You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Martin Kelly or Yohan Cabaye?
November 16 2026 8.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Martin Kelly or Yohan Cabaye?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Aug 17 6.42pm

By playing 3 at the back it feels like we have effectively swapped a midfield maestro for a defender.

It was my first live game of the season and that's my conclusion. The first half was dull dull dull. De Bore as it were.
Great to see Dann bringing it out from the back but he's not Yohan.

Quite simply we are not using our best players and we're losing.

We are playing with 5 defenders and unfortunately they aren't our best players.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

gambler Flag Kent 26 Aug 17 6.44pm

Jesus Christ parrot. That is all.

Parrot.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 26 Aug 17 6.48pm

I don't think we need to play 3 at the back, if we have a midfielder who is comfortable dropping deep to collect the ball and provide a screen. The Dutch boys will have been trained playing 3 at the back but Dann and Tomkins, no chance.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Aug 17 6.48pm

Originally posted by gambler

Jesus Christ parrot. That is all.

Parrot.

Walks on water
Water into wine
But can't get Yohan into a 3 4 3

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Aug 17 6.49pm

Originally posted by Alex1991

I don't think we need to play 3 at the back, if we have a midfielder who is comfortable dropping deep to collect the ball and provide a screen. The Dutch boys will have been trained playing 3 at the back but Dann and Tomkins, no chance.

Wish FDB agreed with you

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 26 Aug 17 6.50pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

Wish FDB agreed with you

Parrot

Do you not think after the improvement in the second half (despite the goal) he will look to change. He has played 4-3-3 before and it looks far more effective.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Aug 17 6.54pm

Originally posted by Alex1991
Do you not think after the improvement in the second half (despite the goal) he will look to change. He has played 4-3-3 before and it looks far more effective.

I'm worried that Swansea played a different game plan in the second, they could afford to . The first half was really poor, so many bad passes. That was more of an indication of FDB tactics.
Swansea are terrible we were worse.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Elpis Flag In a pub 26 Aug 17 7.02pm

Cabaye has to play , he is one of few players we have who is quality ,not asking him to come on as sub and save us when 2-0 down .

Kelly is a squad player at best and should really only be appearing after injuries and Suspensions to others . he has put in a few good performances when fresh but when used regularly he tends to make errors .

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Aug 17 7.37pm

OP is correct this time - in the first half, our 5 at the back only meant that we had another pointless CB. When Cabaye came on, he was dropping really deep and then distributing. No need for 3 CBs faffing around with the ball.

 

willdonnelly27 Flag 27 Aug 17 12.41am

Cabaye ought to have started the match. But regardless, when Tomkins got injured the big mistake was bringing Kelly on instead of Schlupp.

Ought to have gone to a 4231 side of:
Hennessey
Ward TFM Dann PVA
Luka McArthur
Townsend Cabaye Schlupp
Beneteke

Then a sub later in the game bringing Cabaye on for Puncheon.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 27 Aug 17 1.31am

Originally posted by willdonnelly27

Cabaye ought to have started the match. But regardless, when Tomkins got injured the big mistake was bringing Kelly on instead of Schlupp.

Ought to have gone to a 4231 side of:
Hennessey
Ward TFM Dann PVA
Luka McArthur
Townsend Cabaye Schlupp
Beneteke

Then a sub later in the game bringing Cabaye on for Puncheon.

But he has been injured.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 27 Aug 17 9.26am

Originally posted by MrCParrot

Walks on water
Water into wine
But can't get Yohan into a 3 4 3

Parrot

Good job we played 5-3-2 then.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

heath_eagle Flag haywards heath 27 Aug 17 9.32am

Cabaye looks the most comfortable of all our players in a passing game and when he came on yesterday was the best player on the pitch by some distance. But he's still too deep to be as effective as he could be.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Aug 17 9.46am

Originally posted by Nobbybm
Good job we played 5-3-2 then.

Exactly my point. We played 5 defenders. 5 defenders are not our best players.
Putting an extra defender on the field eliminates a player like Cabaye

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Aug 17 9.56am

Originally posted by willdonnelly27

Cabaye ought to have started the match. But regardless, when Tomkins got injured the big mistake was bringing Kelly on instead of Schlupp.

Ought to have gone to a 4231 side of:
Hennessey
Ward TFM Dann PVA
Luka McArthur
Townsend Cabaye Schlupp
Beneteke

Then a sub later in the game bringing Cabaye on for Puncheon.

I think we had to have had that first half yesterday to fully understand how bad 3 4 3 or 5 3 2 is for us. Waste of our midfield talent.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 27 Aug 17 10.22am

It was a godawful 1st half between two teams playing exactly the same boring continental type of football. It was decided by two awful pieces of defending either side of half time by Kelly. Swansea were clearly more comfortable with it as they have played this way for years and we clearly lacked conviction for the style.
Second half was better as we actually started to play with some pace as we had to chase the game. Comeback was never on though as we are incapable of cleanly striking a ball or managing a Tammy Abrahams type of improvised finish.
If FdB wants to play this way then surely Cabaye has to start along RLC and a new signing. Wilf, Andros and Tekkers up front with a new wideman/forward genuinely pushing for a start keeping them on their toes.
Change of style isn't the problem, it's the lack of signings happy in this style that is baffling.
I have no inside knowledge, but something must be wrong behind the scenes for there to be absolutely no backing of the manager. SP has backed every one he's had so far.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Aug 17 10.33am

So far seen nothing to suggest that de Boer would make best use of the players he has even if we had bottomless coffers.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Aug 17 10.42am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

It was a godawful 1st half between two teams playing exactly the same boring continental type of football. It was decided by two awful pieces of defending either side of half time by Kelly. Swansea were clearly more comfortable with it as they have played this way for years and we clearly lacked conviction for the style.
Second half was better as we actually started to play with some pace as we had to chase the game. Comeback was never on though as we are incapable of cleanly striking a ball or managing a Tammy Abrahams type of improvised finish.
If FdB wants to play this way then surely Cabaye has to start along RLC and a new signing. Wilf, Andros and Tekkers up front with a new wideman/forward genuinely pushing for a start keeping them on their toes.
Change of style isn't the problem, it's the lack of signings happy in this style that is baffling.
I have no inside knowledge, but something must be wrong behind the scenes for there to be absolutely no backing of the manager. SP has backed every one he's had so far.

But that's another problem. The crosses yesterday were from too deep to be effective.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Pikester Flag Worthing 27 Aug 17 11.09am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

It was a godawful 1st half between two teams playing exactly the same boring continental type of football. It was decided by two awful pieces of defending either side of half time by Kelly. Swansea were clearly more comfortable with it as they have played this way for years and we clearly lacked conviction for the style.
Second half was better as we actually started to play with some pace as we had to chase the game. Comeback was never on though as we are incapable of cleanly striking a ball or managing a Tammy Abrahams type of improvised finish.
If FdB wants to play this way then surely Cabaye has to start along RLC and a new signing. Wilf, Andros and Tekkers up front with a new wideman/forward genuinely pushing for a start keeping them on their toes.

Agreed.
In he 1st half the players didn't seem to have a clue what the next step was after playing it across the back for a bit. They then reverted to hoofing it as there was no creative outlet (Wilf).

Cabaye was absolute class. The way he conjures up those few extra seconds on the ball and then drifts past defenders is beautiful to watch. Without him we have Luka and Jimmy who are fairly similar - break up the play followed by a short pass to someone who can run with it.

The 2nd half we looked much better - obviously Swansea were letting us have more room - but we were looking to make things happen.

The back four looked OK - TFM looked a beast at right back and Joel Ward didn't have a bad game despite his critics.
Jimmy and Cabaye looked good together - like old times - and had we had Wilf on at this point instead of Lee (who tried his best) I would have fancied us to get back in it.

The problem is the way we start matches and having to tinker after the damage is done.

I would love to see more of a 4-5-1 or 4-3-3 with:

WH or replacement

TFM - Dann- Tompkins - PVA

RLC - Cabaye - McArthur or Luka

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend

I'm not one for overreacting so I hope FDB turns it around - but he really needs to get the boys firing very very soon.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Aug 17 1.35pm

Originally posted by Pikester

Agreed.
In he 1st half the players didn't seem to have a clue what the next step was after playing it across the back for a bit. They then reverted to hoofing it as there was no creative outlet (Wilf).

Cabaye was absolute class. The way he conjures up those few extra seconds on the ball and then drifts past defenders is beautiful to watch. Without him we have Luka and Jimmy who are fairly similar - break up the play followed by a short pass to someone who can run with it.

The 2nd half we looked much better - obviously Swansea were letting us have more room - but we were looking to make things happen.

The back four looked OK - TFM looked a beast at right back and Joel Ward didn't have a bad game despite his critics.
Jimmy and Cabaye looked good together - like old times - and had we had Wilf on at this point instead of Lee (who tried his best) I would have fancied us to get back in it.

The problem is the way we start matches and having to tinker after the damage is done.

I would love to see more of a 4-5-1 or 4-3-3 with:

WH or replacement

TFM - Dann- Tompkins - PVA

RLC - Cabaye - McArthur or Luka

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend

I'm not one for overreacting so I hope FDB turns it around - but he really needs to get the boys firing very very soon.

I like that team

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Martin Kelly or Yohan Cabaye?