You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Was the City result for the best?
November 16 2026 9.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Was the City result for the best?


speediej Flag Northampton 08 May 17 12.31pm

Now don't get me wrong, it would of been great to pick up points v City, but with Hull around the corner, was us getting beaten 5 0 a wake up call to the players? If we of lost 1 0, the whole mood would of been different, yes still a loss but not a embarrassing loss, so maybe this will make the team give more than they normally do to repay us back after a pathetic display?

It is just a thought, it has happened with teams in the past.

Sorry if someone has said this somewhere already

Thoughts?

 


COYP

adamnye27 Flag Bracknell 08 May 17 12.48pm

I think the only positive to take out of it is that our backup players are not good enough and that the squad needs a shake up at the end of the season.
I mean where is Ledley for starters surely he isnt behind all the players on the bench in the pecking order?

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 08 May 17 12.51pm

Yup. With the Manchester United result against Arsenal going the way it did it means that they are even less likely to turn up on the last game of the season too.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 08 May 17 12.54pm

Originally posted by adamnye27

I think the only positive to take out of it is that our backup players are not good enough and that the squad needs a shake up at the end of the season.
I mean where is Ledley for starters surely he isnt behind all the players on the bench in the pecking order?

Not as good as McArthur, and not a patch on Miliojavic - In terms of the bench its debatable whether Ledley is a better option than Flamini (Defensively) or provides the kind of ability Sako or Lee have (offensively).

But I believe he is actually injured.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 May 17 1.02pm

Originally posted by adamnye27

I think the only positive to take out of it is that our backup players are not good enough and that the squad needs a shake up at the end of the season.
I mean where is Ledley for starters surely he isnt behind all the players on the bench in the pecking order?

We have known this for ages.
No great revelation at the Man C game !

In terms of "Backup players" are you referring to McArthur and Kelly ? McArthur has been praised for his performances in the past and Kelly, once severely criticised has received plaudits of late.

As for some of the others - just NOT up to the required standard IE, Lee, Mutch, Flamini,Ledley,Sako etc etc.
Big re-building job for next season, irrespective of the Division we will be playing in.

Edited by Willo (08 May 2017 1.03pm)

 

adamnye27 Flag Bracknell 08 May 17 1.25pm

Yea i agree. Other things like chungy hasnt been on the bench for ages, where has sako has every game yet, he brings on chungy instead of Sako i find that odd. Chungy is way too lightweight we are better off having Kakai and his young energy.

I just find it a shame our youth team gets battered every week hence why nobody is coming through the ranks.

The other thing is at least if we had a reserve team the fringe players would get some match fitness, they are so unfit when they play and they dont help us.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 08 May 17 1.34pm

Originally posted by adamnye27

Yea i agree. Other things like chungy hasnt been on the bench for ages, where has sako has every game yet, he brings on chungy instead of Sako i find that odd. Chungy is way too lightweight we are better off having Kakai and his young energy.

I just find it a shame our youth team gets battered every week hence why nobody is coming through the ranks.

The other thing is at least if we had a reserve team the fringe players would get some match fitness, they are so unfit when they play and they dont help us.

have to think bringing on chungy was putting him in the shop window.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 May 17 1.46pm

Hopefully had a similar effect to the Sunderland game which gave us a kick up the arse. In his post-match comments, Allardyce didn't hold back from blaming the players for making mistakes, and I doubt there will be any complacency this weekend.

 

Woolsy Flag Essex 08 May 17 1.51pm

In a way I'm glad its happened against Man City and not Hull. I think it the kick up the arse that the players need to re-motivate them for Sunday's game.
With the crowd behind them I think we will get the result we need.

 

whitehorselane Flag 08 May 17 1.57pm

Me and my old man thought we played okay first half, and we were a bit disorganised and City turned up the gas after the 2nd. Thought we offered an attacking threat and goal difference won't be a factor, so was happy we tried to attack

We don't have much of a defence, so have to continue to play to our strengths. As an attacking force I fancy us to outscore Hull on Sunday, and there isn't a great deal of logic playing defensively with our personnel available

As long as we continue to create I cannot see Sunday being a problem.

Happy to see Chungy come on, great at keeping possession. Milo was taken off as was booked. Would drop Remy and bring in Kaikai for bench v Hull

 

Painter Flag Croydon 08 May 17 2.05pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Hopefully had a similar effect to the Sunderland game which gave us a kick up the arse. In his post-match comments, Allardyce didn't hold back from blaming the players for making mistakes, and I doubt there will be any complacency this weekend.

We lost the game following the Sunderland debacle!

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 08 May 17 2.15pm

It is very ofthen teams who get beaten heavyly bounce back from sutch a bad performance in the next game.Let`s hope that goes for us as well.

Originally posted by speediej

Now don't get me wrong, it would of been great to pick up points v City, but with Hull around the corner, was us getting beaten 5 0 a wake up call to the players? If we of lost 1 0, the whole mood would of been different, yes still a loss but not a embarrassing loss, so maybe this will make the team give more than they normally do to repay us back after a pathetic display?

It is just a thought, it has happened with teams in the past.

Sorry if someone has said this somewhere already

Thoughts?

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 May 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by Painter

We lost the game following the Sunderland debacle!

We were edged out away at Stoke, but we looked competitive again. I think the Sunderland game was the turning point, and there have been a few interviews with Allardyce and the players where they've mentioned a few 'home truths' being aired after that game.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 08 May 17 5.05pm

I am not sure how getting thumped 5-0 can be for the best, especially if we had won we would have guaranteed our survival. But perhaps that is just me.

 

chateauferret Flag 08 May 17 5.12pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I am not sure how getting thumped 5-0 can be for the best, especially if we had won we would have guaranteed our survival. But perhaps that is just me.

Well, presumably the premise is that away vs Citeh one loses anyway. But losing 1-0 after a good performance may have produced complacency, I think is the point. I don't necessarily agree with it, but if anyone has the bollocking skills required to produce the bounce-back we need it's Allardyce.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 May 17 5.15pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I am not sure how getting thumped 5-0 can be for the best, especially if we had won we would have guaranteed our survival. But perhaps that is just me.

Exactly what I was thinking.
No 'Positives' to be taken from the 5-0 mauling.

 

adamnye27 Flag Bracknell 08 May 17 5.15pm

Probably not a great way of looking at it but if someone said your going too win away at Liverpool but get battered at City you would bite someones hand off

 

Casual Flag Orpington 08 May 17 6.03pm

If we manage stay up and get hammered at Old Trafford as well, we will probably spend more on players than we would have if we'd beaten, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool then went on a good run and finished 9th or 10th. So long term as long as we stay up, maybe.

 

aashman12 Flag 09 May 17 7.23am

Originally posted by nairb75

have to think bringing on chungy was putting him in the shop window.

We're not a shop. And if a player has suitors he'll go without getting fleeting minutes in a match

 

chateauferret Flag 09 May 17 7.51am

Originally posted by aashman12

We're not a shop. And if a player has suitors he'll go without getting fleeting minutes in a match

Indeed. Lukaku will fetch £60m despite ninety minutes of complete and utter s***e on Saturday.

 


============
The Ferret
============


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Was the City result for the best?