This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Schlupp
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
CJr94 Holmesdale Road 27 Apr 17 10.11am |
|
|
What do we all make of him? I'm not convinced. Giving Kyle Walker acres of space last night to run down the right wing. Noticed it quite a few times Walker was virtually left alone to do what he wanted. If Zaha wasn't out there tracking back I think Walker would have ben a lot more dangerous.
|
aashman12 27 Apr 17 10.26am |
|
Originally posted by CJr94
What do we all make of him? I'm not convinced. Giving Kyle Walker acres of space last night to run down the right wing. Noticed it quite a few times Walker was virtually left alone to do what he wanted. If Zaha wasn't out there tracking back I think Walker would have ben a lot more dangerous.
It's a tough one playing against wing backs. Looked like he was order to tuck in. And it's part of the wingers jobs to track back anyway.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Apr 17 10.28am |
|
Originally posted by CJr94
What do we all make of him? I'm not convinced. Giving Kyle Walker acres of space last night to run down the right wing. Noticed it quite a few times Walker was virtually left alone to do what he wanted. If Zaha wasn't out there tracking back I think Walker would have ben a lot more dangerous.
Not convinced about him at left-back either. He is one of those players who can play up front, out wide and has played at left-back of course but never really impresses that much in any position. "Jack of all trades, master of none" ? Maybe he will improve defensively under Allardyce and we will be talking about a good left-back in the future !
|
JacksonEagle Croydon 27 Apr 17 10.29am |
|
|
I think the last 2 games he's actually been pretty good, it seems defensively we play quite narrow to keep it tight and hard to break down, if he had been charging in to Kyle it would have open up gaps on the inside for the likes of Alli and Eriksen, who despite the goal, were both pretty ineffective for much of the game.
|
Mad4palace 27 Apr 17 10.29am |
|
|
I heard people shouting at him when Walker got the ball on a couple of occasions, my conclusion was they weren't understanding the game and how to defend against Tottenham. If Schlupp goes out there he leaves a huge space in between where Alli or Eriksen can be a threat.
Townsend lost Walker on a couple of occasions, Schlupp's instructions were to maintain our compact shape.
That was my assessment of the first half anyway, second half it's difficult to tell as I'm seated in the opposite corner to where Walker was attacking us.
All that said, Schlupp did have a poor game in terms of his distribution, we had the chance to counter a few times down the left and he failed to make the pass. I rate him defensively but not so much attacking from what I've seen so far. I hope Van Aanholt starts vs Burnley.
|
Jamesrichards8 27 Apr 17 10.33am |
|
|
Van aanholt is clearly superior. Schlupp looks an occasional weak link at the back and is clumsy going forward from left back. A good substitute winger i think. Still glad we bought him- we'd have been screwed when van aanholt got injured. Shrewd by allardyce
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
chateauferret 27 Apr 17 11.19am |
|
|
I think he's a winger who can be played at left back whereas van Aanholt is a left back who can overlap on the left wing very well. Schlupp's main attribute is his pace: putting him at left back is not exactly out of position. He had a good burrowing run at the bin dippers' defence on Sunday and nearly exposed them.
I wonder if Sam might not have removed Puncheon, moved Schlupp up to the wing, and brought van Aanholt in at left back. I think he was preparing van Aanholt when Sakho got injured and then decided (I don't know why) to replace Benteke with Campbell instead. I suppose he wanted to rest the latter, though.
People here were concerned about van Aanholt's defending when we bought him but after the first couple of matches and certainly since he scored that goal he's looked pretty good to me.
Edited by chateauferret (27 Apr 2017 11.21am)
============ The Ferret ============
|
miss smith london 27 Apr 17 12.31pm |
|
|
geoffery schlupp is a utility player and a very good one,made some great tackles last night , i think he is great signing
|
eritheagle Erith 27 Apr 17 12.48pm |
|
|
PVA was about to come on to help him out against Sissoko and Walker but then they scored and he was told to go and sit back down again.
|
Noz North Hampshire 27 Apr 17 12.55pm |
|
|
Both Walker and Davies hugged the touchline for the whole game and were (i imagine) purposely told to do that to pull our 2 full backs out of position to open up the middle of the frontline where Alli and Kane work so effectively.
For most of that time, Ward and Schlupp stuck to their positioning and were not lured out to stick with them, which was good work.
Kudos to Townsend and Zaha who tracked back a lot to cover them when needed.
So in short, i think Schlupp actually played really well.
|
Dixie Eagle Chatham 27 Apr 17 1.21pm |
|
|
I think he's a bit dodgy too. Plays like a winger being asked to cover a LB position, and has no composure when defending. Recently he's done quite well but in the 2nd half yesterday, he kept tucking in too much and leaving too much space on the right for Spurs.
|
Mad4palace 27 Apr 17 1.24pm |
|
Originally posted by Noz
Both Walker and Davies hugged the touchline for the whole game and were (i imagine) purposely told to do that to pull our 2 full backs out of position to open up the middle of the frontline where Alli and Kane work so effectively.
For most of that time, Ward and Schlupp stuck to their positioning and were not lured out to stick with them, which was good work.
Kudos to Townsend and Zaha who tracked back a lot to cover them when needed.
So in short, i think Schlupp actually played really well.
Which is the correct assessment, the few times where Walker got the ball in free space was down to Townsend or Zaha losing him.
Second half was a bit different because they matched our 4-1-4-1 formation but the first half Eriksen and Alli were looking to find the space in between the CB's and full-backs but because of Ward and Schlupp's discipline they hardly did.
Edited by Mad4palace (27 Apr 2017 1.26pm)
|
CJr94 Holmesdale Road 27 Apr 17 1.29pm |
|
|
I'm no Sam Allardyce but the plan was to not allow Alli and Eriksen on the ball in the centre of the park, but instead to allow Davies and Walker acres of space to put balls in?
|
Mad4palace 27 Apr 17 2.00pm |
|
Originally posted by CJr94
I'm no Sam Allardyce but the plan was to not allow Alli and Eriksen on the ball in the centre of the park, but instead to allow Davies and Walker acres of space to put balls in?
No, but it was the full backs job to keep tight with the centre-backs. It was Zaha and Townsend's job to track their wing-backs. As long as the central area was compact it wasn't such an issue to have them forced through the sides and crossing because Kane would find himself in between a tight diamond of Sakho, Kelly, Luka and Hennessey.
But you'll note we didn't just want to camp in our box, we tried to press like we haven't seen much under Allardyce. He must have thought we could allow them the constant pressure. Having McArthur on allowed us to press. In the second half we ran out of legs.
When this club had defended successfully in this league, it's been through forcing teams to pass side to side and out wide. The whole problem with the Pardew era was how easily we were carved open centrally.
Edited by Mad4palace (27 Apr 2017 2.06pm)
|
Ray in Houston Houston 27 Apr 17 3.08pm |
|
Originally posted by CJr94
I'm no Sam Allardyce but the plan was to not allow Alli and Eriksen on the ball in the centre of the park, but instead to allow Davies and Walker acres of space to put balls in?
And the one time Eriksen got the ball in the middle of the park with time and space...
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
CJr94 Holmesdale Road 27 Apr 17 4.01pm |
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
And the one time Eriksen got the ball in the middle of the park with time and space...
He luckily managed to get the ball through the masses ofdefenders all crowded around the centre circle!
|
Mad4palace 27 Apr 17 5.59pm |
|
Originally posted by CJr94
He luckily managed to get the ball through the masses ofdefenders all crowded around the centre circle!
Puncheon didn't drop back into position until too late. I wonder if Sakho was there if Punch would have got the call to drop back...but that's if and buts.
|
george1212 london 27 Apr 17 6.30pm |
|
|
I've been watching him from the middle of the main stand so tend to get quite a close view of his attacking (and overall) ability over a half. I'm not convinced at all about his technical ability - he almost seems Championship level. Very poor distribution, scuffs passes, generally runs one way and over dribbles, and never seems to pass successfully to a team mate in a counter attack.
That said, he seems good enough from a defensive point of view but definitely unconvinced. Still, let's give the lad sometime under big Sam to show what he can do.
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 27 Apr 17 8.02pm |
|
|
The worst Allardyce signing by a country mile. He's a rabbit in the headlights with the ball and positionally weak defensively. His pace is a big help though.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 27 Apr 17 8.06pm |
|
|
Leicester fans pretty much said word for word what you lot are saying when he was sold on their forum. They couldn't quite believe they got £14mill for a reserve whom they like but didn't really rate. I mean, £14mill? That makes him our record signing in 112 years of existence.....if we ignore Benteke
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|