This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Puncheon or Cabaye??
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Jules111 Preston, Lancashire 13 Feb 18 8.13pm |
|
|
At the peak of their powers with us, which player has produced most for us?
In my opinion it’s puncheon all day long, he single handedly kept us up the first season and was excellent the following seasons. I think due to the rapid decline in JP’s performances fans forget how good he was.
I think Cabaye is a quality player but he has failed to live up to his reputation as our stellar signing.
Thoughts?
|
d_stone85 south croydon 13 Feb 18 8.39pm |
|
|
Truth is cabaye was past peak when he joined us. Best years at Lille and Newcastle. We caught punch in the the prime of his, he’s done far more than cabaye for palace. But cabaye at his peak at Newcastle was a level above punch
|
mattteo 13 Feb 18 10.55pm |
|
|
Pucheon as a side midfielder. Cabaye as a central midfielder.
Puncheon had been amazing for a team like Palace on the right (mainly due to being left footed):
5 goals, 6 assists in 2100 minutes in 2012/13 season 7 goals, 4 assists in 2500 minutes in 2013/14 season 6 goals, 7 assists in 2800 minutes in 2014/15 season (There was strong talk of the national team and rightly so)
Moving him to the center was the worst idea ever:
2 goals, 3 assists in 2600 minutes in 2015/16 season 0 goals, 5 assists in 3700 minutes since then
Edited by mattteo (13 Feb 2018 10.56pm)
|
the.universal 13 Feb 18 11.11pm |
|
|
OP makes a great point. I really rate Cabaye and probably the better player all told but when Puncheon was on it for us, he almost single handedly kept us up. Like a boss. So I’m voting JP.
I think we’re generally too soon to write players off but he has been poor of late, hopefully he can get back to somewhere near his best as a squad player for us.
Vive le Roy!
|
pssguy 14 Feb 18 9.54am |
|
|
I think saying JP single-handedly kept us up is stretching it. He was our most effective creative player in 2013/14 but Pulis, Jedinal and the defence in the second half of the season can take a lot of credit
As the above figures indicate, he has been on a steady decline (in fact he was better at Southampton). Given his age and injury, I'd be surprised to see him play for the team again if we stay up
|
paperhat croydon 14 Feb 18 9.57am |
|
|
personally i'd get shot of both, replace with someone younger, harder, better.
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 14 Feb 18 10.22am |
|
|
Puncheon played in a much worst team (in terms of individuals at least), so not surprising he stood out. But would agree his contribution at Palace has been greater.
In terms of actual ability however, it's a no brainer IMO; you only have to look at what they've each achieved in their careers...
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 14 Feb 18 8.24pm |
|
|
Puncheon’s goals and set piece delivery in big games were one of the main reasons we stayed up first two seasons. A superb Holloway and Parish signing. Cabaye a better CM and footballer but has had less impact overall for us IMO.
|
spartakev2 Anerley 15 Feb 18 9.23am |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Pucheon as a side midfielder. Cabaye as a central midfielder.
Puncheon had been amazing for a team like Palace on the right (mainly due to being left footed):
5 goals, 6 assists in 2100 minutes in 2012/13 season 7 goals, 4 assists in 2500 minutes in 2013/14 season 6 goals, 7 assists in 2800 minutes in 2014/15 season (There was strong talk of the national team and rightly so)
Moving him to the center was the worst idea ever:
2 goals, 3 assists in 2600 minutes in 2015/16 season 0 goals, 5 assists in 3700 minutes since then
Edited by mattteo (13 Feb 2018 10.56pm)
He was pardewed. ..who in their right mind would try and make puncheon a defensive central midfielder. Ruined him.
|
spartakev2 Anerley 15 Feb 18 9.25am |
|
Originally posted by paperhat
personally i'd get shot of both, replace with someone younger, harder, better.
That wasn't the question. ..
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 15 Feb 18 9.39am |
|
|
this thread should be put in the sentimental history section. Sadly, one of these players is completely shot and the other is rapidly losing popularity among fans.
the Prem is ruthless. Lets thank the two boys for some good performances and go and recruit some hungry 21 year olds.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
ex hibitionist Hastings 15 Feb 18 9.45am |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
this thread should be put in the sentimental history section. Sadly, one of these players is completely shot and the other is rapidly losing popularity among fans.
the Prem is ruthless. Lets thank the two boys for some good performances and go and recruit some hungry 21 year olds.
agreed
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 15 Feb 18 9.56am |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
this thread should be put in the sentimental history section. Sadly, one of these players is completely shot and the other is rapidly losing popularity among fans.
the Prem is ruthless. Lets thank the two boys for some good performances and go and recruit some hungry 21 year olds.
Well they're both current Palace players, so that's an entirely null point.
What 21 year old can you think of who would be an improvement on Cabaye?
'Hungry 21 year olds' sounds great, but it's a complete throwaway of a point - any 21 year old in world football who's at least as good as Cabaye is going to be hot property, and probably cost north of £30m.
|
PatrickA London 15 Feb 18 10.34am |
|
|
It has been evident for a few seasons that Palace are one paced in midfield. MacArthur, Cabaye,Luka,Puncheon (and for that matter Riedewald or Mutch) - none of them are dynamic or quick. There has been a reliance on Bolassie and Zaha to carry the game to the opposition at pace which presents a problem in their absence. Cabaye is a very good footballer but can’t seem to play effectively for more than 60 minutes. Puncheon has not played well for more than a year. I hoped that a younger energetic midfielder would be added in the window but this didn’t happen. Regardless of the division Palace are in next season I think Cabaye will not be there and that Puncheon will have a limited role.
|
Loz83 Crawley 15 Feb 18 10.45pm |
|
|
I’m still baffled why punch was dropped back into midfield, he’s always been best as a right winger. He’s way too lightweight for centre mid, no surprise his form has been nowhere near as good as it was.
|
spartakev2 Anerley 16 Feb 18 12.06am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
It has been evident for a few seasons that Palace are one paced in midfield. MacArthur, Cabaye,Luka,Puncheon (and for that matter Riedewald or Mutch) - none of them are dynamic or quick. There has been a reliance on Bolassie and Zaha to carry the game to the opposition at pace which presents a problem in their absence. Cabaye is a very good footballer but can’t seem to play effectively for more than 60 minutes. Puncheon has not played well for more than a year. I hoped that a younger energetic midfielder would be added in the window but this didn’t happen. Regardless of the division Palace are in next season I think Cabaye will not be there and that Puncheon will have a limited role.
Rakip??
|
sprites Auckland 16 Feb 18 2.18am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
It has been evident for a few seasons that Palace are one paced in midfield. MacArthur, Cabaye,Luka,Puncheon (and for that matter Riedewald or Mutch) - none of them are dynamic or quick. There has been a reliance on Bolassie and Zaha to carry the game to the opposition at pace which presents a problem in their absence. Cabaye is a very good footballer but can’t seem to play effectively for more than 60 minutes. Puncheon has not played well for more than a year. I hoped that a younger energetic midfielder would be added in the window but this didn’t happen. Regardless of the division Palace are in next season I think Cabaye will not be there and that Puncheon will have a limited role.
His name is Chungy and he gets grossly overlooked on here all the time. Agile, nippy, good vision.
|
steven_t92 Orpington 16 Feb 18 9.41am |
|
Originally posted by sprites
His name is Chungy and he gets grossly overlooked on here all the time. Agile, nippy, good vision.
The same player that can only pass sideways? Not exactly a great demonstration of vision is it.
One of Pardew's worst mistakes was ruining Puncheon, although his pace had gone he was still better out wide. Never did anything in the middle for us.
Edited by steven_t92 (16 Feb 2018 9.42am)
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 16 Feb 18 11.23am |
|
Originally posted by steven_t92
One of Pardew's worst mistakes was.....
Edited by steven_t92 (16 Feb 2018 9.42am)
thats a tough competition. So many to choose from.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 16 Feb 18 10.49pm |
|
Originally posted by steven_t92
The same player that can only pass sideways? Not exactly a great demonstration of vision is it.
One of Pardew's worst mistakes was ruining Puncheon, although his pace had gone he was still better out wide. Never did anything in the middle for us.
Edited by steven_t92 (16 Feb 2018 9.42am)
Not true. Second half of 2014-15 season was standout in the no 10 position and a big reason we stayed up a second season.
|