You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Whatever happened to the magic of the cup?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Whatever happened to the magic of the cup?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
OhthisbloodyPC Flag 09 Jan 18 9.35am

I must say I'm disappointed that clubs don't take the FA Cup more seriously.

Am I alone in this?

Yes, resting players gives Palace a better chance of survival in The Premiership.

And we all know how important the money is.

Hang on. Are we fans or financial consultants?

The FA Cup is our one hope of real glory. We've nearly won it twice.

Nobody else seems to care.

Is it just me? Am I howling at the moon?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 09 Jan 18 9.38am

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

I must say I'm disappointed that clubs don't take the FA Cup more seriously.

Am I alone in this?

Yes, resting players gives Palace a better chance of survival in The Premiership.

And we all know how important the money is.

Hang on. Are we fans or financial consultants?

The FA Cup is our one hope of real glory. We've nearly won it twice.

Nobody else seems to care.

Is it just me? Am I howling at the moon?

You can blame Man Utd for the demise of the FA Cup when they didn't enter because they went and played in a meaningless Int'l club competition.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 09 Jan 18 9.46am

For PL teams the magic of the cup starts at the quarter or even semi finals. Before that it has become an inconvenience, which is a shame.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

miles18 Flag Telford 09 Jan 18 9.57am

Last time we made the Cup final we lost because of the ref. It would have meant everything to us and United sacked the manager after winning it. Bloody disgrace!

League is more important now because of the money so big teams don't give a s***.

 



.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Jan 18 10.04am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

You can blame Man Utd for the demise of the FA Cup when they didn't enter because they went and played in a meaningless Int'l club competition.

I think that's just a small cause tbf.

Sky money and hundreds of games on tv, managers resting and protecting players from injury and 6 or however many of your own games on tv takes away the magic of cup final day. It's for the top 6, the safe mid-table teams and championship and league 1 teams with momentum.

I'm guilty of eventually following the herd and not caring too much.

 


COYP

Headbert Flag Mitcham 09 Jan 18 10.52am

PL riches dwarfs the glory of the FA Cup. They're going to have to raise the incentives somehow for teams trying to stay in or get into the PL. It is largely British people that remember the glory of the old FA Cup dramas - not today's international audiences of the PL. The FA Cup needs to be upgraded commercially to bring in the money to make it worth the risk. It probably cannot be done.

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 09 Jan 18 11.45am

Many years ago the FA Cup was (and still is to most lower league clubs) a potential major source of revenue as well as club glory. Winning 'The Cup' was then on a par with winning the league.

This has changed now mainly due to Sky and the amount of money now concentrated in the EPL.

Today,given the importance to PL clubs of remaining in the league, it is only a handful of wealthy clubs who who have a large squad of quality players who can afford to take the cup really seriously. They can rotate their squad and have cover for most potential injuries.
Smaller (poorer) clubs - like Palace just do not have the means of really competing in the FA /League cups while also ensuring they protect their league status.

The FA cup is still very attractive to most club supporters, and I suspect many players ,but not so much now to club owners whos main concern now is the TV money available in the PL.


Edited by rob1969 (09 Jan 2018 11.46am)

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 09 Jan 18 11.50am

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC


And we all know how important the money is.

Hang on. Are we fans or financial consultants?

The FA Cup is our one hope of real glory. We've nearly won it twice.

Nobody else seems to care.

Is it just me? Am I howling at the moon?

I'm sure the club cares a hell of a lot about the money but my personal reasons are more selfish, living in France these days, the lower down the leagues Palace go the less chance I get to see them play.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

YT Flag Oxford 09 Jan 18 12.03pm

Simple solution. Cut the crap and give the FA Cup winners an automatic place in the (so called) Champions League.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

leejaneagles Flag 09 Jan 18 12.04pm

Let's not pretend as if the soul has been completely ripped out of the club and the fans and that it would be this way under any circumstance.

Manchester City fielded one of their strongest line-ups in the 3rd round because winning cups is important. However, it is not as important as the league. Man City are 15 points clear of 2nd place, they will now be fielding their strongest team in the FA Cup and Europe, with the backup string in the intervening Prem fixtures. Does this mean the league has lost all meaning to them? Of course not.

Palace aren't just in a relegation battle, they were dead and buried by October. They broke so many records of being the statistically worst team ever and through so much mental and physical strength managed to pull themselves out of it with a fighting chance of staying up.

In any of our 8 game unbeaten run, all it would have taken is one goal from any of the opposition and we'd probably be rock bottom now. Imagine losing to Brighton at the Amex, or not equalising against West Ham. Do you know how much concentration that must take to be that switched on in pressure situations, not just for 1 or 2 games but every game we've had since Hodgson took over, just to try and get ourselves out of a terrible mess.

This season, screw the cup. The players have to keep going at these ridiculously high levels just to keep us up. And they are ridiculously high levels because we're in European places by Form, so we're still suffering the effects of the start of the season because we should be many points clear of relegation.

Now, if we had started with Roy, had the players we needed rather than start with 1 striker and been sitting comfortably 6 points clear of the relegation zone, I'd say start the best team at Brighton. It's Brighton away, our biggest rivals.

But I think we can let the Club have the night off in this circumstance. Hopefully next year we'll draw them again and be in a position to start the best 11.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Jan 18 12.19pm

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Absolutely spot on.

 


COYP

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 09 Jan 18 12.24pm

You are not, I felt horrible last night and I can not understand giving up before the start and not having a go. Of course I see the risk of injury but genuinely I wonder if all this talk and resting has not an opposite effect and causes harm over all.
So lets stop cups and all become accountants and count our tv money so we can be one of the little friends of the big bullies in the playground of the PL. f*** modern football.

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

I must say I'm disappointed that clubs don't take the FA Cup more seriously.

Am I alone in this?

Yes, resting players gives Palace a better chance of survival in The Premiership.

And we all know how important the money is.

Hang on. Are we fans or financial consultants?

The FA Cup is our one hope of real glory. We've nearly won it twice.

Nobody else seems to care.

Is it just me? Am I howling at the moon?


 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 09 Jan 18 12.25pm

Blame SKY and armchair supporters.

As a football club, what would you rather ?

1. A day at Wemberlee
2. 5hlt loads of money in the bank. ?

Ask Coventry what they think.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 09 Jan 18 12.29pm

Very good post Lee.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 09 Jan 18 12.45pm

Originally posted by YT

Simple solution. Cut the crap and give the FA Cup winners an automatic place in the (so called) Champions League.

^^ is the correct answer ^^

Well played, Sir

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Jan 18 12.46pm

Scrap that waste of a competition the League Cup for starters

 

HoltonThunderBoots Flag East Grinstead 09 Jan 18 12.50pm

In all this let's remember Brighton made more changes than we did, but had more fit players too. If we had one we can presume the same discussion would be occurring on the Brighton Fans Forum.
Personally I am happy with keeping the money coming in rather than facing the prospect of a third insolvency
.
Besides it wasn't like we were playing Millwall!

 

GerryQueen10 Flag Swanage 09 Jan 18 12.51pm

No you are not alone. My dream will always be for palace to win the FA cup. Cup games have always been special for me which means I suppose l am a football dinosaur.

 


Been to Anfield twice seen 14 goals and my team haven't scored any

EagleEssex Flag Essex 09 Jan 18 1.11pm

The premier league teams, manager and many fans are p**sing all over the heritage of the FA Cup, the worlds greatest Domestic cup competition, bar none.

Some of my best memories as a Palace fan involve this competition, and yesterdays debacle in terms of very few people seemingly caring whether we won or lost, including the manager, and a half empty stadium devalues the Cup and also our memories of this great competition.

I'd rather they scrapped both cups altogether and let us keep our memories untarnished.

 

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 09 Jan 18 1.22pm

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

I must say I'm disappointed that clubs don't take the FA Cup more seriously.

Am I alone in this?

Yes, resting players gives Palace a better chance of survival in The Premiership.

And we all know how important the money is.

Hang on. Are we fans or financial consultants?

The FA Cup is our one hope of real glory. We've nearly won it twice.

Nobody else seems to care.

Is it just me? Am I howling at the moon?

I am with you on loving the cup! Was really hacked off that we didn't take it seriously and most of all against our bitter rival's.
I think that victory from them will improve their league form and outs will be effected the opposite way.
Travelled with others yesterday and most of them did tend to agree.
Perhaps its the older generation that still believed in it, opposed to the younger fans who feel the premiership is the be all and end all.
If Puncheons goal had won the cup and we had gone down, I would not have cared less.

GT

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Whatever happened to the magic of the cup?