This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Would you care to share the points that made you review your own ideas?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm admittedly one of the hysterical "get him out, this football is suicidal, why haven't we signed anyone, SP has murdered us" people and although admitting it doesn't justify my petulance sometimes I am liable to calm down! I had an interesting chat with someone on here last night which really reminded me of just how nuanced and unpredictable football can be and no matter how sure I am on my usually radical views it is worth listening to other people's perspectives. Would genuinely like to hear what people would like to see between now and Burnley however small or big as I think it's fair to say something needs to change? I was all for the "revert back to our tried and tested formation with players in the right positions and sign a GK,CB, no.10 and a striker and/or sack FdB" stance but as mentioned was challenged on this with some genuine and insightful comments which made me rethink! Would preferably not hear back from anyone looking to just slate people be it from either the murderous mob or rose tinted la la land side although you are entitled I suppose. would do my blood pressure some good to hear a few genuine footballing perspectives for some good for thought! IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper. Excellent suggestion, as it also allows Luka to drop back into the middle of the back 4 giving a back 5 against the 'big' teams. I'd support that. Oh, and give Luka the armband.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eewires
Excellent suggestion, as it also allows Luka to drop back into the middle of the back 4 giving a back 5 against the 'big' teams. I'd support that. Oh, and give Luka the armband. Should add that I wouldn't object if Schlupp replaced PVA based on recent showings.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper. Nice. Gets my vote. Can't keep playing Punch (much as I love him) when better options are available.
|
|
|
Yep much better system and formation
|
|
|
Originally posted by The_Aviator
Would you care to share the points that made you review your own ideas? Yeah, One of the things I was challenged on was the fact that FdB might only be suited to playing one style of football and getting him to try and adapt the way he wants to play could be even worse (although hard to worsen current form) - LVG at Utd was referenced. Haven't radically changed my thinking but found it helpful to have a genuine football chat rather than a to and fro between either being from one extreme to another which seems to be happening on here. Feel a bit more open now to considerations of giving FdB a bit more time or what me actually want/not want change hence opening up the thread in general. Still an overwhelming feeling of dread within me and I am bricking the fact we might not sign anyone but talking through matters seems more helpful to me than just irately moaning (which I'm most inclined to do!)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper. This is exactly the formation we finished last season with.
"The object of war is not to die for your country but to make some other b*stard die for theirs" - General Patton |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper. This did echo my thinking and still does but then I would question the point in having FdB as manager and even if he did would he be able to work with this (mentioned in another post). My only other comments or suggestion would be I wouldn't mind it being adapted to having two deeper CMs with a No.10 (4-2-3-1) and yeah I actually prefer Schluppy although not too tough, would also like a GK,CB, attacking mid. (No.10/winger) and some CF cover with regards to new signings if it is possible!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm admittedly one of the hysterical "get him out, this football is suicidal, why haven't we signed anyone, SP has murdered us" people and although admitting it doesn't justify my petulance sometimes I am liable to calm down! I had an interesting chat with someone on here last night which really reminded me of just how nuanced and unpredictable football can be and no matter how sure I am on my usually radical views it is worth listening to other people's perspectives. Would genuinely like to hear what people would like to see between now and Burnley however small or big as I think it's fair to say something needs to change? I was all for the "revert back to our tried and tested formation with players in the right positions and sign a GK,CB, no.10 and a striker and/or sack FdB" stance but as mentioned was challenged on this with some genuine and insightful comments which made me rethink! Would preferably not hear back from anyone looking to just slate people be it from either the murderous mob or rose tinted la la land side although you are entitled I suppose. would do my blood pressure some good to hear a few genuine footballing perspectives for some good for thought! I tend to be more on the side of "let's give FdB a chance." I felt that way previously with Pardew, and it did not work out. I felt that way with Allardyce and it did work out. These things are difficult to predict, I suppose. That being said, I agree with you that something needs to change. We have now put ourselves into a position of difficulty and the season has barely started. I agree with FdB that the team should have been as aggressive as they were when we went 2-0 down to Swansea yesterday but I feel his tactics and his motivational prowess are to blame - he's a damp squib, personailty-wise. My solutions: (1) I have yet to see compelling reason why Speroni is not in goal for us. When he plays, he does great things and makes far less mistakes than Hennessey. (2) I think the 4-5-1 option suits our personnel the best, with the two wingers pushing up, and a defensive midfielder playing off two more attacking midfielders. (3) I love Puncheon for what he represents but our best midfield options are Luka, Cabaye and RLC. Punch is a sub at best. (4) Our back four should be TFS-Dann-Sakho-PVA/Schlupp (5) That's right: I said Sakho.
Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987. |
|
|
Originally posted by Podyonkers
I tend to be more on the side of "let's give FdB a chance." I felt that way previously with Pardew, and it did not work out. I felt that way with Allardyce and it did work out. These things are difficult to predict, I suppose. That being said, I agree with you that something needs to change. We have now put ourselves into a position of difficulty and the season has barely started. I agree with FdB that the team should have been as aggressive as they were when we went 2-0 down to Swansea yesterday but I feel his tactics and his motivational prowess are to blame - he's a damp squib, personailty-wise. My solutions: (1) I have yet to see compelling reason why Speroni is not in goal for us. When he plays, he does great things and makes far less mistakes than Hennessey. (2) I think the 4-5-1 option suits our personnel the best, with the two wingers pushing up, and a defensive midfielder playing off two more attacking midfielders. (3) I love Puncheon for what he represents but our best midfield options are Luka, Cabaye and RLC. Punch is a sub at best. (4) Our back four should be TFS-Dann-Sakho-PVA/Schlupp (5) That's right: I said Sakho. can you kindly go and read one of my posts on this very subject (just click on my profile and you might get your answer or you may not) but it's on another thread. Sorry if you don't want to go through HOL but all the answers are already given by others in the other 127 unhelpful before the 31 August threads. Again and again and again and again
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by majorkaios
SORRY THIS POST WAS MEANT FOR THE OP can you kindly go and read one of my posts on this very subject (just click on my profile and you might get your answer or you may not) but it's on another thread. Sorry if you don't want to go through HOL but all the answers are already given by others in the other 127 unhelpful before the 31 August threads. Again and again and again and again
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm admittedly one of the hysterical "get him out, this football is suicidal, why haven't we signed anyone, SP has murdered us" people and although admitting it doesn't justify my petulance sometimes I am liable to calm down! I had an interesting chat with someone on here last night which really reminded me of just how nuanced and unpredictable football can be and no matter how sure I am on my usually radical views it is worth listening to other people's perspectives. Would genuinely like to hear what people would like to see between now and Burnley however small or big as I think it's fair to say something needs to change? I was all for the "revert back to our tried and tested formation with players in the right positions and sign a GK,CB, no.10 and a striker and/or sack FdB" stance but as mentioned was challenged on this with some genuine and insightful comments which made me rethink! Would preferably not hear back from anyone looking to just slate people be it from either the murderous mob or rose tinted la la land side although you are entitled I suppose. would do my blood pressure some good to hear a few genuine footballing perspectives for some good for thought! can you kindly go and read one of my posts on this very subject (just click on my profile and you might get your answer or you may not) but it's on another thread. Sorry if you don't want to go through HOL but all the answers are already given by others in the other 127 unhelpful before the 31 August threads. Again and again and again and again
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by majorkaios
can you kindly go and read one of my posts on this very subject (just click on my profile and you might get your answer or you may not) but it's on another thread. Sorry if you don't want to go through HOL but all the answers are already given by others in the other 127 unhelpful before the 31 August threads. Again and again and again and again Sorry bit confused as to what you're asking me to do here or what is going on?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
We shouldn't drop Punch. He was brilliant vs. Hudders and is important for retaining the ball. Riede isn't good enough due to his lack of physical presence for me. I think we need to sign a CB still. PVA should be dropped for Schlupp who is far better defensively. Still not convinced by Mensa but Ward hasn't been great the last 6mths either. On the brightside, the players to choose from in our midfield are the best they've ever been! Originally posted by Eaglecoops
IMO this is our best team and set up with who is available (forget the injuries we are suffering). Hennessey Fosu-Mensah, Tomkins Dann, PVA Milivojevic Townsend, Cabaye, RLC, Zaha Benteke 4-1-4-1 for me allows Zaha and Townsend to provide the width and Cabaye and RLC to join the attack through the middle. We simply cannot play with wingbacks as the first three games have clearly shown. In this format Ward can be substituted for FM, Jimmy Mc for Cabaye and Riedewalde for either of the CH positions. For me Punch doesn't start and is behind Jimmy Mc in the pecking order for that midfield spot. Everyone else in the squad is cover. Upgrades would be Sakho as we know, and a new keeper.
We'reTheRedAndBlueArmyy ! [Link] - Neil Danns Born A Champion [Requested Video From The Man Himself] SUBSCRIBE to SilverLiningVideos on youtube for more palace videos here - [Link] |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.