You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A theory behind our injury crisis
November 16 2026 7.38am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A theory behind our injury crisis


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
raggy Flag 05 Feb 18 10.54pm

Now, i love Roy as much as we all do, but i am starting to get the impression that his reluctance to make substitutions is a large factor behind our injury crisis.

While Wilf is an exempt case where we have to leave him on due to the fact that he offers so much late in games, the injury to Kelly for example seems to be due to fatigue.

While Roy is right in stating that many of our injuries are trauma related (Puncheon, Dann etc.), it would help if he gave players a rest now and again, even if it means bringing on an inexperienced U23's player. Loaning out Kaikai to Charlton already appears to be an error because although he is unproven, he is a consistent figure in the U23's and has played at Championship level.

My fear is that integral players such as Townsend or Cabaye may burn out late into the season, leaving as incredibly weak as a squad. While he is crucial to the team, Luka has also been playing non-stop since Roy came in and i do wonder whether he may run out of steam too.

Lets hope my fears don't bear fruit.

 

YT Flag Oxford 05 Feb 18 10.59pm

It's interesting how the running out of steam metaphor prevails almost 50 years on from the last steam passenger train to run in Britain.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

TheArmaniCode Flag 05 Feb 18 11.21pm

This has been a problem long before Roy came in. Including under Pardew, who often made at least one sub at the start of the second half.

Nope, I STILL stand by my claim that it's the medical staff that are the problem. And unless someone can point me to another factor, that's an opinion that I'll be keeping for a while

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 05 Feb 18 11.28pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

This has been a problem long before Roy came in. Including under Pardew, who often made at least one sub at the start of the second half.

Nope, I STILL stand by my claim that it's the medical staff that are the problem. And unless someone can point me to another factor, that's an opinion that I'll be keeping for a while

So let me get this straight Zabaleta tackles Sako really hard and Sako breaks his ankle.
And you say it’s the medical staffs fault and not Steve Parish. ?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 18 11.33pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

This has been a problem long before Roy came in. Including under Pardew, who often made at least one sub at the start of the second half.

Nope, I STILL stand by my claim that it's the medical staff that are the problem. And unless someone can point me to another factor, that's an opinion that I'll be keeping for a while

This incidence of injury and occurring at about the same time in successive seasons cannot be a matter of chance. It's so far above average that (without doi g the math) it must amount to several standard deviations.

Doesn't mean it's the doctors but there has to be some sort of cause in the system somewhere. Perhaps doctors' advice not receiving sufficient weight?

Should have been investigated the first time but now just seems to be tolerated by the Board as a fact of life.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 18 11.37pm

Originally posted by raggy

Now, i love Roy as much as we all do, but i am starting to get the impression that his reluctance to make substitutions is a large factor behind our injury crisis.

While Wilf is an exempt case where we have to leave him on due to the fact that he offers so much late in games, the injury to Kelly for example seems to be due to fatigue.

While Roy is right in stating that many of our injuries are trauma related (Puncheon, Dann etc.), it would help if he gave players a rest now and again, even if it means bringing on an inexperienced U23's player. Loaning out Kaikai to Charlton already appears to be an error because although he is unproven, he is a consistent figure in the U23's and has played at Championship level.

My fear is that integral players such as Townsend or Cabaye may burn out late into the season, leaving as incredibly weak as a squad. While he is crucial to the team, Luka has also been playing non-stop since Roy came in and i do wonder whether he may run out of steam too.

Lets hope my fears don't bear fruit.

Perhaps his options on the bench have a lot to do with it !

And in the 'Transfer Window' we buy players who have not played since November and December ! And a centre-half who is probably 5th choice ! Contrast this with some of the purchases made by our relegation rivals, one of whom, Deulofeu scored tonight and was man of the match.

Edited by Willo (05 Feb 2018 11.39pm)

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 05 Feb 18 11.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

Perhaps his options on the bench have a lot to do with it !

And in the 'Transfer Window' we buy players who have not played since November and December ! And a centre-half who is probably 5th choice ! Contrast this with some of the purchases made by our relegation rivals, one of whom, Deulofeu scored tonight and was man of the match.

Edited by Willo (05 Feb 2018 11.39pm)

Your example did very well tonight,against a Top 6 side,who fortunately for Watford tonight and the Cherries last week were more like a bottom 3 side.
I think Antonio will be sacked soon.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Feb 18 12.02am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Your example did very well tonight,against a Top 6 side,who fortunately for Watford tonight and the Cherries last week were more like a bottom 3 side.
I think Antonio will be sacked soon.

I cannot recall seeing Chelsea play as poorly as they did tonight.They were shambolic.
And I wouldn't be surprised to see Conte relieved of his duties in the near future.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Feb 18 12.22am

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

This has been a problem long before Roy came in. Including under Pardew, who often made at least one sub at the start of the second half.

Nope, I STILL stand by my claim that it's the medical staff that are the problem. And unless someone can point me to another factor, that's an opinion that I'll be keeping for a while

So even when Roy himself tells us these injuries are all impact ones so can’t be prevented by training etc you still think it’s to do with the medical staff? The only one that could be considered as muscular and, therefore, possibly due to fatigue is Kelly’s - problem is, as has been pointed out, that was actually caused whilst he was being fouled.

From what I’ve seen, we pick up injuries when the team is playing flat out, fighting for survival. When the players are giving everything then they are more at risk of impact injuries.

It probably doesn’t help when officials seemingly think it’s ok to bully, kick & batter Palace players without adequate retribution. I don’t think it’s just us but if Pep thinks his prima-donnas get little protection then he should take a long look some of the blatant fouling we’ve seen this season.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 06 Feb 18 6.21am

I've got a theory how about just bad luck.

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 18 7.08am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

It probably doesn’t help when officials seemingly think it’s ok to bully, kick & batter Palace players without adequate retribution. I don’t think it’s just us but if Pep thinks his prima-donnas get little protection then he should take a long look some of the blatant fouling we’ve seen this season.

Like Puncheon's foul on de Bruyn you mean

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 06 Feb 18 7.31am

Originally posted by raggy

Now, i love Roy as much as we all do, but i am starting to get the impression that his reluctance to make substitutions is a large factor behind our injury crisis.

While Wilf is an exempt case where we have to leave him on due to the fact that he offers so much late in games, the injury to Kelly for example seems to be due to fatigue.

While Roy is right in stating that many of our injuries are trauma related (Puncheon, Dann etc.), it would help if he gave players a rest now and again, even if it means bringing on an inexperienced U23's player. Loaning out Kaikai to Charlton already appears to be an error because although he is unproven, he is a consistent figure in the U23's and has played at Championship level.

My fear is that integral players such as Townsend or Cabaye may burn out late into the season, leaving as incredibly weak as a squad. While he is crucial to the team, Luka has also been playing non-stop since Roy came in and i do wonder whether he may run out of steam too.

Lets hope my fears don't bear fruit.


Sorry but i'm not having that.

Professional,highly trained,in their prime,play for 90 mins of football a week,3/4 hours training a day and your saying that they should be rested now and again.

Your be asking for them to be paid a thousand pounds a week next for all their hard work and maybe a little bonus as well at the end of the season...Ooops

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 06 Feb 18 7.44am

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

This has been a problem long before Roy came in. Including under Pardew, who often made at least one sub at the start of the second half.

Nope, I STILL stand by my claim that it's the medical staff that are the problem. And unless someone can point me to another factor, that's an opinion that I'll be keeping for a while

Its just as likely down to poor refereeing allow bad tackles on our players whilst at the same time pulling ours up for innocuous misdemeanors

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

The Dolphin Flag 06 Feb 18 8.24am

It is down to bad luck - surely
Sako - broken ankle
Puncheon - lunging at De Bruyne
Dann - knee to knee tackle
Wickham - way before Roy
Wilf - looked like a tackle on Sunday did it albeit he should have come off immediately
5 out of our 9 injuries where I do not see how you blame the Club?
As for the others - I cannot answer

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 Feb 18 8.44am

Originally posted by YT

It's interesting how the running out of steam metaphor prevails almost 50 years on from the last steam passenger train to run in Britain.

Very much so.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Feb 18 9.18am

The vast majority of long term injuries, not just here are knees.
Football needs to take a close look at this.
Players are so highly tuned these days that knees are clearly a weak point in tackles etc.
Our pile of injuries is due to the fact our players are giving just that little bit more than the average hence overstretching etc.
The outcome is inevitable, a very long injury list.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 18 9.25am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

So even when Roy himself tells us these injuries are all impact ones so can’t be prevented by training etc you still think it’s to do with the medical staff? The only one that could be considered as muscular and, therefore, possibly due to fatigue is Kelly’s - problem is, as has been pointed out, that was actually caused whilst he was being fouled.

From what I’ve seen, we pick up injuries when the team is playing flat out, fighting for survival. When the players are giving everything then they are more at risk of impact injuries.

It probably doesn’t help when officials seemingly think it’s ok to bully, kick & batter Palace players without adequate retribution. I don’t think it’s just us but if Pep thinks his prima-donnas get little protection then he should take a long look some of the blatant fouling we’ve seen this season.

This is probably the most accurate explanation that cannot be doubted. Playing a cup final every week is what Zaha said. How often do we go on unbeaten runs like we have, only losing to Arsenal twice isn't it, and with a threadbare team and squad? The team and squad is low in quality numbers before the injuries, then we can't make subs because most weeks there's either one quality sub or no attacking players with any premier league quality or experience.

 


COYP

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Feb 18 9.55am

for me the the problem is they train them as sprint athletes that puts more strain on the the muscles and joints. all clubs train the same the bigger clubs have a larger squard of first team players, so it doesnt notice to much, than can have 8 injurys and still have 17 first team players to pick from,
smaller teams like us are trying to repalce with championship standed players, and that is the bottom line, until we are lucky to get multi billionaires backers that is what we have to live with.
Its nothing to do with the pyshios or doctors its the way football has evoled

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Feb 18 12.52pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

The vast majority of long term injuries, not just here are knees.
Football needs to take a close look at this.
Players are so highly tuned these days that knees are clearly a weak point in tackles etc.
Our pile of injuries is due to the fact our players are giving just that little bit more than the average hence overstretching etc.
The outcome is inevitable, a very long injury list.

There is a bit of science to back this up. Modern footballers are trained to build lean muscle like track athletes & cyclists, both of which have knees as a weak spot. A mate who cycles competitively had an ACL go when all he did was turn suddenly when someone shouted his name as he walked across a car park. His consultant explained that lean muscle in the legs tends to shorten both the quads & calves putting strain on a joint that already had minimum protection. Any sudden twist or impact can be catastrophic.

Perhaps this might go some way to explain these knee problems.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

boo909 Flag Figeac 06 Feb 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by YT

It's interesting how the running out of steam metaphor prevails almost 50 years on from the last steam passenger train to run in Britain.


Most metaphora/idioms stem from outdated things though don't they? Riding shotgun (stagecoaches) and know the ropes (sailing) are two obvious ones.

As fit as a Palace first 11 could well become an unfortunate new one though at this rate.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A theory behind our injury crisis