You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > England vs Italy
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

England vs Italy


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Direwolf Flag Lincoln 27 Mar 18 7.42pm

England team for tonight:

Butland
Walker
Stones
Tarkowski
Dier
Trippier
Oxlade-Chamberlain
Lingard
Young
Vardy
Sterling

I can't say I'm enthused with the sheer quality of this team.

Mind you I have hardly heard of most of the Italians:

Donnarumma
Zappacosta
Rugani
Bonucci
De Sciglio
Pellegrini
Frello Filho
Parolo
Candreva
Immobile
Insigne

Can any of the more informed watchers of Italian football offer any insights?

Will we actually score or have to watch a long drawn out 0-0?

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Mar 18 9.01pm

Gosh, a real derth of quality there.

What's our best team, if everyone's fit? I think it's 442 diamond for me. A bit like the Tottenham model where Dier sits in and Rose/Walker push on?


GK: Pickford
RWB: Walker
CB: Stones
CB: Cahill
LWB: Rose
DM: Dier
CM: Wilshire
CM: Henderson
AM: Ali
ST: Sterling
ST: Kane

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 27 Mar 18 9.06pm

Originally posted by sprites

Gosh, a real derth of quality there.

What's our best team, if everyone's fit? I think it's 442 diamond for me. A bit like the Tottenham model where Dier sits in and Rose/Walker push on?


GK: Pickford
RWB: Walker
CB: Stones
CB: Cahill
LWB: Rose
DM: Dier
CM: Wilshire
CM: Henderson
AM: Ali
ST: Sterling
ST: Kane


Stones worries me a bit. He's decent but gives the impression that he thinks he is better than he is. Maybe that's just the self-confidence that you need at this level.

 

chateauferret Flag 27 Mar 18 10.06pm

Well that proves that VAR will not prevent the more shall we say gifted thespians amongst football's elite from wangling ridiculous penalties.

 


============
The Ferret
============

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 27 Mar 18 10.15pm

You kidding Ferret? Tarkowski stands full on on his foot, as clear a pen as anything to me.

Originally posted by chateauferret

Well that proves that VAR will not prevent the more shall we say gifted thespians amongst football's elite from wangling ridiculous penalties.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Mar 18 10.40pm

Not impressed with that VAR decision looked totally innocuous.

 

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 27 Mar 18 11.29pm

Originally posted by sprites

Gosh, a real derth of quality there.

What's our best team, if everyone's fit? I think it's 442 diamond for me. A bit like the Tottenham model where Dier sits in and Rose/Walker push on?


GK: Pickford
RWB: Walker
CB: Stones
CB: Cahill
LWB: Rose
DM: Dier
CM: Wilshire
CM: Henderson
AM: Ali
ST: Sterling
ST: Kane

If you watched the game England were playing a 3 at the back.
Walker plays for Man City.
Gareth was trying him as one of the 3 Centre Backs.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 27 Mar 18 11.30pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

You kidding Ferret? Tarkowski stands full on on his foot, as clear a pen as anything to me.

Didn't see it, but amazed Tarkowski gets a nod over Tomkins. Zaha tore up Tarkovski, and if I'm not mistaken he has the most penalties called against him of any center back in the league (maybe that was last season).

 

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 27 Mar 18 11.31pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Well that proves that VAR will not prevent the more shall we say gifted thespians amongst football's elite from wangling ridiculous penalties.

As Johan said he trod on the Italians foot.
Penalty.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Mar 18 4.47am

Originally posted by Bill Glazier

As Johan said he trod on the Italians foot.
Penalty.


Not for me, no intention, Southgate glad it didn't happen in a World Cup game (yet).

I can see players 'learning' about the VAR and who is deciding what is 'clear' makes it subjective.

Still hoping for its ultimate success though, like the cricket system where its proven technology.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 28 Mar 18 7.03am

Originally posted by steeleye20
Not for me, no intention, Southgate glad it didn't happen in a World Cup game (yet).

I can see players 'learning' about the VAR and who is deciding what is 'clear' makes it subjective.

Still hoping for its ultimate success though, like the cricket system where its proven technology.

Yep no intention to foul but still took him out. It was a good decision to award a penalty. Well done VAR.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

jeeagles Flag 28 Mar 18 8.52am

Not much has been said about the fact he was going down prior to his foot being stepped on without any contact after losing possession. Therefore, the scoring opportunity had already gone.

I'm not sure there was a clear and obvious error here so I'm not convinced it should have been reviewed in the first place.

It looked like more of a simple coming together of players.

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 28 Mar 18 9.18am

Should it really be down to the referee to make the decision, i thought there was supposed to be another official in the stands who views it and decides like cricket and rugby

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 28 Mar 18 9.38am

Since when is "intention" part of a decision wheter a foul is a foul? There is an element of it in handball, which also is a dubious part as it is impossible to judge on, but surely it is nothing to do with fouls.

Do you think the Italian player was diving?

Originally posted by steeleye20


Not for me, no intention, Southgate glad it didn't happen in a World Cup game (yet).

I can see players 'learning' about the VAR and who is deciding what is 'clear' makes it subjective.

Still hoping for its ultimate success though, like the cricket system where its proven technology.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Mar 18 1.37pm

Concerned about the playing it out from the back requiring Stones to unnecessarily turn players in possession in and on the edge of the area. Has this t1t not learnt his lesson yet?

Had an Acca which should've returned nicely last night if the Columbian striker could notch one of the 4 chances from 2-3 yards out he had. What a cvnt. The free bet refund softened the blow a slight amount.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (28 Mar 2018 1.37pm)

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Mar 18 1.41pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Not much has been said about the fact he was going down prior to his foot being stepped on without any contact after losing possession. Therefore, the scoring opportunity had already gone.

I'm not sure there was a clear and obvious error here so I'm not convinced it should have been reviewed in the first place.

It looked like more of a simple coming together of players.

I believe there is going to be quite a debate as to what is a "Clear and obvious error".Very subjective.

In terms of the review, the referee would have been advised by the VAR to watch footrage of the incident and reconsider his decision.

Edited by Willo (28 Mar 2018 1.50pm)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 28 Mar 18 9.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

I believe there is going to be quite a debate as to what is a "Clear and obvious error".Very subjective.

In terms of the review, the referee would have been advised by the VAR to watch footrage of the incident and reconsider his decision.

Edited by Willo (28 Mar 2018 1.50pm)

Just advising the ref to look at the VAR could put doubt in his mind and for him to reverse his initial thoughts - don’t like the ref having this control. It should be someone else telling him it should have been a penalty. As it was, I was surprised it wasn’t given without VAR as most of us in real time must of believed it was a pen. I then thought when seeing it again, well done ref as it wasn’t a pen. In my opinion for it to work, it has to be done by a ref watching it of the pitch and telling the ref on the pitch what the decision should be?

 

chateauferret Flag 28 Mar 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Not much has been said about the fact he was going down prior to his foot being stepped on without any contact after losing possession. Therefore, the scoring opportunity had already gone.

I'm not sure there was a clear and obvious error here so I'm not convinced it should have been reviewed in the first place.

It looked like more of a simple coming together of players.

Well that's what I thought. The ref only reviewed it because of Italian histrionics, which I didn't think were a criterion for the ref going and watching telly. Then the offence itself might have been given as a penalty I suppose, but since it doesn't amount to a "clear and obvious error" I would have expected the video ref to give it as umpire's call.

 


============
The Ferret
============

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Mar 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Since when is "intention" part of a decision wheter a foul is a foul? There is an element of it in handball, which also is a dubious part as it is impossible to judge on, but surely it is nothing to do with fouls.

Do you think the Italian player was diving?

Yes I think the Italy player was going down.

Good penalty conversion, wasn't it?.

'clear and obvious error' who decides, that is subjective.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 28 Mar 18 10.29pm

I must admit that I thought the ref had been advised via his earpiece to look at it again via VAR. Presumably that means it came from the remote ref?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > England vs Italy