You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are Punch and Wilf two of our greatest ever player
November 16 2026 9.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are Punch and Wilf two of our greatest ever player


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
MalcomsFedora Flag Brockley 15 May 17 7.35pm

Discuss?

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 May 17 7.44pm

Combined, quite possibly.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 May 17 7.44pm

Wilf yes. deffo.

Punch, nah, ponichetto knew straight away what he was capable of and that's midtable/lower midtable premiership standard, he's a better leader than dann, he is respected amongst the group, he is a good player, but if you wanna see palace finish 7th or the like next year, I think we need to improve on him sadly, not necessarily sell him though, we need players of his caliber in the squad to strengthen us when the injuries come in.

Edited by matthau (15 May 2017 7.45pm)

 

Aray Flag South London 15 May 17 7.48pm

Well apparently they turned up in the Whitehorse last night! Not sure if anyone can confirm but a nice touch if true.

In my view Wilf is definitely heading that way, but needs to have the kind of season where he scores 15 goals, and makes as many, to get into the real legend zone. He is a constant threat and finally this season has become more clinical. I'd have put money on him fluffing that chance a couple of years back.

As for Punch...he needs to regain his shooting boots but played well yesterday. If only he wasn't so one-footed he'd be a significantly better player.

 

PalaceSi Flag Brockley 15 May 17 8.07pm

One is worth 50M and coveted by the top clubs the other is worth 5M and no other premier league team would want him, bit of a difference.
Punch is a great Captain and talisman but as a defensive/ non scoring midfielder he is decidedly championship.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 15 May 17 8.12pm

Wilf is certainly up there with the best but, in my book, Johnny Byrne was the best ever in my lifetime of watching Palace.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 15 May 17 8.59pm

Originally posted by MalcomsFedora

Discuss?

-.-'

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 May 17 9.31pm

Wilf has to go down as one of the greats. He has been instrumental in our recent success.

Play offs - two goals against the weed
Play off final - draws a penalty
Yesterday, scored the opener settled the teams nerves = PL survival.

Then you have his overall ability and application. He has been sensational the last two seasons.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Painter Flag Croydon 15 May 17 9.56pm

I don't think either make the top 10 yet, Zaha has potential, but has only really had one good season in the Premier.

 

merganser Flag 15 May 17 10.02pm

If it's permissible to nominate goalkeepers, John Jackson.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 15 May 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by merganser

If it's permissible to nominate goalkeepers, John Jackson.

Second this.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 May 17 10.29pm

Originally posted by Painter

I don't think either make the top 10 yet, Zaha has potential, but has only really had one good season in the Premier.

He was superb last season too. He was left to try and carry the team for half of it and did a bloody good job of it.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

bicycle repair man 15 May 17 11.08pm

IMO Wilf most definitely would make an all time great Palace team,along with Peter Taylor,John Jackson and Kenny Samson.
Punch really is a terrific player, but not an all time great.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 15 May 17 11.55pm

Wilf has to be. He's come through the ranks, proved himself in the Championship AND in the Premier League now I think we can say. His goal tally and appearance record for a player of his age is pretty darn good if you ask me.

People say he doesn't score enough, but Wilf's a true winger in an age where you see fewer and fewer wingers, just wing backs or wide forwards.
To me that's what makes him so special and why he gets so much attention in our team. There isn't a player out there more tricky than him in the whole division when it comes to dribbling imho. Unique. So proud that he's ours, even if he goes in the Summer.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

pssguy Flag 16 May 17 12.48am

Puncheon. Clearly not

Zaha, I would put alongside Rogers and Taylor as the best wingers I have seen who have played 50+ games for the club ahead of the likes of Salako, Hilaire Routledge & McGoldrick

 

pssguy Flag 16 May 17 12.51am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

He was superb last season too. He was left to try and carry the team for half of it and did a bloody good job of it.

He's made quite the progression this year though. Much stronger on the ball and his vision and passing ability is at a much higher level

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 16 May 17 6.30am

And they say that a week is a long time in politics...

 


[Link]

VeganPower Flag Chesham 16 May 17 10.50am

Wilf is the best player we have ever had. He is amazing. Magical.

tfw he megged Ozil in the 3-0

Edited by VeganPower (16 May 2017 10.50am)

 


22 years eating a vegan diet. Perfectly happy and healthy on it.

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 16 May 17 10.50am

Originally posted by Aray

Well apparently they turned up in the Whitehorse last night! Not sure if anyone can confirm but a nice touch if true.

They did!

 

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 16 May 17 10.50am

+ Fraizer Campbell

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are Punch and Wilf two of our greatest ever player