This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Looks like we will be relying on the eagle-eyed vision of the likes of Madley again for another year. Cosmic.
============ |
|
|
I must admit I didn't think that the clubs would vote for VAR for next season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
It's not been a success so far. Let other leagues keep using and perfecting it then maybe start using it in a few years time. One of the issues raised is the communication in the stadium with supporters unaware if a decision is under consideration between the referee and the VAR. If the pitch screen is going to be used the referee signals the shape of the screen so supporters are aware that he is about to look at the TV footage.In other incidents referees place their finger on their ear piece but this isn't seen by everybody - maybe there could be a signal of two hands in the air whilst communication is taking place which of course would be seen by all in the ground.I have heard it suggested that information could be relayed on to stadium screens but not all stadiums have screens which can be seen by everyone. I suspect the general feeling is that more time is needed to refine and trial the system in the PL and indeed educate the supporters, before it can go 'Live'.It will happen for sure. Edited by Willo (13 Apr 2018 4.39pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by dorking
The main annoyance for me is that people at home watching on tv can see replays galore, yet the paying fans in the stadium cannot see anything and just have to wait, and wait, and wait. If the whole point of VAR is that the correct decision is reached, then why can't the paying fans in the stadium see the video review as well. We're not going to riot because after all the correct decision is always (supposedly) reached. Let the fans in the ground see what the armchair fans can see, or don't bother with VAR at all. Indeed I agree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I must admit I didn't think that the clubs would vote for VAR for next season. It still has some issues to iron out but as another poster said this is more to do with communication to the crowd. The actual decisions once made most people would agree with. I am not surprised that the chief objectors are the big boys as I suspect they get the most home decisions and they want to protect that.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
I think everyone is looking to how it works in the World Cup before committing to it. After last night's UCL match, there will be more calling for it since the officials had a total 'mare. Did I read recently that the crowd at WC matches are going to be able to see the video that the officials see?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Did I read recently that the crowd at WC matches are going to be able to see the video that the officials see? Mark Clattenburg, of all people, made that exact point on NBC this past weekend. He doesn't favor the way England has done it, which is the VAR is at a central location rather than at the ground. He wants VAR at the ground and shown on the stadium screen. Given the mess replay has become in the NFL, where one guy sitting in a studio on Park Avenue, Manhattan, decides every challenged decision (When is a catch not a catch? When Park Avenue guy says so!). There's plenty of space in the TV production trucks on site to accommodate the VAR. As Clattenburg said, it needs to be as transparent a process as possible. He even went so far as saying the decision should be explained so that fns at least get a better idea of how the decisions are being made using VAR. Edited by kenbarr (16 May 2018 8.31pm)
Divorced...And LOVING it! |
|
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
Mark Clattenburg, of all people, made that exact point on NBC this past weekend. He doesn't favor the way England has done it, which is the VAR is at a central location rather than at the ground. HE wants VAR at the ground and shown on the stadium screen. Given the mess replay has become in the NFL, where one guy sitting in studio on Park Avenue, Manhattan, decides every challenged decision (When is a catch not a catch? When Park Avenue guy says so!). There's plenty of space in the TV production trucks on site to accommodate the VAR. As Clattenburg said, it needs to be as transparent a process as possible. He even went so far as saying the decision should be explained so that fns at least get a better idea of how the decisions are being made using VAR. So Clattenburg wants the ruling changed relating to that controversial moments can't be replayed on the screen.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!! Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in? |
|
|
Today's Gazzetta dello sport in Italy published the final report of the 1st season with VAR in Italy. Edited by Ian-VI (09 Jun 2018 7.52am)
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Not in my lifetime but I can envisage when there will be NO referee on the field of play and the game will be refereed remotely using the technology available.There will only be an official (Like the current 4th official) who will control the substitutions and the respective dug-outs. Seems somewhat far-fetched but so did GPS, sat-navs, the Internet and mobile phones ! I believe that it the automation of officiating in football will begin with the ARs (linesmen) and will concentrate on enforcing offside. The football ref has to cover a much greater distance/area and has a more complex series of decisions to make. For example, George Courtney's famous penalty decision in the 1989 playoffs was for a foul by Colin Hendrie on Mark Bright, not Eddie McGoldrick who had possession of the ball at the time. An automated official may not have made that call due to its concentration on who was in possession. A more likely sport to have automated officiating is baseball. The rulings each umpire makes are specific to the base they are assigned to. There are experiments under way now for automated officiating for balls and strikes at home plate. Human umpires tend to have different strike zones based on how they set up behind the plate and also can be inconsistent during the game. Edited by kenbarr (09 Jun 2018 8.55am)
Divorced...And LOVING it! |
|
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
I believe that it the automation of officiating in football will begin with the ARs (linesmen) and will concentrate on enforcing offside. The football ref has to cover a much greater distance/area and has a more complex series of decisions to make. For example, George Courtney's famous penalty decision in the 1989 playoffs was for a foul by Colin Hendrie on Mark Bright, not Eddie McGoldrick who had possession of the ball at the time. An automated official may not have made that call due to its concentration on who was in possession. Edited by kenbarr (09 Jun 2018 8.55am) I understand what you are saying,however it is feasible that there might be perhaps a couple of remote VAR's covering on and off the ball.And I agree that such automation might start with the ARs and the offside calls. I suspect that when I am 'Pushing up the daisies' officiating will be vastly different to what it is at the present time with technology at the forefront and less officials at stadia for supporters to vent their spleen ! Be a world away from what it is now - shame I won't be around to witness it ! Edited by Willo (09 Jun 2018 9.14am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
Another major issue with automated officiating is security. Hacking into these systems is far too frequent and could affect the integrity of the sport. I've been working on remote voting in elections via the internet and security is the major stumbling block. Given the international nature of football and the influence of worldwide gambling interests, an automated officiating system would be a prime target for those who want to fi games for monetary gain. Given there is noted hacker sitting in the can at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London with nothing but time on his hands and an overweening ego to feed, Im sure for the right price he would be happy to provide his "services" to the highest bidder. Ken When you mention "Automated officiating" are you referring to technology itself which makes the decisions so there is no need for any human element ? The point I have been making refers to remote officials (like the current VAR) viewing the vast array of technology available to him/her and making decisions based on what they have witnessed.Perhaps "Automated officiating" with technology making the decisions itself (With no VAR) will be the next advance after that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Ken When you mention "Automated officiating" are you referring to technology itself which makes the decisions so there is no need for any human element ? The point I have been making refers to remote officials (like the current VAR) viewing the vast array of technology available to him/her and making decisions based on what they have witnessed.Perhaps "Automated officiating" with technology making the decisions itself (With no VAR) will be the next advance after that. I am talking about a system that makes the calls and replaces humans. This is where Major League Baseball is headed according to the Umpire's Union. There is little chance of hacking in VAR, unless the replay feeds are sabotaged.
Divorced...And LOVING it! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.