You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Was the referee ...
November 16 2026 7.37am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Was the referee ...


Blue'n'red Flag Field of Chels (Orpington) 31 Jan 18 2.14am

Of the wet spam game a homer?

 


They say hard work never hurt anyone ... but why take a chance?

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 31 Jan 18 2.24am

He was probably guest of honour on the spammers Christmas party...free drinks and a couple of the owner's (one of the two) pretty babes to care for his hangover!

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 31 Jan 18 2.32am

Here we go...

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

viveasheagle Flag perth 31 Jan 18 8.17am

Just watched the replay of the game and in my humble opinion there was not much more the ref could have done to give West Ham 3 points. The penalty was part Tompkins fault in that he left his leg out and gave the chance for someone to go over it. Townsend does virtually the same thing in second 1/2 and gets a yellow card for simulation. Byron should have been yellow carded in first half for a similar offence to the one Milovojevic did to get his booking.This would have meant Byron would have been off when he got his booking in the second 1/2. Noble took out Zaha and got no card and got so many free kicks when there was minimal contact - usually when we were in posession - i thought these type of refereeing displays were a thing of the past.

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jan 18 8.37am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

Just watched the replay of the game and in my humble opinion there was not much more the ref could have done to give West Ham 3 points. The penalty was part Tompkins fault in that he left his leg out and gave the chance for someone to go over it. Townsend does virtually the same thing in second 1/2 and gets a yellow card for simulation. Byron should have been yellow carded in first half for a similar offence to the one Milovojevic did to get his booking.This would have meant Byron would have been off when he got his booking in the second 1/2. Noble took out Zaha and got no card and got so many free kicks when there was minimal contact - usually when we were in posession - i thought these type of refereeing displays were a thing of the past.

You’ve not been following this forum in recent times then?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 31 Jan 18 8.51am

My view from the game was that he was extremely inconsistent and managed the game poorly. I don't think he made any mistakes that would have meant a different result. I think it was a penalty, albeit a soft one. I do think West Ham were lucky to get away without more cautions and Luka was extremely unlucky to get carded after one challenge, which wasn't as bad as Zabaleta's for which he didn't even give a foul.

Poor performance, but ultimately not the worst I've seen and not one that had a bearing on the result IMO.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 31 Jan 18 9.18am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

My view from the game was that he was extremely inconsistent and managed the game poorly. I don't think he made any mistakes that would have meant a different result. I think it was a penalty, albeit a soft one. I do think West Ham were lucky to get away without more cautions and Luka was extremely unlucky to get carded after one challenge, which wasn't as bad as Zabaleta's for which he didn't even give a foul.

Poor performance, but ultimately not the worst I've seen and not one that had a bearing on the result IMO.

If he'd dished out the cards he should've in the first half I doubt WHU would have been so aggressive in the 2nd - maybe the crowd fouling would have stopped or at least one might have seen a red. Inconsistency like that can, and does, directly impact on the game itself.

Edited by Nobbybm (31 Jan 2018 9.18am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Pierre Flag Purley 31 Jan 18 9.32am

Whilst I am not quite agreeing that the refereeing was quite as biased as some are suggesting.
The tackle come grapple by Byron on Wilf should have been a card which would have been more consistent considering Milovojevic had already received one.
The fact that it then took 2 more fouls by Byron to achieve his yellow card I thought was very poor decision making by Neil Swarbrick.
The penalty however was correct.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 31 Jan 18 9.34am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

If he'd dished out the cards he should've in the first half I doubt WHU would have been so aggressive in the 2nd - maybe the crowd fouling would have stopped or at least one might have seen a red. Inconsistency like that can, and does, directly impact on the game itself.

Edited by Nobbybm (31 Jan 2018 9.18am)

I don't disagree with you, but I'm not sure it would have made any difference to the result. Ref was poor but not the reason we didn't win. I'm happy with a point. Hopefully results go our way tonight.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 31 Jan 18 11.40am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

I don't disagree with you, but I'm not sure it would have made any difference to the result. Ref was poor but not the reason we didn't win. I'm happy with a point. Hopefully results go our way tonight.

Is correct. Great opportunity to pick up 3 away points last night, but didn't have the guile to breakdown a packed defence.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 31 Jan 18 12.02pm

The commentator (Tony Gayle?) said on at least 2 separate occasions 'he will be lucky to not get a yellow for that' for fouls that I considered worthy, in today's climate, of a card.
How was the tackle on Sako,although I would have been happy with it during my playing time, not classed as a foul? He was not in control and it was clearly dangerous. Likewise Collins' tackle on Zaha, if wilf had planted his foot instead of jumping over the tackle I think we would have had a leg breaker.

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 18 12.17pm

It sounds to me as though he was way too hasty in carding Luca and so decided to reign his insticts in which in turn went against us.
Referees are way too inconsistent now sadly and that is probably my biggest gripe game on game.

 

Thereandbackagain Flag Crawley 31 Jan 18 12.36pm

Collins was a firm one on Wilf in the first half which put Wilf off a bit as everytime he was near the ball he got a firm challenge , Byron should of had a yellow for the first on Wilf , yet it took the ref three fouls later by him to before he gave him a yellow. Cant argue with the Pen as if it was Wilf he would of looked for the trailing leg and gone down as well , I think the Spam game plan worked which was to rough us up a bit a close us down ads soon as we got on the ball ...on a side note : Noble is a little t*** who always hounds the ref and gives it the waving yellow action yet puts it about himself

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 31 Jan 18 7.31pm

Originally posted by Thereandbackagain

Collins was a firm one on Wilf in the first half which put Wilf off a bit as everytime he was near the ball he got a firm challenge , Byron should of had a yellow for the first on Wilf , yet it took the ref three fouls later by him to before he gave him a yellow. Cant argue with the Pen as if it was Wilf he would of looked for the trailing leg and gone down as well , I think the Spam game plan worked which was to rough us up a bit a close us down ads soon as we got on the ball ...on a side note : Noble is a little t*** who always hounds the ref and gives it the waving yellow action yet puts it about himself


and he wouldnt have got the penalty...ref was certainly cheating, favoured WH all match and was in fact their MOM.......Swarbrick needs investigating urgently....gave Wilf nothing all night, let Byram get away with everything til he eventually got booked after 3 bad fouls, each of which should have been a card, then he kicked the ball away after yet another foul which could have been red... but the ref had a different agenda almost a la Clattenberk

 

chateauferret Flag 02 Feb 18 6.29pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

I don't disagree with you, but I'm not sure it would have made any difference to the result. Ref was poor but not the reason we didn't win. I'm happy with a point. Hopefully results go our way tonight.

Really? I teckon both Byrom and Zabaleta should have been sent off.

Edited by chateauferret (02 Feb 2018 6.29pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 02 Feb 18 6.44pm

Originally posted by the silurian


and he wouldnt have got the penalty...ref was certainly cheating, favoured WH all match and was in fact their MOM.......Swarbrick needs investigating urgently....gave Wilf nothing all night, let Byram get away with everything til he eventually got booked after 3 bad fouls, each of which should have been a card, then he kicked the ball away after yet another foul which could have been red... but the ref had a different agenda almost a la Clattenberk

Agreed. Gave us nothing all game. I was seething, not helped a bit by that t*** Tony Gayle's hopelessly biaised commentary.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 Feb 18 7.18pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Agreed. Gave us nothing all game. I was seething, not helped a bit by that t*** Tony Gayle's hopelessly biaised commentary.

Always wondered why they have him commentating on West Ham games as he's an ex hammer (and doesnt it show) one of the most biased commentators out there! Also a master of stating the bleeding obvious!!!

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 Feb 18 8.21pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Agreed. Gave us nothing all game. I was seething, not helped a bit by that t*** Tony Gayle's hopelessly biaised commentary.

Always wondered why they have him commentating on West Ham games as he's an ex hammer (and doesnt it show) one of the most biased commentators out there! Also a master of stating the bleeding obvious!!!

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 Feb 18 8.43pm

He was f***ing awful and was biased as anything towards them.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Was the referee ...