This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
If we average out the cost of a new player to be just £5m then it will cost £65m to replace all 13 players with bang average replacements/players for the future. We have a goalkeeper on a pre-contract who is a free and we can take Rakip for £10m. That's an average of £5m. We won't have to pay a transfer fee for the keeper but no doubt we'll have to pay the equivalent to him and his agent instead
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
We won't have to pay a transfer fee for the keeper but no doubt we'll have to pay the equivalent to him and his agent instead That's the thing about free transfers, they are never really free. I just struggle to see, given how our finances have been painted, how we'll replace 13 players in the summer unless we rely on the youth plan we tried last summer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
I've written an article explaining this a lot better than I will be able to here but I'll summarise. In the summer we'll have 13 or more (as things stand) players out of contract, including the 3 loan players. Granted, many of the players we'll be happy to see the back of but a man out, even Mutch, has to be replaced. If we average out the cost of a new player to be just £5m then it will cost £65m to replace all 13 players with bang average replacements/players for the future. We have a goalkeeper on a pre-contract who is a free and we can take Rakip for £10m. That's an average of £5m. Given that we are notorious for being hard up we're either going to have to be lucky with free transfers or Freedman is going to have to pull something special out of the bag because we don't have the players in the academy who can step up. Staying up (which I think we'll manage) will only be part of the struggle because of poor planning. I haven't heard about any such deal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I haven't heard about any such deal. You seem to be the only one who hasn't.
|
|
|
Originally posted by johnno42000
I look at it slightly differently. We spent, relatively, little in the January window so should have some from that budget. The players that I'd expect us to try and keep would be Hennessey (if he keeps up his form), Kelly (good squad player), Ward, McArthur, Cabaye and Sako. That leaves the 2 loanees, who can be replaced as we normally do, Speroni, Delaney, Mutch and Chung-Yong to replace. 4 players isn't bad and does leave the manager a chance to really shape the squad with some of his own choices. According to Parish he and the Americans were lending the club money to use in the January window so I presume that isn't in the club to be used in the summer. I too would expect us to at least try and retain some of the players but the fact we haven't done it already baffles me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
You seem to be the only one who hasn't. There you are - I keep telling everyone I'm not an omniscient sage with phone alerts from the Hierarchy !
Edited by Willo (08 Feb 2018 6.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by xomnea
Presumably the reason these 10 players are being released (ignoring loans) is that they’re not having much of an impact on the squad/first team so the premise we have to replace them all doesn’t make sense to me. My thoughts exactly, the youngsters can start filling up the squad positions, surely there must be a few ready for that level.
|
|
|
Originally posted by xomnea
Presumably the reason these 10 players are being released (ignoring loans) is that they’re not having much of an impact on the squad/first team so the premise we have to replace them all doesn’t make sense to me. And that is the hard bit...we ain't the only ones looking.
|
|
|
Cabaye won't stay, he'll be off to France.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
I've written an article explaining this a lot better than I will be able to here but I'll summarise. In the summer we'll have 13 or more (as things stand) players out of contract, including the 3 loan players. Granted, many of the players we'll be happy to see the back of but a man out, even Mutch, has to be replaced. If we average out the cost of a new player to be just £5m then it will cost £65m to replace all 13 players with bang average replacements/players for the future. We have a goalkeeper on a pre-contract who is a free and we can take Rakip for £10m. That's an average of £5m. Given that we are notorious for being hard up we're either going to have to be lucky with free transfers or Freedman is going to have to pull something special out of the bag because we don't have the players in the academy who can step up. Staying up (which I think we'll manage) will only be part of the struggle because of poor planning. Not sure about your reasoning. Just because players are out of contract, doesn’t mean they will be released. Therefore the rest of your argument doesn’t stack up.
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
Not sure about your reasoning. Just because players are out of contract, doesn’t mean they will be released. Therefore the rest of your argument doesn’t stack up.
We needed another 6+ players in the summer just gone and didn't get them so don't have much hope in going out and buying a load this summer. Again we will get multi loans I expect 2 from Prem maybe some others from abroad. SP doesn't really like to spend on multi players he would rather waste time and get one big signing which is why we are in trouble. This clubs needs a rebuild and our current owners are the wrong guys to do that (getting in the Americans was wrong move and clearly a panic decision from SP)
|
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
Not sure about your reasoning. Just because players are out of contract, doesn’t mean they will be released. Therefore the rest of your argument doesn’t stack up. I agree with your sentiment however they can already discuss deals with other clubs as they are under 6 months left of their contract. The 3 loans end, Mutch, Lee, Delaney, Sako, Speroni could easily not be renewed. Cabaye won't stay. That's 9. We have no choice if they leave or stay if they have no contract. Therefore we either buy, sign a free or play youth which we don't have in numbers. Stacking up yet?
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
We needed another 6+ players in the summer just gone and didn't get them so don't have much hope in going out and buying a load this summer. Again we will get multi loans I expect 2 from Prem maybe some others from abroad. SP doesn't really like to spend on multi players he would rather waste time and get one big signing which is why we are in trouble. This clubs needs a rebuild and our current owners are the wrong guys to do that (getting in the Americans was wrong move and clearly a panic decision from SP) Grumpy Mart rather than just moan,could you not explain your reasoning.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
I agree with your sentiment however they can already discuss deals with other clubs as they are under 6 months left of their contract. The 3 loans end, Mutch, Lee, Delaney, Sako, Speroni could easily not be renewed. Cabaye won't stay. That's 9. We have no choice if they leave or stay if they have no contract. Therefore we either buy, sign a free or play youth which we don't have in numbers. Stacking up yet? Expat unfortunately Mutch is going nowhere,his contract has one more year to go.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Need to stay up first and foremost.
laddo "People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist". |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.