This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
What's happened to Puncheon ?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
palacenomatterwhat Kings Lynn 27 Aug 17 8.17am |
|
|
Seemed to let the game pass him by, is the captaincy weighing him down, looks disinterested to me. Lacking conviction in his role ? Is he/can he drive the team forward, or is it too much for him and the midfield ?
and it's goodnight from me.......
|
Welling Eagle Welling 27 Aug 17 8.23am |
|
|
He now plays a role as a t-Rex! All I see him do all game is pointing, not actually getting stuck in. He didn't want the ball! Not only should he no longer be captain. He needs to be dropped!
|
slubglurge welling 27 Aug 17 8.24am |
|
|
Both he and Ward are shadows of their former selves and should not be in the team
|
Coach 3 Sandown Isle of Wight 27 Aug 17 8.25am |
|
|
Quite simple he has reached the end of the line, if you think back he's not been effective for almost 2 years. Gone are the days of him really "making it happen" he is now shot shy when going forward and his passing is frankly awful. Seems he can only run in circles or turn backwards. Time for him to be taken out of the firing line.
|
Face in Wetherspoons 27 Aug 17 8.44am |
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
Both he and Ward are shadows of their former selves and should not be in the team
Sadly you are right as things currently stand. It is possible that the captaincy is weighing Punch down and he seems to lack confidence in all that he does. When did he last score a goal or even looked like scoring one ? He loves the Palace and must be scared of doing the wrong thing and this may be preventing him from playing his natural game. Wardy still tries his best to give 100% but now seems to be in two minds about going forward or staying back. Am I the only one, but I thought that he played more of a wing back anyway getting forward and playing in some fair crosses from the right. Perhaps he has taken the new style too much to heart and is confusing himself. Just play your normal game mate and, if Frank doesn't like it, he knows what he can do as most supporters will be behind you.
|
aashman12 27 Aug 17 9.18am |
|
Originally posted by palacenomatterwhat
Seemed to let the game pass him by, is the captaincy weighing him down, looks disinterested to me. Lacking conviction in his role ? Is he/can he drive the team forward, or is it too much for him and the midfield ?
Nothing to do with the captaincy, he was poor way before that. Should not be playing cm. If he has to play put him in the front 3 where he can't be such a liability
|
Kant exeter 27 Aug 17 9.22am |
|
|
I suspect Jason is one of the few players who loves the club and genuinely cares. There were players a lot worse than him yesterday and from what I witnessed he looked anything but 'disinterested'. As unpopular as this sentiment might be among the fickle boo boys, give it a rest.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 27 Aug 17 9.28am |
|
|
I love the club, play football and care too, but is that enough to put me in the team? Punch & Waard ahve come to the end of line...time for a change. What about Chungy? Thought he looked positive and at least tried to play, run and have a go....
|
Kant exeter 27 Aug 17 9.41am |
|
|
my point, perhaps badly expressed, is that Jason is being unfairly singled out. I find it ironic that a club like ours would choose to gang upon him when there are other more 'mercenary' characters who are equally deserving of criticism.
Had others taken their (pretty decent) chances yesterday I suspect people would he hailing Jason's captaincy, as they did a few months ago when he was playing the same game under Sam.
I do however agree with your comments about Chungy.
|
Xchurch Eagle Christchurch 27 Aug 17 9.45am |
|
|
Jason Puncheon has been one of our best players in recent years... However before this season started I was wondering whether the attacking midfield centre position he played between Wilf and Andros could do with bolstering... However different formation now and he's deeper than before, don't know if he's as effective this way?
Edited by Xchurch Eagle (27 Aug 2017 9.45am)
Hopkin looks to curl one!
|
Dan89 Se25 27 Aug 17 9.45am |
|
|
His one of our own makes him undroppable. Seems that way
Edited by Dan89 (27 Aug 2017 9.45am)
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
Casual Orpington 27 Aug 17 9.47am |
|
Originally posted by Xchurch Eagle
Jason Puncheon has been one of our best players in recent years... However before this season started I was wondering whether the attacking midfield centre position he played between Wilf and Andros could do with bolstering... However different formation now and he's deeper than before, don't know if he's as effective this way?
Edited by Xchurch Eagle (27 Aug 2017 9.45am)
He really hasn't. We have been pretty much been playing with 10 men for the past 2 years. He offers us nothing, either attacking or defending.
|
Kant exeter 27 Aug 17 10.01am |
|
|
I know this will go down on here like a bacon sandwich at a bar mitzvah but I thought Luka for one has been deserving of at least the same level of opprobrium.
|
spartakev2 Anerley 27 Aug 17 10.05am |
|
|
He's lost that speed of thought. You can see him hesitate when he gets the ball, rather than know g what to do with it before he get's it.....if that makes sense..
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 27 Aug 17 10.13am |
|
|
He has been getting old and now has got older.
Time to move him upstairs and bring in someone younger
|
Mr_Gristle In the land of Whelk Eaters 27 Aug 17 10.23am |
|
|
All that's happened to Punch is that his pre-retirement performance drop-off has started early whilst the level of the league has increased.
It's a shame that he appears to be the only player we have who can do the on-pitch organising that every team needs.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)
|
Bangell Oxford 27 Aug 17 10.43am |
|
|
It's almost comical to watch him and remember that he's meant to be one of our creative players.
|
palacenomatterwhat Kings Lynn 27 Aug 17 10.47am |
|
Originally posted by Kant
I suspect Jason is one of the few players who loves the club and genuinely cares. There were players a lot worse than him yesterday and from what I witnessed he looked anything but 'disinterested'. As unpopular as this sentiment might be among the fickle boo boys, give it a rest.
I agree my point of the post was if you bothered to read it, is he appears non effective at the moment. So is the captaincy a step too far for him. Remove the captaincy he may be more positive, effective without the added pressure ? It's a thought from someone who cares about our club. How can we get Puncheon playing at his most effective ?
and it's goodnight from me.......
|
cpj Kent 27 Aug 17 12.03pm |
|
Originally posted by Coach 3
Quite simple he has reached the end of the line, if you think back he's not been effective for almost 2 years. Gone are the days of him really "making it happen" he is now shot shy when going forward and his passing is frankly awful. Seems he can only run in circles or turn backwards. Time for him to be taken out of the firing line.
^^ This. Has been poor for two years now. We've lost 7 of our last 8 PL games without scoring a goal so how he can be thought of as a good captain escapes me. Should be nowhere near the first team, especially when he's ahead of YC or JM.
|
Kant exeter 27 Aug 17 1.37pm |
|
|
"my point of the post was if you bothered to read it..."
And the point of my post was to take issue with your unfounded criticism that Jason is 'disinterested'. Or didn't you bother to read it?
I know it's fashionable on here to slag him off whilst ignoring the poor performances of others, but questioning his commitment is taking it too far.
We are all disappointed and frustrated, but Jason isn't the sole (or even principle) cause.
I'm hoping it will all still come good. Like most on here I'd have preferred us to have stuck with what we do best. But we've chosen a different route and it's a time to pull together, not look for scapegoats.
|