You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Football officials (Ref's)
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Football officials (Ref's)


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 13 Dec 17 3.51pm

I think the performance of ref's in this day and age is appalling. And think the FA should set up a rotating board attending by duty premier managers, to assess each referee performance maybe bi-weekly/Monthly to asses there performance. With a system similar to the yellow/red card for players. Meaning if a performance by a referee is deemed to be below an acceptable standard they should receive a yellow card if they reach 4 yellows they should receive a 2 match ban and no salary for that period. If a performance is so poor that it effects the result it should be a red card and an automatic ban for 2 to 3 matches. If that was adopted the refereeing would soon improve or those repeatedly offending should be dropped in standard

Thoughts and opinions please

Edited by Medway Eagle (13 Dec 2017 3.53pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 4.17pm

Subject to the specifics eveyone here would agree that the standard of match officials is s*** and they need to be morr accountable.

Everyone except one person, that is.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 17 4.26pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Subject to the specifics eveyone here would agree that the standard of match officials is s*** and they need to be morr accountable.

Everyone except one person, that is.

You are certainly right about that "One person".Well done.

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 13 Dec 17 4.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

You are certainly right about that "One person".Well done.

Willo can you give a few reasons that match officials should not be held accountable for the decisions with so much at stake??

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 17 4.42pm

Originally posted by Medway Eagle

Willo can you give a few reasons that match officials should not be held accountable for the decisions with so much at stake??

Ther ARE answerable for their decisions and actions as part of the post match 'Forensic' vigorous assessments of their match performance.

It really is detailed scrutiny using the match coverage and 'ProZone'. Referees are assessed not only for their technical performance but their match management and their decision making.

Edited by Willo (13 Dec 2017 4.47pm)

 

merganser Flag 13 Dec 17 5.08pm

Willo makes a fair point.

But is it time for the assessments to be made public?

At the moment, the information is kept under wraps.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 13 Dec 17 5.50pm

Originally posted by merganser

Willo makes a fair point.

But is it time for the assessments to be made public?

At the moment, the information is kept under wraps.

Yes, it is, same as all info on players, clubs, county & national assoc. It is the same in the business & commerce world too, 'what you don't know, wont harm you'

In response to the OP & in agreement with Willo here, having been an assessor for 6 years, EVERY match official in the top 9 tiers are assessed every game

IF, a match official is deemed to fall below certain standards they are put into a lower league till those standards are brought back up.

With the 'Elite' group, there are 30 professional Officials....10 in the middle, 10 as 4th official & the other 10 either hols/away/lower lge appointments.

Hope this helps to explain what goes on.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 6.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

You are certainly right about that "One person".Well done.

Predicting your response to a ref thread is no harder than predicting the result of Benteke taking a penalty.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 6.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

Ther ARE answerable for their decisions and actions as part of the post match 'Forensic' vigorous assessments of their match performance.

It really is detailed scrutiny using the match coverage and 'ProZone'. Referees are assessed not only for their technical performance but their match management and their decision making.


Edited by Willo (13 Dec 2017 4.47pm)

Please look up the following words in a dictionary:

"Accountable"

"Assessed"

and tell me whether you still think they mean the same thing.


Edited by chateauferret (13 Dec 2017 6.32pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 17 6.39pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Please look up the following words in a dictionary:

"Accountable"

"Assessed"

and tell me whether you still think they mean the same thing.


Edited by chateauferret (13 Dec 2017 6.32pm)


I don't need to look them up.

I am happy that one can be "Accountable" and be "Assessed" at the same time.
One can explain decisions or action or none in the case of both as part of a performance evaluation.

Dear me - 'Semantics' or just another English lesson.

My views on this subject have been well documented and I stand 'Four square' behind them.

Edited by Willo (13 Dec 2017 6.40pm)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 13 Dec 17 6.53pm

I think it will be excellent when they have more video reviews and, Clattenburg aside - who now appears to have admitted to what we have always accused him of - they don’t deliberately make errors. Having said that they are guilty of pre-judging players (Zaha, Andy Johnson) and hopefully they will be under a lot of pressure to ensure this doesn’t happen, as video reviews will really put any poor decisions in the full glare of public scrutiny.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 13 Dec 17 6.54pm

how easy is it to be promoted/demoted to/from elite ref status? sometimes I wonder if the closed-door nature of the PL as a franchise has created issues with the quality of reffing.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

dg1937 Flag 13 Dec 17 7.00pm

The standard of refereeing is, I agree, very poor and seems to have got much worse. This is the thing that makes my blood boil at matches more than anything else.

However, without wishing to sound like Willo, I would make a couple of points in defence of refs:

- as a supporter for 54 years and counting I do wonder if we oldies suffer a bit from 'everything was better in the olden days' syndrome;

- in the distant past every decision wasn't subject to scrutiny from multiple angles in slow motion. I suspect referees have always been sh*t, it's just more obvious now;

- the game is certainly much faster these days, much faster. This certainly makes the officials job harder. If John Sewell ever burst forward on the overlap (I'm not sure he ever did) it was probably at walking pace and quite easy to decide whether or not he was offside!

- I also very much doubt 'simulation' was much of an issue in the '60s when I started following Palace. Players' willingness to cheat makes life tough for the officials.

I have thought about doing a survey, contacting fans' forums up and down the land to get a broader view. I strongly suspect that the fans of every club believe they are hard done by, even the top four probably believe refs are biased against them. I can't be arsed to do the survey but I think it would be an interesting exercise if there are any students out there looking for a dissertation topic!

I do agree that greater 'transparency' would help, as would greater honesty on the part of officials. It's very rare for one to admit that they got a big decision wrong, we might respect them more if they did.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 13 Dec 17 7.03pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

how easy is it to be promoted/demoted to/from elite ref status? sometimes I wonder if the closed-door nature of the PL as a franchise has created issues with the quality of reffing.

You don't is the short answer.....

Every match official OUTSIDE this group of 30 are amateur ie they are NOT paid a wage like the 'Elite' group is. So, these officials DO get asked to join the group IF they are willing to give up their full time jobs.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Dec 17 8.16pm

I have long since said that the standard of refereeing has got worse since they became full time professional. The Premier league likes to promote itself as number 1 on the world stage but the officials are making a mockery of this. The lino on the main stand side last night was the same one as on Saturday, he was appalling and could not see a hold if it was on him!!

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 13 Dec 17 9.02pm

Originally posted by Willo

Ther ARE answerable for their decisions and actions as part of the post match 'Forensic' vigorous assessments of their match performance.

It really is detailed scrutiny using the match coverage and 'ProZone'. Referees are assessed not only for their technical performance but their match management and their decision making.

-----------------------------------------------------

Willo as I said it should be a panel of Premier Managers or ex managers. Not a closed shop of the old boys network. With the TV scrutiny surely you see how bad the refereeing is each week in numerous games. In a multi-million £ industry surely it deserved better policing than what we have at the moment, And as long as its behind closed doors it will continue as it is


Edited by Willo (13 Dec 2017 4.47pm)

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 Dec 17 9.16pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I have long since said that the standard of refereeing has got worse since they became full time professional. The Premier league likes to promote itself as number 1 on the world stage but the officials are making a mockery of this. The lino on the main stand side last night was the same one as on Saturday, he was appalling and could not see a hold if it was on him!!

The issue is that the provision and performance assessment of referees was outsourced to the PGMOL by the Premier League. Basically, the refs now police themselves and, as far as they (and Willo) are concerned, they're doing a great job.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

merganser Flag 13 Dec 17 10.46pm

I am grateful to Eagleman13 for his insights.

My view is that there should be much more transparency.

Premier refs are handsomely remunerated, so I think the assessments should be made public.

The game’s governing bodies owe that to the public.

Everything at the moment is clouded by vagueness - not helped by the fact that the refs’ boss, Mike Riley, is so uncommunicative.

Talk about Mr Invisible . . .

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 10.49pm

Originally posted by Willo


I don't need to look them up.

I am happy that one can be "Accountable" and be "Assessed" at the same time.
One can explain decisions or action or none in the case of both as part of a performance evaluation.

Your logic is as appalling as ever.

One can of course be assessed and accountable at the same time.

My point was that just because one is assessed doesn't mean one is accountable.

Or can you tell me when a referee has explained his appalling decisions after a match? (Clattenburg doesn't count because he was just using it to get himself back in the limelight).

 


============
The Ferret
============

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 13 Dec 17 10.54pm

Clearly when we get a video ref 3rd official in matches it's going to make a massive difference. A lot of the decisions referees get wrong are going to be overruled and then we will see which referees are good at their jobs and which aren't.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Football officials (Ref's)