You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rakip, and Harry Kane taking corners
November 16 2026 7.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rakip, and Harry Kane taking corners


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 12 Apr 18 7.22pm

Maybe this has been asked and discussed before, but can someone explain to me why on earth we signed Rakip? Hodgson said the other day the reason he didn't bring any subs on lately was a lack of options.

Luka was out on his feet in the last 10 mins versus Man Utd, but this bloke is nowhere to be seen. Does that strike anyone here as weird?

So basically the signing of Rakip was completely misaligned with Hodgson, who refuses to play the guy.

In years gone by we have tried to add some quality in January while in the midst of our perennial relegation scrap, but with the exception of a backup goalie and a striker who, guess what, is injured and therefore remains unproven, we totally failed to do that.

Jach makes some kind of sense to me, even though with recent centre back injuries he hasn't even had a look in, but what on earth are we doing signing Rakip on loan to play in the U23s and then leave? Talk about a lack of alignment between the manager and the hierarchy.

One thing Hodgson showed us with Harry Kane taking corners is that he is bloody minded and sticks to his guns at all costs - therefore due to the seemingly totally misaligned exploits of the January window, we aren't going to be seeing many substitutions made in the run in I guess.

Hence get ready for more late goals being conceded.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Apr 18 7.26pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Maybe this has been asked and discussed before, but can someone explain to me why on earth we signed Rakip?

The truthful answer is that no-one knows

 

YT Flag Oxford 12 Apr 18 7.44pm

I thought this was some kind of celebrity (or not quite celebrity in Rakip’s case) boxing match thread until I saw the excellently-used comma.

Edited by YT (12 Apr 2018 7.44pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

chateauferret Flag 12 Apr 18 10.47pm

I don't know about bloody-minded. He's got Milivojevic taking corners now and only using the odd floaty Cabaye one. I can't understand what the Rakip deal was about unless it was cover in case Cabaye, Milivojevic and say Riedewald all went sick at once, but with a view to bringing him on next season as well.

 


============
The Ferret
============

h.smith91 Flag Sanderstead 12 Apr 18 11.04pm

My understanding is, at the end of last season, Rakip found himself without a club after being released by Malmo. As a young, promising player Benfica saw an opportunity to make a bit of money. In what I see as a relatively unprecedented move (or at least a unspoken tactic) they signed him on a contract, knowing full well they had no intention of playing him due to not fitting their system or not being good enough yet and planned from the off loaning him out to ‘put him in the shop window’ and then sell him to us for a few million at the end of this season. They got him for free and may end up selling him on for a profit. He seems to be playing well for the U23’s and whenever I have tuned in or watched the highlights he seems to have that something special!

I guess, in a nutshell, I expect us to sign him on a permanent in the summer with a view to start introducing him to the first team to replace the aging Cabaye over the next season or so. Strange situation but for me is the only thing that explains signing him on loan in the first place.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 13 Apr 18 7.32am

Maybe there's some kind of pre arranged price with benfica that would see it rise depending on first team appearances.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 13 Apr 18 11.30am

I agree its bizzare - why pay the temporary wages for a player we didn't need and had no experience of anything like the PL?
The attached link suggests is not a huge amount - it says "So, that’s no loan fee and just wages for Crystal Palace to pay, which makes this a very cheap deal given Benfica don’t hand out huge contracts to squad players". I suppose an extended trial period for which we pay him.

[Link]

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

pssguy Flag 13 Apr 18 11.57am

Hodgson asked for Rakitic and this was the closest they could find

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 13 Apr 18 12.14pm

Originally posted by h.smith91

My understanding is, at the end of last season, Rakip found himself without a club after being released by Malmo. As a young, promising player Benfica saw an opportunity to make a bit of money. In what I see as a relatively unprecedented move (or at least a unspoken tactic) they signed him on a contract, knowing full well they had no intention of playing him due to not fitting their system or not being good enough yet and planned from the off loaning him out to ‘put him in the shop window’ and then sell him to us for a few million at the end of this season. They got him for free and may end up selling him on for a profit. He seems to be playing well for the U23’s and whenever I have tuned in or watched the highlights he seems to have that something special!


I guess, in a nutshell, I expect us to sign him on a permanent in the summer with a view to start introducing him to the first team to replace the aging Cabaye over the next season or so. Strange situation but for me is the only thing that explains signing him on loan in the first place.


We wont sign him in the summer, his new club put in a 10 million release fee. The only way we’d have paid that is if he played a few games and impressed big time

Which obviously hasn’t happened

 

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 13 Apr 18 3.22pm

Our January business was nothing short of embarrassing, and Parish & Co. should directly take the blame if we were to perish at the end of the season.

 


Dont let Cabaye go

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Apr 18 3.39pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Hodgson asked for Rakitic and this was the closest they could find

I think he told Parish he fancied a kip, due to tiredness.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Apr 18 3.44pm

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Our January business was nothing short of embarrassing, and Parish & Co. should directly take the blame if we were to perish at the end of the season.

Same old same old, isn't it. Since the first window under Holloway we have maybe had 2 half decent windows out of all of them.

I hoped bringing Freedman in would somehow change our schoolboy, poorly planned, last minute, amateur hour approach to running transfer windows (or managerial searches). Alas, we seem unable to learn from our mistakes, develop, or grow in any way, shape or form re transfer dealings.

Shame really as it "might mean our a$$es" this year, as the yanks say.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Apr 18 3.50pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I don't know about bloody-minded. He's got Milivojevic taking corners now and only using the odd floaty Cabaye one. I can't understand what the Rakip deal was about unless it was cover in case Cabaye, Milivojevic and say Riedewald all went sick at once, but with a view to bringing him on next season as well.

If RH is not bloody minded, then why doesn't he EVER try to protect a lead by making substitutions, like every other manager in every other league in the world, in vital games in the midst of a relegation scrap?

Bringing someone like Riedewald into the fray towards the end of the Man U and Bournemouth games, to name just 2 games, would seem to be pretty obvious? Our midfield 2 were totally shot at the end of the Man U game, but still we didnt do anything.

How about not taking Zaha off towards the end vs Huddersfield? Thats not the very definition of bloody minded?

I am generally a fan of RH but his use of substitutions to close out games is horrendously poor.

When asked the other day by a journo why he didnt make a substitution towards the end of Bournemouth, he said it was because he didnt have enough attacking options on the bench.

Only problem was we needed to make a defensive substitution at that time, not bring on a forward....

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 13 Apr 18 3.56pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The truthful answer is that no-one knows

That hasn't stopped it being discussed multiple times already.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

chateauferret Flag 13 Apr 18 6.58pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If RH is not bloody minded, then why doesn't he EVER try to protect a lead by making substitutions, like every other manager in every other league in the world, in vital games in the midst of a relegation scrap?

Bringing someone like Riedewald into the fray towards the end of the Man U and Bournemouth games, to name just 2 games, would seem to be pretty obvious? Our midfield 2 were totally shot at the end of the Man U game, but still we didnt do anything.

How about not taking Zaha off towards the end vs Huddersfield? Thats not the very definition of bloody minded?

I am generally a fan of RH but his use of substitutions to close out games is horrendously poor.

When asked the other day by a journo why he didnt make a substitution towards the end of Bournemouth, he said it was because he didnt have enough attacking options on the bench.

Only problem was we needed to make a defensive substitution at that time, not bring on a forward....

I don't see how any of that qualifies him for a highly negative epithet that connotes stupid, arrogant and uncompromising. If Hodgson is bloody-minded then WTF was Frank de Boer?

There might be any number of reasons. Perhaps what happened when he (had to) bring Delaney on has something to do with it. And don't bother expecting him to disclose tactical secrets to journalists; he has more sense.

Nobody knows what would have happened if he had made those substitutions and it is as much supposition to state that fresh legs would have helped close the game out as it is to suggest that a cold player coming on might make a mistake (which is what happened against Spurs).

 


============
The Ferret
============

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 13 Apr 18 7.47pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I don't see how any of that qualifies him for a highly negative epithet that connotes stupid, arrogant and uncompromising. If Hodgson is bloody-minded then WTF was Frank de Boer?

There might be any number of reasons. Perhaps what happened when he (had to) bring Delaney on has something to do with it. And don't bother expecting him to disclose tactical secrets to journalists; he has more sense.

Nobody knows what would have happened if he had made those substitutions and it is as much supposition to state that fresh legs would have helped close the game out as it is to suggest that a cold player coming on might make a mistake (which is what happened against Spurs).

Have to say that to leave Zaha and townsend on up front, and they were both staying up front, when you're winning, desperate for points, and under huge pressure from Bournemouth, is either stubborn or just a bit daft. Surely the sensuble thing to have done would have been to take townsend off and bring ridewald on to add an extra defensive midfielder?

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 13 Apr 18 10.20pm

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Our January business was nothing short of embarrassing, and Parish & Co. should directly take the blame if we were to perish at the end of the season.

Agree completely... It's as if Parish wouldn't step up with what Hodgson wanted and Rakip was a last minute thing that Hodgson didn't want and he's not playing him as some kind of protest.

Either way our January window was nothing short of pathetic.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 14 Apr 18 11.52am

Isn't a good to be bloody minded at times?

I sometimes wish I was a bit more bloody minded.

As long as you don't mind, of course.

 

HuckEagle Flag South Godstone 18 Apr 18 3.25am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'What’s the point in signing Rakip and Jach?' by Midlands Eagle

What is the point of signing Erdal Rakip on loan and Jaroslaw Jach if they aren’t even going to be playing or even in the match day squad each week?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Apr 18 4.21am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'What’s the point in signing Rakip and Jach?' by Midlands Eagle

Not all signings work out. Some signings take longer to adapt to the English game and some never do.

Sometimes you make a signing and discover that they aren't as good or no better than your reserve options anyway.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2018 5.11am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rakip, and Harry Kane taking corners