You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who might go...?
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who might go...?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 10.30am

Ok first off let me make it clear that I hugely love, respect and appreciate everything these guys have done. But we're in the midst of a big squad shake up and I can't imagine that won't mean possibly more players leaving.

At time of writing we've signed Loftus-Cheek on loan and JR for £8m

There's talk of us in discussions with Arsenal over a £20m deal for Chambers.

Also being linked with Martins Indi £10m and Sakho rumours are never far away.

Also in the obvious need for a right wing back (possibly George van der Weil for £5-8m

And not forgetting a striker and keeper wouldn't go amiss..

Well that's a lot of places still potentially to fill.

Who for the right money if reinvested would you be willing to see leave...

I think Ward has done fantastic service for us but I just don't think he'll ever make the wing back role his or be a CB. If we can get £5-8m to cover the cost of George van der Weil, I honestly think that's sound buisness considering it seems like our own obi-wan could offer decent cover.

Next is the question of JimmyMac apparently clubs are circling and an offer of £9-12m wouldn't be a suprise. For me it's a tricky one, I still think he adds value to our squad but logically we've got Cabaye, Luka, Punch (captain) and Loftus-Cheek ahead of him fighting for two midfield places.

For that reason only I'd be able to accept him moving on if his £9-12m is reinvested in say half of Sakho cost or top keeper or young talented striker...

Cabaye I can't see leaving, I just don't think anyone will offer a decent enough wedge for him. I expect him to stay and fight for a starting place. Way to talented to let go for peanuts even if it's his last year.

Expect Tomkins, Dann and Kelly to stay. Unless a stupid bid comes in for Dann from china but I can't see that happening.

Thoughts?

Edited by Goldfiinger (25 Jul 2017 10.42am)

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 25 Jul 17 10.34am

Why hasc anyone got to leave? We do not have enough depth in the squad as it is.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 10.37am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Ok first off let me make it clear that I hugely love, respect and appreciate everything these guys have done. But we're in the midst of a big squad shake up and I can't imagine that won't mean possibly more players leaving.

At time of writing we've signed Loftus-Cheek on loan and JR for £8m

There's talk of us in discussions with Arsenal over a £20m deal for Chambers.

Also being linked with Martins Indi £10m and Sakho rumours are never far away.

Also through in the obvious need for a right wing back (possibly George van der Weil for £5-8m

And not forgetting a striker and keeper wouldn't go amiss..

Well that's a lot of places still potentially to fill.

Who for the right money if reinvested would you be willing to see leave...

I think Ward has done fantastic service for us but I just don't think he'll ever make the wing back role his or be a CB. If we can get £5-8m to cover the cost of George van der Weil, I honestly think that's sound buisness considering it seems like our own obi-wan could offer decent cover.

Next is the question of JimmyMac apparently clubs are circling and an offer of £9-12m wouldn't be a suprise. For me it's a tricky one, I still think he adds value to our squad but logically we've got Cabaye, Luka, Punch (captain) and Loftus-Cheek ahead of him fighting for two midfield places.

For that reason only I'd be able to accept him moving on if his £9-12m is reinvested in say half of Sakho cost or top keeper or young talented striker...

Cabaye I can't see leaving, I just don't think anyone will offer a decent enough wedge for him. I expect him to stay and fight for a starting place. Way to talented to let go for peanuts even if it's his last year.

Expect Tomkins, Dann and Kelly to stay. Unless a stupid bid comes in for Dann from china but I can't see that happening.

Thoughts?

Quote Painter:- The thoughts are we are not playing fantasy football here, we only need TWO players at most. Well that he'd say if I posted something similar.


Edited by Dan89 (25 Jul 2017 10.37am)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 10.40am

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Why hasc anyone got to leave? We do not have enough depth in the squad as it is.

Sorry if it was missed in the OP but it seems like we still need a fair few players. So maybe one or two will need to go to balance the books so we've a better squad for the managers plans.

We've five central midfielders fighting for two places yet don't have a right wing back second striker third goal keeper or center backs which are actually good enough....

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jul 17 10.41am

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Why hasc anyone got to leave? We do not have enough depth in the squad as it is.

Quite

I'd rather hoped that, in our fifth season, we'd be adding strength to the squad. If 3-4-3 was so obviously suited to this squad (supposedly) then don't we just need to add a bit strength in depth. The number of disposals and acquisitions being talked about by some are at a level you'd expect at a newly promoted club.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 10.47am

Im pretty sure I've only named two players to leave...

Not sure it's FdBs fault that we need a striker and third keeper.

Also not sure it's his fault if he doesn't rate any of our defenders. Did you see the state they got in last year...

Is any of that becuase we're changing formation?

Only part of the formation causing an issue would be right wing back.

Just one signing due to the formation change.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 25 Jul 17 10.52am

Jordan Mutch
Lee Chung yong
James MacArthur
Martin Kelly

Can see those 4 possibly leaving

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jul 17 11.55am

Originally posted by bexleydave

Quite

I'd rather hoped that, in our fifth season, we'd be adding strength to the squad. If 3-4-3 was so obviously suited to this squad (supposedly) then don't we just need to add a bit strength in depth. The number of disposals and acquisitions being talked about by some are at a level you'd expect at a newly promoted club.

3-4-3 is suited to the front players and possibly half or just over of the starting XI. Anyone claiming otherwise is wrong, including Frank, which is why he needs to completely change the defence.

This is going to be interesting. Before the window started we had a net spend of £30 mil available, about 15 good players and a handful of positions to fill. 2 in with £22 mil left, a good few or more to recruit, and one at £20 mil. If we had £60 mil available it'd be safer to do. We don't. Better be ready to play 4-3-3 as well as 3-4-3.

 


COYP

Part Time James Flag 25 Jul 17 11.57am

Originally posted by rossboss29

Jordan Mutch
Lee Chung yong
James MacArthur
Martin Kelly

Can see those 4 possibly leaving

I never thought I'd say this but of that list Martin Kelly is the one I'd most like to retain.

*dons a tin hat*

 




Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jul 17 12.01pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Im pretty sure I've only named two players to leave...

Not sure it's FdBs fault that we need a striker and third keeper.

Also not sure it's his fault if he doesn't rate any of our defenders. Did you see the state they got in last year...

Is any of that becuase we're changing formation?

Only part of the formation causing an issue would be right wing back.

Just one signing due to the formation change.

Possibly but none of our CBs have any pace for a 3-4-3 when its needed. Then the 3-4-3 is flawed for us anyway.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (25 Jul 2017 12.03pm)

 


COYP

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 12.03pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Possibly but none of our CBs have any pace in a 3-4-3 when its needed. Then the 3-4-3 is flawed for us anyway.

I guess we'd have suitors for likes of dann, Tomkins otherwise we wouldn't even consider the likes of chambers, martins indi or Sakho.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Part Time James Flag 25 Jul 17 12.04pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Possibly but none of our CBs have any pace in a 3-4-3 when its needed. Then the 3-4-3 is flawed for us anyway.

I'd like to think any manager worth his salt will have at least one other formation in his back pocket anyway.

 




Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jul 17 8.08pm

Hopefully Mutch and Williams, but unfortunately I cannot see anyone buying them.
Unless a club has a physio requiring extra work, in that case Williams is ideal.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 25 Jul 17 8.15pm

Someone might take Chungy, but you are asking alot for someone to take Mutch. He didn't exactly sparkle at Reading last season.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 25 Jul 17 8.17pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

3-4-3 is suited to the front players and possibly half or just over of the starting XI. Anyone claiming otherwise is wrong, including Frank, which is why he needs to completely change the defence.

This is going to be interesting. Before the window started we had a net spend of £30 mil available, about 15 good players and a handful of positions to fill. 2 in with £22 mil left, a good few or more to recruit, and one at £20 mil. If we had £60 mil available it'd be safer to do. We don't. Better be ready to play 4-3-3 as well as 3-4-3.

We do not need to change all the defence.
And we won't be.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 8.49pm

Yeah I don't think he's buying new defenders becuase ours are slow. Chamber isn't known for his speed, nor is Martins Indi nor Sakho. He's buying new center backs becuase he doesn't rate ours. Period.

New Keeper becuase we only have two.
New striker becuase we only have one and half.

I'll repeat myself, only position we haven't got a player for is right wing back. Our right back everyone wants strengthening anyway so really that would have been a position looked at.

So really all he is doing is buying BETTER defenders.... now come on that's only a good thing. There's not a leader between he current crop.

Everyone should stop wetting themselves that someone wants to be able to play two systems.

433 and 343 that's what he's stated.

And to do that he wants to have a rock solid defence which means Ward Dann Tomkins Kelly Damo will need to be upgraded, they've had long enough to show what there made of. Maybe he won't replace them all but there's not a leader between the lot of them. So drastic surgery is being undertaken.

Anyone who thinks we should go in to the season playing Ward, Dann, Tomkins, Schlupp needs there head seeing to. It'd be a game or two before there confidence is crushed as they are absolutely headless chickens without a leader in there.

In 343 we'll end up with 5 defenders on the pitch which again should help us from leaking a god awful amount of goals.

Plus our magical wingers can play higher up the pitch and not worry about bailing out said shocking defenders...

I hope both systems he wants to be able to play work. But let's be perfectly honest. He's replacing defenders who aren't up to the job.

And yes to be able to have TWO systems we need three decent center backs. Stop with the bed wetting...

We have been crying out for a manager to have more than one game plan. Low and behold as soon as we get a manager who spends presession training the guys in another system everyone gets there sissy little pink knickers wet.

 

chateauferret Flag 25 Jul 17 9.07pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I never thought I'd say this but of that list Martin Kelly is the one I'd most like to retain.

*dons a tin hat*

Nothing wrong with that. He's done OK at centre-back since the idiot who nearly Pardewed him out of football altogether was chucked out on his arse.

 


============
The Ferret
============

bodge Flag 25 Jul 17 9.55pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Yeah I don't think he's buying new defenders becuase ours are slow. Chamber isn't known for his speed, nor is Martins Indi nor Sakho. He's buying new center backs becuase he doesn't rate ours. Period.

New Keeper becuase we only have two.
New striker becuase we only have one and half.

I'll repeat myself, only position we haven't got a player for is right wing back. Our right back everyone wants strengthening anyway so really that would have been a position looked at.

So really all he is doing is buying BETTER defenders.... now come on that's only a good thing. There's not a leader between he current crop.

Everyone should stop wetting themselves that someone wants to be able to play two systems.

433 and 343 that's what he's stated.

And to do that he wants to have a rock solid defence which means Ward Dann Tomkins Kelly Damo will need to be upgraded, they've had long enough to show what there made of. Maybe he won't replace them all but there's not a leader between the lot of them. So drastic surgery is being undertaken.

Anyone who thinks we should go in to the season playing Ward, Dann, Tomkins, Schlupp needs there head seeing to. It'd be a game or two before there confidence is crushed as they are absolutely headless chickens without a leader in there.

In 343 we'll end up with 5 defenders on the pitch which again should help us from leaking a god awful amount of goals.

Plus our magical wingers can play higher up the pitch and not worry about bailing out said shocking defenders...

I hope both systems he wants to be able to play work. But let's be perfectly honest. He's replacing defenders who aren't up to the job.

And yes to be able to have TWO systems we need three decent center backs. Stop with the bed wetting...

We have been crying out for a manager to have more than one game plan. Low and behold as soon as we get a manager who spends presession training the guys in another system everyone gets there sissy little pink knickers wet.

Dann Tomkins Ward Schlupp all good players shocking they are not.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by bodge

Dann Tomkins Ward Schlupp all good players shocking they are not.

Granted sorry they're not shocking, my point is we don't have any leaders in the back line. And as good as they've been in the past they were seriously found wanting for large parts of last season.

If anyone wants to start with the same back line. Fair enough, but I'm all for a top top world class defender who's now our manager, being backed over weather he thinks he needs to change things up.

He gets my vote and I'm not gonna wet myself if he wants a couple of new defenders...

They were god awful for most of last season, I'd think it'd be boardline gross negligence not to reinforce the back line..

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 25 Jul 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Granted sorry they're not shocking, my point is we don't have any leaders in the back line. And as good as they've been in the past they were seriously found wanting for large parts of last season.

If anyone wants to start with the same back line. Fair enough, but I'm all for a top top world class defender who's now our manager, being backed over weather he thinks he needs to change things up.

He gets my vote and I'm not gonna wet myself if he wants a couple of new defenders...

They were god awful for most of last season, I'd think it'd be boardline gross negligence not to reinforce the back line..

You got to remember, we on a tight budget as easy as it is to buy defenders, we got to find some suitors for dann and others as we can't afford to have a player like dann in the stands on 65k a week.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who might go...?