You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Medical students learn nothing about nutrition
November 21 2026 11.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Medical students learn nothing about nutrition


sitdownstandup Flag 25 Mar 18 12.10pm

[Link]

Health effects of diet and nutrition form a very minor part of medical training claim medical students. So if this is the case then the information regarding diet given by health professionals must be questioned as they had little knowledge or training in this field themselves.
"We're taught about 10 to 24 hours over five to six years in medical school on nutrition."
I remember seeing this information in a documentary recently and being quite shocked. The basis for good health is diet and its amazing to think that medical students receive so little training in nutrition at all. Its poor diet that causes health problems at the end of the day and a healthy diet will prevent us needing to visit doctors in the first place. Im sure if doctors had better training in nutrition they'd be more likely to recommend a vegan diet to their patients in order to reverse and prevent many of the diseases that are prevalent in society today.
Shocking statistic and no wonder so many people are suffering from ill health when there is so much misinformation out there.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

sitdownstandup Flag 25 Mar 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

[Link]

Health effects of diet and nutrition form a very minor part of medical training claim medical students. So if this is the case then the information regarding diet given by health professionals must be questioned as they had little knowledge or training in this field themselves.
"We're taught about 10 to 24 hours over five to six years in medical school on nutrition."
I remember seeing this information in a documentary recently and being quite shocked. The basis for good health is diet and its amazing to think that medical students receive so little training in nutrition at all. Its poor diet that causes health problems at the end of the day and a healthy diet will prevent us needing to visit doctors in the first place. Im sure if doctors had better training in nutrition they'd be more likely to recommend a vegan diet to their patients in order to reverse and prevent many of the diseases that are prevalent in society today.
Shocking statistic and no wonder so many people are suffering from ill health when those who are meant to be the ones teaching about it know so little themselves.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Park Road Flag 25 Mar 18 12.17pm

I've never been taught nutrition nor needed to attend a course.
I do know however that fruit, veg, meat in moderation etc.. Is good for you, and that too much fried or process food is bad for you.

It's not rocket science.

If you have high cholesterol you are given a sheet of things that are good and things to avoid.

It's one sheet with all the relevant info.

Also, exercising is good.


Edited by Park Road (25 Mar 2018 12.18pm)

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 25 Mar 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

[Link]

Health effects of diet and nutrition form a very minor part of medical training claim medical students. So if this is the case then the information regarding diet given by health professionals must be questioned as they had little knowledge or training in this field themselves.
"We're taught about 10 to 24 hours over five to six years in medical school on nutrition."
I remember seeing this information in a documentary recently and being quite shocked. The basis for good health is diet and its amazing to think that medical students receive so little training in nutrition at all. Its poor diet that causes health problems at the end of the day and a healthy diet will prevent us needing to visit doctors in the first place. Im sure if doctors had better training in nutrition they'd be more likely to recommend a vegan diet to their patients in order to reverse and prevent many of the diseases that are prevalent in society today.
Shocking statistic and no wonder so many people are suffering from ill health when there is so much misinformation out there.

I'm not sure that I'd call 10-24 hours of teaching nothing. Given standard teaching hours that's up to 4 days or so on nutrition and it's a quote from a single individual that may not represent other medical Schools. The five to six year timeframe is also a bit of a red herring as that implies that all of that time is study when in fact a considerable portion is spent in practice, supposedly where medical students are meant to learn about such matters. As University students they are also expected to study such matters independently as well as through direct teaching. These students at Bristol have found nutrition interesting and focused on it. Others, as they note through the presence of medical societies, choose to focus on other subject areas. Nutrition is without doubt important and GP's may well need additional knowledge in this respect but they can also already refer people onto dieticians or health visitors or specialist nurses/medics for specific conditions like diabetes. Ultimately, as the article notes, diet is a lifestyle choice and the real challenge for medics is not one of nutritional knowledge but one of persuading people to actually change their diet and lifestyle.

Edited by Direwolf (25 Mar 2018 12.40pm)

 

Rubin Flag 25 Mar 18 1.16pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

[Link]

Health effects of diet and nutrition form a very minor part of medical training claim medical students. So if this is the case then the information regarding diet given by health professionals must be questioned as they had little knowledge or training in this field themselves.
"We're taught about 10 to 24 hours over five to six years in medical school on nutrition."
I remember seeing this information in a documentary recently and being quite shocked. The basis for good health is diet and its amazing to think that medical students receive so little training in nutrition at all. Its poor diet that causes health problems at the end of the day and a healthy diet will prevent us needing to visit doctors in the first place. Im sure if doctors had better training in nutrition they'd be more likely to recommend a vegan diet to their patients in order to reverse and prevent many of the diseases that are prevalent in society today.
Shocking statistic and no wonder so many people are suffering from ill health when there is so much misinformation out there.

There's no money in prevention, though.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Mar 18 1.59pm

Does a vegan diet turn you nuts?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

JusticeToad Flag Beckenham 25 Mar 18 5.30pm

Heh. Was waiting for the mention of veganism

But on topic, the basics of nutrition are very simple. Given the huge amount of critical material doctors have to cover I think 10-24 hours on nutrition seems about right.

 

sitdownstandup Flag 25 Mar 18 8.39pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Does a vegan diet turn you nuts?

Not any nuttier than you but it will lessen the likelihood of developing disease in later life according to a growing number of doctors. Read the china study and you'll find out more.


 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Mar 18 9.16pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

Not any nuttier than you but it will lessen the likelihood of developing disease in later life according to a growing number of doctors. Read the china study and you'll find out more.


Lettuce reflect on your words....I've reflected....Leaf it out!

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

becky Flag over the moon 26 Mar 18 7.10am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Lettuce reflect on your words....I've reflected....Leaf it out!

Can't you even meat him half way?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

sitdownstandup Flag 26 Mar 18 12.35pm

Originally posted by becky

Can't you even meat him half way?


Bean there before.. doughnut think I'll go back. Vegan change everything and create a more peas full world.

Edited by sitdownstandup (26 Mar 2018 11.12pm)

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Mar 18 6.31pm

The world isn't going to turn vegan.

But technology will eventually end meat farming......just as technology is going to end many jobs and professions.

Kids born today will end up seeing cows and chickens in zoos instead of farms......in the west anyway.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Park Road Flag 26 Mar 18 6.40pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The world isn't going to turn vegan.

But technology will eventually end meat farming......just as technology is going to end many jobs and professions.

Kids born today will end up seeing cows and chickens in zoos instead of farms......in the west anyway.

That will only happen if we as a species haven't already destroyed ourselves and become extinct and replaced by a far superior species.

Which is probably the more likely outcome.

 

sitdownstandup Flag 27 Mar 18 8.08pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The world isn't going to turn vegan.

But technology will eventually end meat farming......just as technology is going to end many jobs and professions.

Kids born today will end up seeing cows and chickens in zoos instead of farms......in the west anyway.

It already is. You only have to look at the number of films on netflix - What the health, cowspiracy, Forks over knives, Okja amongst about 20 of them and the fact that they are influencing people and opening their eyes to the health benefits of a vegan diet as well as the devastating effect the meat and dairy industries are having on the planet. There are people who dont believe in climate change but plenty of people do and knowing that their diet is a major cause will make them question their dietary choices further.
If people go into any major bookstore and look in the cookery section and they'll see an ever growing number of books in the vegan section - a section that didn't even exist 10 years ago. Then look in the supermarkets and see the number of alternatives to milk available. The growing number of vegan products and meals in restaurants also shows that demand for vegan products is increasing and businesses can see this. As the products increase people will find it easier to switch and transition to a vegan diet. This is just the start of people being more informed about what happens to animals in the meat and dairy industry. The mainstream media hasn't entertained a discussion on these issues in my lifetime and they still rarely discuss what happens or show images of what happens to animals but it cant be hidden anymore and as more people see what is happening and understand the effects on our health and the planet then more people will question the necessity for eating animal products. Whereas previously there was no debate because there was nobody to debate with, the steadily growing numbers mean the voices will become louder and it will become more and more difficult to justify the unnecessary killing of animals while it destroys the planet and causes so much suffering. This vegan world might not happen in our lifetime but it will happen... and it'll be a step forward in our evolution and as Einstein said
"Nothing will benefit health or increase chances of survival on earth as the evolution to a vegetarian diet."

I believe it will happen and if it doesnt it will only be because we are so stupid and messed up that we destroy ourselves, the planet and everything on it first.
Very possible but hopefully we will wise up before that happens.

Edited by sitdownstandup (28 Mar 2018 7.03am)

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Park Road Flag 28 Mar 18 5.40am

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

It already is. You only have to look at the number of films on netflix - What the health, cowspiracy, Forks over knives, Okja amongst about 20 of them and the fact that they are influencing people and opening their eyes to the health benefits of a vegan diet as well as the devastating effect the meat and dairy industries are having on the planet. There are people who dont believe in climate change but plenty of people do and knowing that their diet is a major cause will make them question their dietary choices further.
If people go into any major bookstore and look in the cookery section and they'll see an ever growing number of books in the vegan section - a section that didn't even exist 10 years ago. Then look in the supermarkets and see the number of alternatives to milk available. The growing number of vegan products and meals in restaurants also shows that demand for vegan products is increasing and businesses can see this. As the products increase people will find it easier to switch and transition to a vegan diet. This is just the start of people being more informed about what happens to animals in the meat and dairy industry. The mainstream media hasn't entertained a discussion on these issues in my lifetime and they still rarely discuss what happens or show images of what happens to animals but it cant be hidden anymore and as more people see what is happening and understand the effects on our health and the planet then more people will question the necessity for eating animal products. Whereas previously there was no debate because there was nobody to debate with, the steadily growing numbers mean the voices will become louder and it will become more and more difficult to justify the unnecessary killing of animals while it destroys the planet and causes so much unnecessary suffering. This vegan world might not happen in our lifetime but it will happen... and it'll be a step forward in our evolution and as Einstein said
"Nothing will benefit health or increase chances of survival on earth as the evolution to a vegetarian diet."

I believe it will happen and if it doesnt it will only be because we are so stupid and messed up that we destroy ourselves, the planet and everything on it first.
Very possible but hopefully we will wise up before that happens.

Edited by sitdownstandup (27 Mar 2018 9.33pm)

What about insects? It's true meat consumption will go down for reasons stated, maybe...
It's been predicted that as in Asia the west will follow their dietary options.
Insects are easier to farm and cheaper. They are full of protein and environmentally friendly.

They are slowly being introduced into western culture now, so surely it's just a matter of time.

Scorpion on a stick is really tasty so I hear.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Mar 18 6.00am

Originally posted by Park Road

What about insects? It's true meat consumption will go down for reasons stated, maybe...
It's been predicted that as in Asia the west will follow their dietary options.
Insects are easier to farm and cheaper. They are full of protein and environmentally friendly.

They are slowly being introduced into western culture now, so surely it's just a matter of time.

Scorpion on a stick is really tasty so I hear.

I saw a TV program a few months ago about a UK company that breeds insects to cook in their own restaurant and everyone that tried their insect burgers said how nice they were.

Anyone who fancies nibbling on a bug can buy them here [Link]


Edited by Midlands Eagle (28 Mar 2018 6.10am)

 

Park Road Flag 28 Mar 18 7.36am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I saw a TV program a few months ago about a UK company that breeds insects to cook in their own restaurant and everyone that tried their insect burgers said how nice they were.

Anyone who fancies nibbling on a bug can buy them here [Link]


Edited by Midlands Eagle (28 Mar 2018 6.10am)

Crunchycritters doesn't sound appetizing .
Maybe, another title would help but still worth a read,

Bush tucker banquets sounds good


Edited by Park Road (28 Mar 2018 7.38am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Mar 18 11.42am

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

It already is. You only have to look at the number of films on netflix - What the health, cowspiracy, Forks over knives, Okja amongst about 20 of them and the fact that they are influencing people and opening their eyes to the health benefits of a vegan diet as well as the devastating effect the meat and dairy industries are having on the planet. There are people who dont believe in climate change but plenty of people do and knowing that their diet is a major cause will make them question their dietary choices further.
If people go into any major bookstore and look in the cookery section and they'll see an ever growing number of books in the vegan section - a section that didn't even exist 10 years ago. Then look in the supermarkets and see the number of alternatives to milk available. The growing number of vegan products and meals in restaurants also shows that demand for vegan products is increasing and businesses can see this. As the products increase people will find it easier to switch and transition to a vegan diet. This is just the start of people being more informed about what happens to animals in the meat and dairy industry. The mainstream media hasn't entertained a discussion on these issues in my lifetime and they still rarely discuss what happens or show images of what happens to animals but it cant be hidden anymore and as more people see what is happening and understand the effects on our health and the planet then more people will question the necessity for eating animal products. Whereas previously there was no debate because there was nobody to debate with, the steadily growing numbers mean the voices will become louder and it will become more and more difficult to justify the unnecessary killing of animals while it destroys the planet and causes so much suffering. This vegan world might not happen in our lifetime but it will happen... and it'll be a step forward in our evolution and as Einstein said
"Nothing will benefit health or increase chances of survival on earth as the evolution to a vegetarian diet."

I believe it will happen and if it doesnt it will only be because we are so stupid and messed up that we destroy ourselves, the planet and everything on it first.
Very possible but hopefully we will wise up before that happens.

Edited by sitdownstandup (28 Mar 2018 7.03am)

Ha ha. You are funny. People would live longer if they stopped drinking alcohol all the time, didn't smoke, exercised regularly, ate less and wore sunscreen when outside for long periods.
What you eat is way down the list of risk. Humanity is doomed by rising population. The planet will take care of itself until the Sun expands. How many times have I got to tell you that you can't fix a problem like rising population by worrying about the symptoms?

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Medical students learn nothing about nutrition