You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game vs New
November 16 2026 7.38am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game vs New


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
osborny99 Flag 04 Feb 18 8.41pm

For old times sakes- an insight for those fans who weren’t able to attend/ watch today’s match.

Hennessey 8- Personally don’t understand the criticism he receives. Every keeper has a bad game now and again (ie Cech vs Swansea). Played well today, with a top double save and a commanding performance from crosses. Handled shots well and distributed well when called upon.

TFM 6 - Always looks a threat going forwards, but seems to get into good positions and then run out of ideas.
Will be a great defender in 3,4 years time, but a couple of times caught out positionally from crosses today. His pace got him out of trouble a couple of times.

Tomkins 7- Improves every game, cleared his lines when necessary and played from the back when appropriate. A few air kicks early on, but nullified the threat of Gayle and Perez.

Kelly 6- Welcome to the 100 club. Won everything in the air, but , alongside Luka, lost Diame from the corner which lead to the goal. Unfortunate to go off, as he probably realised that Sakho and Tomkins will now be starters until an inevitable injury.

PVA 8.5 MOM (along with the pitch invader)- seems revolutionised. Energy going forwards and , unlike the West Ham game, also defended well against Kenedy and Ritchie. Played Benteke in early and overlapped where he could. Best game of the season for him and , on this form, would keep schlupp out the side.

Luka 7- Squeezed in his penalty, won his aerial duels and broke up play effectively- seems to have achieved Jedinak cult hero status.
Switched off for the Newcastle goal, but was the defensive shield in the second half which allowed zaha and co to push on. Diame, physically, is probably one of the sternest tests he’ll face in the CM this year.

McArthur 7.5- Again after a slow start grew into the game and interlinked defence and attack. After starting on the left wing, he looked more at ease in the second half and almost scored from a great team move in the 75th. Didn’t give Hayden or Shelvey any spare time to play in the second half and was subsequently the catalyst for numerous attacks.


Cabaye 6.5 - Started brightly and retained the ball. Almost finished off a great team move in the first half and supplied Benteke with ball to feet. Fatigued as the game wore on, but couldn’t be criticised against his former club.

Townsend 6.5- Provides much better defensive cover then Sako, puts the ball in the box effectively but sometimes today just not direct enough when in possession. When he was at Newcastle, was never scared to have a shot- today he beat his man a few times and then would play backwards.

Zaha 6.5- similar to Townsend, although must be said ATs delivery and decision making was better today. Quiet first half when through the middle, but got the better of Yedlin a few times in the second half. Put in a great ball for Benteke which led to the almighty scramble at the end. Stands out, but for his own exceptional standards a slightly quieter game.

Benteke 6- Difficult one. His general hold up play was good and he won his fair share of headers against Lascelles and Clark. However, he’s on the pitch to score goals.
Missed an early one on one after being put through by PVA, missed a sitter at the end of the first half when pretty much in the goal and generally looked nervy when he had the ball at his feet.

Sakho 7- instantly reminded everyone what we’d been missing (although Kelly has excelled). Despite palace dominating the second half in general, he is calming presence who builds from the back and equals our strongest CB pairing with Tomkins.

Hodgson 7- Couldn’t do much more with his resources, continues to get the best out of a strong first XI with limited depth. The sooner Sørloth is match fit the better in order to provide a plan B.

Marriner 5- Every 50:50 went Newcastle’s way in the first half. Only scoring as high as a 5 for his team of officials spotting the penalty decision which,at the time, confused the whole stadium. Missed another penalty appeal and constantly penalised Benteke for what looked like just standing his ground.

Ultimately, 2 points dropped although Atsu’s 93rd minute effort could have crept in to make it 3 dropped points. Another point closer to 40- but games like these and West Ham need to be identified as must wins when you look at our March fixtures- especially considering ,again, how much we dominated the general balance of play.

Edited by osborny99 (04 Feb 2018 8.49pm)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 04 Feb 18 8.46pm

Thanks, nice insight. Let's hope we can convert a bit better against the Toffees. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 04 Feb 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by osborny99

For old times sakes- an insight for those fans who weren’t able to attend/ watch today’s match.

Hennessey 8- Personally don’t understand the criticism he receives. Every keeper has a bad game now and again (ie Cech vs Swansea). Played well today, with a top double save and a commanding performance from crosses. Handled shots well and distributed well when called upon.

TFM 6 - Always looks a threat going forwards, but seems to get into good positions and then run out of ideas.
Will be a great defender in 3,4 years time, but a couple of times caught out positionally from crosses today. His pace got him out of trouble a couple of times.

Tomkins 7- Improves every game, cleared his lines when necessary and played from the back when appropriate. A few air kicks early on, but nullified the threat of Gayle and Perez.

Kelly 6- Welcome to the 100 club. Won everything in the air, but , alongside Luka, lost Diame from the corner which lead to the goal. Unfortunate to go off, as he probably realised that Sakho and Tomkins will now be starters until an inevitable injury.

PVA 8.5 MOM (along with the pitch invader)- seems revolutionised. Energy going forwards and , unlike the West Ham game, also defended well against Kenedy and Ritchie. Played Benteke in early and overlapped where he could. Best game of the season for him and , on this form, would keep schlupp out the side.

Luka 7- Squeezed in his penalty, won his aerial duels and broke up play effectively- seems to have achieved Jedinak cult hero status.
Switched off for the Newcastle goal, but was the defensive shield in the second half which allowed zaha and co to push on. Diame, physically, is probably one of the sternest tests he’ll face in the CM this year.

McArthur 7.5- Again after a slow start grew into the game and interlinked defence and attack. After starting on the left wing, he looked more at ease in the second half and almost scored from a great team move in the 75th. Didn’t give Hayden or Shelvey any spare time to play in the second half and was subsequently the catalyst for numerous attacks.


Cabaye 6.5 - Started brightly and retained the ball. Almost finished off a great team move in the first half and supplied Benteke with ball to feet. Fatigued as the game wore on, but couldn’t be criticised against his former club.

Townsend 6.5- Provides much better defensive cover then Sako, puts the ball in the box effectively but sometimes today just not direct enough when in possession. When he was at Newcastle, was never scared to have a shot- today he beat his man a few times and then would play backwards.

Zaha 6.5- similar to Townsend, although must be said ATs delivery and decision making was better today. Quiet first half when through the middle, but got the better of Yedlin a few times in the second half. Put in a great ball for Benteke which led to the almighty scramble at the end. Stands out, but for his own exceptional standards a slightly quieter game.

Benteke 6- Difficult one. His general hold up play was good and he won his fair share of headers against Lascelles and Clark. However, he’s on the pitch to score goals.
Missed an early one on one after being put through by PVA, missed a sitter at the end of the first half when pretty much in the goal and generally looked nervy when he had the ball at his feet.

Sakho 7- instantly reminded everyone what we’d been missing (although Kelly has excelled). Despite palace dominating the second half in general, he is calming presence who builds from the back and equals our strongest CB pairing with Tomkins.

Hodgson 7- Couldn’t do much more with his resources, continues to get the best out of a strong first XI with limited depth. The sooner Sørloth is match fit the better in order to provide a plan B.

Marriner 5- Every 50:50 went Newcastle’s way in the first half. Only scoring as high as a 5 for his team of officials spotting the penalty decision which,at the time, confused the whole stadium. Missed another penalty appeal and constantly penalised Benteke for what looked like just standing his ground.

Edited by osborny99 (04 Feb 2018 8.44pm)

Edited by osborny99 (04 Feb 2018 8.45pm)

Sakho and Tomkins play to the end of the season and we stay up. that simple. it's not just the defensive side of it. they give us so much scope to build attacks and keep pressure up.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 04 Feb 18 8.56pm

Originally posted by osborny99

For old times sakes- an insight for those fans who weren’t able to attend/ watch today’s match.

Hennessey 8- Personally don’t understand the criticism he receives. Every keeper has a bad game now and again (ie Cech vs Swansea). Played well today, with a top double save and a commanding performance from crosses. Handled shots well and distributed well when called upon.

TFM 6 - Always looks a threat going forwards, but seems to get into good positions and then run out of ideas.
Will be a great defender in 3,4 years time, but a couple of times caught out positionally from crosses today. His pace got him out of trouble a couple of times.

Tomkins 7- Improves every game, cleared his lines when necessary and played from the back when appropriate. A few air kicks early on, but nullified the threat of Gayle and Perez.

Kelly 6- Welcome to the 100 club. Won everything in the air, but , alongside Luka, lost Diame from the corner which lead to the goal. Unfortunate to go off, as he probably realised that Sakho and Tomkins will now be starters until an inevitable injury.

PVA 8.5 MOM (along with the pitch invader)- seems revolutionised. Energy going forwards and , unlike the West Ham game, also defended well against Kenedy and Ritchie. Played Benteke in early and overlapped where he could. Best game of the season for him and , on this form, would keep schlupp out the side.

Luka 7- Squeezed in his penalty, won his aerial duels and broke up play effectively- seems to have achieved Jedinak cult hero status.
Switched off for the Newcastle goal, but was the defensive shield in the second half which allowed zaha and co to push on. Diame, physically, is probably one of the sternest tests he’ll face in the CM this year.

McArthur 7.5- Again after a slow start grew into the game and interlinked defence and attack. After starting on the left wing, he looked more at ease in the second half and almost scored from a great team move in the 75th. Didn’t give Hayden or Shelvey any spare time to play in the second half and was subsequently the catalyst for numerous attacks.


Cabaye 6.5 - Started brightly and retained the ball. Almost finished off a great team move in the first half and supplied Benteke with ball to feet. Fatigued as the game wore on, but couldn’t be criticised against his former club.

Townsend 6.5- Provides much better defensive cover then Sako, puts the ball in the box effectively but sometimes today just not direct enough when in possession. When he was at Newcastle, was never scared to have a shot- today he beat his man a few times and then would play backwards.

Zaha 6.5- similar to Townsend, although must be said ATs delivery and decision making was better today. Quiet first half when through the middle, but got the better of Yedlin a few times in the second half. Put in a great ball for Benteke which led to the almighty scramble at the end. Stands out, but for his own exceptional standards a slightly quieter game.

Benteke 6- Difficult one. His general hold up play was good and he won his fair share of headers against Lascelles and Clark. However, he’s on the pitch to score goals.
Missed an early one on one after being put through by PVA, missed a sitter at the end of the first half when pretty much in the goal and generally looked nervy when he had the ball at his feet.

Sakho 7- instantly reminded everyone what we’d been missing (although Kelly has excelled). Despite palace dominating the second half in general, he is calming presence who builds from the back and equals our strongest CB pairing with Tomkins.

Hodgson 7- Couldn’t do much more with his resources, continues to get the best out of a strong first XI with limited depth. The sooner Sørloth is match fit the better in order to provide a plan B.

Marriner 5- Every 50:50 went Newcastle’s way in the first half. Only scoring as high as a 5 for his team of officials spotting the penalty decision which,at the time, confused the whole stadium. Missed another penalty appeal and constantly penalised Benteke for what looked like just standing his ground.

Ultimately, 2 points dropped although Atsu’s 93rd minute effort could have crept in to make it 3 dropped points. Another point closer to 40- but games like these and West Ham need to be identified as must wins when you look at our March fixtures- especially considering ,again, how much we dominated the general balance of play.

Edited by osborny99 (04 Feb 2018 8.49pm)

Nicely done. Thanks.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

merganser Flag 04 Feb 18 9.49pm

Good summary. Mostly agree but think you're a bit harsh on Wilf who I thought was fantastic

 

cpj Flag Kent 04 Feb 18 10.23pm

Originally posted by merganser

Good summary. Mostly agree but think you're a bit harsh on Wilf who I thought was fantastic

Thought he was poor again.

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 04 Feb 18 10.56pm

Thought we were poor. Exceptionally fortunate a) to win the penalty, and b) to convert it. Never really looked like scoring, despite a fair spell of pressure in the first 30 mins of the 2nd half. 1st half very poor, and by a distance the worse team.

Fact is not one of our front three has any real competition for starting place, and Sorloth aside (who we cant expect much from at first) we have zero cover / options anywhere in attack.

That is negligent and typically reckless of Parish IMHO.

Two points dropped.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Feb 18 11.58pm

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

Thought we were poor. Exceptionally fortunate a) to win the penalty, and b) to convert it. Never really looked like scoring, despite a fair spell of pressure in the first 30 mins of the 2nd half. 1st half very poor, and by a distance the worse team.

Fact is not one of our front three has any real competition for starting place, and Sorloth aside (who we cant expect much from at first) we have zero cover / options anywhere in attack.

That is negligent and typically reckless of Parish IMHO.

Two points dropped.

You should think about changing your username you miserable b@stard

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 05 Feb 18 1.17am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

You should think about changing your username you miserable b@stard

Very good Tom.
Or Unhappy Stan.!!
One point gained.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

sprites Flag Auckland 05 Feb 18 2.52am

Originally posted by merganser

Good summary. Mostly agree but think you're a bit harsh on Wilf who I thought was fantastic

He was pretty poor. Especially consider what we know he can do.
Seems to have developed an attitude over the last couple of weeks...almost seems like he's taken a step back in time a year or two.

Unfortunately for him, teams are doubling/tripling up on him...and even Wilf can't take on 3 every time.

 

tpuffpendants Flag 05 Feb 18 4.45am

Agree with all, except I think Cabaye was poor today

 

The Dolphin Flag 05 Feb 18 6.59am

Watched the highlights having been at the game.
Roy set us up worng in the first half - changed at half time and obviously much better.
We just do not take our chances and therein lies our problem.
Benteke has to be dropped despite his overall performance.
No goals in 11 league games at home this season including THAT penalty miss.
Also - when shooting from distance could someone please tell our players that always aiming for the glory goal in the top corner that hitting the target generally makes more sense.
We are not beating teams around us again and whilst I think we will scrape it this time the thought of needing points against West Brom at our place on the last day sits very uncomfortable with me!

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 05 Feb 18 7.38am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

You should think about changing your username you miserable b@stard

Love it

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 05 Feb 18 8.03am

Originally posted by osborny99

For old times sakes- an insight for those fans who weren’t able to attend/ watch today’s match.

Hennessey 8- Personally don’t understand the criticism he receives. Every keeper has a bad game now and again (ie Cech vs Swansea). Played well today, with a top double save and a commanding performance from crosses. Handled shots well and distributed well when called upon.

TFM 6 - Always looks a threat going forwards, but seems to get into good positions and then run out of ideas.
Will be a great defender in 3,4 years time, but a couple of times caught out positionally from crosses today. His pace got him out of trouble a couple of times.

Tomkins 7- Improves every game, cleared his lines when necessary and played from the back when appropriate. A few air kicks early on, but nullified the threat of Gayle and Perez.

Kelly 6- Welcome to the 100 club. Won everything in the air, but , alongside Luka, lost Diame from the corner which lead to the goal. Unfortunate to go off, as he probably realised that Sakho and Tomkins will now be starters until an inevitable injury.

PVA 8.5 MOM (along with the pitch invader)- seems revolutionised. Energy going forwards and , unlike the West Ham game, also defended well against Kenedy and Ritchie. Played Benteke in early and overlapped where he could. Best game of the season for him and , on this form, would keep schlupp out the side.

Luka 7- Squeezed in his penalty, won his aerial duels and broke up play effectively- seems to have achieved Jedinak cult hero status.
Switched off for the Newcastle goal, but was the defensive shield in the second half which allowed zaha and co to push on. Diame, physically, is probably one of the sternest tests he’ll face in the CM this year.

McArthur 7.5- Again after a slow start grew into the game and interlinked defence and attack. After starting on the left wing, he looked more at ease in the second half and almost scored from a great team move in the 75th. Didn’t give Hayden or Shelvey any spare time to play in the second half and was subsequently the catalyst for numerous attacks.


Cabaye 6.5 - Started brightly and retained the ball. Almost finished off a great team move in the first half and supplied Benteke with ball to feet. Fatigued as the game wore on, but couldn’t be criticised against his former club.

Townsend 6.5- Provides much better defensive cover then Sako, puts the ball in the box effectively but sometimes today just not direct enough when in possession. When he was at Newcastle, was never scared to have a shot- today he beat his man a few times and then would play backwards.

Zaha 6.5- similar to Townsend, although must be said ATs delivery and decision making was better today. Quiet first half when through the middle, but got the better of Yedlin a few times in the second half. Put in a great ball for Benteke which led to the almighty scramble at the end. Stands out, but for his own exceptional standards a slightly quieter game.

Benteke 6- Difficult one. His general hold up play was good and he won his fair share of headers against Lascelles and Clark. However, he’s on the pitch to score goals.
Missed an early one on one after being put through by PVA, missed a sitter at the end of the first half when pretty much in the goal and generally looked nervy when he had the ball at his feet.

Sakho 7- instantly reminded everyone what we’d been missing (although Kelly has excelled). Despite palace dominating the second half in general, he is calming presence who builds from the back and equals our strongest CB pairing with Tomkins.

Hodgson 7- Couldn’t do much more with his resources, continues to get the best out of a strong first XI with limited depth. The sooner Sørloth is match fit the better in order to provide a plan B.

Marriner 5- Every 50:50 went Newcastle’s way in the first half. Only scoring as high as a 5 for his team of officials spotting the penalty decision which,at the time, confused the whole stadium. Missed another penalty appeal and constantly penalised Benteke for what looked like just standing his ground.

Ultimately, 2 points dropped although Atsu’s 93rd minute effort could have crept in to make it 3 dropped points. Another point closer to 40- but games like these and West Ham need to be identified as must wins when you look at our March fixtures- especially considering ,again, how much we dominated the general balance of play.

Edited by osborny99 (04 Feb 2018 8.49pm)

Great summary, agree on most. PVA and Wayne our stand out performers, but with two injury-prone central defenders left I hope we get thru till May. And whatever money we get for Benteke, please sell in summer. Imagine Andy J. in the box yesterday - would have been an other 5-1 victory. PS! Roy, please find an other corner taker than Cabaye!

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 05 Feb 18 8.52am

I thought PVA was head and shoulders the best player opening 25 minutes, in fact I thought our biggest threat came from him and also the excellent Fosu-Mensah. Refreshing to see us dribble out from the back and mix things up, enhanced even more when Sakho came on. Just needed Loftus-Cheek in that team/a confident Benteke and we may have steamrollered Newcastle yesterday. McArthur was woeful first half but knitted things together nicely as the second half progressed, how the beeb gave him MOTM i'll never know. Wilf seems slower than usual, less tricks etc at the moment, although still massively influential in everything we do. Has he been told by Roy to keep it simple? I enjoyed the game a lot for an affair that was disjointed and scrappy at times, there was somehow still a nice flow to proceedings. Disappointed not to get a win but still bucket loads of points to play for. Keeps it fun!

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

unload_em_palace Flag 05 Feb 18 9.26am

Wilf took a knock very early on, and seemed to take a while to shake it off - physically and psychologically.
2nd half he was much better, having also changed position.
Agree that Sakho coming on completely changed our approach. Having someone who can pass the ball accurately out of defence changes things and allows better build up in my opinion.
Just need the team to bring their shooting boots with them next game. Newcastle were there for the taking, and someone like them is going to take a battering from us soon.

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 05 Feb 18 10.37am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

You should think about changing your username you miserable b@stard

heh... just calling it as i see it. We got a ridiculous penalty today, if that had gone the other way people would be calling blue murder on here. Other than that didnt really trouble their keeper. Our front three was poor, we let in a very very soft goal and looked dodgy at the back.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 05 Feb 18 10.43am

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

heh... just calling it as i see it. We got a ridiculous penalty today, if that had gone the other way people would be calling blue murder on here. Other than that didnt really trouble their keeper. Our front three was poor, we let in a very very soft goal and looked dodgy at the back.

Agree Stan.But there were positives to.

All part of the Palace roller coaster my friend

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Aray Flag South London 05 Feb 18 11.05am


Not watched the highlights yet.

Hennessy player very well - top performance. 8

PVA was simply excellent- he deserved to be on the winning team. 8.5

TFM kept going to ground when he needs to stay on his feet. They had a breakaway and he was completely ineffective dealing with it. Wilf bailed him/us out. He was ok going forward though. 6.5

Tomkins and Kelly were ok but that goal was a defensive shocker. Both 7 for me.

Luka was ok 7?

Cabaye needs to shoot on target and get his corners past the first man. Also was anonymous in the first half. But they both played their part in the comeback. 6.5

Jimmy 7.5 if only for his willingness to make the runs.

Townsend went MIA in the first half. Played better in the second but lacked quality. 6.5

Could say the same about Wilf but he turned up in the end. 7

Benteke couldn’t score in a brothel. 6.5

Sakho seemed ready when he came on. 7

Roy had us set up wrong. It’s easier to mark Wilf out the match if he’s central. On the wing he gets to expose play. 6.

Crowd 6.5

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 18 11.13am

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

heh... just calling it as i see it. We got a ridiculous penalty today, if that had gone the other way people would be calling blue murder on here. Other than that didnt really trouble their keeper. Our front three was poor, we let in a very very soft goal and looked dodgy at the back.

Well it was a significant shirt pull which prevented Benteke heading the ball so a penalty for me.The Assistant had a good view of the incident.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game vs New