You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish and recruiting too blame
November 16 2026 8.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish and recruiting too blame


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
stevenmacpherson Flag 16 Sep 17 2.59pm

A terrible transfer window. Too many defenders. No striker bought to at least put pressure on Bentake's place in the team. He knows he'll be picked and play 90 mins every game. Parish and recruiting have to take blame for poor squad. After 5 seasons we should have quality in reserve all over the pitch, and not be just hoping for Wilf to return

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 16 Sep 17 3.03pm

Benteke is laughing all the way to the bank. He knows he has got nobody that can challenge him for his place in the team.

An established Premiership club with ONE striker... Disgusting.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 16 Sep 17 3.05pm

NO we`we got two! The other one is made of glass!

An established Premiership club with ONE striker... Disgusting.

 

chateauferret Flag 16 Sep 17 3.10pm

Originally posted by stevenmacpherson

A terrible transfer window. Too many defenders. No striker bought to at least put pressure on Bentake's place in the team. He knows he'll be picked and play 90 mins every game.

It's a while since I've seen him play 90 minutes in a game. Been on the park 90 mins, but play?

 


============
The Ferret
============

jeeagles Flag 16 Sep 17 3.25pm

I blame capitalism

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Sep 17 3.32pm

I'd drop benteke fir a game, and stick one of the kids up front. Can't do any worse, and might give benteke a kick up the a**e

 

Brisbane Eagle Flag Brisbane 16 Sep 17 3.33pm

Originally posted by Asian Eagle

NO we`we got two! The other one is made of glass!

An established Premiership club with ONE striker... Disgusting.

[/quote

We needed 4 new tyres and he got two handbrakes

Edited by Brisbane Eagle (16 Sep 2017 3.33pm)

 

cpj Flag Kent 16 Sep 17 3.46pm

Do we have any scouts? You look at that guy in the middle for Southampton today they bought in the summer from Italy - he was immense. Why can't we get players in like that?

I still wonder if there was another reason why Sam walked - had he been told there wouldn't be much money to spend? Very odd for a PL club to have two managers resign. You have to wonder about how the club is tun. To go into a PL season with 1 recognised striker is an appalling situation.

 

Calder Flag 16 Sep 17 4.04pm

Our over achievements in the first two years back, seem to have blinded 'those' of the severity of how inadequate our squad, cover and depth has always been. We may have added quality here and there but we have also let much quality, and leadership leave during this time.

"If you're not moving forward you're moving backward", I remember someone quoting.

Manager, formation, confidence, attitude, application, quality - whatever it may be, the last 24 months have been pretty challenging to follow. Just a bit bored of the losing to be honest.

Appreciate we have 33 games to go and I naturally hope we can turn it around but is it bad to begin having a feeling of relief almost, if we were to find ourselves in the championship next season?

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Sep 17 4.16pm

As a hands on Chairman, the buck obviously stops with SP.
We are diabolical. We are NOT GOOD ENOUGH.
We all know this now. What SP clearly doesn't know is how to correct things.
This has been coming for some time. Too many management changes brings uncertainty and a lack of stability. Different players being bought in by different consortiums all now muddling together. There is a total lack of unity and teamwork. But above all, our collected group of players are sub standard for this league. We are dire.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 16 Sep 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by Calder

Our over achievements in the first two years back, seem to have blinded 'those' of the severity of how inadequate our squad, cover and depth has always been. We may have added quality here and there but we have also let much quality, and leadership leave during this time.

"If you're not moving forward you're moving backward", I remember someone quoting.

Manager, formation, confidence, attitude, application, quality - whatever it may be, the last 24 months have been pretty challenging to follow. Just a bit bored of the losing to be honest.

Appreciate we have 33 games to go and I naturally hope we can turn it around but is it bad to begin having a feeling of relief almost, if we were to find ourselves in the championship next season?

The talk of top ten finish and Europe a couple of years back. First you crawl, then you walk.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 16 Sep 17 4.25pm

It is very easy to be critical when the chips are down and I think in a situation like ours (can't really get much worse (P5 W0 Goals 0)you have to look forwards because the past is history which, we can do nothing about except learn from.

I did not attend the game today but from what I am told the team lacked fitness, shape and commitment.

Hopefully Roy and his team will sort all three out on the training pitch, starting with what should be tomorrow given the capitulation today.

We have three key players to return in Sakho, Tompkins and Zaha.

Sakho in my opinion should be made Captain with immediate effect. Many players need a kick up the derriere and he is the one to give it. He will also sort out the defence which, is woeful.

Tompkins IMO is the natural Sakho partner not Dann who just isn't up to it.

Zaha will hopefully provide the spark and attacking quality that is missing.

Puncheon, who I have been a fan of is I am afraid not good enough on the last 5 games showing. As Captain he needs to motivate all around him and it just isn't happening. Also to be Captain his personal form needs to be in the top drawer....it is not.

If there are divisive factions within the dressing room then they need to be removed.

SP needs to concentrate on affairs associated with being Chairman of the club and nothing else.

Its easy asking the fans to give their undying support and get behind the team but the team need to look also in the mirror, forget their pay packets and play for those same fans who give up their hard earned money to watch what is currently rubbish!

 


Bring back Brolin

fishbone Flag London 16 Sep 17 4.28pm

Oh great we've only got Man City next week who are slapping Watford 4 nil then the othe manc b****** the following week,the future looks s...!!!

 

Robk Flag 16 Sep 17 4.44pm

SP seems to play this game where he had two months to appoint someone ie Dyche or Marco Silva....he then waits and decides to pull a rabbit out of the hat in De Boer, some rabbit! I think both of the others would have been better suited and more long term appointments...he tries to be too clever for his own good......

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Sep 17 5.50pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

It is very easy to be critical when the chips are down and I think in a situation like ours (can't really get much worse (P5 W0 Goals 0)you have to look forwards because the past is history which, we can do nothing about except learn from.

I did not attend the game today but from what I am told the team lacked fitness, shape and commitment.

Hopefully Roy and his team will sort all three out on the training pitch, starting with what should be tomorrow given the capitulation today.

We have three key players to return in Sakho, Tompkins and Zaha.

Sakho in my opinion should be made Captain with immediate effect. Many players need a kick up the derriere and he is the one to give it. He will also sort out the defence which, is woeful.

Tompkins IMO is the natural Sakho partner not Dann who just isn't up to it.

Zaha will hopefully provide the spark and attacking quality that is missing.

Puncheon, who I have been a fan of is I am afraid not good enough on the last 5 games showing. As Captain he needs to motivate all around him and it just isn't happening. Also to be Captain his personal form needs to be in the top drawer....it is not.

If there are divisive factions within the dressing room then they need to be removed.

SP needs to concentrate on affairs associated with being Chairman of the club and nothing else.

Its easy asking the fans to give their undying support and get behind the team but the team need to look also in the mirror, forget their pay packets and play for those same fans who give up their hard earned money to watch what is currently rubbish!

I can tell from your optimism you weren't at the game. In fact you probably haven't been at any!!!
I can tell you that all three home games have been dire. We just aren't up to the job. I watched Bournmouth last night. They are in a different league.

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Sep 17 5.57pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I can tell from your optimism you weren't at the game. In fact you probably haven't been at any!!!
I can tell you that all three home games have been dire. We just aren't up to the job. I watched Bournmouth last night. They are in a different league.

You are spot on my friend this team is terrible and that was obvious after last seasons performance, yet SP buried his head in the sand spent 8m on an unknown and added a couple of loan signings who needed more experience, signed Sakho at last moment and thought he was going to play football like Barcelona or Real Madrid, he needs to stop meddling in team matters because he is hopeless and needs to get someone in who knows what they are doing and that is not DF!

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 16 Sep 17 7.57pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I can tell from your optimism you weren't at the game. In fact you probably haven't been at any!!!
I can tell you that all three home games have been dire. We just aren't up to the job. I watched Bournmouth last night. They are in a different league.

I am glass half full not half empty. My comments were balanced and earring on the optimistic because this situation is retrievable. The home games have been dire, whilst the two away matches haven't. Doesn't that say something? We play pretty well at Burnley then sack our manager...... It could only happen at Palace! Be pessimistic if that makes you feel better but just think what our future would be if the management team had that mindset!!

 


Bring back Brolin

bodge Flag 16 Sep 17 8.02pm

Yes it was tough as the new manager should have had a list of targets and you do not want to sign players the new manager does not want still the buck stops with SP.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Sep 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by Robk

SP seems to play this game where he had two months to appoint someone ie Dyche or Marco Silva....he then waits and decides to pull a rabbit out of the hat in De Boer, some rabbit! I think both of the others would have been better suited and more long term appointments...he tries to be too clever for his own good......

I have always been a staunch supporter of SP but I am now beginning to think he may be the problem. It is great to have a chairman who is a fan but you must think as a chairman not as a fan. From what I hear, FDB wanted Chambers, a goalkeeper and a striker (cant argue with that) SP wanted Sakho, presumably because that is what the fans wanted (me included). Apparently it was the Americans who came over and pulled the plug on FDB and appointed RH (he was interviewed before Burnley) Parish is under severe pressure, perhaps the Americans know more about "soccer" than we have given them credit for, and perhaps they would like someone else at the helm but with the shareholding dont know how this would work. Although as SP is salaried presumably he could be removed. I am not advocating this but he has tried to play games with the big boys (ie Liverpool) and f***** up. Is he out of his depth? discuss

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 16 Sep 17 8.45pm

Is Parish making the decisions anymore?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish and recruiting too blame