You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch at RWB
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Punch at RWB


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 11.38am

I've just posted this under 3-4-3 but thinking about it, it might deserve it's own topic. What do you think?

The only position I can see Punch getting into the team believe it or not is at right wing back. Before anyone dies laughing remember that Milner has successfully converted to this role and Punch to me is a better tackler than Townsend and better going forward than Ward, so if he could learn his trade in that position it answers the question of keeping the captain in the team without him taking up either Cabaye's or Luka's position.

Based on current staff the team for me would be:

Hennessey

Punch, Tomkins, Dann, Reidewald, PVA

Cabaye, Milivojevic

Townsend, Benteke, Zaha

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 11.40am

You need energy as wingback, if he wasn't captain you wouldn't even consider the idea. Think it would be a disaster personally.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 25 Jul 17 11.42am

Milner has converted to lb in a 4-3-3 , not wingback in a 3-4-3 , he had also already played lb quite a few times at club level and for the under 21s when he was younger.

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 25 Jul 17 11.44am

Personally I think if we are playing this formation we need specialist wing backs for it to truly work

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 25 Jul 17 11.45am

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

Milner has converted to lb in a 4-3-3 , not wingback in a 3-4-3 , he had also already played lb quite a few times at club level and for the under 21s when he was younger.

he was also a stop gap who has now been replaced

 


@sxp55555

Winch Eagle Flag Fleet, Hampshire 25 Jul 17 11.47am

Can't maintain possession when passing with his left foot so on his right he would be awful. Souare is probably the only player at the club who is more one footed.
I agree positions are at a premium but on that basis bench rather than RWB...

 


Winch Eagle

MikeCrete Flag Crete 25 Jul 17 11.49am

He cannot play RWB, he only has left foot!!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 11.49am

To be honest this is why I mentioned it because most already are saying that he shouldn't be there, so where do you play him and given that question, why is he captain, because captain should be first name on the team sheet every time?

 

Part Time James Flag 25 Jul 17 11.50am

What about fans favourite, Julian Speroni? Train up to not reflexively use his hands and I reckon he'd be just as good up the right hand side as Joel Ward. Thoughts?

 




Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 11.55am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

To be honest this is why I mentioned it because most already are saying that he shouldn't be there, so where do you play him and given that question, why is he captain, because captain should be first name on the team sheet every time?

You adjust the formation to a 3-5-2

Hennessy

Tomkins dann. Riedewald

Rwb (new). PVA

Luka

Cabaye Puncheon


Zaha. Benteke

Edited by Dan89 (25 Jul 2017 11.56am)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 11.58am

Originally posted by Dan89

You adjust the formation to a 3-5-2

Hennessy

Tomkins dann. Riedewald

Rwb (new). PVA

Luka

Cabaye Puncheon


Zaha. Benteke

Edited by Dan89 (25 Jul 2017 11.56am)

So what you are saying is that Punch is better than Townsend. Sorry I can't agree with that.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 12.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So what you are saying is that Punch is better than Townsend. Sorry I can't agree with that.

I now saying he's better but he suits the cm role more than Townsend


In 3-5-2

You have 3 cb's - Rcb, cb, Lcb
2 wingbacks- rwb , Lwb
3 central mids - cdm, cm , cm
2 strikers- right striker and left striker

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

miles18 Flag Telford 25 Jul 17 12.01pm

Punch on the bench sounds better.

 



.

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 12.05pm

Originally posted by miles18

Punch on the bench sounds better.

When jedinak was captain he didn't play every game, under pardew.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

gambler Flag Kent 25 Jul 17 12.07pm

Can't carry anyone in the premier league.

Punch at rwb? A quick way to ruin the last few years progress

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 25 Jul 17 12.11pm

Punch at best on the bench,at best; better if we sold him & used the £ elsewhere in the squad.

 

beak Flag croydon 25 Jul 17 12.19pm

Oh dear!

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 25 Jul 17 12.29pm

Forget a square peg in a round hole... This would be like trying to push a Toblerone through the eye of a needle

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 25 Jul 17 1.00pm

Originally posted by gambler

Can't carry anyone in the premier league.

Punch at rwb? A quick way to ruin the last few years progress

We made progress last season? Suppose the electronic entry system is progress but on the pitch we took a step bacl

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 25 Jul 17 1.07pm

He had his best games for us as a right winger so it's not too bad a suggestion! We should go for van der Weil he would be cheap so we could spend money elsewhere!

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch at RWB