justify your choices in each case.

worst

clattenburg...a million dodgy decisions, a cloud of controversy that follows him and that photo with ferguson before making a balls of it at the fa cup final.

howard webb...thought he was good. that world cup final where the Dutch team took up Karate, not his finest moment.

best.
Ellery....gave Roy Keane a ton of red cards. bravo.

what others ?

Eze Peasy at Anfield....

In the interests of HOL I have decided not to offer my opinions on this thread for as sure as night follows day it will disintegrate into vitriol and opprobrium akin to rooks squabbling over carrion with the thread being de-railed by feuds.

In the words of 'Midlands Eagle' "Same old,same old".

Roger Kirkpatrick was the best.

Palace 13th 2017/18.

its ok willo. The coast is clear. he has gone back to the bbs to abuse people with impunity.

cmon. Its a football subject on a football discussion board. If anybody mentions the advantages of electoral systems in Sweden over those in France i will recommend them for strong medicinal sedation , and a digital referee's yellow card.

now, getting back to topic. Which is better refereeing ? allow the game to flow or to stop the game frequently as needed ?

Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 Feb 2018 2.07pm)

Eze Peasy at Anfield....

David Ellery - utter w***er. One of those 'big I am' refs who thinks they're always right, head up their ass type.

Keith Hackett stands out as a decent one but I was quite young in his day and may have missed some things.

Roger Milford?