You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Universal Credit
November 21 2026 11.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Universal Credit


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Oct 17 12.36pm

Surprised this hasn't been brought up yet.

According to TM at pmqs just now, 4 out of 5 people using UC are satisfied with it.

That still leaves 20% dissatisfied.

Good idea badly implemented? Lots if reports of people being evicted because they have to wait so long for any support.
What do others think? Anyone experienced UC, it's been rolled out in Croydon.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Oct 17 12.39pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Surprised this hasn't been brought up yet.

According to TM at pmqs just now, 4 out of 5 people using UC are satisfied with it.

That still leaves 20% dissatisfied.

Good idea badly implemented? Lots if reports of people being evicted because they have to wait so long for any support.
What do others think? Anyone experienced UC, it's been rolled out in Croydon.

I think you are a Labour Party drone who spends most of his life trying to bad mouth the Tories.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Oct 17 1.03pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I think you are a Labour Party drone who spends most of his life trying to bad mouth the Tories.

Oh dear. Sorry that people might want to debate about things wot are in the news.

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 25 Oct 17 1.07pm

Lots of people evicted because of the benefits cap ?

and also they do not pay rent direct to landlords anymore, giving all the cash to claimants

You can talk about nasty tories and the poorest in society bearing the brunt for austerity cuts etc but I feel this misses the point slightly, the idea is that people are weened off benefits and we stop the benefits culture.

More should be done about minimum wage though, lower corporation tax and business rates and increase the minimum wage. Then work really will pay

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 25 Oct 17 1.16pm

It has been brought up in parliament with a 300 vote majority (tories abstained too ashamed) for labour and others.

The motion to halt it, sort it out so people are not evicted etc.

However like the EU vote it is an advisory vote and, unlike the EU vote they just carried on anyway.

Like anything the main thing is it does not happen to you but it is an outrage.

Poverty is being reborn in society by the conservatives deliberately.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Oct 17 1.18pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

Lots of people evicted because of the benefits cap ?

and also they do not pay rent direct to landlords anymore, giving all the cash to claimants

You can talk about nasty tories and the poorest in society bearing the brunt for austerity cuts etc but I feel this misses the point slightly, the idea is that people are weened off benefits and we stop the benefits culture.

More should be done about minimum wage though, lower corporation tax and business rates and increase the minimum wage. Then work really will pay

As I said good idea badly administered. The wait of over 6 weeks to get any money is far too long. Those in social housing can probably get away with missing a couple of rent payments but those in private rented accommodation are finding landlords aren't quite so accommodating, this is the sector where evictions are happening.

Good to see TM announce the lifting of the benefit cap towards social housing rents.
Another u turn brought about by that weak opposition everyone kept saying were cr AP.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Oct 17 1.20pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

Lots of people evicted because of the benefits cap ?

and also they do not pay rent direct to landlords anymore, giving all the cash to claimants

You can talk about nasty tories and the poorest in society bearing the brunt for austerity cuts etc but I feel this misses the point slightly, the idea is that people are weened off benefits and we stop the benefits culture.

More should be done about minimum wage though, lower corporation tax and business rates and increase the minimum wage. Then work really will pay

BINGO!! But seriously, benefits in the UK pays s**t, and most people claiming universal credit and tax credits, work 16 hours a week to top up their benefits.

I don't think you can 'ween people' off benefits, without having a viable alternative (which is jobs that pay reasonable wages) or capping rents etc.

I'd say its reasonable to tie a cut in corporation tax and business rates, to a rise in the minimum wage.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Oct 17 2.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I think you are a Labour Party drone who spends most of his life trying to bad mouth the Tories.

I think that you should either make an attempt to answer the question or go forth and multiply

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Oct 17 2.14pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I think that you should either make an attempt to answer the question or go forth and multiply

Of course you do.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 25 Oct 17 3.08pm

UC a good idea in theory, but bungled (like most other things) by the government for ideological reasons and ineptitude.

Makes work pay as long as you don't actually get a job as the taper rate is effectively a 63% tax rate (imagine the reaction on here and among Tory grandees if that was the top tax rate).

Things like payment in arrears and unifying the system is all well and good but it has to be done competently and with proper transitional arrangements. Also the fact that cash no longer goes directly to social landlords is such a bad idea.

A universal basic income, combined with proper top rates of tax, fair taxation of capital (vs income) would be a much better idea, easier to administer and have significant benefits to people's productivity. It would also have a massive beneficial impact on mental health.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 25 Oct 17 3.23pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

and also they do not pay rent direct to landlords anymore, giving all the cash to claimants

This is where it falls down.
Easy to spend and give it large to rent.
Some maybe knowing that whatever they will be rehoused.
I said ' maybe'
I understand the delay in payments but not many courts would sanction this eviction if you proved it was out of your control.
I stand to be corrected if I'm wrong but logic says it won't happen often if at all.


 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 25 Oct 17 3.42pm

Sadly don't know enough about it to comment

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

npn Flag Crowborough 25 Oct 17 3.42pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

UC a good idea in theory, but bungled (like most other things) by the government for ideological reasons and ineptitude.

Makes work pay as long as you don't actually get a job as the taper rate is effectively a 63% tax rate (imagine the reaction on here and among Tory grandees if that was the top tax rate).

Things like payment in arrears and unifying the system is all well and good but it has to be done competently and with proper transitional arrangements. Also the fact that cash no longer goes directly to social landlords is such a bad idea.

A universal basic income, combined with proper top rates of tax, fair taxation of capital (vs income) would be a much better idea, easier to administer and have significant benefits to people's productivity. It would also have a massive beneficial impact on mental health.

What, in your opinion, is a "proper top rate of tax"?

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 25 Oct 17 3.47pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

UC a good idea in theory, but bungled (like most other things) by the government for ideological reasons and ineptitude.

Makes work pay as long as you don't actually get a job as the taper rate is effectively a 63% tax rate (imagine the reaction on here and among Tory grandees if that was the top tax rate).

Things like payment in arrears and unifying the system is all well and good but it has to be done competently and with proper transitional arrangements. Also the fact that cash no longer goes directly to social landlords is such a bad idea.

A universal basic income, combined with proper top rates of tax, fair taxation of capital (vs income) would be a much better idea, easier to administer and have significant benefits to people's productivity. It would also have a massive beneficial impact on mental health.

It sounds a bad idea on the face of it and yes, there will be some wasters who will spunk it but, again, the idea is noble, that people should be responsible for their own budgeting and how they make ends meet. To move away from the notion that the government will give you a place to live and pay your rent for you is the right way. Yes, we should support the poor, vulnerable and those in need as we will always have an obligation as a society but lets make 'something for nothing' a thing of the past

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 25 Oct 17 3.56pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

It sounds a bad idea on the face of it and yes, there will be some wasters who will spunk it but, again, the idea is noble, that people should be responsible for their own budgeting and how they make ends meet. To move away from the notion that the government will give you a place to live and pay your rent for you is the right way. Yes, we should support the poor, vulnerable and those in need as we will always have an obligation as a society but lets make 'something for nothing' a thing of the past

Would you tell us how the award of 1p per week universal credit to a mother of two facing losing her home is 'something for nothing'?

Driving people into poverty for no reason except some perverted false ideology.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Oct 17 4.17pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Would you tell us how the award of 1p per week universal credit to a mother of two facing losing her home is 'something for nothing'?

Driving people into poverty for no reason except some perverted false ideology.

Why doesn't her partner get a job and support her

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Oct 17 4.43pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

It sounds a bad idea on the face of it and yes, there will be some wasters who will spunk it but, again, the idea is noble, that people should be responsible for their own budgeting and how they make ends meet. To move away from the notion that the government will give you a place to live and pay your rent for you is the right way. Yes, we should support the poor, vulnerable and those in need as we will always have an obligation as a society but lets make 'something for nothing' a thing of the past

Problem is, the situation tends to be a bit f**ked up the moment that any change in status occurs. Friend of ours when her son turned 18, she rightly contacted Social Services, and the change in benefit/tax credits meant her benefits were recalculated - and a result of this was that all her benefits were frozen for six or seven weeks in the process.

The problem of course is that people on benefits don't have money to fall back on, and people don't suddenly stop wanting to be paid either.

So six weeks on, she's now behind on all bills, in arrears on her rent, and basically has only managed to stay afloat on the 16 hours a week she works at minimum wage, borrowing money from other people, the grace of her landlord. Meanwhile her kids have to be fed, clothed, sent to school etc.

The system is already a f**king travesty that fails people reliant on it. I wouldn't trust a British government to deal with Benefits, except to make it harder and f**k over more people.

People on benefits or tax credits, don't need new systems - They need the capacity to earn more money themselves, by working.

Increase the minimum wage and the hours they can work. Incentivise them back into work, where possible and provide a reasonable system for those who need it.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Oct 17 4.44pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why doesn't her partner get a job and support her

Maybe he's not in the picture, maybe he's a feckless dosser. Friend of mine, sadly, had a habit of feckless wastes of space as partners.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 25 Oct 17 4.52pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

It sounds a bad idea on the face of it and yes, there will be some wasters who will spunk it but, again, the idea is noble, that people should be responsible for their own budgeting and how they make ends meet. To move away from the notion that the government will give you a place to live and pay your rent for you is the right way. Yes, we should support the poor, vulnerable and those in need as we will always have an obligation as a society but lets make 'something for nothing' a thing of the past

What you've actually seen is that Landlords are unwilling to give new leases to tenants on UC simply because they don't trust them to make the payments. They're not even getting the chance.

As I've pointed out the taper rate means that work doesn't pay. Figures following inflation data showed that real earnings have fallen by most for families working but still on UC, and those just on UC but not working have been more insulated. This isn't right.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 25 Oct 17 4.58pm

Originally posted by npn

What, in your opinion, is a "proper top rate of tax"?


Additional 5% for over £80k sounded like a reasonable start to me as proposed by Labour in previous GE.

More importantly taxes on unearned income such as capital gains and inheritance needs looking at as it's way too low. It shouldn't be so much lower than income tax. Why you get taxed more on money you work for is grossly unfair.

Reforming property tax so that your home isn't exempt from CGT would be a good idea as well and would help cool down the market. I would advocate replacing SDLT with CGT so that you pay taxes on exiting rather than going in, which would help first time buyers and tax large unearned gains. It would also mean if you've worked hard and saved to buy a bigger house you'd not be penalised by a transaction tax. This would have to still apply on inheritance and inheritance tax taken after CGT was charged on any property in a death estate.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Universal Credit