You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Two defensive midfielders
November 16 2026 8.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Two defensive midfielders


glaziermart Flag 18 Sep 17 3.16pm

We got bullied against Southampton in our last game, both McArthur and Cabaye looked lightweight. So why not try Fosu-Mensah or Reidewald alongside Luka in the centre and push Loftus-Cheek into the number 10 role. It would also allow Wilf and Andros to wreck havoc up alongside Benteke. Punch would therefore be dropped as well. I would go with the following;

Hennessey

Ward Dann Sakho Schlupp

Fosu-Mensah/Reidewald Luka

Loftus-Cheek


Zaha Townsend

Benteke

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 18 Sep 17 3.31pm

Against City I would go

--------------------------- Speroni-------------------------
Ward Kelly TFM Tomkins Dann Sakho PVA Riedewald Schlupp
------------------------------ Luka--------------------------

Edited by hastingseagle67 (18 Sep 2017 3.34pm)

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 18 Sep 17 3.33pm

I'm not clear what that formation is meant to be, but I'm not too keen on pushing inexperienced CBs into alternative positions they're even less experienced at.

I'd go with the tried and tested 4-2-3-1 and have no arguments with your front four or Milivojevic who I'd partner with another dedicated midfielder. I don't think Riedewald is ready for PL football.

Maybe I'd try Fosu Mensah at RB in tomorrow's game and see how he gets on and I understand Roy is going to play Soure tomorrow, so if he plays well I'd keep him in for Saturday.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Deleted11 18 Sep 17 3.46pm

We lacked any threat against Southampton so you can't play Punch out there.
I would like to see some kind of threat on both flanks with Townsend and Schlupp/PVA on the left.
Let's face it, the next 2 to 3 games are extremely difficult and our GD could be insane, but we can't go out against these teams without some kind of threat.

 

dumbell Flag edenbridge 18 Sep 17 4.02pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Against City I would go

--------------------------- Speroni-------------------------
Ward Kelly TFM Tomkins Dann Sakho PVA Riedewald Schlupp
------------------------------ Luka--------------------------

Edited by hastingseagle67 (18 Sep 2017 3.34pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 18 Sep 17 4.21pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Against City I would go

--------------------------- Speroni-------------------------
Ward Kelly TFM Tomkins Dann Sakho PVA Riedewald Schlupp
------------------------------ Luka--------------------------

Edited by hastingseagle67 (18 Sep 2017 3.34pm)

Like it

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Sep 17 4.26pm

Maybe that was THE PLAN.

 


COYP

Part Time James Flag 18 Sep 17 4.33pm

This is close to some thinking I had earlier. Genuinely thinking we should drop Benteke (yes we'll miss all his goals) for Man City and play an attacking midfield lineup of Zaha (if available), RLC and Townsend. Play an extra DM as mentioned and sit deep. Look for breaks by telling everybody to pass to one of those three and....ok ok, I'd make a sh*t manager, I've been told.

But we'll be counter attacking if we attack City at all and I'm not really bothered for Benteke being at the front of that attack. Not slating him really, but I think we could ditch an out and out striker in favour of a ball winner.

So maybe (assuming fitness):

Hennessey

TFM, Dann, Sakho, PvA

Luka, Jimmy

Cabaye

Zaha, RLC, Townsend


*Tin hat is on ready for the word 'prat' to rain down upon my head*

I should've caveated that I bunged in Jimmy Mac at random. He's not really the right guy to go there. Riedewald if you must.

Edited by Part Time James (18 Sep 2017 4.34pm)

 




Dan89 Flag Se25 18 Sep 17 4.43pm

I was thinking something like this against man city

IMG_0669.JPG Attachment: IMG_0669.JPG (67.80Kb)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 18 Sep 17 5.04pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Against City I would go

--------------------------- Speroni-------------------------
Ward Kelly TFM Tomkins Dann Sakho PVA Riedewald Schlupp
------------------------------ Luka--------------------------

Edited by hastingseagle67 (18 Sep 2017 3.34pm)

LOL - we'll only lose by 4 then!

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 18 Sep 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

We got bullied against Southampton in our last game, both McArthur and Cabaye looked lightweight. So why not try Fosu-Mensah or Reidewald alongside Luka in the centre and push Loftus-Cheek into the number 10 role. It would also allow Wilf and Andros to wreck havoc up alongside Benteke. Punch would therefore be dropped as well. I would go with the following;

Hennessey

Ward Dann Sakho Schlupp

Fosu-Mensah/Reidewald Luka

Loftus-Cheek


Zaha Townsend

Benteke

Think this is a good suggestion, I'd also like to see us try RCL along side Luka. But deff think one of the three (RCL, TFM, Reidwield) should regularly play along side Luka as a second DM.


 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 18 Sep 17 6.45pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Against City I would go

--------------------------- Speroni-------------------------
Ward Kelly TFM Tomkins Dann Sakho PVA Riedewald Schlupp
------------------------------ Luka--------------------------

Edited by hastingseagle67 (18 Sep 2017 3.34pm)


I heard we was allowed to play with two goalies

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 18 Sep 17 6.57pm

Riedewald can play DM apparently, so yeah why not, him alongside Milo and L cheek/Cabaye CAM/Benteke central link up.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Sep 17 7.18pm

The way I see it is all midfielders should be defensive ,attacking , and goalscorers . That's what midfield players do . Maybe we just havnt got the right players .

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 18 Sep 17 7.39pm

We need to be defensive and try and get some joy from set pieces. If we try to play we're f***ed! Please no more puncheon and ward!

 

Aray Flag South London 18 Sep 17 9.44pm

I reckon Roy will look at what worked last year. Why wouldn't he?

Against Arsenal we played

Hennessey
Ward, Kelly, Sakho, Schlupp,
Milivojevic, Cabaye,
Zaha , Puncheon, Townsend ,
Benteke

Although JC failed to track back for the Saints' goal - the spine of that line up is fine in my view.

I'd drop ward and Kelly for TFM and Dann. RLC replaces Punch. Schlupp wasn't great on Sunday but he should surely have a couple of games before he's dropped.

I don't think we should be playing 20-year old defenders in central midfield.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Two defensive midfielders