parents and then cease to exist thus making your original action impossible. For that reason a paradox just can't happen as imagined in Terminator or a host of other films.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 27 Feb 17 1.07pm

HOLs version of The Big Bang theory !!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 1.18pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Its a shame that most people missed the Sarah Conner Chronicles. The element of time travel becomes quite interesting and complex.

Those who travel to the past, and change it, create a new future, but themselves are consistent with the future they experienced. So when his older brother, Derek, who travels to the past in season 1, meets up with Jessie (his girlfriend in the future), who travels back later, his memory of the future is very different of events than hers.

Skynet and the Resistance, are conducting operations across time, more geared to influencing the war, rather than avoiding it (although John Conner in the now, won't realise that for some time). The resistance are setting up safe houses, and conducting operations often about denying assets to the machines, whilst Skynet is targeting people of key influence and influence the past (for example pushing new tech in AI to improve its chance of winning in the future) - as well as to ensure the future.

Or at least a future.

Also, Skynet and John Conner also exist (to some degree) in the past (so have knowledge to influence their own decisions in the future). Plus you get to see that the machines are 'somewhat more complex' than just operating systems.

Sadly it got canned rather than get a season 3, because we'd just been introduced to a second machine faction, who are operating in the past, to produce a different AI to Skynet. Who are on neither side, directly.

I thought it was fairly decent. Good cast and well written. A lot of quite good sci fi gets canned. The ratings war is ruthless in the US.
I was even sad to see the new 'V' cancelled.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

HOLs version of The Big Bang theory !!

You're in my spot.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 4.19pm

Originally posted by Pikester

Jamie,

Sometimes when you're standing in a pub, resplendent in your Husker Du T-shirt, explaining time travel to a new drinking buddy..... do you ever notice their eyes glaze over and they seem to be just nodding rather than really listening?

Just wondering like....

Often, and its cheaper than rhoypnl.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 4.28pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Ha ha. Good one.

There is no doubt that the original movie is a wonderful piece of self contained science fiction but the wider issue of paradox does not stand up to scrutiny. If the machines could travel back in time they could have gone back and killed Sarah Conner's mother for example or the human race from day one. It is only conceivable that new parallel timelines can be created by changing past events or you could effectively kill your own parents and then cease to exist thus making your original action impossible. For that reason a paradox just can't happen as imagined in Terminator or a host of other films.

Skynet isn't omniscient, it only know's where Sarah Conner is at a specific time period, presumably the amount of information available in the future is limited (destroyed, ironically in the war).

It doesn't even know what she looks like, where she is. Only that she's called Sarah Conner and was in a specific area of LA during that time period.

Of course, if it succeeds, it becomes a paradox, but for Skynet, which has effectively lost the war, so that doesn't matter, its a 'hail mary' pass - Whatever the outcome, its better than being destroyed.

John Conner, has no choice, but to effectively stop that happening, and in doing so probably changes his own fate somewhat but not extensively (in fact arguably it probably results in a better equipped John Conner in the future).

It doesn't even ensure that humanity will lose the war either, only that it will change it, by changing the leader.

Skynet also, can't go too far back. It can't wipe out the human race, before it exists. Nor can it risk its own existence by changing the past either.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Feb 17 4.44pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I thought it was fairly decent. Good cast and well written. A lot of quite good sci fi gets canned. The ratings war is ruthless in the US.
I was even sad to see the new 'V' cancelled.

I certainly wouldn't be shy about sending 'Cameron' back in time for me....

I thought Summer Glau really excelled as a 'friendly terminator'.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 4.50pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Skynet isn't omniscient, it only know's where Sarah Conner is at a specific time period, presumably the amount of information available in the future is limited (destroyed, ironically in the war).

It doesn't even know what she looks like, where she is. Only that she's called Sarah Conner and was in a specific area of LA during that time period.

Of course, if it succeeds, it becomes a paradox, but for Skynet, which has effectively lost the war, so that doesn't matter, its a 'hail mary' pass - Whatever the outcome, its better than being destroyed.

John Conner, has no choice, but to effectively stop that happening, and in doing so probably changes his own fate somewhat but not extensively (in fact arguably it probably results in a better equipped John Conner in the future).

It doesn't even ensure that humanity will lose the war either, only that it will change it, by changing the leader.

Skynet also, can't go too far back. It can't wipe out the human race, before it exists. Nor can it risk its own existence by changing the past either.

So what you are saying is that because no destructive paradox occurred then it's OK.
The problem is that by sending a time traveler back, you would take an unacceptable risk of a butterfly effect that could change the entire future and erase your own existence.
Equally, anything that you alter in the past has effectively already happened from you point of view so is therefore a matter of record. That means you could check to see if something had changed. That would render it useless as a tactic. John Connor sending his own father back is also a causal loop which would mean that in theory, he had no free will in making that decision and that he came into existence from nowhere.
I have a big problem with that.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (27 Feb 2017 4.52pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Feb 17 4.57pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I certainly wouldn't be shy about sending 'Cameron' back in time for me....

I thought Summer Glau really excelled as a 'friendly terminator'.

I'd let her play with my phased plasma rifle.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 27 Feb 17 5.57pm

Originally posted by Pikester

Jamie,

Sometimes when you're standing in a pub, resplendent in your Husker Du T-shirt, explaining time travel to a new drinking buddy..... do you ever notice their eyes glaze over and they seem to be just nodding rather than really listening?

Just wondering like....

This almost made me spit my beer out

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Feb 17 10.43am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

So what you are saying is that because no destructive paradox occurred then it's OK.
The problem is that by sending a time traveler back, you would take an unacceptable risk of a butterfly effect that could change the entire future and erase your own existence.
Equally, anything that you alter in the past has effectively already happened from you point of view so is therefore a matter of record. That means you could check to see if something had changed. That would render it useless as a tactic. John Connor sending his own father back is also a causal loop which would mean that in theory, he had no free will in making that decision and that he came into existence from nowhere.
I have a big problem with that.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (27 Feb 2017 4.52pm)

We can't tell if he has free will, but realistically, even if he does, sending Kyle Reese back would be the right choice - even before Kyle Reese is his father. Other than himself, Reese is the person most familiar with Sarah Conner, and the most likely to give 'everything' to save her. We know he's also an experienced and resourceful solider - The ideal choice.

John Conner always existed, and was always Sarah Conner's son. What we don't know is who was his father before Reese is sent back. Remember that the terminator is not successful, and all that happens is that the time line of John Conner is altered.

In fact, the actions of Skynet, actually improve the situation for the future John Conner, because now his whole life is spent in preparation for the future.

Of course its entirely possible people do not have free will, but it likely doesn't matter who JC sends back to save his mother, as long as they are successful, he will be born at some point - Its irrelevant that Reese is his father (because we know a john conner must exist to send him back).

JC could choose not to send anyone back, or someone else, but why would he, even if he knows Reese is his father, they've just won the war, any sacrifice is acceptable. So he sends the best option he has. It would be insane to make any other decision (even from a point where he doesn't know Reese is his father). He knows Reese is incredibly loyal to him, and possibly in love with his mother.

So all that Conners time change involves is minor shifts in his existence, it doesn't involved a contradictory paradox (which him not existing would).

Of course killing Sarah probably just means a different person would lead the surviving humans. It would be erroneous to assume that only John Conner can do it. We believe that, because of the stories told about the great leader. But say if Churchill died in 1938, do you really think the UK wouldn't have fought or that no one would have led the UK.

The war with the machines is inevitable, and the resistance from humans is inevitable. All that changes are small aspects.

So maybe John Conner is born a few years earlier, and has different genetic make up.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Feb 17 10.44am

Originally posted by Pikester

Jamie,

Sometimes when you're standing in a pub, resplendent in your Husker Du T-shirt, explaining time travel to a new drinking buddy..... do you ever notice their eyes glaze over and they seem to be just nodding rather than really listening?

Just wondering like....

Also, technically, its a Husker Du sweatshirt... but...

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself