You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New system (thoughts)
November 16 2026 8.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New system (thoughts)


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Zaha Oh Yes Flag Epsom 12 Aug 17 10.36pm

It seems as the team was very mixed messages. One minute you had Riedewald trying to play out from the back. Then you had PVA smashing forward. I am struggling to see this system being effective. Out of the ordinal players that FDB inherited. Who does this system actually suit. I'm struggling to come up with 4 names. We now found a system to make Zaha less effective. Who do you think suits the formation?

 

chateauferret Flag 12 Aug 17 10.43pm

Originally posted by Zaha Oh Yes

It seems as the team was very mixed messages. One minute you had Riedewald trying to play out from the back. Then you had PVA smashing forward. I am struggling to see this system being effective. Out of the ordinal players that FDB inherited. Who does this system actually suit. I'm struggling to come up with 4 names. We now found a system to make Zaha less effective. Who do you think suits the formation?

Manchester City.

HTH.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 10.44pm

Frank said the players suit it and at that point we were 5-6 players short for 3-4-3. We're now at least 2 players short. RWB and keeper. But if there's injuries we'll be short again.

It's frustrating seeing the left sided players Riederwald and PVA receive the ball and not turn out wide to the left. Instead they pass inside every time. Very predictable and possible for 2-3 opposition players to act on and press Hennessey, Dann, Mensah, Luka, fvcking anybody really.

First 15 mins though I thought we looked dangerous going at them from all angles. Once they weathered that it was all over.

 


COYP

Zaha Oh Yes Flag Epsom 12 Aug 17 10.50pm

Doesn't Suit Benteke, Zaha, Townsend, puncheon, ward, Luka . Many more.

 

Zaha Oh Yes Flag Epsom 12 Aug 17 10.57pm

If de Boer was given a good chunk of money do you believe he should buy for 433 or 343.

 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 12 Aug 17 11.04pm

It's difficult to determine which players it does and doesn't suit, as we haven't seen it performed properly yet.

I have noticed the system has been the focus of all the players interviewing in the pre-season, so it's obvious how much it's weighing on everyone's minds.

When I saw today's teamsheet, I thought that Riedewald and TFM were starting because of their knowledge and experience of the system would provide stability at this early stage of the season. What worries me though is that positionally, I felt they were continually in the wrong areas, exposing every missed pass from Dann, loss of possession from Ward and absent PVA.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 12 Aug 17 11.27pm

We do not have enough technically gifted players that are comfortable playing this style. It is and will continue to be a disaster. Just because everyone else seems to want to play 3-4-3 doesn't mean it's right

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 12 Aug 17 11.35pm

Essentially we'd need to sign a completely new team to have it be effective. Our best players are suited to counter attacking football. Wilf received the ball with his back to goal too many times in the first half. All our chances came from long balls or corners- i didn't see much of the total football that the system promised. We got killed by a team who i would still peg for relegation, and if De Boer doesn't admit we can't do this then he'll be gone by Christmas. I feel for Joel Ward, as he has never claimed to be a wing back- his best qualities are defensive and he looked out of place today, as did Tomkins in the wider central role. We all know that they're both good players in the right system, so why change it

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Zaha Oh Yes Flag Epsom 12 Aug 17 11.38pm

I like to see something like this experience at the back in dann and Tomkins. Riedewald in central defensive mid. Dropping back if need to be he seems to be decent on the ball. Well for 10 minutes anyway.

IMG_0287.JPG Attachment: IMG_0287.JPG (80.79Kb)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 13 Aug 17 12.01am

Change to 4-3-3. Buy Sakho make him captain along side Dann or Tomkins. TFM to RB Riedwalde to left side of midfield with RLC and Luka and Townsend back up top with Benteke and Wilf. Thats getting the best out of what we've got. Puncheon and Ward dropped

 

new_in_Wait Flag Lewisham 13 Aug 17 1.08am

It also depends on the opponent. Huddersfield played with tight wing defence (the fullback and wide midfielder doubled all the time), which pushed our wing-backs to rush and pass the ball either back to the central defenders or (more likely) the two central midfielders. Luka got a knock and it took him out and Punch is just Punch, can't ask for much. There was a lot of waste in the middle of the park, which made us regress to Warnockian long balls into nothing (remember the hundreds of longs balls played on Zaha and Campbell back then? yolo).

Disappointing: Ward (out of position, slow and so easy to dribble past), Puncheon (I fail to see what influence he has, which apparently is the reason he's not dropped. PVA and RLC were shouting at him), Benteke (all too familiar self-indulgence and lack of judgement), Zaha (played on the left, where he's not as dangerous), Dann (physically weak and tactically erratic). Probably the players CAN play this system, but it will take a long time to drill. The question is if the price is worth paying- price being lots and lots of lost points. RLC and Mensah decent and episodically excellent, but they're not ours, so...

Watching MOTD as I type this- worrying that most teams in the EPL look v. comfortable in their systems, even the ones that lost!

 

Nevada Eagle Flag Carson City, Nevada 13 Aug 17 1.53am

This system is great.Can't wait till next week.

 


Sing up ya bums

dannyboy1978 Flag 13 Aug 17 8.09am

We missed cabaye(for puncheon) who is our David desilva and is comfortable on the ball. Midfield and forwards im happy with it's the lack of quick passing and distribution from the defence/goaly I am worried about.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 13 Aug 17 8.34am

Personally I would prefer not to see Riedewald start again until he has undergone some basic training in marking, tackling and challenging for headers

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

beak Flag croydon 13 Aug 17 8.48am

The truth has dawned on me,the players have no belief In this system and cannot/will not play it,the confidence levels are non existent. We are looking at a king sized mess.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Aug 17 9.10am

The bit I'm really struggling with is that FDB was appointed and immediately announced his tactical intentions without seeing the players available to him.

I've been sceptical since then and of course yesterdays performance and result is only adding fuel to that fire.

I haven't seen a Palace team that easy to play against since Burley's era.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Aug 17 9.39am

Games are so often defined by what happens from set pieces. Irrespective of all the pointless and risky playing with ball in our own third we looked very disorganised and aerially weak defending them.
As much of a worry as all the more general stuff about style and formation IMO.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 13 Aug 17 10.10am

We need to be patient and trust our manager.

The players won't be comfortable overnight with the system but we are work in progress.

Arsenal didn't always play the silky football they play now.they had to learn.

I for one think FdB will get it right.

Might take time but would rather watch us playing pass and move than kick and rush.

 

exiledeagle123 Flag 13 Aug 17 10.13am

Just saw interesting discussion about Liverpool and playing 3 at back . Carragher was saying whatever players they buy they will ship goals as there is always space for crosses to come in where wing backs are caught upfield . Also said you need 3 good dominant players at back .
Just don't understand why we want to play that way . 4 1 4 1 suits us perfectly . FDB can get us to pass move and keep possession better but why does it have to be 3 4 3 when we are just going to ship goals .

 

slubglurge Flag welling 13 Aug 17 10.26am

Frank the Plank said that the way Huddersfield played was not a surprise because he done his homework on them. He clearly didnt tell the players. Playing 3 at the back you need 3 dominant headers whereas Riedwalde isnt and he didnt move for the 2nd goal. He was also probably mystified by the near post corner routine circa 1988.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New system (thoughts)